SPET of a computerised model of diffuse lung disease.

Emphysema is a common and debilitating disease that is the commonest cause of end-stage respiratory failure. Treatment is either by lung transplantation or by lung volume reduction surgery (LVRS) that improves the biomechanics of respiration. Patient selection for LVRS hinges on the demonstration of heterogeneous disease, predominantly involving the upper lobes, as a good surgical outcome is most likely in these patients. We used a virtual model of lung scintigraphy to compare planar with tomographic scintigraphy for the detection of diffuse lung disease. Lesions of the magnitude of the lung acinus, as well as larger and smaller lesions, were distributed throughout the lungs in volumes from 2% to 50%. Single-photon emission tomography does not add incremental value to planar images for the detection of diffuse lung disease.

Determining the cross-sectional segmental anatomy of cadaveric human lungs.

An investigation of the complex boundaries between adjacent lobes and segments in human cadaveric lungs was undertaken to provide information for the later construction of a three-dimensional model of the segmental and subsegmental anatomy of the human lungs. This was performed by analyzing scanned cross-sections of the lungs after color-coded gelatin had been injected into segmental bronchi and the lungs embedded in gelatin and frozen. The resulting images provided information regarding the pattern of boundaries present between both lobes and segments.

Creation of a three-dimensional model of human segmental lung anatomy.

OBJECTIVE: The investigation of pulmonary embolism using scintigraphic tomography requires a model of the internal architecture of the segments and subsegments in the human lung. Such a model has been developed by the segmentation and subsegmentation of an existing whole-body tissue-segmented phantom. MATERIALS AND METHODS: By using information from suitably windowed human axial CT scans, combined with the information gained from the injection of color-coded dyes into the segmental bronchi of human cadaveric lungs, the lobar and segmental boundaries were added to the existing phantom. Further refinements were added from reports in the literature regarding the predominant pattern of subsegmental bronchi in a series of human cadavers, enabling the creation of subsegmental boundaries. RESULTS: A digitized model of the segmental and subsegmental anatomy of the human lung was successfully created. External, or pleural, projections of the complex internal arrangement of the segments closely corresponded with the projections of the best available authorities on the subject. CONCLUSION: The model provides the opportunity to address several issues germane to scintigraphy and important for diagnosing pulmonary embolic disease. In particular, the model allows the manipulation of three-dimensional data sets to explore issues of importance to tomographic lung scanning.

Single-photon emission tomography of a computerised model of pulmonary embolism.

Planar pulmonary scintigraphy is currently the standard investigation for the diagnosis of pulmonary embolism. There are a number of problems with the technique, particularly in patients with an intermediate scan report under the PIOPED criteria. The technique is also under threat from the increasing use of spiral CT angiography. A putative improvement may be gained by use of tomography. The incremental value of tomography over planar studies was therefore evaluated in a virtual model of pulmonary scintigraphy. A model of the segmental anatomy of the lungs was developed from computed tomography, cadaveric human lungs and available anatomical texts. Counts were generated within the phantom by Monte Carlo simulation of photon emission. Eighteen single segmental lesions were interspersed with 47 subsegmental defects and displayed on an Icon reporting station. These were presented in the transaxial, sagittal and coronal planes to four experienced reporters to obtain assessment of defect size. Planar studies of the same defects were displayed to the same observers in the standard eight views with a normal study for comparison. With planar studies, the accuracy of estimation of defect size was 51% compared with 97% using tomographic studies. Defects in the medial basal segment of the right lower lobe were not identified in planar studies but were easily seen by all observers in the tomographic study. It is concluded that there is marked improvement in the accuracy of determination of defect size for tomographic studies over the planar equivalents. This is especially important in the lung bases, the most common reported site of pulmonary emboli. Tomography permits visualisation of defects in the medial basal segment of the right lung, which are not seen in planar studies.

Rationalization of the optimal views in planar lung scintigraphy.

A knowledge of the segmental anatomy of the lungs is the cornerstone for interpreting lung scintigraphy. Many attempts have been made to determine the best views for the appreciation of segmental defects and various theories have been formulated to explain the mechanisms of this process. In earlier work, we hypothesized that the arrangements of the segments was the principal determinant of this process. However, data subsequently derived from work on a model of diffuse lung disease indicates that the external shape of the lobes and lungs may be the most significant contributor to the optimal views of the lungs.

Threshold of detection of diffuse lung disease.

UNLABELLED: A scintigraphic model of the lungs was used to study the threshold of detection of diffuse disease of the lungs. METHODS: Randomly distributed cold lesions of 4, 8, 12 and 16 mm3 block sizes were created, occupying 0%-50% of lung tissue in steps of 1%. These were submitted for reporting to five observers each with a normal study for comparison. RESULTS: No observer detected lesions of 4-mm3 block size even when up to 50% of the lung was involved. All observers detected lesions of 8-mm3 block size when a mean of 27% of lung tissue was involved with lesions. As lesion size increased to 12 and 16 mm3, observers detected lesions when a mean of 10% and 6% of lung tissue was involved, respectively. Comparison between views for each observer showed that the lateral and anterior oblique views were used more often than the anterior, posterior oblique and posterior views. CONCLUSION: This model suggests that pulmonary scintigraphy has the potential to detect a diffuse disease such as emphysema at an early stage of lung involvement. In general, small anatomic lesions appear to have more profound scintigraphic consequences. However, even scintigraphic lesions of the order of size of the pulmonary acinus are easily detected.

Enhanced accuracy and reproducibility in reporting of lung scintigrams by a segmental reference chart.

UNLABELLED: The diagnostic probability of pulmonary embolic disease is based on the recognition of unmatched segmental perfusion defects. Although interobserver and intraobserver reproducibility have been studied, accuracy has been an elusive goal due to the lack of a gold standard. We investigated the accuracy and reproducibility of reporting in a virtual scintigraphic model of the lungs, with and without the use of a lung segmental reference chart. METHODS: A Monte Carlo package was used to model lung scintigraphy from a digital phantom of the human lungs. An ideal lung segmental reference chart was created from the phantom. Five experienced nuclear medicine physicians reported a set of all possible defects involving 100% of a segment, without and with the chart. A further set of defects involving 45%-55% of a segment in the lower lobes was investigated using the chart. RESULTS: There was a significant improvement in accuracy (from 48% to 72%) and intraobserver agreement (from 61% to 77%) with the chart. The accuracy of reporting defects in the upper and middle lobes was consistently better than that in the lower lobes. There was no significant difference between the accuracy of reporting large defects and that of reporting moderate defects in the lower lobes. CONCLUSION: The lung segmental reference chart significantly improves both the accuracy and reproducibility of reporting lung scintigrams; however, although reporting in the lung bases is improved, absolute accuracy is substantially less than that in the upper and middle lobes. This emphasizes the need for caution because the lung bases are the most common site of embolic disease.

Variability of perceived defect size in virtual lung scintigraphy.

UNLABELLED: The diagnosis of pulmonary embolism is based on the presence of mismatched segmental or subsegmental defects. An important axiom is the classification of defect sizes into small, moderate and large. Little information about the recognition and classification of such defects has been published. We undertook a study of the perception of defect size using a model of the virtual scintigraphic anatomy of the lungs to address this issue. METHODS: Segmental anatomy of the lungs was modeled with CT, cadaveric lungs and standard anatomical tests. The emission, scatter and attenuation of photons were modeled within these virtual lungs and the surrounding tissues. Single segmental lesions, each 100% of a segment, were created in eight projections and submitted for blinded reporting by four experienced nuclear medicine physicians to obtain their assessment of the size of each defect on two occasions. RESULTS: Of the 144 defects submitted for reporting, 15% were reported as <25% of a segment, 35% were reported as 25%-75% and 50% were reported as 75%-100%. The accuracy of each reporter and the intraobserver agreement were calculated; the weighted kappa value ranged from 0.34 to 0.60. The segmental defects that were most likely to be underestimated in size were in the right lower lobe. CONCLUSION: It is clear that segmental defect sizes were underestimated, particularly in the right lower lobe. Although the intraobserver agreement in reporting was fair, the accuracy of estimation was only 50%. The variability and inaccuracy might be reduced by the use of a guide to segmental anatomy.

Recognition of subsegmental scintigraphic defects in virtual lung scintigraphy.

A virtual model of the segmental scintigraphic anatomy of the lungs was used to investigate the threshold at which small defects are perceptible. A model of the segmental anatomy of the lungs was developed from a number of sources and counts generated within the phantom by Monte-Carlo simulation of photon emission. Multiple subsegmental defects were created in both lungs and submitted for blinded reporting to detect the presence of any defect. A total of 36 of the 47 (77%) defects were seen. Of those defects in the lower lobes, 16 of 22 (73%) were visible. All the defects in the left lung (n = 21) were visible, while 15 of 26 (58%) of the defects on the right were visible. In the lower lobe of the right lung, 4 of 10 defects were visible. The defects that were not visible were all in the right lung. We conclude that absolute size and location are critical in the perception of defects. The perception of defects was dependent on absolute defect size rather than the proportion of a segment involved. Defects less than 3% of the volume of a lung were not detected.

Simulation of the stripe sign in a scintigraphic model of the lungs.

Using a virtual model of the lungs, we investigated the nature of the 'stripe sign' which is sometimes encountered in pulmonary scintigraphy. A model of the segmental anatomy of the lungs was developed from a number of sources and counts generated within the phantom by Monte-Carlo simulation of photon emission. Multiple segmental and subsegmental defects were created in both lungs and submitted for blinded reporting of the 'stripe sign'. Images were resubmitted for reporting with the contralateral lung removed. The stripe sign was reported in 32 of the 117 studies performed. Nearly half of these were present in defects involving approximately 25% of a segment and the sign was most commonly seen in the lateral projection. Removal of activity from the contralateral lung abolished the sign in only 2 of 32 cases. We conclude that shine through of activity from the contralateral lung is a mechanism rarely responsible for the stripe sign. Most occurrences of the sign are due to interposition of activity from unaffected areas of the same lung between the defect and the periphery of the lung. Orientation of the segments, particularly in the lung bases, accounts for the lateral projection being the most common view in which the sign is present.

Optimization of the scintigraphic segmental anatomy of the lungs.

UNLABELLED: Accurate and reproducible reporting of lung scintigraphy is predicated on a sound knowledge of the segmental anatomy of the lungs. A limited amount of hard data exists about the true segmental anatomy of the lungs. A virtual model of human lungs was created using a CT-based dataset and a Monte Carlo simulation technique to examine the optimal projections for the visualization of each segment in the lungs. METHODS: Segmental anatomy of the lungs was modeled using CT, cadaveric lungs and standard anatomical texts. The emission, scatter and attenuation of photons was modeled within these virtual lungs and the surrounding tissues. Single segmental lesions were created in eight projections and submitted for blinded reporting to four experienced nuclear medicine physicians to obtain the best views for each segment. RESULTS: The anterior and posterior oblique projections yielded the best views for 10 of 18 segments, with the laterals contributing four views, the anterior contributing two views and the posterior contributing one view. The majority of basal segments (six of nine) were best seen in the anterior and posterior oblique projections. CONCLUSION: This model overcomes the major problems associated with experimentation in the normal human and has the potential to provide answers to the major problems of scatter, attenuation and "shine-through" in lung scintigraphy.