Is ultraviolet light disinfection fit to be the future standard for the disinfection of flexible endoscopes without a working channel?

OBJECTIVE: To investigate colony-forming unit (CFU) reduction on contaminated flexible endoscopes (FEs) without a working channel after UV-C light disinfection, compared to the current disinfection method with the endoscope washer disinfector (EWD). DESIGN, SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS: After pharyngolaryngoscopy, a manual pre-cleaning with tap water was performed. A culture was then collected by rolling the distal 8-10 cm of the FE over an Agar plate. The FE was disinfected using the D60 (60-s disinfection process with UV-C light) or the EWD (gold standard reprocessing process with water and chemicals). Another culture was then taken. After incubation, a CFU count was performed. RESULTS: A total of 200 FEs without a working channel were divided equally between the two disinfection groups. After clinical use and manual pre-cleaning, 84 of the 100 (84.0%) (UV-C light group) and 79 of the 100 (79.0%) (EWD) FEs were contaminated with at least 1 CFU. FEs that showed no contamination after use were excluded from further analysis. After disinfection with UV-C light, 72 (85.7%) FEs showed no contamination (i.e., 0 CFUs) versus 66 (83.5%) FEs after reprocessing with the EWD. CONCLUSION: There is no difference in CFUs reduction on contaminated FEs without a working channel between UV-C light disinfection and the current gold standard, the EWD.

Description and results of a new method for assessing real-life performance of a UV-C disinfection robot.

Background: Due to the disadvantages of manual disinfection of patient rooms, mobile disinfection robots using ultraviolet C (UV-C) radiation are increasingly being used. Assessing their in situ effectiveness remains challenging. Aim: This study describes a new method to prove adequate in situ disinfection (≥5-log reduction in bacterial load), and uses this method to assess the efficacy of a mobile disinfection robot using UV-C radiation. Methods: Agar plates serving as proxies for smooth surfaces in patient rooms were inoculated with bacterial suspension and placed on various surfaces in a patient room. After irradiation by an automated mobile UV-C robot, reduction in colony growth was determined by comparing the irradiated plates to a reference series of non-irradiated plates, enabling the evaluation of whether an adequate reduction in colony-forming units (CFU's) of ≥5-log was reached on these irradiated surfaces. Findings: The new technique described here proved a successful method for demonstrating an in situ ≥5-log reduction in CFU's for five different bacterial pathogens. Of the 32 plates placed on UV-accessible surfaces, 31 showed an adequate reduction in CFU's of ≥5-log. One plate could not be assessed. Conclusion: Inoculated agar plates placed in patient rooms before irradiation and subsequently compared to a reference series can be used to assess in situ efficacy of mobile disinfection robots using UV-C radiation. Our findings support the idea that UV-C robots, used adjunctively to conventional manual washing and disinfection, may achieve adequate bacterial load reduction on UV-accessible smooth surfaces in patient rooms for a selected subset of pathogens.