Routine childhood vaccination rates in an academic family health team before and during the first wave of the COVID-19 pandemic: a pre-post analysis of a retrospective chart review.

BACKGROUND: There has been concern about declining routine vaccination rates during the COVID-19 pandemic. We evaluated the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on early childhood vaccination rates at 2 sites of an academic family health team in the Greater Toronto Area, Ontario, serving both an urban and suburban patient population. METHODS: We conducted a pre-post analysis of vaccination records from Jan. 1, 2018, to Nov. 30, 2020, for a cohort of children born between Jan. 1, 2018, and Aug. 31, 2020, from the electronic medical record (EMR) of the Mount Sinai Academic Family Health Team (including an urban academic site in Toronto and a suburban community site in Vaughan, Ontario). We estimated the proportion of children receiving timely, delayed or no vaccination for 10 publicly funded vaccines in the Ontario immunization schedule for the pre-COVID-19 (Jan. 1, 2018, to Mar. 16, 2020) and COVID-19 (Mar. 17 to Nov. 30, 2020) pandemic periods. We determined timeliness in accordance with the recommended age of administration, with a 28-day window; we considered vaccines administered after this window to be delayed. We estimated the median time to vaccination for each vaccine and present cumulative incidence curves. RESULTS: The patient population was balanced between boys (52.4%) and girls (47.6%), with an average age of 18.5 months and representation across low-, middle- and high-income groups. Of the 506 children in our cohort, 422 were up to date with vaccinations (83.4%) by the end of the study period. Comparatively, 308 (83.2%) of the 370 eligible patients were up to date for all required vaccinations by the end of the pre-COVID-19 period. Among children younger than 12 months, vaccination rates were similar in the pre-COVID-19 and COVID-19 pandemic periods. Lower rates of timely vaccination for children between 12 and 18 months of age were amplified during the pandemic. Cumulative incidence curves were suggestive of a decrease in the timeliness of vaccinations in the COVID-19 period for the vaccines administered at 12, 15 and 18 months, compared with the pre-COVID-19 period. INTERPRETATION: Our local findings suggest a deterioration in the uptake of routine childhood vaccines in children aged 12 to 18 months in the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic. Further study is needed to determine the extent of the vaccination gap in children across Canada, including the impact of subsequent waves of the COVID-19 pandemic.

Development and evaluation of a primary care antimicrobial stewardship program (PC-ASP) in Toronto, Ontario, Canada.

Background: Effective community-based antimicrobial stewardship programs (ASPs) are needed because 90% of antimicrobials are prescribed in the community. A primary care ASP (PC-ASP) was evaluated for its effectiveness in lowering antibiotic prescriptions for six common infections. Methods: A multi-faceted educational program was assessed using a before-and-after design in four primary care clinics from 2015 through 2017. The primary outcome was the difference between control and intervention clinics in total antibiotic prescriptions for six common infections before and after the intervention. Secondary outcomes included changes in condition-specific antibiotic use, delayed antibiotic prescriptions, prescriptions exceeding 7 days duration, use of recommended antibiotics, and emergency department visits or hospitalizations within 30 days. Multi-method models adjusting for demographics, case mix, and clustering by physician were used to estimate treatment effects. Results: Total antibiotic prescriptions in control and intervention clinics did not differ (difference in differences = 1.7%; 95% CI -12.5% to 15.9%), nor did use of delayed prescriptions (-5.2%; 95% CI -24.2% to 13.8%). Prescriptions for longer than 7 days were significantly reduced (-21.3%; 95% CI -42.5% to -0.1%). However, only 781 of 1,777 encounters (44.0%) involved providers who completed the ASP education. Where providers completed the education, delayed prescriptions increased 17.7% (p = 0.06), and prescriptions exceeding 7 days duration declined (-27%; 95% CI -48.3% to -5.6%). Subsequent emergency department visits and hospitalizations did not increase. Conclusions: PC-ASP effectiveness on antibiotic use was variable. Shorter prescription durations and increased use of delayed prescriptions were adopted by engaged primary care providers.

Historique: Des programmes de gestion antimicrobienne (PGA) communautaires efficaces doivent exister, parce que 90 % des antimicrobiens sont prescrits dans la communauté. Des chercheurs ont évalué un PGA en première ligne (PGA-PL) afin d'en déterminer l'efficacité à réduire les prescriptions d'antibiotiques pour six infections courantes. Méthodologie: Les chercheurs ont évalué un programme de formation polyvalent au moyen d'une méthodologie avant-après dans quatre cliniques de soins de première ligne entre 2015 et 2017. Le résultat clinique primaire était la différence entre les cliniques de contrôle et d'intervention pour ce qui est du total de prescriptions antibiotiques contre six infections courantes avant et après l'intervention. Les résultats cliniques secondaires incluaient des modifications à l'utilisation des antibiotiques propres au trouble de santé, le report des prescriptions d'antibiotiques, des prescriptions de plus de sept jours, l'utilisation des antibiotiques recommandés et les visites à l'urgence ou les hospitalisations dans les 30 jours. Les chercheurs ont utilisé des méthodes multimodèles tenant compte de la démographie, du mélange de cas et du regroupement par médecin pour évaluer l'effet des traitements. Résultats: Les prescriptions totales d'antibiotiques dans les cliniques de contrôle et d'intervention ne différaient pas (différences des différences = 1,7 %; IC à 95 %, ­12,5 % à 15,9 %), ni l'utilisation de prescriptions reportées (­5,2 %; IC à 95 %, ­24,2 % à 13,8 %). Les prescriptions de plus de sept jours étaient très peu courantes (­21,3 %; IC à 95 %, ­42,5 % à ­0,1 %). Cependant, seulement 781 des 1 777 rencontres (44,0 %) avaient eu lieu avec des dispensateurs qui avaient suivi la formation sur le PGA. Lorsque les dispensateurs avaient suivi la formation, les reports de prescriptions augmentaient de 17,7 % (p = 0,06) et les prescriptions de plus de sept jours diminuaient (­27 %; IC à 95 %, ­48,3 % à ­5,6 %). Les visites subséquentes à l'urgence et les hospitalisations n'ont pas augmenté. Conclusions: L'efficacité du PGA-PL pour l'utilisation d'antibiotiques était variable. Les dispensateurs de soins de première ligne qui y avaient participé préparaient des prescriptions de moins longue durée et reportaient davantage leurs prescriptions.