Mössbauer Spectroscopy and Theoretical Studies of Iron Bimetallic Complexes Showing Electrocatalytic Hydrogen Evolution.

Mössbauer spectroscopy and density functional theory (DFT) calculations are reported for the mononuclear Fe-nitrosyl complex [Fe( N, N'-bis(2-mercaptoethyl)-1,4-diazacycloheptane)NO] {[Fe(bme-dach)(NO)] (1)} and the series of dithiolate-bridged dinuclear complexes M-Fe(CO)Cp [M = Fe(bme-dach)(NO) (1-A), Ni(bme-dach) (2-A), and Co(bme-dach)(NO) (3-A)], in which M is a metallo-ligand to Fe(CO)Cp+ (Fe'Cp). The latter is an organometallic fragment in which Fe is coordinated by one CO and one cyclopentadienyl ligand. Complexes 1-A and 2-A were previously shown to have electrocatalytic hydrogen evolution activity. Mononuclear {Fe-NO}7 complex 1, with overall spin of 1/2, has an isomer shift of 0.23(2) mm/s [Δ EQ = 1.37(2) mm/s] and magnetic hyperfine couplings of {-38 T, -26.8 T, 8.6 T}. In complexes 2-A and 3-A, Fe'(CO)Cp+ has a diamagnetic ground state and δ = 0.33(2) mm/s (Δ EQ ≈ 1.78 mm/s), consistent with a low-spin FeII site. In contrast, in complex 1-A, M = Fe(bme-dach)(NO) (i.e., complex 1) the magnetic hyperfine interactions of both metallo-ligand, M, and low-spin Fe'Cp are perturbed and Fe'Cp exhibits small magnetic hyperfine interactions, although its isomer shift and quadrupole splittings are largely unaltered. The DFT calculations for 1-A are in agreement with the paramagnetism observed for the Fe'(CO)Cp+ iron site.

Structural and Electronic Responses to the Three Redox Levels of Fe(NO)N2 S2 -Fe(NO)2.

The nitrosylated diiron complexes, Fe2 (NO)3 , of this study are interpreted as a mono-nitrosyl Fe(NO) unit, MNIU, within an N2 S2 ligand field that serves as a metallodithiolate ligand to a dinitrosyl iron unit, DNIU. The cationic Fe(NO)N2 S2 ⋅Fe(NO)2 + complex, 1+ , of Enemark-Feltham electronic notation {Fe(NO)}7 -{Fe(NO)2 }9 , is readily obtained via myriad synthetic routes, and shown to be spin coupled and diamagnetic. Its singly and doubly reduced forms, {Fe(NO)}7 -{Fe(NO)2 }10 , 10 , and {Fe(NO)}8 -{Fe(NO)2 }10 , 1- , were isolated and characterized. While structural parameters of the DNIU are largely unaffected by redox levels, the MNIU readily responds; the neutral, S= 1 / 2 , complex, 10 , finds the extra electron density added into the DNIU affects the adjacent MNIU as seen by the decrease its Fe-N-O angle (from 171° to 149°). In contrast, addition of the second electron, now into the MNIU, returns the Fe-N-O angle to 171° in 1- . Compensating shifts in FeMNIU distances from the N2 S2 plane (from 0.518 to 0.551 to 0.851 Å) contribute to the stability of the bimetallic complex. These features are addressed by computational studies which indicate that the MNIU in 1- is a triplet-state {Fe(NO)}8 with strong spin polarization in the more linear FeNO unit. Magnetic susceptibility and parallel mode EPR results are consistent with the triplet state assignment.

Cyanide Docking and Linkage Isomerism in Models for the Artificial [FeFe]-Hydrogenase Maturation Process.

Linkage isomerization of the cyanide on the [2Fe] subsite of the [FeFe]-H2ase active site was reported to occur during the docking of various synthetic diiron complexes onto a carrier protein, apo-HydF, as the initial step for the artificial maturation of the [FeFe]-H2ase enzyme (Berggren et al., Nature, 2013, 499, 66-70). An investigation of our triiron organometallic models (FeFe-CN/NC-Fe') revealed that, once a Fe-CN-Fe connection is formed, high barriers prevent such cyanide linkage isomerization ( Chem. Sci., 2016, 7, 3710-3719). To explore effects of variable oxidation states of the receiver unit, we introduce copper(I/II) fragments, precedented in Holm's models of cytochrome c oxidase to induce cyanide isomerization (Cu-CN/NC-Fe), to the diiron synthetic analogues of [FeFe]-H2ase. For comparison, a zinc variant of the cytochrome c oxidase model is also examined. According to the oxidation state of copper, a cyanide flip was induced during the formation of both Zn-NC-Cu and FeFe-CN-Cu complexes. Density functional theory calculations are used to predict the mechanisms for such linkage isomerization and account for optimal conditions including oxidation states of metals, spin states, and solvation. These results on synthetic paradigms imply a role for oxidation state control of cyanide isomerization during hydrogenase active site assembly.

Interplay of hemilability and redox activity in models of hydrogenase active sites.

The hydrogen evolution reaction, as catalyzed by two electrocatalysts [M(N2S2)·Fe(NO)2]+, [Fe-Fe]+ (M = Fe(NO)) and [Ni-Fe]+ (M = Ni) was investigated by computational chemistry. As nominal models of hydrogenase active sites, these bimetallics feature two kinds of actor ligands: Hemilabile, MN2S2 ligands and redox-active, nitrosyl ligands, whose interplay guides the H2 production mechanism. The requisite base and metal open site are masked in the resting state but revealed within the catalytic cycle by cleavage of the MS-Fe(NO)2 bond from the hemilabile metallodithiolate ligand. Introducing two electrons and two protons to [Ni-Fe]+ produces H2 from coupling a hydride temporarily stored on Fe(NO)2 (Lewis acid) and a proton accommodated on the exposed sulfur of the MN2S2 thiolate (Lewis base). This Lewis acid-base pair is initiated and preserved by disrupting the dative donation through protonation on the thiolate or reduction on the thiolate-bound metal. Either manipulation modulates the electron density of the pair to prevent it from reestablishing the dative bond. The electron-buffering nitrosyl's role is subtler as a bifunctional electron reservoir. With more nitrosyls as in [Fe-Fe]+, accumulated electronic space in the nitrosyls' π*-orbitals makes reductions easier, but redirects the protonation and reduction to sites that postpone the actuation of the hemilability. Additionally, two electrons donated from two nitrosyl-buffered irons, along with two external electrons, reduce two protons into two hydrides, from which reductive elimination generates H2.

Comparisons of MN2S2vs. bipyridine as redox-active ligands to manganese and rhenium in (L-L)M'(CO)3Cl complexes.

The bipyridine ligand is renowned as a photo- and redox-active ligand in catalysis; the latter has been particularly explored in the complex Re(bipy)(CO)3Cl for CO2 reduction. We ask whether a bidentate, redox-active MN2S2 metallodithiolate ligand in heterobimetallic complexes of Mn and Re might similarly serve as a receptor and conduit of electrons. In order to assess the electrochemical features of such designed bimetallics, a series of complexes featuring redox active MN2S2 metallodithiolates, with M = Ni2+, {Fe(NO)}2+, and {Co(NO)}2+, bound to M'(CO)3X, where M' = Mn and Re, were synthesized and characterized using IR and EPR spectroscopies, X-ray diffraction, cyclic voltammetry, and density functional theory (DFT) computations. Butterfly type structures resulted from binding of the convergent lone pairs of the cis-sulfur atoms to the M'(CO)3X unit. Bond distances and angles are similar across the M' metal series regardless of the ligand attached. Electrochemical characterizations of [MN2S2·Re(CO)3Cl] showed the redox potential of the Re is significantly altered by the identity of the metal in the N2S2 pocket. DFT calculations proved useful to identify the roles played by the MN2S2 ligands, upon reduction of the bimetallics, in altering the lability of the Re-Cl bond and the ensuing effect on the reduction of ReI to Re0.

A matrix of heterobimetallic complexes for interrogation of hydrogen evolution reaction electrocatalysts.

Experimental and computational studies address key questions in a structure-function analysis of bioinspired electrocatalysts for the HER. Combinations of NiN2S2 or [(NO)Fe]N2S2 as donors to (η5-C5H5)Fe(CO)+ or [Fe(NO)2]+/0 generate a series of four bimetallics, gradually "softened" by increasing nitrosylation, from 0 to 3, by the non-innocent NO ligands. The nitrosylated NiFe complexes are isolated and structurally characterized in two redox levels, demonstrating required features of electrocatalysis. Computational modeling of experimental structures and likely transient intermediates that connect the electrochemical events find roles for electron delocalization by NO, as well as Fe-S bond dissociation that produce a terminal thiolate as pendant base well positioned to facilitate proton uptake and transfer. Dihydrogen formation is via proton/hydride coupling by internal S-H+···-H-Fe units of the "harder" bimetallic arrangements with more localized electron density, while softer units convert H-···H-via reductive elimination from two Fe-H deriving from the highly delocalized, doubly reduced [Fe2(NO)3]- derivative. Computational studies also account for the inactivity of a Ni2Fe complex resulting from entanglement of added H+ in a pinched -S δ-···H+··· δ-S- arrangement.

Hemilabile Bridging Thiolates as Proton Shuttles in Bioinspired H2 Production Electrocatalysts.

Synthetic analogues and computationally assisted structure-function analyses have been used to explore the features that control proton-electron and proton-hydride coupling in electrocatalysts inspired by the [NiFe]-hydrogenase active site. Of the bimetallic complexes derived from aggregation of the dithiolato complexes MN2S2 (N2S2 = bismercaptoethane diazacycloheptane; M = Ni or Fe(NO)) with (η5-C5H5)Fe(CO)+ (the Fe' component) or (η5-C5H5)Fe(CO)2+, Fe″, which yielded Ni-Fe'+, Fe-Fe'+, Ni-Fe″+, and Fe-Fe″+, respectively, both Ni-Fe'+ and Fe-Fe'+ were determined to be active electrocatalysts for H2 production in the presence of trifluoroacetic acid. Correlations of electrochemical potentials and H2 generation are consistent with calculated parameters in a predicted mechanism that delineates the order of addition of electrons and protons, the role of the redox-active, noninnocent NO ligand in electron uptake, the necessity for Fe'-S bond breaking (or the hemilability of the metallodithiolate ligand), and hydride-proton coupling routes. Although the redox active {Fe(NO)}7 moiety can accept and store an electron and subsequently a proton (forming the relatively unstable Fe-bound HNO), it cannot form a hydride as the NO shields the Fe from protonation. Successful coupling occurs from a hydride on Fe' with a proton on thiolate S and requires a propitious orientation of the H-S bond that places H+ and H- within coupling distance. This orientation and coupling barrier are redox-level dependent. While the Ni-Fe' derivative has vacant sites on both metals for hydride formation, the uptake of the required electron is more energy intensive than that in Fe-Fe' featuring the noninnocent NO ligand. The Fe'-S bond cleavage facilitated by the hemilability of thiolate to produce a terminal thiolate as a proton shuttle is a key feature in both mechanisms. The analogous Fe″-S bond cleavage on Ni-Fe″ leads to degradation.

Cyanide-bridged iron complexes as biomimetics of tri-iron arrangements in maturases of the H cluster of the di-iron hydrogenase.

Developing from certain catalytic processes required for ancient life forms, the H2 processing enzymes [NiFe]- and [FeFe]-hydrogenase (H2ase) have active sites that are organometallic in composition, possessing carbon monoxide and cyanide as ligands. Simple synthetic analogues of the 2Fe portion of the active site of [FeFe]-H2ase have been shown to dock into the empty carrier (maturation) protein, apo-Hyd-F, via the bridging ability of a terminal cyanide ligand from a low valent FeIFeI unit to the iron of a 4Fe4S cluster of Hyd-F, with spectral evidence indicating CN isomerization during the coupling process (Berggren, et al., Nature, 2013, 499, 66-70). To probe the requirements for such cyanide couplings, we have prepared and characterized four cyanide-bridged analogues of 3-Fe systems with features related to the organoiron moiety within the loaded HydF protein. As in classical organometallic chemistry, the orientation of the CN bridge in the biomimetics is determined by the precursor reagents; no cyanide flipping or linkage isomerization was observed. Density functional theory computations evaluated the energetics of cyanide isomerization in such [FeFe]-CN-Fe ⇌ [FeFe]-NC-Fe units, and found excessively high barriers account for the failure to observe the alternative isomers. These results highlight roles for cyanide as an unusual ligand in biology that may stabilize low spin iron in [FeFe]-hydrogenase, and can act as a bridge connecting multi-iron units during bioassembly of the active site.

A reduced 2Fe2S cluster probe of sulfur-hydrogen versus sulfur-gold interactions.

The Ph3 PAu(+) cation, renowned as an isolobal analogue of H(+) , was found to serve as a proton surrogate and form a stable Au2 Fe2 complex, [(µ-SAuPPh3 )2 {Fe(CO)3 }2 ], analogous to the highly reactive dihydrosulfide [(µ-SH)2 {Fe(CO)3 }2 ]. Solid-state X-ray diffraction analysis found the two SAuPPh3 and SH bridges in anti configurations. VT NMR studies, supported by DFT computations, confirmed substantial barriers of approximately 25 kcal mol(-1) to intramolecular interconversion between the three stereoisomers of [(µ-SH)2 {Fe(CO)3 }2 ]. In contrast, the largely dative SAu bond in µ-SAuPPh3 facilitates inversion at S and accounts for the facile equilibration of the SAuPPh3 units, with an energy barrier half that of the SH analogue. The reactivity of the gold-protected sulfur atoms of [(µ-SAuPPh3 )2 {Fe(CO)3 }2 ] was accessed by release of the gold ligand with a strong acid to generate the [(µ-SH)2 {Fe(CO)3 }2 ] precursor of the [FeFe]H2 ase-active-site biomimetic [(µ2 -SCH2 (NR)CH2 S){Fe(CO)3 }2 ].

Intramolecular iron-mediated C-H bond heterolysis with an assist of pendant base in a [FeFe]-hydrogenase model.

Although many metalloenzymes containing iron play a prominent role in biological C-H activation processes, to date iron-mediated C(sp(3))-H heterolysis has not been reported for synthetic models of Fe/S-metalloenzymes. In contrast, ample precedent has established that nature's design for reversible hydrogen activation by the diiron hydrogenase ([FeFe]-H2ase) active site involves multiple irons, sulfur bridges, a redox switch, and a pendant amine base, in an intricate arrangement to perform H-H heterolytic cleavage. In response to whether this strategy might be extended to C-H activation, we report that a [FeFe]-H2ase model demonstrates iron-mediated intramolecular C-H heterolytic cleavage via an agostic C-H interaction, with proton removal by a nearby pendant amine, affording Fe(II)-[Fe'(II)-CH-S] three-membered-ring products, which can be reduced back to 1 by Cp2Co in the presence of HBF4. The function of the pendant base as a proton shuttle was confirmed by the crystal structures of the N-protonated intermediate and the final deprotonated product in comparison with that of a similar but pendant-amine-free complex that does not show evidence of C-H activation. The mechanism of the process was backed up by DFT calculations.

Redox active iron nitrosyl units in proton reduction electrocatalysis.

Base metal, molecular catalysts for the fundamental process of conversion of protons and electrons to dihydrogen, remain a substantial synthetic goal related to a sustainable energy future. Here we report a diiron complex with bridging thiolates in the butterfly shape of the 2Fe2S core of the [FeFe]-hydrogenase active site but with nitrosyl rather than carbonyl or cyanide ligands. This binuclear [(NO)Fe(N2S2)Fe(NO)2](+) complex maintains structural integrity in two redox levels; it consists of a (N2S2)Fe(NO) complex (N2S2=N,N'-bis(2-mercaptoethyl)-1,4-diazacycloheptane) that serves as redox active metallodithiolato bidentate ligand to a redox active dinitrosyl iron unit, Fe(NO)2. Experimental and theoretical methods demonstrate the accommodation of redox levels in both components of the complex, each involving electronically versatile nitrosyl ligands. An interplay of orbital mixing between the Fe(NO) and Fe(NO)2 sites and within the iron nitrosyl bonds in each moiety is revealed, accounting for the interactions that facilitate electron uptake, storage and proton reduction.