ABSTRACT
Background Numerous investigators have shown that early postinjury Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) values are associated with later clinical outcomes in patients with traumatic brain injury (TBI), in-hospital mortality, and post-hospital discharge Glasgow Outcome Scale (GOS) results. Following TBI, early GCS, and brain computed tomography (CT) scores have been associated with clinical outcomes. However, only one previous study combined GCS scores with CT scan results and demonstrated an interaction with in-hospital mortality and GOS results. We aimed to determine if interactive GCS and CT findings would be associated with outcomes better than GCS and CT findings alone. Methodology Our study included TBI patients who had GCS scores of 3-12 and required mechanical ventilation for ≥five days. The GCS deficit was determined as 15 minus the GCS score. The mass effect CT score was calculated as lateral ventricular compression plus basal cistern compression plus midline shift. Each value was 1 for present. A prognostic CT score was the mass effect score plus subarachnoid hemorrhage (2 if present).The CT-GCS deficit score was the sum of the GCS deficit and the prognostic CT score. Results One hundred and twelve consecutive TBI patients met the inclusion criteria. Patients with surgical decompression had a lower GCS score (6.0±3.0) than those without (7.7±3.3; Cohen d=0.54). Patients with surgical decompression had a higher mass effect CT score (2.8±0.5) than those without (1.7±1.0; Cohen d=1.4). The GCS deficit was greater in patients not following commands at hospital discharge (9.6±2.6) than in those following commands (6.8±3.2; Cohen d=0.96). The prognostic CT score was greater in patients not following commands at hospital discharge (3.7±1.2) than in those following commands (3.1±1.1; Cohen d=0.52). The CT-GCS deficit score was greater in patients not following commands at hospital discharge (13.3±3.2) than in those following commands (9.9±3.2; Cohen d=1.06). Logistic regression stepwise analysis showed that the failure to follow commands at hospital discharge was associated with the CT-GCS deficit score but not with the GCS deficit. The GCS deficit was greater in patients not following commands at three months (9.7±2.8) than in those following commands (7.4±3.2; Cohen d=0.78). The CT-GCS deficit score was greater in patients not following commands at three months (13.6±3.1) than in those following commands (10.5±3.4; Cohen d=0.94). Logistic regression stepwise analysis showed that failure to follow commands at three months was associated with the CT-GCS deficit score but not with the GCS deficit. The proportion not following commands at three months was greater with a GCS deficit of 9-12 (50.9%) than with a GCS deficit of 3-8 (21.1%; odds ratio=3.9; risk ratio=2.1). The proportion of not following commands at three months was greater with a CT-GCS deficit score of 13-17 (56.0%) than with a CT-GCS deficit score of 4-12 (18.3%; OR=5.7; RR=3.1). Conclusion The mass effect CT score had a substantially better association with the need for surgical decompression than did the GCS score. The degree of association for not following commands at hospital discharge and three months was greater with the CT-GCS deficit score than with the GCS deficit. These observations support the notion that a mass effect and subarachnoid hemorrhage composite CT score can interact with the GCS score to better prognosticate TBI outcomes than the GCS score alone.
ABSTRACT
Although hypertonic saline (HTS) decreases intracranial pressure (ICP) with traumatic brain injury (TBI), its effects on survival and post-discharge neurologic function are less certain. We assessed the impact of HTS administration on TBI outcomes and hypothesized that favorable outcomes would be associated with larger amounts of 3% saline. This is a retrospective study of consecutive-patients with the following criteria: blunt trauma, age 18-70 years, intracranial hemorrhage, Glasgow Coma Scale score (GCS) 3-12, and mechanical ventilation ≥ 5 days. The need for craniotomy or craniectomy denoted surgical decompression patients. Amounts of HTS were during the first-5 trauma center days. Traits for the 112 patients during 2012-2016 were as follows: GCS, 6.8 ± 3.2; subdural hematoma, 71.4%; cerebral contusion, 31.3%, ICP device, 47.3%; surgical decompression, 51.8%; ventilator days, 14.8 ± 6.7; trauma center mortality, 13.4%; and no commands at 3 months 35.5%. In surgically decompressed patients, trauma center mortality was greater with ≤ 8.0 mEq/kg sodium (38.9%) than with > 8.0 mEq/kg (7.5%; P = 0.0037). In surgically decompressed patients, following commands at 3 months was greater with ≥ 1400 mEq sodium (76.9%) than with < 1400 mEq (50.0%; P = 0.0489). For trauma center surviving non-decompression patients with no ICP device, those following commands at 3 months received more sodium (513 ± 784 mEq) than individuals not following commands (82 ± 144 mEq; P = 0.0142). For patients with a GCS 5-8, following commands at 3 months was greater with ≥ 1350 mEq sodium (92.3%) than with < 1350 mEq (60.0%; P = 0.0214). In patients with subdural hematoma or cerebral contusion, following commands at 3 months was greater with ≥ 1400 mEq sodium (84.2%) than with < 1400 mEq (61.8%; P = 0.0333). Patients with ICP > 20 mmHg for ≤ 10 hours (mean hours 2.0) received more sodium (16.5 ± 11.5 mEq/kg) when compared to ICP elevation for ≥ 11 hours (mean hours 34) (9.4 ± 6.3 mEq/kg; P = 0.0139). These observations demonstrate that hypertonic saline administration in patients with complex traumatic brain injury is associated with 1) mitigation of intracranial hypertension, 2) trauma center survival, and 3) following commands at 3 months post-injury.
ABSTRACT
INTRODUCTION: In blunt trauma, comatose patients (Glasgow Coma Scale score 3 to 8) with a negative comprehensive cervical spine (CS) computed tomography assessment and no apparent spinal deficit, CS clearance strategies (magnetic resonance imaging [MRI] and prolonged cervical collar use) are controversial. METHODS: We conducted a literature review to delineate risks for coma, CS instability, prolonged cervical collar use, and CS MRI. RESULTS: Based on our search of the literature, the numbers of functional survivor patients among those who had sustained blunt trauma were as follows: 350 per 1,000 comatose unstable patients (increased intracranial pressure [ICP], hypotension, hypoxia, or early ventilator-associated pneumonia); 150 per 1,000 comatose high-risk patients (age > 45 years or Glasgow Coma Scale score 3 to 5); and 600 per 1,000 comatose stable patients (not unstable or high risk). Risk probabilities for adverse events among unstable, high-risk, and stable patients were as follows: 2.5% for CS instability; 26.2% for increased intensive care unit complications with prolonged cervical collar use; 9.3% to 14.6% for secondary brain injury with MRI transportation; and 20.6% for aspiration during MRI scanning (supine position). Additional risk probabilities for adverse events among unstable patients were as follows: 35.8% for increased ICP with cervical collar; and 72.1% for increased ICP during MRI scan (supine position). CONCLUSION: Blunt trauma coma functional survivor (independent living) rates are alarming. When a comprehensive CS computed tomography evaluation is negative and there is no apparent spinal deficit, CS instability is unlikely (2.5%). Secondary brain injury from the cervical collar or MRI is more probable than CS instability and jeopardizes cerebral recovery. Brain injury severity, probability of CS instability, cervical collar risk, and MRI risk assessments are essential when deciding whether CS MRI is appropriate and for determining the timing of cervical collar removal.
