Evolution of biological catalysis: ribozyme to RNP enzyme.

The enzymes that perform biological catalysis in contemporary organisms are usually proteins, occasionally ribonucleoprotein (RNP) complexes, and in rare instances pure RNA (ribozymes). Because RNA can serve as both an informational molecule and a biocatalyst, it has been attractive to consider a primordial RNA World in which RNA enzymes catalyzed the replication of RNA genomes and an array of other metabolic steps, before the advent of protein enzymes and DNA genomes. By what pathways, then, did the RNA World evolve to the present state? Here, I describe plausible pathways for the evolution of biological catalysis, with special emphasis on the origin of RNP enzymes. Recent findings support the argument that RNP enzymes are not undergoing extinction, but instead, they are continuing to evolve and to elaborate new functions.

RNA as a flexible scaffold for proteins: yeast telomerase and beyond.

Yeast telomerase, the enzyme that adds a repeated DNA sequence to the ends of the chromosomes, consists of a 1157- nucleotide RNA (TLC1) plus several protein subunits: the telomerase reverse transcriptase Est2p, the regulatory subunit Est1p, the nonhomologous end-joining heterodimer Ku, and the seven Sm proteins involved in ribonucleoprotein (RNP) maturation. The RNA subunit provides the template for telomeric DNA synthesis. In addition, we have reported evidence that it serves as a flexible scaffold to tether the proteins into the complex. More generally, we consider the possibility that RNPs may be considered in three structural categories: (1) those that have specific structures determined in large part by the RNA, including RNase P, other ribozyme-protein complexes, and the ribosome; (2) those that have specific structures determined in large part by proteins, including many small nuclear RNPs (snRNPs) and small nucleolar RNPs (snoRNPs); and (3) flexible scaffolds, with no specific structure of the RNP as a whole, as exemplified by yeast telomerase. Other candidates for flexible scaffold structures are other telomerases, viral IRES (internal ribosome entry site) elements, tmRNA (transfer-messenger RNA), the SRP (signal recognition particle), and Xist and roX1 RNAs that alter chromatin structure to achieve dosage compensation.

Ribozymes, the first 20 years.

In 1982 we reported the first catalytic RNA or ribozyme: the self-splicing intron of the Tetrahymena pre-rRNA. Additional examples of natural ribozymes were soon found, and research in the field focused on their enzymic mechanism and secondary and tertiary structure. Ribozymes identified through in vitro selection extended the repertoire of RNA catalysis. Two directions of current and future interest are the determination of atomic-resolution structures of large ribozymes by X-ray crystallography and the structural and mechanistic analysis of complexes of ribozymes with protein facilitators of their activity.

A stem-loop of Tetrahymena telomerase RNA distant from the template potentiates RNA folding and telomerase activity.

The ribonucleoprotein enzyme telomerase adds telomeric repeats to the ends of linear chromosomes. The Tetrahymena telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT) protein and the telomerase RNA can be reconstituted into an active complex in vitro in rabbit reticulocyte lysates. We have probed the structure of the telomerase RNA in the reconstituted complex with RNases T1 and V1. Upon TERT binding to the RNA, sites of both protection and enhancement of cleavage were observed, suggesting potential protein-binding sites and conformational changes in the RNA. Especially prominent was a large region of RNase V1 protection in stem-loop IV. A number of loop IV mutants still bound TERT but showed drastic decreases in the level of telomerase activity and the loss of protein-dependent folding of the pseudoknot region of the telomerase RNA. The telomerase activity defect and the misfolding of the pseudoknot were partially separable, leading to the proposal of two functions for stem-loop IV: to aid in the folding of the pseudoknot and to function more directly in the active site of telomerase. Thus an RNA element far from the template makes a major contribution to Tetrahymena telomerase enzyme activity.

Pot1, the putative telomere end-binding protein in fission yeast and humans.

Telomere proteins from ciliated protozoa bind to the single-stranded G-rich DNA extensions at the ends of macronuclear chromosomes. We have now identified homologous proteins in fission yeast and in humans. These Pot1 (protection of telomeres) proteins each bind the G-rich strand of their own telomeric repeat sequence, consistent with a direct role in protecting chromosome ends. Deletion of the fission yeast pot1+ gene has an immediate effect on chromosome stability, causing rapid loss of telomeric DNA and chromosome circularization. It now appears that the protein that caps the ends of chromosomes is widely dispersed throughout the eukaryotic kingdom.

Structural basis of the enhanced stability of a mutant ribozyme domain and a detailed view of RNA--solvent interactions.

BACKGROUND: The structure of P4-P6, a 160 nucleotide domain of the self-splicing Tetrahymena thermophila intron, was solved previously. Mutants of the P4-P6 RNA that form a more stable tertiary structure in solution were recently isolated by successive rounds of in vitro selection and amplification. RESULTS: We show that a single-site mutant (Delta C209) possessing greater tertiary stability than wild-type P4-P6 also crystallizes much more rapidly and under a wider variety of conditions. The crystal structure provides a satisfying explanation for the increased stability of the mutant; the deletion of C209 allows the adjacent bulged adenine to enter the P4 helix and form an A-G base pair, presumably attenuating the conformational flexibility of the helix. The structure of another mutant (Delta A210) was also solved and supports this interpretation. The crystals of Delta C209 diffract to a higher resolution limit than those of wild-type RNA (2.25 A versus 2.8 A), allowing assignment of innersphere and outersphere coordination contacts for 27 magnesium ions. Structural analysis reveals an intricate solvent scaffold with a preponderance of ordered water molecules on the inside rather than the surface of the folded RNA domain. CONCLUSIONS: In vitro evolution facilitated the identification of a highly stable, structurally homogeneous mutant RNA that was readily crystallizable. Analysis of the structure suggests that improving RNA secondary structure can stabilize tertiary structure and perhaps promote crystallization. In addition, the higher resolution model provides new details of metal ion-RNA interactions and identifies a core of ordered water molecules that may be integral to RNA tertiary structure formation.

An early transition state for folding of the P4-P6 RNA domain.

Tertiary folding of the 160-nt P4-P6 domain of the Tetrahymena group I intron RNA involves burying of substantial surface area, providing a model for the folding of other large RNA domains involved in catalysis. Stopped-flow fluorescence was used to monitor the Mg2+-induced tertiary folding of pyrene-labeled P4-P6. At 35 degrees C with [Mg2+] approximately 10 mM, P4-P6 folds on the tens of milliseconds timescale with k(obs) = 15-31 s(-1). From these values, an activation free energy deltaG(double dagger) of approximately 8-16 kcal/mol is calculated, where the large range for deltaG(double dagger) arises from uncertainty in the pre-exponential factor relating k(obs) and delta G(double dagger). The folding rates of six mutant P4-P6 RNAs were measured and found to be similar to that of the wild-type RNA, in spite of significant thermodynamic destabilization or stabilization. The ratios of the kinetic and thermodynamic free energy changes phi = delta deltaG(double dagger)/delta deltaG(o') are approximately 0, implying a folding transition state in which most of the native-state tertiary contacts are not yet formed (an early folding transition state). The k(obs) depends on the Mg2+ concentration, and the initial slope of k(obs) versus [Mg2+] suggests that only approximately 1 Mg2+ ion is bound in the rate-limiting folding step. This is consistent with an early folding transition state, because folded P4-P6 binds many Mg2+ ions. The observation of a substantial deltaG(double dagger) despite an early folding transition state suggests that a simple two-state folding diagram for Mg2+-induced P4-P6 folding is incomplete. Our kinetic data are some of the first to provide quantitative values for an activation barrier and location of a transition state for tertiary folding of an RNA domain.

Engineering disulfide cross-links in RNA using thiol-disulfide interchange chemistry.

Protocols for postsynthetic modification of 2-amino-containing oligoribonucleotides with either an alkyl-phenyl disulfide or an alkyl thiol group are described. These groups react under mild conditions to form disulfide cross-links by thiol-disulfide interchange. These reactants do not form a disulfide bond when incorporated on opposite faces of a short continuous RNA helix, but do form disulfide bonds rapidly when they are placed in proximity. In addition, by incorporating these groups at various positions on large RNAs by semisynthesis, the dynamics of thermal motions can be detected. Such motions are believed to be linked to biological function, and the protocols presented in this unit are among the few simple ways to assess such dynamics.

Euplotes telomerase contains an La motif protein produced by apparent translational frameshifting.

Telomerase is the ribonucleoprotein enzyme responsible for the replication of chromosome ends in most eukaryotes. In the ciliate Euplotes aediculatus, the protein p43 biochemically co-purifies with active telomerase and appears to be stoichiometric with both the RNA and the catalytic protein subunit of this telomerase complex. Here we describe cloning of the gene for p43 and present evidence that it is an authentic component of the telomerase holoenzyme. Comparison of the nucleotide sequence of the cloned gene with peptide sequences of the protein suggests that production of full-length p43 relies on a programmed ribosomal frameshift, an extremely rare translational mechanism. Anti-p43 antibodies immunodeplete telomerase RNA and telomerase activity from E.aediculatus nuclear extracts, indicating that the vast majority of mature telomerase complexes in the cell are associated with p43. The sequence of p43 reveals similarity to the La autoantigen, an RNA-binding protein involved in maturation of RNA polymerase III transcripts, and recombinant p43 binds telomerase RNA in vitro. By analogy to other La proteins, p43 may function in chaperoning the assembly and/or facilitating nuclear retention of telomerase.

Multiple folding pathways for the P4-P6 RNA domain.

We recently described site-specific pyrene labeling of RNA to monitor Mg(2+)-dependent equilibrium formation of tertiary structure. Here we extend these studies to follow the folding kinetics of the 160-nucleotide P4-P6 domain of the Tetrahymena group I intron RNA, using stopped-flow fluorescence with approximately 1 ms time resolution. Pyrene-labeled P4-P6 was prepared using a new phosphoramidite that allows high-yield automated synthesis of oligoribonucleotides with pyrene incorporated at a specific 2'-amino-2'-deoxyuridine residue. P4-P6 forms its higher-order tertiary structure rapidly, with k(obs) = 15-31 s(-1) (t(1/2) approximately 20-50 ms) at 35 degrees C and [Mg(2+)] approximately 10 mM in Tris-borate (TB) buffer. The folding rate increases strongly with temperature from 4 to 45 degrees C, demonstrating a large activation enthalpy DeltaH(double dagger) approximately 26 kcal/mol; the activation entropy DeltaS(double dagger) is large and positive. In low ionic strength 10 mM sodium cacodylate buffer at 35 degrees C, a slow (t(1/2) approximately 1 s) folding component is also observed. The folding kinetics are both ionic strength- and temperature-dependent; the slow phase vanishes upon increasing [Na(+)] in the cacodylate buffer, and the kinetics switch completely from fast at 30 degrees C to slow at 40 degrees C. Using synchrotron hydroxyl radical footprinting, we confirm that fluorescence monitors the same kinetic events as hydroxyl radical cleavage, and we show that the previously reported slow P4-P6 folding kinetics apply only to low ionic strength conditions. One model to explain the fast and slow folding kinetics postulates that some tertiary interactions are present even without Mg(2+) in the initial state. The fast kinetic phase reflects folding that is facilitated by these interactions, whereas the slow kinetics are observed when these interactions are disrupted at lower ionic strength and higher temperature.

Protection of telomeres by the Ku protein in fission yeast.

Schizosaccharomyces pombe cells survive loss of telomeres by a unique pathway of chromosome circularization. Factors potentially involved in this survival mechanism include the heterodimeric Ku protein and ligase IV, both of which are involved in the repair of DNA double-strand breaks in mammalian cells. Furthermore, Ku plays a role in telomere maintenance as well as in DNA double-strand break repair in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. We have identified Ku and ligase IV homologues in S. pombe and analyzed their functions during normal growth and in cells undergoing senescence. In the absence of either a Ku subunit (pku70(+)) or ligase IV (lig4(+)), nonhomologous DNA end-joining was severely reduced. Lack of functional Ku led to shorter but stable telomeres and caused striking rearrangements of telomere-associated sequences, indicating a function for Ku in inhibiting recombinational activities near chromosome ends. In contrast to S. cerevisiae, concurrent deletion of pku70(+) and the gene for the catalytic subunit of telomerase (trt1(+)) was not lethal, allowing for the first time the dissection of the roles of Ku during senescence. Our results support a model in which Ku protects chromosome termini from nucleolytic and recombinational activities but is not involved in the formation of chromosome end fusions during senescence. The conclusion that nonhomologous end-joining is not required for chromosome circularization was further supported by analysis of survivors in strains lacking the genes for both trt1(+) and lig4(+).

Telomerase RNA bound by protein motifs specific to telomerase reverse transcriptase.

Telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT) differs from many other reverse transcriptases in that it remains stably associated with its template-containing RNA subunit. Elements of TERT involved in binding the RNA subunit have now been identified by mutagenesis and in vitro reconstitution of the Tetrahymena ribonucleoprotein complex. Mutations in the reverse transcriptase motifs of TERT reduced activity as expected but did not greatly reduce its binding to the telomerase RNA. In contrast, all mutations in the T and CP motifs dramatically reduced RNA binding. We therefore suggest that the T and CP motifs of TERT function to hold on to the telomerase RNA, leaving the RNA template region free to translocate through the RT domain.

Structural biology. The ribosome is a ribozyme.

Ribosomes, the cellular factories that manufacture proteins, contain both RNA and protein, but exactly how all of the different ribosomal components contribute to protein synthesis is still not clear. Now, as Thomas Cech explains in his Perspective, atomic resolution of the structure of the large ribosomal subunit reveals that, as predicted by those convinced of a prebiotic RNA world, RNA is the catalytic component with proteins being the structural units that support and stabilize it (Ban et al., Nissen et al., Muth et al.).

Analysis of telomerase catalytic subunit mutants in vivo and in vitro in Schizosaccharomycespombe.

The chromosome end-replicating enzyme telomerase is composed of a template-containing RNA subunit, a reverse transcriptase (TERT), and additional proteins. The importance of conserved amino acid residues in Trt1p, the TERT of Schizosaccharomyces pombe, was tested. Mutation to alanine of the proposed catalytic aspartates in reverse transcriptase motifs A and C and of conserved amino acids in motifs 1 and B' resulted in defective growth, progressive loss of telomeric DNA, and loss of detectable telomerase enzymatic activity in vitro. Mutation of the phenylalanine (F) in the conserved FYxTE of telomerase-specific motif T had no phenotype in vivo or in vitro whereas mutation of a conserved amino acid in RT motif 2 had an intermediate effect. In addition to identifying single amino acids of TERT required for telomere maintenance in the fission yeast, this work provides useful tools for S. pombe telomerase research: a functional epitope-tagged version of Trt1p that allows detection of the protein even in crude cellular extracts, and a convenient and robust in vitro enzymatic activity assay based on immunopurification of telomerase.

A mutant of Tetrahymena telomerase reverse transcriptase with increased processivity.

The protein catalytic subunit of telomerase (TERT) is a reverse transcriptase (RT) that utilizes an internal RNA molecule as a template for the extension of chromosomal DNA ends. In all retroviral RTs there is a conserved tyrosine two amino acids preceding the catalytic aspartic acids in motif C, a motif that is critical for catalysis. In TERTs, however, this position is a leucine, valine, or phenylalanine. We developed and characterized a robust in vitro reconstitution system for Tetrahymena telomerase and tested the effects of amino acid substitutions on activity. Substitution of the retroviral-like tyrosine in motif C did not change overall enzymatic activity but increased processivity. This increase in processivity correlated with an increased affinity for telomeric DNA primer. Substitution of an alanine did not increase processivity, while substitution of a phenylalanine had an intermediate effect. The data suggest that this amino acid is involved in interactions with the primer in telomerase as in other RTs, and show that mutating an amino acid to that conserved in retroviral RTs makes telomerase more closely resemble these other RTs.

Quantifying the energetic interplay of RNA tertiary and secondary structure interactions.

To understand the RNA-folding problem, we must know the extent to which RNA structure formation is hierarchical (tertiary folding of preformed secondary structure). Recently, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy was used to show that Mg2+-dependent tertiary interactions force secondary structure rearrangement in the 56-nt tP5abc RNA, a truncated subdomain of the Tetrahymena group I intron. Here we combine mutagenesis with folding computations, nondenaturing gel electrophoresis, high-resolution NMR spectroscopy, and chemical-modification experiments to probe further the energetic interplay of tertiary and secondary interactions in tP5abc. Point mutations predicted to destabilize the secondary structure of folded tP5abc greatly disrupt its Mg2+-dependent folding, as monitored by nondenaturing gels. Imino proton assignments and sequential NOE walks of the two-dimensional NMR spectrum of one of the tP5abc mutants confirm the predicted secondary structure, which does not change in the presence of Mg2+. In contrast to these data on tP5abc, the same point mutations in the context of the P4-P6 domain (of which P5abc is a subdomain) shift the Mg2+ dependence of P4-P6 folding only moderately, and dimethyl sulfate (DMS) modification experiments demonstrate that Mg2+ does cause secondary structure rearrangement of the P4-P6 mutants' P5abc subdomains. Our data provide experimental support for two simple conclusions: (1) Even single point mutations at bases involved only in secondary structure can be enough to tip the balance between RNA tertiary and secondary interactions. (2) Domain context must be considered in evaluating the relative importance of tertiary and secondary contributions. This tertiary/secondary interplay is likely relevant to the folding of many large RNA and to bimolecular snRNA-snRNA and snRNA-intron RNA interactions.

Self-splicing of the Tetrahymena intron from mRNA in mammalian cells.

The Tetrahymena pre-rRNA self-splicing intron is shown to function in the unnatural context of an mRNA transcribed by RNA polymerase II in mammalian cells. Mutational analysis supports the conclusion that splicing in cells occurs by the same RNA-catalyzed mechanism established for splicing in vitro. Insertion of the intron at five positions spanning the luciferase open reading frame revealed 10-fold differences in accumulation of ligated exons and in luciferase activity; thus, the intron self-splices in many exon contexts, but the context can have a significant effect on activity. In addition, even the best self-splicing constructs, which produced half as much mRNA as did an uninterrupted luciferase gene, gave approximately 100-fold less luciferase enzyme activity, revealing an unexpected discontinuity between mRNA production and translation in cells. The finding that production of accurately spliced mRNA in cells does not guarantee a corresponding level of protein production is surprising, and may have implications for the development of trans-splicing ribozymes as therapeutics.