Factors influencing the solubilization of membrane proteins from Escherichia coli membranes by styrene-maleic acid copolymers.

Styrene-maleic acid (SMA) copolymers are a promising alternative to detergents for the solubilization of membrane proteins. Here we employ Escherichia coli membranes containing KcsA as a model protein to investigate the influence of different environmental conditions on SMA solubilization efficiency. We show that SMA concentration, temperature, incubation time, ionic strength, presence of divalent cations and pH all influence the amount of protein that is extracted by SMA. The observed effects are consistent with observations from lipid-only model membrane systems, with the exception of the effect of pH. Increasing pH from 7 to 9 was found to result in an increase of the solubilization yield of E. coli membranes, whereas in lipid-only model systems it decreased over the same pH range, based on optical density (OD) measurements. Similar opposite pH-dependent effects were observed in OD experiments comparing solubilization of native yeast membranes and yeast lipid-only membranes. We propose a model in which pH-dependent electrostatic interactions affect binding of the polymers to extramembraneous parts of membrane proteins, which in turn affects the availability of polymer for membrane solubilization. This model is supported by the observations that a similar pH-dependence as for SMA is observed for the anionic detergent SDS, but not for the nonionic detergent DDM and that the pH-dependence can be largely overcome by increasing the SMA concentration. The results are useful as guidelines to derive optimal conditions for solubilization of biological membranes by SMA.

Correction: Bacillus subtilis MraY in detergent-free system of nanodiscs wrapped by styrene-maleic acid copolymers.

[This corrects the article DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0206692.].

Bacillus subtilis MraY in detergent-free system of nanodiscs wrapped by styrene-maleic acid copolymers.

As an integral membrane protein, purification and characterization of phospho-N- acetylmuramyl- pentapeptide translocase MraY have proven difficult. Low yield and concerns of retaining stability and activity after detergent solubilization have hampered the structure-function analysis. The recently developed detergent-free styrene-maleic acid (SMA) co-polymer system offers an alternative approach that may overcome these disadvantages. In this study, we used the detergent free system to purify MraY from Bacillus subtilis. This allowed efficient extraction of MraY that was heterologously produced in Escherichia coli membranes into SMA-wrapped nanodiscs. The purified MraY embedded in these nanodiscs (SMA-MraY) was comparable to the micellar MraY extracted with a conventional detergent (DDM) with regard to the yield and the purity of the recombinant protein but required significantly less time. The predominantly alpha-helical secondary structure of the protein in SMA-wrapped nanodiscs was also more stable against heat denaturation compared to the micellar protein. Thus, this detergent-free system is amenable to extract MraY efficiently and effectively while maintaining the biophysical properties of the protein. However, the apparent activity of the SMA-MraY was reduced compared to that of the detergent-solubilized protein. The present data indicates that this is caused by a lower accessibility of the enzyme in SMA-wrapped nanodiscs towards its polyisoprenoid substrate.

Solubilization of human cells by the styrene-maleic acid copolymer: Insights from fluorescence microscopy.

Extracting membrane proteins from biological membranes by styrene-maleic acid copolymers (SMAs) in the form of nanodiscs has developed into a powerful tool in membrane research. However, the mode of action of membrane (protein) solubilization in a cellular context is still poorly understood and potential specificity for cellular compartments has not been investigated. Here, we use fluorescence microscopy to visualize the process of SMA solubilization of human cells, exemplified by the immortalized human HeLa cell line. Using fluorescent protein fusion constructs that mark distinct subcellular compartments, we found that SMA solubilizes membranes in a concentration-dependent multi-stage process. While all major intracellular compartments were affected without a strong preference, plasma membrane solubilization was found to be generally slower than the solubilization of organelle membranes. Interestingly, some plasma membrane-localized proteins were more resistant against solubilization than others, which might be explained by their presence in specific membrane domains with differing properties. Our results support the general applicability of SMA for the isolation of membrane proteins from different types of (sub)cellular membranes.

Proton-Detected Solid-State NMR Spectroscopy of a Zinc Diffusion Facilitator Protein in Native Nanodiscs.

The structure, dynamics, and function of membrane proteins are intimately linked to the properties of the membrane environment in which the proteins are embedded. For structural and biophysical characterization, membrane proteins generally need to be extracted from the membrane and reconstituted in a suitable membrane-mimicking environment. Ensuring functional and structural integrity in these environments is often a major concern. The styrene/maleic acid co-polymer has recently been shown to be able to extract lipid/membrane protein patches directly from native membranes to form nanosize discoidal proteolipid particles, also referred to as native nanodiscs. In this work, we show that high-resolution solid-state NMR spectra can be obtained from an integral membrane protein in native nanodiscs, as exemplified by the 2×34 kDa bacterial cation diffusion facilitator CzcD.

Solubilization of lipids and lipid phases by the styrene-maleic acid copolymer.

A promising tool in membrane research is the use of the styrene-maleic acid (SMA) copolymer to solubilize membranes in the form of nanodiscs. Since membranes are heterogeneous in composition, it is important to know whether SMA thereby has a preference for solubilization of either specific types of lipids or specific bilayer phases. Here, we investigated this by performing partial solubilization of model membranes and analyzing the lipid composition of the solubilized fraction. We found that SMA displays no significant lipid preference in homogeneous binary lipid mixtures in the fluid phase, even when using lipids that by themselves show very different solubilization kinetics. By contrast, in heterogeneous phase-separated bilayers, SMA was found to have a strong preference for solubilization of lipids in the fluid phase as compared to those in either a gel phase or a liquid-ordered phase. Together the results suggest that (1) SMA is a reliable tool to characterize native interactions between membrane constituents, (2) any solubilization preference of SMA is not due to properties of individual lipids but rather due to properties of the membrane or membrane domains in which these lipids reside and (3) exploiting SMA resistance rather than detergent resistance may be an attractive approach for the isolation of ordered domains from biological membranes.

Effect of Polymer Composition and pH on Membrane Solubilization by Styrene-Maleic Acid Copolymers.

The styrene-maleic acid (SMA) copolymer is rapidly gaining attention as a tool in membrane research, due to its ability to directly solubilize lipid membranes into nanodisk particles without the requirement of conventional detergents. Although many variants of SMA are commercially available, so far only SMA variants with a 2:1 and 3:1 styrene-to-maleic acid ratio have been used in lipid membrane studies. It is not known how SMA composition affects the solubilization behavior of SMA. Here, we systematically investigated the effect of varying the styrene/maleic acid on the properties of SMA in solution and on its interaction with membranes. Also the effect of pH was studied, because the proton concentration in the solution will affect the charge density and thereby may modulate the properties of the polymers. Using model membranes of 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine lipids at pH > pHagg, we found that membrane solubilization is promoted by a low charge density and by a relatively high fraction of maleic acid units in the polymer. Furthermore, it was found that a collapsed conformation of the polymer is required to ensure efficient insertion into the lipid membrane and that efficient solubilization may be improved by a more homogenous distribution of the maleic acid monomer units along the polymer chain. Altogether, the results show large differences in behavior between the SMA variants tested in the various steps of solubilization. The main conclusion is that the variant with a 2:1 styrene-to-maleic acid ratio is the most efficient membrane solubilizer in a wide pH range.

The styrene-maleic acid copolymer: a versatile tool in membrane research.

A new and promising tool in membrane research is the detergent-free solubilization of membrane proteins by styrene-maleic acid copolymers (SMAs). These amphipathic molecules are able to solubilize lipid bilayers in the form of nanodiscs that are bounded by the polymer. Thus, membrane proteins can be directly extracted from cells in a water-soluble form while conserving a patch of native membrane around them. In this review article, we briefly discuss current methods of membrane protein solubilization and stabilization. We then zoom in on SMAs, describe their physico-chemical properties, and discuss their membrane-solubilizing effect. This is followed by an overview of studies in which SMA has been used to isolate and investigate membrane proteins. Finally, potential future applications of the methodology are discussed for structural and functional studies on membrane proteins in a near-native environment and for characterizing protein-lipid and protein-protein interactions.

Detergent-free isolation, characterization, and functional reconstitution of a tetrameric K+ channel: the power of native nanodiscs.

A major obstacle in the study of membrane proteins is their solubilization in a stable and active conformation when using detergents. Here, we explored a detergent-free approach to isolating the tetrameric potassium channel KcsA directly from the membrane of Escherichia coli, using a styrene-maleic acid copolymer. This polymer self-inserts into membranes and is capable of extracting membrane patches in the form of nanosize discoidal proteolipid particles or "native nanodiscs." Using circular dichroism and tryptophan fluorescence spectroscopy, we show that the conformation of KcsA in native nanodiscs is very similar to that in detergent micelles, but that the thermal stability of the protein is higher in the nanodiscs. Furthermore, as a promising new application, we show that quantitative analysis of the co-isolated lipids in purified KcsA-containing nanodiscs allows determination of preferential lipid-protein interactions. Thin-layer chromatography experiments revealed an enrichment of the anionic lipids cardiolipin and phosphatidylglycerol, indicating their close proximity to the channel in biological membranes and supporting their functional relevance. Finally, we demonstrate that KcsA can be reconstituted into planar lipid bilayers directly from native nanodiscs, which enables functional characterization of the channel by electrophysiology without first depriving the protein of its native environment. Together, these findings highlight the potential of the use of native nanodiscs as a tool in the study of ion channels, and of membrane proteins in general.