The variability of practice hypothesis in motor learning: does it apply to Alzheimer's disease?

Based on Schmidt's (1975) variability of practice hypothesis, this study examined acquisition and transfer of a gross motor skill, namely tossing, in 58 patients with Alzheimer's disease (AD) and 58 healthy older adults under constant, blocked, and random practice conditions. While healthy older adults were able to learn the tossing task equally well under the three practice conditions, only AD patients receiving constant practice showed significant improvements. Tests of intermediate transfer yielded the expected random practice advantage in healthy controls but not AD patients. None of the practice conditions facilitated intermediate transfer in AD patients; however, constant practice did benefit these impaired individuals on tests of near transfer. These results indicate that the variability of practice hypothesis does not extend to AD patients. As motor learning and transfer were clearly a function of constant practice, future attempts to retrain basic activities of daily living in AD patients should emphasize consistency in training.

Acquisition and long-term retention of a gross motor skill in Alzheimer's disease patients under constant and varied practice conditions.

This study examined the acquisition and long-term retention of a gross motor skill, namely, tossing, in 23 moderately to severely demented Alzheimer's disease (AD) patients and 22 health older adults. To identify optimal learning strategies, subjects received 10 weeks of training under either constant or variable practice conditions. Accuracy at the tossing task was assessed immediately, one week, and one month following training. AD patients given constant practice were able to learn and retain the tossing task as well as healthy adults. Although controls performed equally well in both conditions, AD patients showed significantly less improvement when practiced at various distances from the target. By the one-month post-test, these patients had lost any minimal gains achieved through practice. In comparison, AD patients receiving constant practice showed essentially no forgetting across post-tests. The inability to benefit from varied practice suggests that AD patients may have difficulty accessing and/or forming motor schemas.