Representation of genetic association via attributable familial relative risks in order to identify polymorphisms functionally relevant to rheumatoid arthritis.

The results from association studies are usually summarized by a measure of evidence of association (frequentist or Bayesian probability values) that does not directly reflect the impact of the detected signals on familial aggregation. This article investigates the possible advantage of a two-dimensional representation of genetic association in order to identify polymorphisms relevant to disease: a measure of evidence of association (the Bayes factor, BF) combined with the estimated contribution to familiality (the attributable sibling relative risk, lambdas). Simulation and data from the North American Rheumatoid Consortium (NARAC) were used to assess the possible benefit under several scenarios. Simulation indicated that the allele frequencies to reach the maximum BF and the maximum attributable lambdas diverged as the size of the genetic effect increased. The representation of BF versus attributable lambdas for selected regions of NARAC data revealed that SNPs involved in replicated associations clearly departed from the bulk of SNPs in these regions. In the 12 investigated regions, and particularly in the low-recombination major histocompatibility region, the ranking of SNPs according to BF differed from the ranking of SNPs according to attributable lambdas. The present results should be generalized using more extensive simulations and additional real data, but they suggest that a characterization of genetic association by both BF and attributable lambdas may result in an improved ranking of variants for further biological analyses.

Haplotype-based analysis: a summary of GAW16 Group 4 analysis.

In this summary article, we describe the contributions included in the haplotype-based analysis group (Group 4) at the Genetic Analysis Workshop 16, which was held in September 17-20, 2008. Our group applied a large number of haplotype-based methods in the context of genome-wide association studies. Two general approaches were applied: a two-stage approach that selected significant single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in the first stage and then created haplotypes in the second stage and genome-wide analysis of smaller sets of SNPs selected by sliding windows or estimating haplotype blocks. Genome-wide haplotype analyses performed in these ways were feasible. The presence of the very strong chromosome 6 association in the North American Rheumatoid Arthritis Consortium data was detected by every method, and additional analyses attempted to control for this strong result to allow detection of additional haplotype associations.