Review of economic methods used in complementary medicine.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this research is to review the economic methods used in complementary medicine (CM). METHOD: A comprehensive literature review was undertaken (1995-2007) to identify peer-reviewed articles related to economic methods used in CM. RESULTS: The literature found 15 full economic evaluations of CM: 3 in the manipulative and body-based practices, 5 in the whole medical systems, and 7 in the biologically based practices. No evaluations were identified for the areas of mind-body medicine, alternative medical systems, or energy medicine. The review failed to locate any articles that used alternate economic methods such as contingent valuation or discrete choice modelling. The overall consensus from the 15 economic evaluations, despite variations in project design and methodological rigor, was that CM, as evaluated in these studies, was cost-effective compared to usual care. CONCLUSIONS: As health care costs continue to rise, decision makers, both consumers and policymakers, must allocate scarce resources toward those treatments that offer the best value for the money. Considerable scope exists to advance the science behind CM through a more systematic integration of economic methods into CM research.

Direct cardiac effects of coronary site-directed thiopental and its enantiomers: a comparison to propofol in conscious sheep.

BACKGROUND: Previous evidence from laboratory animal studies indicates that R-thiopental has a greater margin of safety than either the more potent S-thiopental or the clinically used rac-thiopental. Although thiopental can cause cardiovascular depression from direct myocardial effects as well as indirect central nervous system and peripheral effects, no studies have yet determined whether its myocardial effects are enantioselective. A lesser direct effect would provide further evidence supporting R-thiopental as a preferred single enantiomer replacement for rac-thiopental. METHODS: The direct myocardial effects of the thiopental enantiomers were compared to those of rac-thiopental and propofol, using a crossover design with small incremental doses infused over 3 min, on separate days, into the left coronary arteries of conscious sheep. Hemodynamic and electrocardiographic measurements were acquired, and serial blood samples were collected during the studies for drug analyses. RESULTS: All three forms of thiopental and propofol produced significant hemodynamic effects consisting of dose-related and rapid-onset decreases in left ventricular dP/dtmax and stroke volume, and increases in left coronary blood flow and heart rate. Cardiac output, mean arterial blood pressure, and central venous pressure remained unaltered. The effects did not differ significantly among rac-thiopental, enantiopure R- or S-thiopental, or propofol. Arterial blood drug concentrations were consistently less than those associated with systemic effects. CONCLUSIONS: Although previous evidence indicates that R-thiopental could make a suitable single-enantiomer replacement for rac-thiopental, the current study did not find a significant difference in direct cardiac effects among the thiopental enantiomers, racemate, or propofol.

Effects of imposed acid-base derangement on the cardiovascular effects and pharmacokinetics of bupivacaine and thiopental.

BACKGROUND: By changing physicochemical properties such as effective lipophilicity, changes in blood pH could alter the distribution, elimination, and effects of weakly ionizing drugs. The authors examined the outcome of imposed acid-base derangement on cardiovascular effects and myocardial and whole body pharmacokinetics of bupivacaine, a weak base, and thiopental, a weak acid. METHODS: Intravenous infusions of rac-bupivacaine HCl (37.5 mg) or rac-thiopental sodium (250 mg, subanesthetic dose) were administered over 3 min to previously instrumented conscious ewes with normal blood pH, acidemia imposed by lactic acid infusion, or alkalemia imposed by bicarbonate infusion. Hemodynamic and electrocardiographic effects were recorded; arterial and coronary sinus drug blood concentrations were analyzed by chiral high-performance liquid chromatography. RESULTS: Bupivacaine decreased myocardial contractility, coronary perfusion, heart rate, and cardiac output; however, cardiac output and stroke volume were not as affected by bupivacaine with acidemia. Thiopental decreased myocardial contractility and stroke volume and increased heart rate; acidemia enhanced the tachycardia and produced a greater decrease in stroke volume than with alkalemia. Taken as a whole, the cardiovascular changes were not systematically modified by acid-base derangement. Overall, the tissue distribution of bupivacaine was favored by alkalemia, but thiopental pharmacokinetics were essentially unaffected by acid-base derangement. Acid-base derangement did not influence the kinetics of either drug enantioselectively. CONCLUSIONS: At the doses used, the hemodynamic and electrocardiographic effects of bupivacaine and thiopental were not systematically modified by acid-base derangement, nor were there changes in regional or whole body pharmacokinetics of either drug that were clearly related to acid-base status.

Effects of CNS site-directed carotid arterial infusions of bupivacaine, levobupivacaine, and ropivacaine in sheep.

BACKGROUND: Previous preclinical safety studies in ewes have found intravenous levobupivacaine and ropivacaine to be less potent toward causing central nervous system (CNS) and cardiac toxicity than bupivacaine. Analogous cardiotoxicity has been demonstrated directly in various cardiac preparations ex vivo. Moreover, drug-related arrhythmogenicity has been demonstrated from direct CNS injection of local anesthetic agents in vivo, suggesting CNS-related cardiotoxicity. This study investigated whether CNS site-directed blood-borne drug administration (with minimal systemic recirculation) would demonstrate drug-related cardiotoxicity. METHODS: Direct CNS effects and indirect cardiotoxic sequelae were determined after bilateral carotid arterial infusions of levobupivacaine, bupivacaine, or ropivacaine in ewes. After pilot studies to validate the procedures, equimolar doses (24-96 micromol, approximately 7.5-30 mg) were infused over 3 min using a crossover design. Behavioral CNS signs, quantitative electroencephalographic (EEG), cardiovascular, and electrocardiographic effects were recorded. Drug blood concentrations in superior sagittal sinus and aorta were measured serially. RESULTS: Blood drug concentrations in the superior sagittal sinus were 5-10 times those concurrently in the aorta, confirming highly selective CNS delivery with minimal systemic recirculation. Dose-dependent CNS excitatory behavior and EEG changes, with increased mean arterial blood pressure, heart rate, cardiac output, and myocardial contractility, were found, consistent with sympathetic nervous system stimulation. The overall rank order of potency for these effects was ropivacaine < levobupivacaine < bupivacaine. Nonfatal cardiac arrhythmias were observed, but the type or frequency did not differ between drugs. CONCLUSIONS: Although CNS site-selective drug delivery produced quantitative differences between bupivacaine, levobupivacaine, and ropivacaine in some CNS effects and cardiac sequelae, no differences were found in their arrhythmogenic potential.