A conceptual model of how mental health clubhouses impact health and quality of life among individuals with serious mental illness.

OBJECTIVE: People with serious mental illness (PWSMI) experience dramatic disparities in health, quality of life, and longevity. Mental health Clubhouses are a community-based treatment model that can positively affect health and quality of life among PWSMI. However, few studies investigate the processes within Clubhouses and what factors are related to the improvement of health and quality of life among members. To address this gap, this research offers a conceptual model of how Clubhouses contribute to health and quality of life. METHOD: This conceptual model was created using participatory qualitative methods, combining Photovoice and grounded theory. Forty-two participants (37 Clubhouse members and six staff) from four Clubhouses in Hawai'i were engaged in 22 sessions over the course of 2 years. RESULTS: The conceptual model begins with quality of participation in Clubhouse activities, which refers not only to being present in the Clubhouse but being actively and meaningfully engaged in Clubhouse activities. Engagement in Clubhouse activities and working side-by-side with members and staff led to reciprocal social support. As members were supported and supported others, they gained a sense that they mattered, and they perceived themselves as more capable, more efficacious, and less stigmatized over time. They became a contributing member of a community, which supported health and quality of life directly and indirectly. CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: This work offers a novel conceptual framework of Clubhouse processes that highlights the importance and potential of empowering psychosocial treatment models. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).

Can Photovoice foster the development of social support?

Photovoice is a participatory, photo-based research method that differs from conventional (non-participatory) research in that the process is meant to be empowering and beneficial. However, empirical research on the Photovoice process remains very limited. Based on feedback from participants who reported Photovoice helped them develop closer relationships, we examine whether engaging in Photovoice fosters social support. Transcripts from a Photovoice study on wellness in mental health Clubhouses (voluntary, community mental health centers) were retrospectively analyzed for instrumental support, appraisal, informational support, and emotional support. Appraisal was the most common form of social support identified, and was primarily expressed through peer praise for photos and insights. Informational support included advice on managing symptoms, promoting wellness, and navigating challenges. Instrumental support was fostered by learning the tangible skill of digital photography and by supporting fellow members with physical or visual limitations to participate in the process. Emotional support was cultivated through encouragement, identification of shared experiences, and connection through humor. In sum, the findings suggest that Photovoice has the potential to foster social support, which may support relational empowerment.

Mapping community: A scoping review of clubhouse members' social networks and their impact on recovery in mental illness.

OBJECTIVE: Social support is an important component of recovery-based interventions for individuals living with severe mental illness (IWSMI). Clubhouses are local community centers that facilitate the development of meaningful relationships among IWSMI through an empowering structure and engagement with the work-ordered day. This review synthesizes research on social networks in Clubhouses to provide insights on the role of supportive relationships in mental illness recovery, including the size and features of social networks of Clubhouse members, methodological trends and gaps, and the associations between social networks and demographic variables, recovery, health, and perceived social support. METHOD: Research on social networks within Clubhouses were identified and analyzed following a systematic six-stage scoping review design. RESULTS: Twelve articles across six studies were included. Results revealed considerable variation in social network interview methods and network size and features. Overall findings suggest that network size is not consistently associated with reported loneliness, social support, recovery, or quality of life. A deep relationship with at least one supportive person, level of perceived affiliation with Clubhouses, or positive comments from network members may be more or equally valuable than a larger network. Some studies found that types of relationships were associated with unique benefits. Stronger peer networks were associated with relationship satisfaction, while increased connections with health care professionals and family were associated with reduced hospitalizations. CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: Future research should diversify research designs, expand the use of social network analysis and visualization, measure additional outcomes including recovery and health, and increase sample diversity. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved).

Understanding the Role of Mental Health Clubhouses in Promoting Wellness and Health Equity Using Pilinaha-An Indigenous Framework for Health.

Individuals with severe mental illness need to be engaged in defining their own vision of wellness to promote equity and reduce disparities. This photovoice study helps define what wellness is and how it is achieved in mental health Clubhouses in Hawai'i. Results from a photovoice study with 43 members and staff were analyzed using Pilinaha, a Native Hawaiian framework for health. Pilinaha envisions health through connection to place, community, past and future, and one's better self. Within Clubhouses, connection to place included connection to 'aina (land) and the access to a safe space. Connection to community occurred through reciprocal social support, which developed kuleana (responsibility), and a sense of 'ohana (family) for many members who were previously isolated. Connection to one's better self-involved positive identity change, development of hope, and pursuing opportunities within and outside the Clubhouse. Connection to past and future was described through individual narratives, remembering members who had died, and connection to cultural traditions. Overall, wellness was conceptualized as the ability to work toward dreams, engage in cultural practice, and feel accepted, respected, and valued-to be treated with aloha. Findings provide a culturally responsive perspective on wellness and illustrate the value of Clubhouses as a space for mental health recovery and transformative change.