ABSTRACT
Personal and professional rivalries involving prominent neurologists mark the history of nineteenth-century French neurology. One of the great examples is the feud between Pierre Marie and Jules Dejerine. The dispute between the two, nevertheless, did not prevent Pierre Marie's son, André Marie, and Gustave Roussy - one of Dejerine's favorite pupils, from collaborating on significant research that led to the doctoral dissertation by Andre Marie regarding sensory disturbances associated with painful hemiagnosia found in thalamic lesions.
As rivalidades pessoais e profissionais entre neurologistas proeminentes marcaram a história da neurologia francesa do século XIX. Um dos grandes exemplos é a rivalidade entre Pierre Marie e Jules Dejerine. A disputa entre os dois, no entanto, não impediu que o filho de Pierre Marie, André Marie, e Gustave Roussy, um dos pupilos preferidos de Dejerine, colaborassem numa investigação significativa que resultou na tese de doutorado de André Marie sobre os distúrbios sensoriais associados à hemiagnosia dolorosa encontrada nas lesões talâmicas.
Subject(s)
Neurology , History, 19th Century , France , Neurology/history , Sensation Disorders/history , Sensation Disorders/etiologyABSTRACT
More frequent use of next-generation sequencing led to a paradigm shift in assessing heredodegenerative diseases. This is particularly notable in progressive myoclonus epilepsy (PME) and progressive myoclonus ataxia (PMA) where a group of disorders linked to novel genetic mutations has now been added to these phenotypical realms. Despite the historical value of Ramsay Hunt's contribution defining the syndrome later known as PMA, recent genetic developments have made this eponym obsolete and a new definition and classification of PMA and PME seem necessary. A rational possibility is to adopt the wider term progressive myoclonus ataxia and epilepsy syndrome (PMAES), which can be subdivided into its main subtypes, PME and PMA, whenever clinical data is sufficient to make that distinction.
