Season of birth and not vitamin D receptor promoter polymorphisms is a risk factor for multiple sclerosis.

Both genetic and environmental factors contribute to multiple sclerosis, the most common neurodegenerative disorder with onset in young adults. The objective of the current study is, based on the hypothesis that environmentally predisposed individuals are at risk for multiple sclerosis, to investigate whether they also carry genetic variants within the vitamin D machinery. Using medical files and DNA samples from 583 trios (a patient and both parents) of the French Multiple Sclerosis Genetics Group as well as data from the French Statistics Bureau, we aimed to assess whether: (1) a seasonality of birth was observed in French multiple sclerosis patients; (2) three single nucleotide polymorphisms within the promoter region of the vitamin D receptor were associated with multiple sclerosis susceptibility; and (3) the combination of a high risk month of birth and vitamin D receptor polymorphisms were correlated to multiple sclerosis incidence. We observed a significantly reduced number of individuals born in November who were later diagnosed as multiple sclerosis patients. However, we found no association between the three studied vitamin D receptor polymorphisms and multiple sclerosis. In conclusion, our data suggest that high levels of vitamin D during the third trimester of pregnancy could be a protective factor for multiple sclerosis.

HLA-DRB1*15 allele influences the later course of relapsing remitting multiple sclerosis.

Most of the published works so far have aimed at finding genes associated with multiple sclerosis (MS) susceptibility. Very few studies have attempted to correlate disease features with DNA variants. In a well-characterized sample (651 patients) representative of multiple sclerosis natural history, we engaged a comprehensive study of the role of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) in the course of the disease. We investigated the role of HLA-DRB1*15 allele in samples stratified according to severity evaluated by the Multiple Sclerosis Severity Score (MSSS), time to reach EDSS 6.0 and disease type. We found that HLA-DRB1*15 genotype does not influence MS severity even among patients presenting with a given type of the disease. However, we show for the first time that HLA-DRB1*15 allele modulates the course of MS for relapsing-remitting (RR) onset patients likely by precipitating the secondary progressive (SP) phase.

IL2RA and IL7RA genes confer susceptibility for multiple sclerosis in two independent European populations.

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is the most common chronic inflammatory neurologic disorder diagnosed in young adults and, due to its chronic course, is responsible for a substantial economic burden. MS is considered to be a multifactorial disease in which both genetic and environmental factors intervene. The well-established human leukocyte antigen (HLA) association does not completely explain the genetic impact on disease susceptibility. However, identification and validation of non-HLA-genes conferring susceptibility to MS has proven to be difficult probably because of the small individual contribution of each of these genes. Recently, associations with two single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the IL2RA gene (rs12722489, rs2104286) and one SNP in the IL7RA gene (rs6897932) have been reported by several groups. These three SNPs were genotyped in a French and a German population of MS patients using the hME assay by the matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time of flight technology (Sequenom, San Diego, CA, USA). We show that these SNPs do contribute to the risk of MS in these two unrelated European MS patient populations with odds ratios varying from 1.1 to 1.5. The discovery and validation of new genetic risk factors in independent populations may help toward the understanding of MS pathogenesis by providing valuable information on biological pathways to be investigated.

[What's new in multiple sclerosis genetics?]. / Où en sont les études génétiques de la SEP?

INTRODUCTION: Multiple Sclerosis (MS) is a multifactorial disorder caused by the interaction of environmental factors with a genetic predisposition. BACKGROUND: The chromosomal region comprising MHC contains one or several genes which contributes from 20 to 50 p. 100 to MS genetic predisposition. Other genes are unknown but are likely to have an individual contribution less than MHC. PERSPECTIVES AND CONCLUSION: Large DNA collections, high output genotyping facilities, a precise knowledge of the human genome and adequate statistical methods should allow the identification of MS predisposition genes.

Strategy for detecting susceptibility genes with weak or no marginal effect.

Most human diseases result from complex interactions among multiple genes that yield weak or modest effects. Despite the growing awareness of the importance of gene-gene interactions, the paradigm of detectable effects of individual variants remains the cornerstone of genome association studies with tagSNPs. The interactive effect of two variants is only tested once the individual effect of one variant is detected. Both genes, however, may have at the same time a weak (or even no) marginal effect but an important effect through their interaction. In such a situation, current approaches may fail to detect variants having a crucial role in the causal chain. Here, we propose a new strategy: the 2-locus TDT. It allows the detection of the involvement of two genes without individual effect. Our strategy simultaneously uses information on biallelic candidate polymorphisms in two genes M and N. We first estimate the relative marginal penetrances of the genotype at each locus and of the joint (two-locus) genotype and then we test for the interactive effect of the two genes using a likelihood ratio test. We show that our approach has good power to detect the effect of two genes in situations for which a locus-by-locus strategy would have been unsuccessful. At a time where genome-wide association studies are fashionable, we think it is important to consider the strategy of studying good candidate pathways with our approach.

A family-based study does not confirm the association of MYO9B with celiac disease in the Italian population.

Association between Myosin IXB (MYO9B) gene polymorphisms and celiac disease (CD) was recently detected by a case-control association study in the Dutch, but not confirmed in the British and Swedish/Norwegian populations. We tested the association between CD and the three most associated single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the Dutch study by the transmission disequilibrium test in the Italian population. A total of 252 pediatric patients and 504 parents were genotyped. No transmission distortion was detected either for the single SNPs or for their haplotypic combinations. Control allele frequencies, calculated from untransmitted alleles, were significantly different from those of the Dutch control population. Conversely, allele frequencies were very similar in Italian, British, Swedish/Norwegian and Dutch patients. In conclusion, MYO9B is not involved in CD susceptibility in the Italian population. The difference with the Dutch result might be explained by an imperfect selection of the Dutch controls.

HLA-DQ relative risks for coeliac disease in European populations: a study of the European Genetics Cluster on Coeliac Disease.

Coeliac disease is an enteropathy due to an intolerance to gluten. The association between HLA-DQ genes and CD is well established. The majority of patients carry the HLA-DQ heterodimer encoded by DQA1*05/DQB1*02, either in cis or in trans. The remaining patients carry either part of the DQ heterodimer or DQA1*03-DQB1*0302. The aim of the study was to estimate the risks associated with different DQ genotypes in European populations. HLA information was available for 470 trio families from four countries: France (117), Italy (128), and Norway and Sweden (225). Five DQA1-DQB1 haplotypes were considered and control haplotype frequencies were estimated from the set of parental haplotypes not transmitted to the affected child. The possible genotypes were grouped into five genotype groups, based on the hierarchy of risk reported in the literature. A north-south gradient in the genotype group frequencies is observed in probands: homogeneity is strongly rejected between all country pairs. For each country, the relative risks associated with each genotype group were computed taking into account the control haplotype frequencies. Homogeneity of relative risks between countries was tested pairwise by maximum likelihood ratio statistics. The hypothesis of homogeneity of relative risks is rejected (P is approximately 10(-6)) for all country pairs. In conclusion, the gradient in the genotype group frequencies in probands is not only due to differences in haplotype frequencies but also due to differences in genotype relative risks in the studied populations; the relative risks associated with each DQ genotype group are different between northern and southern European countries; neither are they ordered in the same way.

Candidate gene region 2q33 in European families with coeliac disease.

Chromosome region 2q33 harbours a cluster of genes, CTLA-4, CD28, ICOS and closely located PD-1, all related to immune activation and considered as promising candidate genes for susceptibility to coeliac disease (CD). We present here the results of a genetic linkage and association analysis of nine markers located in this gene region in a large combined European material of 796 families with CD from Finland, Sweden, Norway, UK, France and Italy. The joint analysis supports earlier findings that this susceptibility locus, assigned as CELIAC3, merits further studies. Nominally significant linkage to CD was found in 314 families including affected sib pairs. Each of the five populations showed weak associations to several marker alleles, but the analysis revealed, however, no conclusive evidence for a primary functional gene or gene variant present in the total set of families. The results suggest that the CD risk due to 2q33 gene region is complex and may involve more than one susceptibility allele, which possibly differ from other autoimmune diseases.

Association in multifactorial traits: how to deal with rare observations?

To detect the role of a candidate gene for a trait in a sample of individuals, we may test SNP haplotype or diplotype effects. For a limited sample size, many haplotype or diplotype categories may contain few individuals. This involves a power decrease when testing the association between the trait and the haplotypes or diplotypes as these categories provide little additional information while increasing the degrees of freedom. The present paper proposes a new strategy to group rare categories based on a measure of similarity between haplotypes or diplotypes and compares it to two other possible strategies to deal with rare categories: a SNP selection strategy based on haplotype diversity, and a grouping strategy that pools all rare categories into a single baseline group. This comparison is performed by means of simulation under four scenarios. We show that this new strategy shows the largest increase in power irrespective of the model underlying the candidate gene in the studied trait. This strategy therefore provides a powerful alternative to currently used methods to reduce the number of rare categories.

Intercellular adhesion molecule-1: a protective haplotype against multiple sclerosis.

Intercellular adhesion molecule-1 (ICAM-1) and its receptors are adhesion molecules that play a key role in the transmigration of inflammatory cells through the blood-brain barrier, one of the earliest events in multiple sclerosis (MS), which leads to demyelination in the central nervous system. To investigate the role of genes encoding ICAM-1 and its receptors, we used a strategy of genetic linkage and association in 439 case-parent MS families of French origin, well characterized according to HLA status and severity. We demonstrate that the genes encoding ICAM-1 receptors do not influence MS susceptibility or severity. ICAM-1 had a modest, but significant effect on MS genetic susceptibility, independent of HLA and disease severity. We observed a rare, and an as yet unreported, ICAM-1 gene haplotype defined by amino acids K469 and R241 that was never transmitted to patients suggesting a protective effect against MS in our population.

Saturation of the 5q31-q33 candidate region for coeliac disease.

The first genome wide screening performed on Italian affected sib-pair families (Greco et al. 1998) gave evidence for linkage with coeliac disease in the 5q region. This finding was replicated in a second independent dataset (Greco et al. 2001). Overall, pooling both samples, the highest MLS value (2.92) was found for the most centromeric marker tested, D5S640. In the present study, the 5q31-q33 region was saturated with 12 new markers around D5S640, in order to verify whether there would be a shift of the MLS position. This study allowed us to support our previous finding of linkage for the region 5q31-q33, with the most significant MLS value at D5S2014, very close to the marker D5S640. No evidence for interaction between this risk factor and the one in the HLA region was found. Furthermore, many different groups have independently obtained analogous results for this region, confirming the presence of a susceptibility locus in the region 5q31-q33. This region contains several interesting candidate genes for coeliac disease.

Improved use of SNP information to detect the role of genes.

A topical question in genetic association studies is the optimal use of the information provided by genotyped single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in order to detect the role of a candidate gene in a multifactorial disease. We propose a strategy called "combination test" that tests the association between a quantitative trait and all possible phased combinations of various numbers of SNPs. We compare this strategy to two alternative strategies: the association test that considers each SNP separately, and a multilocus genotype-based test that considers the phased combination of all SNPs together. To compare these three tests, a quantitative trait was simulated under different models of correspondence between phenotype and genotype, including the extreme case when two SNPs interact with no marginal effects of each SNP. The genotypes were taken from a sample of 290 independent individuals genotyped for three genes with various number of SNPs (from 5-8 SNPs). The results show that the "combination test" is the only one able to detect the association when the two SNPs involved in disease susceptibility interact with no marginal effects. Interestingly, even in the case of a single etiological SNP, the "combination test" performed well. We apply the three tests to Genetic Analysis Workshop 12 (Almasy et al. [2001] Genet. Epidemiol. 21:332-338) simulated data, and show that although there was no interactions between the etiological SNPs, the "combination test" was preferable to the two other compared methods to detect the role of the candidate gene.

Indication of linkage and genetic heterogeneity for asthma and atopy on chromosomes 8p and 12q in 107 French EGEA families.

Using the sample of 107 families with at least two asthmatic siblings, as part of the EGEA study, we have investigated linkage to asthma (or atopy) and genetic heterogeneity according to the presence/absence of atopy (or asthma) using two approaches: (1) the triangle test statistic (TTS), which considers the identical by descent (IBD) distribution among affected sib-pairs discordant for another associated phenotype (eg asthmatic sib-pairs discordant for atopy) and (2) the predivided sample test (PST), which compares the IBD distribution of marker alleles between affected sib-pairs concordant and discordant for the associated phenotype. Two regions, 8p and 12q, already reported to be linked to both asthma and atopy, were examined here. A total of 20 asthmatic sib-pairs discordant for atopy and 24 atopic pairs discordant for asthma were analyzed by both TTS and PST methods and 83 pairs with atopic asthma by PST. Some evidence for linkage was observed for two markers in the 8p23.3-p23.2 region; D8S504 for asthma with genetic heterogeneity according to the presence/absence of atopy and D8S503 for atopy with genetic heterogeneity according to the presence/absence of asthma. In the 12q14.2-q21.33 region, there was also some evidence of linkage to two markers, D12S83 and D12S95, for atopy and asthma, respectively, with genetic heterogeneity according to the presence/absence of the associated trait. Provided the small distance between the two markers on either 8p (16 cM) or 12q (21 cM), it is unclear whether one or two genetic factors are involved in either region.

Missing data in haplotype analysis: a study on the MILC method.

Given the enormous progress in the knowledge of the human genome, genetic markers are now available throughout the genome. Haplotype analysis, allowing the simultaneous use of information from several markers, has thus become increasingly popular. However, we often face the problem of missing data and of haplotype identification. We have proposed a haplotype based method for the genetic study of multifactorial diseases in founder populations, the MILC method (Bourgain et al. 2000). MILC is based on the contrast of identity length between haplotypes transmitted to affected offspring and haplotype non-transmitted. In this study, the impact of different strategies, regarding missing data, on the MLIC method are evaluated. A real situation is considered where data are derived from a genome screen for asthma susceptibility alleles in the Hutterites. Results are illustrated on this asthma data set.

Modeling of HLA class II susceptibility to Type I diabetes reveals an effect associated with DPB1.

In this report, we present evidence that the HLA class II DPB1 locus (or a locus with alleles in linkage disequilibrium with DPB1) contributes to Type I diabetes (IDDM) susceptibility in addition to the contribution of the HLA DR and DQ loci. The marker association segregation chi-square (MASC) method, which fits both genotype frequency and affected sib-pair identity-by-descent (IBD) distributions, was applied to 257 sib pairs affected with IDDM. Fitting DR-DQ as the sole HLA susceptibility loci was strongly rejected. Next, we considered the DPB1 contribution to disease susceptibility. Published reports indicate a predisposing role for alleles DPB1*0301 and DPB1*0202, including our previous stratification analyses of association data on this sample. IDDM probands were stratified into those not carrying the alleles DPB1*0301 and DPB1*0202 (group DPB1-A), and those carrying at least one copy of either allele (group DPB1-B). Both groups of probands have almost identical frequencies of DR and DQ haplotypes but significantly different IBD distributions in the subset of families with probands who do not carry the highly predisposing DR3/DR4 genotype. In these data, DPB1 (or a locus in linkage disequilibrium), in addition to DR-DQ, is involved in IDDM susceptibility and affects IBD in the HLA region. Addition of DPB1 in a genetic model of IDDM gives a better fit to the data than consideration of DR-DQ alone. Our results are consistent with previous reports implicating DPB1 in IDDM susceptibility.

Use of haplotype information to test involvement of the LRP gene in Alzheimer's disease in the French population.

The low density lipoprotein receptor-related protein gene (LRP) is a good candidate gene for Alzheimer's Disease (AD). Its protein is involved in the physiopathology of AD and has been found in senile plaques; on the other hand, LRP is located in 12q, a region in which genetic linkage to AD was reported. Two common polymorphisms, a tetranucleotide repeat in the 5' untranslated region and a single nucleotide polymorphism at position 766 in exon 3, were found to be associated with AD, but contradictory results were obtained in subsequent association studies. In the absence of clear hypotheses concerning the association of these polymorphisms with AD and their functional role, our objective was to test the association between AD and the two LRP polymorphisms in a large French case-control sample (274 Caucasian AD patients and 290 matched controls) using haplotype analysis. First, the separate study of each polymorphism showed no significant difference in genotype and allele frequencies between AD cases and controls. Second, strong linkage disequilibrium was found between alleles of the two polymorphisms in controls and in cases and the linkage disequilibrium between the 91 bp and C alleles were opposite in cases and in controls. Third, we found that the frequency of the 91-C haplotype was higher in cases than in controls, but the type I error was 0.061, slightly higher than the conventional one of 5%. The haplotype frequencies did not vary significantly as a function of age and APOE epsilon4 status. One interest in this study is the use of the haplotype analysis, which can be used to combine information from several polymorphisms, taking into account their dependence.

Existence of a genetic risk factor on chromosome 5q in Italian coeliac disease families.

Coeliac disease (CD) is a malabsorptive disorder of the small intestine resulting from ingestion of gluten. The HLA risk factors involved in CD are well known but do not explain the whole genetic susceptibility. Several regions of potential linkage on chromosomes 3q, 5q, 10q, 11q, 15q and 19q have already been reported in the literature. These six regions were analyzed with the Maximum Lod Score method on a dense set of markers. A new sample of 89 Italian sibpairs was available for study. There was no evidence for linkage for any of the regions tested, except for chromosome 5q. For this region, our data, as well as a sample of 93 sibpairs from our first genome screen (Greco et al. 1998), are compatible with the presence of a risk factor for CD with a moderate effect.