Recurrence after radiotherapy for glottic carcinoma.

A series of 478 patients with T1-3N0 glottic carcinoma treated by irradiation is presented. Of these patients, 320 were previously untreated, whereas 158 patients were referred for treatment of a recurrence after receiving radiotherapy elsewhere. The primary recurrence rate in the previously untreated patients was 10%. The rate was higher in T2 and T3 tumors, poorly differentiated tumors, and in patients who were in poor general condition. Over 80% of the recurrent tumors were Stage pT3 or pT4, whereas 12% of total laryngectomy specimens showed necrosis only with no evidence of tumor. The necrosis rate in previously untreated patients was 1% for T1 tumors, 4% for T2 tumors, and 3% for T3 tumors. Of all tumors, 60% were transglottic when they recurred, whereas only 29% were confined to the glottis at recurrence. Histologic diagnosis had a high sensitivity but a low specificity, indicating that a negative histologic report is unreliable. Of patients with a recurrent primary tumor, 13% were untreatable. The 5-year survival after a primary recurrence was 39%, and the main prognostic factors were sex, T stage at recurrence, and time to recurrence. Of patients available for follow-up at 5 years 49% were alive with a larynx, 5% were alive without a larynx, 13% were dead of the original cancer, and 33% had died of other causes. In those suffering a primary recurrence, the commonest cause of death was a subsequent lymph node metastasis, followed in order of frequency by stomal recurrence and recurrence in the pharyngeal remnant. The hospital mortality rate after laryngectomy was 3%, and 30% of patients undergoing laryngectomy developed a pharyngocutaneous fistula. The recurrence rate in lymph nodes was 14% at 5 years, general condition and T stage being the only significant predictors of recurrence. Only 17% of patients had small (N1) nodes by the time the diagnosis of cervical lymph node recurrence was made, and 27% of all patients were unsuitable for treatment. Host, tumor factors, and time to recurrence were not significant predictors of survival after node recurrence. The survival rate 5 years after node recurrence was 16%, and the main cause of death in those who died was uncontrolled disease in the neck. The hospital mortality after salvage neck dissection was 4.7%.

Recurrence of oropharyngeal carcinoma after radiotherapy.

Two-hundred-and-twenty-one patients with squamous carcinoma of the oropharynx treated by irradiation are presented. The primary recurrence rate at five years in the previously untreated patients was 27%, but was dictated by neither host factors (age, sex and general condition) nor tumour factors (site, T-stage and histological grade). Pre-operative histological diagnosis had a very high sensitivity but a low specificity, indicating that false positives are common but false negatives unusual. Twenty per cent of patients with a recurrent primary tumour were untreatable. The five year survival after a primary recurrence was 31 per cent. Sixty-eight per cent of patients undergoing major surgery recovered without a major complication, and the hospital mortality rate was three per cent, due entirely to major medical catastrophes. The major complication rate in those undergoing flap repair after major resection was seven per cent. The metastatic rate in lymph nodes was 44 per cent at five years, and again this did not depend on any host or tumour factors. The survival at five years after node recurrence was a mere 19 per cent, and the length of survival was related to the primary site of the original tumour and the presence of extranodal disease. Two-thirds of patients had advanced disease (N2 and N3) when node recurrence was diagnosed and about 15 per cent were unsuitable for surgery.

Anaplastic carcinoma presenting with cervical lymphadenopathy.

We describe 50 patients with anaplastic carcinoma presenting with a mass in the neck. The diagnosis of anaplastic carcinoma was confirmed by immunocytochemistry to exclude very poorly differentiated squamous carcinomas, amelanotic melanoma, and non-Hodgkin's lymphoma. The primary site was established immediately in 26 patients (25 in the head and neck; 1 in the lung); a further 4 had radiological evidence of a primary tumour in the lung. The primary site was established later in 1 patient, in the ethmoid sinuses. In 20 patients the primary site was never established. The commonest primary site was the nasopharynx. The basic treatment policy was radiotherapy, although 20% of patients with a known primary tumour, and 50% of those without, were untreated. The 2-year survival was about 30% in both groups, and did not differ significantly. Prognostic factors for survival were age, performance status, and T status of the primary tumour. Sex, node status, node level, and laterality of nodes, were not.

First interim progress report on the second British Institute of Radiology Fractionation Study: short versus long overall treatment times for radiotherapy of carcinoma of the laryngopharynx.

Preliminary data from a second British Institute of Radiology Fractionation Trial comparing short (less than or equal to 4 weeks) and long (greater than 4 weeks) overall treatment times are reported. The intake of patients ran from January, 1975 to December, 1985 when 611 patients with carcinoma of the laryngo-pharynx were registered in this prospective, randomized, multicentre clinical trial. No significant differences have, so far, been demonstrated between the two arms of the trial with respect to observed survival rates, tumour-free or laryngectomy-free rates. Further long-term follow-up is continuing.

Induction VBM plus radiotherapy, versus radiotherapy alone for advanced head and neck cancer: long-term results.

Between 1978 and 1981, 85 patients with advanced squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck were randomized to receive induction VBM followed by radiotherapy, or radiotherapy alone. The shortest follow-up is thus 6 years. The median survival of patients receiving induction chemotherapy was 46 weeks, that of the radiotherapy group alone was 75 weeks. As the two groups were not balanced despite randomization, multivariate methods (GLIM) were used to identify significant prognostic factors. These were: response to radiotherapy (P less than 0.001), nodal status (P less than 0.001), age (P less than 0.01), and histological grade (P less than 0.01). Neither treatment with, nor response to, chemotherapy had a significant effect on survival.

The treatment of early (T1) glottic and supra-glottic carcinoma: does partial laryngectomy have a place?

A series of 900 patients with laryngeal carcinoma is described. Patients with glottic T1N0 tumours were treated by radiotherapy with a 5-year survival of 92%. Seven per cent of patients suffered recurrence and most were salvaged by surgery: vertical hemilaryngectomy was occasionally useful as a salvage procedure. Patients with supra-glottic T1N0 tumours were treated for the first 7 years by supra-glottic laryngectomy and prophylactic neck dissection and thereafter by radiotherapy. The results were equally good in both series: a 5-year survival of 75-80%. Salvage surgery for failed radiotherapy or surgery for supra-glottic carcinoma gave poor results.

The fixed cervical lymph node.

A series of almost 2000 patients with squamous carcinoma of the head and neck is presented. Seven percent of the patients had massive fixed glands at the time of presentation. The incidence of fixed nodes varied between sites, and increased with increasing T-stage of the primary tumor. Forty percent of the patients were treated; the most common cause for withholding treatment was advanced age. Radiotherapy did not produce a significant prolongation of survival, but surgery did. Resection of the mandible, the skin of the neck, and the external carotid artery proved to be valuable procedures both in terms of palliation and survival; radical surgery produced a 5-year survival of approximately 15%.

Sequential chemotherapy and radiotherapy in advanced head and neck cancer.

Eighty-six previously untreated patients with advanced squamous-cell carcinoma of the head and neck were entered into a prospective randomised controlled trial to evaluate whether the addition of a kinetically based chemotherapy regimen before and after radiotherapy would improve survival compared with radiotherapy alone. Survival at 30 months showed there was no evidence that the addition of chemotherapy to radiotherapy improved survival and that the chance of obtaining a significant result in favour of adjuvant chemotherapy was remote. We make a strong plea that all chemotherapy regimens for the treatment of squamous-cell carcinoma of the head and neck regions should be subjected to controlled prospective trials before they are widely adopted.

Seventh interim progress report of the british institute of radiology fractionation study of 3F/week versus 5F/week in radiotherapy of the laryngo-pharynx.

A fresh analysis of the data entered into the multicentre BIR fractionation trial of 3F/week versus 5F/week in radiotherapy of the laryngopharynx has been undertaken. Completed records of the 732 patients initially entered into the trial have now risen from 687 at the last report to 706. The data have been analysed in a manner similar to that adopted previously so as to measure the effects of the two regimes on both tumour and normal tissues, and some additional analyses have now also been made. There have been some modifications in the results in the various sub-groups which may be due to an inadequate number of patients having been followed up for long enough at the time of the previous analyses. More data for late radiation damage to normal tissues and new radiobiological findings have suggested possible explanations for the differences which have emerged between the two groups. The apparent differences between the sub-groups containing patients with highly localized tumours, which were reported in our previous report, are now less marked and not statistically significant.

Management of post-cricoid carcinoma.

This paper discusses the results of treatment of post-cricoid carcinoma based on a personal series of 141 patients. The following conclusions can be drawn: small tumours with no clinical evidence of cervical lymph node metastasis should almost certainly be treated with radiotherapy, which gives a 5-year survival of approximately 35%. Surgery for recurrent disease after radiotherapy if fraught with complications, and satisfactory salvage is seldom possible. Surgery for larger tumours and those associated with neck node metastases has a lower (20%) 5-year survival with a high incidence of complications. The main problem after pharyngolaryngectomy is replacement of the pharynx. There is no evidence that any one of the methods in common use (skin flaps, transposition of the colon or stomach) is superior to any other.

The management of glottic T3 carcinoma.

In the treatment of glottic T3 carcinoma there are four possible methods (1) primary radical surgery, (2) primary radical radiotherapy, (3) radical surgery with preoperative irradiation or (4) partial surgery. This study shows that patients treated primarily by surgery achieve worse results than those treated by radiotherapy.