MADS-box gene evolution beyond flowers: expression in pollen, endosperm, guard cells, roots and trichomes.

MADS-box genes encode transcriptional regulators involved in diverse aspects of plant development. Here we describe the cloning and mRNA spatio-temporal expression patterns of five new MADS-box genes from Arabidopsis: AGL16, AGL18, AGL19, AGL27 and AGL31. These genes will probably become important molecular tools for both evolutionary and functional analyses of vegetative structures. We mapped our data and previous expression patterns onto a new MADS-box phylogeny. These analyses suggest that the evolution of the MADS-box family has involved a rapid and simultaneous functional diversification in vegetative as well as reproductive structures. The hypothetical ancestral genes had broader expression patterns than more derived ones, which have been co-opted for putative specialized functions as suggested by their expression patterns. AGL27 and AGL31, which are closely related to the recently described flowering-time gene FLC (previously AGL25), are expressed in most plant tissues. AGL19 is specifically expressed in the outer layers of the root meristem (lateral root cap and epidermis) and in the central cylinder cells of mature roots. AGL18, which is most similar in sequence to the embryo-expressed AGL15 gene, is expressed in the endosperm and in developing male and female gametophytes, suggesting a role for AGL18 that is distinct from previously characterized MADS-box genes. Finally, AGL16 RNA accumulates in leaf guard cells and trichomes. Our new phylogeny reveals seven new monophyletic clades of MADS-box sequences not specific to flowers, suggesting that complex regulatory networks involving several MADS-box genes, similar to those that control flower development, underlie development of vegetative structures.

Distinct roles of CONSTANS target genes in reproductive development of Arabidopsis.

In plants, flowering is triggered by endogenous and environmental signals. CONSTANS (CO) promotes flowering of Arabidopsis in response to day length. Four early target genes of CO were identified using a steroid-inducible version of the protein. Two of these genes, SUPPRESSOR OF OVEREXPRESSION OF CO 1 (SOC1) and FLOWERING LOCUS T (FT), are required for CO to promote flowering; the others are involved in proline or ethylene biosynthesis. The SOC1 and FT genes are also regulated by a second flowering-time pathway that acts independently of CO. Thus, early target genes of CO define common components of distinct flowering-time pathways.

B and C floral organ identity functions require SEPALLATA MADS-box genes.

Abnormal flowers have been recognized for thousands of years, but only in the past decade have the mysteries of flower development begun to unfold. Among these mysteries is the differentiation of four distinct organ types (sepals, petals, stamens and carpels), each of which may be a modified leaf. A landmark accomplishment in plant developmental biology is the ABC model of flower organ identity. This simple model provides a conceptual framework for explaining how the individual and combined activities of the ABC genes produce the four organ types of the typical eudicot flower. Here we show that the activities of the B and C organ-identity genes require the activities of three closely related and functionally redundant MADS-box genes, SEPALLATA1/2/3 (SEP1/2/3). Triple mutant Arabidopsis plants lacking the activity of all three SEP genes produce flowers in which all organs develop as sepals. Thus SEP1/2/3 are a class of organ-identity genes that is required for development of petals, stamens and carpels.

An ancestral MADS-box gene duplication occurred before the divergence of plants and animals.

Changes in genes encoding transcriptional regulators can alter development and are important components of the molecular mechanisms of morphological evolution. MADS-box genes encode transcriptional regulators of diverse and important biological functions. In plants, MADS-box genes regulate flower, fruit, leaf, and root development. Recent sequencing efforts in Arabidopsis have allowed a nearly complete sampling of the MADS-box gene family from a single plant, something that was lacking in previous phylogenetic studies. To test the long-suspected parallel between the evolution of the MADS-box gene family and the evolution of plant form, a polarized gene phylogeny is necessary. Here we suggest that a gene duplication ancestral to the divergence of plants and animals gave rise to two main lineages of MADS-box genes: TypeI and TypeII. We locate the root of the eukaryotic MADS-box gene family between these two lineages. A novel monophyletic group of plant MADS domains (AGL34 like) seems to be more closely related to previously identified animal SRF-like MADS domains to form TypeI lineage. Most other plant sequences form a clear monophyletic group with animal MEF2-like domains to form TypeII lineage. Only plant TypeII members have a K domain that is downstream of the MADS domain in most plant members previously identified. This suggests that the K domain evolved after the duplication that gave rise to the two lineages. Finally, a group of intermediate plant sequences could be the result of recombination events. These analyses may guide the search for MADS-box sequences in basal eukaryotes and the phylogenetic placement of new genes from other plant species.

SHATTERPROOF MADS-box genes control seed dispersal in Arabidopsis.

The fruit, which mediates the maturation and dispersal of seeds, is a complex structure unique to flowering plants. Seed dispersal in plants such as Arabidopsis occurs by a process called fruit dehiscence, or pod shatter. Few studies have focused on identifying genes that regulate this process, in spite of the agronomic value of controlling seed dispersal in crop plants such as canola. Here we show that the closely related SHATTERPROOF (SHP1) and SHATTERPROOF2 (SHP2) MADS-box genes are required for fruit dehiscence in Arabidopsis. Moreover, SHP1 and SHP2 are functionally redundant, as neither single mutant displays a novel phenotype. Our studies of shp1 shp2 fruit, and of plants constitutively expressing SHP1 and SHP2, show that these two genes control dehiscence zone differentiation and promote the lignification of adjacent cells. Our results indicate that further analysis of the molecular events underlying fruit dehiscence may allow genetic manipulation of pod shatter in crop plants.

Interactions among APETALA1, LEAFY, and TERMINAL FLOWER1 specify meristem fate.

Upon floral induction, the primary shoot meristem of an Arabidopsis plant begins to produce flower meristems rather than leaf primordia on its flanks. Assignment of floral fate to lateral meristems is primarily due to the cooperative activity of the flower meristem identity genes LEAFY (LFY), APETALA1 (AP1), and CAULIFLOWER. We present evidence here that AP1 expression in lateral meristems is activated by at least two independent pathways, one of which is regulated by LFY. In lfy mutants, the onset of AP1 expression is delayed, indicating that LFY is formally a positive regulator of AP1. We have found that AP1, in turn, can positively regulate LFY, because LFY is expressed prematurely in the converted floral meristems of plants constitutively expressing AP1. Shoot meristems maintain an identity distinct from that of flower meristems, in part through the action of genes such as TERMINAL FLOWER1 (TFL1), which bars AP1 and LFY expression from the influorescence shoot meristem. We show here that this negative regulation can be mutual because TFL1 expression is downregulated in plants constitutively expressing AP1. Therefore, the normally sharp phase transition between the production of leaves with associated shoots and formation of the flowers, which occurs upon floral induction, is promoted by positive feedback interactions between LFY and AP1, together with negative interactions of these two genes with TFL1.

Diverse roles for MADS box genes in Arabidopsis development.

Members of the MADS box gene family play important roles in flower development from the early step of determining the identity of floral meristems to specifying the identity of floral organ primordia later in flower development. We describe here the isolation and characterization of six additional members of this family, increasing the number of reported Arabidopsis MADS box genes to 17. All 11 members reported prior to this study are expressed in flowers, and the majority of them are floral specific. RNA expression analyses of the six genes reported here indicate that two genes, AGL11 and AGL13 (AGL for AGAMOUS-like), are preferentially expressed in ovules, but each has a distinct expression pattern. AGL15 is preferentially expressed in embryos, with its onset at or before the octant stage early in embryo development. AGL12, AGL14, and AGL17 are all preferentially expressed in root tissues and therefore represent the only characterized MADS box genes expressed in roots. Phylogenetic analyses showed that the two genes expressed in ovules are closely related to previously isolated MADS box genes, whereas the four genes showing nonfloral expression are more distantly related. Data from this and previous studies indicate that in addition to their proven role in flower development, MADS box genes are likely to play roles in many other aspects of plant development.

The oxygen sensor protein, FixL, of Rhizobium meliloti. Role of histidine residues in heme binding, phosphorylation, and signal transduction.

The two-component system sensor/response regulator pair, FixL/FixJ, controls the expression of Rhizobium meliloti nitrogen fixation (nif and fix) genes in response to changes in oxygen concentration. A truncated version of FixL, FixL*, is an oxygen-binding hemoprotein kinase that phosphorylates and dephosphorylates the nif and fix gene transcriptional activator, FixJ. Phosphorylation of FixJ is required for optimal transcriptional activation, and anaerobic conditions in vitro result in a substantial increase in the level of FixJ-phosphate. In this study, site-directed mutagenesis was carried out at histidine residues in FixL*. Mutant FixL* derivatives were purified and analyzed in vitro for their heme/oxygen binding properties and phosphorylation/dephosphorylation activities. Mutation of histidine 285, the putative autophosphorylation site, to glutamine results in the loss of FixL* phosphorylation activities. However, this mutant protein retains a substantial level of FixJ-phosphate dephosphorylation activity. Mutation of histidine 194 to asparagine results in the loss of heme binding and in the failure of FixL* to regulate its phosphorylation/dephosphorylation activities in response to changes in oxygen concentration. The FixL*H194N mutant protein also exhibits an increased FixJ phosphorylation activity under aerobic conditions. This study provides further evidence for the importance of the heme binding domain of FixL* in regulating FixJ phosphorylation and dephosphorylation activities in response to oxygen.

Oxygen regulation of expression of nitrogen fixation genes in Rhizobium meliloti.

The sensor kinase FixL and the response regulator FixJ induce the expression of the nitrogen fixation genes of Rhizobium meliloti in response to microaerobiosis, which is a characteristic feature of the plant root nodule interior where the bacteria fix nitrogen. The kinase activity of a purified, soluble derivative of the membrane-bound hemoprotein FixL, designated FixL*, is stimulated under low oxygen conditions, thus increasing FixJ-phosphate levels. FixJ-phosphate is a potent transcriptional activator of the nifA and fixK genes, the products of which, in turn, induce the expression of most if not all of the remaining nitrogen fixation genes. FixL* and FixL*-phosphate also dephosphorylate FixJ-phosphate, and this activity is depressed by low oxygen concentrations. In the current model, gene expression is reciprocally coordinated by the kinase and phosphatase activities of FixL according to changes in oxygen tension.

Mutants of the two-component regulatory protein FixJ of Rhizobium meliloti that have increased activity at the nifA promoter.

FixL and FixJ belong to a two-component regulatory system in Rhizobium meliloti that induces the expression of numerous nitrogen-fixation genes during symbiosis with alfalfa. FixJ is a positive activator required for transcription of the regulatory genes nifA and fixK, while FixL is an oxygen-binding hemoprotein capable of regulating the phosphorylation status of both itself and FixJ, in response to oxygen availability. In this study, we isolated four FixJ mutants that display increased activity at the nifA promoter (PnifA) in Escherichia coli. All four mutants possess amino acid changes in a domain of FixJ that is conserved in other response regulator proteins, and all exhibit increased activity at PnifA in R. meliloti that is dependent on the presence of FixL. One of the mutant proteins, while less efficient at accepting phosphate from a truncated derivative of FixL (FixL*), nevertheless has a phosphorylated form that is more stable than the phosphorylated form of wild-type (wt) FixJ and is more resistant to the phosphatase activity of FixL*. The wt FixJ-phosphate was found to have a half-life of approximately 4 h, which makes it an unusually long-lived response regulator protein. The exceptional stability of wt FixJ-phosphate and the altered phosphorylation properties observed for the mutant are discussed in relation to signal transduction in the FixLJ system.

Oxygen regulation of nifA transcription in vitro.

In Rhizobium meliloti, transcription of the key nitrogen-fixation regulatory genes nifA and fixK is induced in response to microaerobiosis through the action of the FixL and FixJ proteins. These two proteins are sensor and regulator homologues, respectively, of a large family of bacterial two-component systems involved in sensing and responding to environmental changes. A soluble, truncated form of the membrane protein FixL, FixL*, has been shown to be a hemoprotein that phosphorylates and dephosphorylates FixJ in response to oxygen tension. Here we use an in vitro transcription system to prove that FixJ is a transcriptional activator of both nifA and fixK and that phosphorylation of FixJ markedly increases its activity. Phosphorylation was achieved either by preincubating FixJ with FixL* and ATP or by exposing FixJ to the inorganic phospho donor ammonium hydrogen phosphoramidate. Both FixJ and FixJ-phosphate formed heparin-resistant complexes under the assay conditions used. Lastly, we were able to show that anaerobiosis, in the presence of FixL* and ATP, greatly stimulates FixJ activity at the nifA promoter with either Escherichia coli or R. meliloti RNA polymerase. This use of atmospheric oxygen to control nifA transcription in vitro represents a reconstitution of a bacterial two-component signal transduction system in its entirety, from effector to ultimate target, by the use of purified components.

Autophosphorylation and phosphatase activities of the oxygen-sensing protein FixL of Rhizobium meliloti are coordinately regulated by oxygen.

The FixL and FixJ proteins of Rhizobium meliloti control the expression of other nif and fix genes in response to oxygen levels. FixL is a hemoprotein kinase that senses oxygen availability and responds to the absence of oxygen by activation of its autophosphorylating activity followed by transfer of the phosphate to FixJ. FixJ in turn activates the nifA and fixK promoters. In vitro studies reported here with a soluble truncated version of FixL (FixL*) indicate that, while low oxygen tension specifically increases the autophosphorylating activity of FixL*, the ability of phospho-FixL* to act as a phosphate donor to FixJ is not affected by the presence or absence of oxygen. FixL* is also shown to possess a phosphatase activity that is repressed under anaerobic conditions only when the protein is in the phosphorylated form. A fixL mutant that induces a higher level of nifA promoter activity in the presence of fixJ in vivo displayed both an increased autophosphorylating activity and a decreased phosphatase activity in vitro. These data provide evidence for a role for both autophosphorylation and phosphatase activities of FixL in the mechanism by which oxygen tension within the alfalfa nodule induces expression of bacterial nitrogen fixation genes during symbiosis.

The oxygen sensor FixL of Rhizobium meliloti is a membrane protein containing four possible transmembrane segments.

Regulation of nitrogen fixation genes in Rhizobium meliloti is mediated by two proteins, FixL and FixJ, in response to oxygen availability. FixL is an oxygen-binding hemoprotein with kinase and phosphatase activities that is thought to sense oxygen levels directly and to transmit this signal to FixJ via phosphorylation-dephosphorylation reactions. FixJ controls the expression of other regulatory genes, including nifA, that regulate the transcription of genes required for symbiotic nitrogen fixation. We have been studying the structural and functional features of FixL that are required for oxygen sensing. We constructed mutant derivatives and confirmed that FixL consists of 505 amino acids instead of 464, as originally reported. Hydropathy plots of the full-length protein, together with TnphoA insertional analysis, lead us to propose that FixL is likely to be a polytopic integral membrane protein containing four membrane-spanning segments. We have also constructed an N-terminal deletion of the FixL protein whose in vivo activity indicates that the hydrophobic membrane-spanning regions are not absolutely required for oxygen sensing in vivo. We also report that FixL shares homology in its N terminus with other sensor proteins, including KinA from Bacillus subtilis and NtrB from Bradyrhizobium parasponia. The region of homology comprises a 70-amino-acid residue stretch that is also conserved in two oxygenases, P-450 and isopenicillin synthase.

Isolation of phosphorylation-deficient mutants of the Rhizobium meliloti two-component regulatory protein, FixJ.

Rhizobium meliloti FixL and FixJ are members of a symbiotically essential two-component system that regulates nitrogen-fixation genes in response to environmental oxygen concentrations. FixL is a membrane protein that is thought to relay information about oxygen availability to FixJ via a phosphotransfer mechanism. FixJ increases expression of the nifA and fixK genes by activating transcription of the nifA and fixK promoters (p-nifA and p-fixK, respectively). In this study, we examined the relationship between the in vivo activity of FixJ as a transcriptional regulator and its ability to be phosphorylated in vitro by the sensor FixL. FixJ mutants were isolated that showed decreased activity on p-nifA in Escherichia coli. Most of the FixJ mutant proteins also showed decreased activity on the fixK promoter. These mutants were analysed in R. meliloti for activity on p-nifA during vegetative growth, where similarities and differences were observed when compared with their phenotypes in E. coli. Three mutants showing significantly less activity in R. meliloti were examined for symbiotic activity in planta and were found to be ineffective. When these three mutant FixJ proteins were examined in vitro for their ability to be phosphorylated by FixL, two mutants were found to have a significantly decreased ability to accept phosphate from FixL. These findings are discussed in relation to signal transduction in the FixLJ system.

Mutational analysis of the Rhizobium meliloti nifA promoter.

The nifA gene of Rhizobium meliloti, the bacterial endosymbiont of alfalfa, is a regulatory nitrogen fixation gene required for the induction of several key nif and fix genes. Transcription of nifA is strongly induced in planta and under microaerobic conditions ex planta. Induction of nifA, in turn, is positively controlled by the fixL and fixJ genes of R. meliloti, the sensor and regulator, respectively, of a two-component system responsible for oxygen sensing by this bacterium. This system is also responsible for the positive induction of fixK. Here, we report that chemical and oligonucleotide site-directed mutageneses of the nifA promoter (nifAp) were conducted to identify nucleotides essential for induction. Nineteen mutants, including 14 single-point mutants, were analyzed for microaerobic induction of nifAp in R. meliloti. Critical residues were identified in an upstream region between base pairs -54 and -39 relative to the transcription start site. Attempts at separating the upstream and downstream regions of the nifA promoter so as to maintain fixJ-dependent activity were unsuccessful. A 5' deletion of the fixK promoter (fixKp) to -67 indicates that sequences upstream of this position are not required for microaerobic induction. A sequence comparison of the -54 to -39 region of nifAp with the upstream sequences of fixKp does not reveal a block of identical nucleotides that could account for the fixJ-dependent microaerobic induction of both promoters. Many of the defective nifAp mutants in this region, however, are in residues with identity to fixKp in an alignment of the promoters according to their transcription start sites. Therefore, it is possible that there is a common sequence motif in the -54 to -39 region of the two promoters that is required for fixLJ-dependent microaerobic induction.

The FixL protein of Rhizobium meliloti can be separated into a heme-binding oxygen-sensing domain and a functional C-terminal kinase domain.

Transcription of nitrogen fixation (nif and fix) genes in Rhizobium meliloti is induced by a decrease in oxygen concentration. The products of two genes, fixL and fixJ, are responsible for sensing and transmitting the low-oxygen signal. The proteins encoded by fixL and fixJ (FixL and FixJ, respectively) are homologous to a family of bacterial proteins that transduce environmental signals through a common phosphotransfer mechanism [David, M., Daveran, M., Batut, J., Dedieu, A., Domergue, O., Ghai, J., Hertig, C., Boistard, P. & Khan, D. (1988) Cell 54, 671-683]. FixL, the oxygen sensor, is a membrane protein. It has previously been shown that a soluble derivative of FixL, FixL*, is an oxygen-binding hemoprotein and a kinase that autophosphorylates and also phosphorylates FixJ [Gilles-Gonzalez, M. A., Ditta, G. S. & Helinski, D. R. (1991) Nature (London) 350, 170-172]. In this work, deletion derivatives of fixL* were constructed and overexpressed in Escherichia coli, and the truncated proteins were purified. We show that a fragment of FixL from amino acid residue 127 to residue 260 binds heme, retains the ability to bind oxygen, and has no detectable kinase activity. A C-terminal fragment of FixL, beginning at residue 260, fails to bind heme but is active as a kinase. We also demonstrate that anaerobiosis results in an enhancement of FixL* autophosphorylation and FixJ phosphorylation activities in vitro. Finally, we show that the heme-binding region of FixL is required in vitro for oxygen regulation of its kinase activities.

A haemoprotein with kinase activity encoded by the oxygen sensor of Rhizobium meliloti.

The expression of the nitrogen-fixation genes of Rhizobium meliloti is controlled by oxygen. These genes are induced when the free oxygen concentration is reduced to microaerobic levels. Two regulator proteins, FixL and FixJ, initiate the oxygen-response cascade, and the genes that encode them have been cloned. The fixL product seems to be a transmembrane sensor that modulates the activity of the fixJ product, a cytoplasmic regulator. FixL and FixJ are homologous to a family of bacterial two-component regulators, for which the mode of signal transduction is phosphorylation. We report here the purification of both FixJ and a soluble truncated FixL (FixL*), overproduced from a single plasmid construct. FixL* catalyses its own phosphorylation and the transfer of the gamma-phosphate of ATP to Fix J. The resulting FixJ-phosphate linkage is sensitive to base, as are the aspartyl phosphates of homologous systems. Visible spectra of purified FixL* show that it is an oxygen-binding haemoprotein. We propose that FixL senses oxygen through its haem moiety and transduces this signal by controlling the phosphorylation of FixJ.

Symbiotic pseudorevertants of Rhizobium meliloti ndv mutants.

Nodule development (ndv) mutants of Rhizobium meliloti cannot invade alfalfa to establish a nitrogen-fixing symbiosis and instead induce the formation of small, white, unoccupied nodules on alfalfa roots. Such mutants also fail to produce the unusual cyclic oligosaccharide beta-(1----2)-glucan and show defects in several aspects of vegetative growth and function. Here we show that ndv mutants are severely reduced, although not totally deficient, in the ability to attach to and initiate infection threads on alfalfa seedlings, and we demonstrate that the symbiotic deficiency can be separated from the rest of the mutant phenotype by isolating second-site pseudorevertants. Pseudorevertants selected for restoration of motility, a vegetative property, regained a substantial amount of attachment capability but only slight infection thread initiation and symbiotic ability. Such strains also regained partial tolerance to growth at low osmolarity, even though they did not recover the ability to synthesize periplasmic beta-(1----2)-glucan. Pseudorevertants selected on alfalfa for restoration of symbiosis were unrestored for beta-(1----2)-glucan production or any other vegetative property and regained little or no attachment or infection thread initiation capability. We take these data to indicate that wild-type R. meliloti normally has considerable excess capability for both attachment and infection thread initiation and that the symbiotic block in ndv mutants lies further along the developmental pathway than either of these processes, probably at the level of infection thread extension. Further, the fact that neither type of pseudorevertant recovered the ability to produce periplasmic beta-(1----2)-glucan raises the possibility that this oligosaccharide is not directly required for nodule development.

Hypoosmotic adaptation in Rhizobium meliloti requires beta-(1----2)-glucan.

beta-(1----2)-Glucan, an unusual cyclic oligosaccharide, can be isolated from the periplasm of bacteria belonging to the family Rhizobiaceae. Data presented here suggest that the periplasmic beta-(1----2)-glucan of Rhizobium meliloti plays a major role in osmotic adaptation. First, growth of R. meliloti in a low-osmolarity medium causes a large accumulation of periplasmic beta-(1----2)-glucan. Second, mutations in the ndv genes, which prevent this accumulation of beta-(1----2)-glucan, reduce cell growth rates under low-osmolarity conditions and cause several other phenotypic changes indicative of an altered or stressed surface. Third, growth of the ndv mutants can be restored by raising the osmolarity of the medium with the addition of a variety of ionic or nonionic compounds. The phenotypic changes associated with the cell surface of the mutants can also be substantially suppressed by increasing the medium osmolarity. On the basis of these data and general considerations about the periplasmic space in gram-negative bacteria, we suggest a mechanism of hypoosmotic adaptation in R. meliloti in which beta-(1----2)-glucan plays an essential role.

The ndvB locus of Rhizobium meliloti encodes a 319-kDa protein involved in the production of beta-(1----2)-glucan.

The ndvB locus of Rhizobium meliloti was sequenced and found to encode a 319-kDa protein involved in the production of beta-(1----2)-glucan. Transposon Tn5 mutagenesis revealed that a large portion of the downstream half of this gene is not essential for symbiosis but is required for optimal production of beta-(1----2)-glucan. A high molecular weight inner membrane protein, believed to be the ndvB gene product, was absent from two different upstream ndvB::Tn5 mutants. This protein could be labeled in vitro with UDP-[U-14C]glucose in the wild type but not in the symbiotically defective mutants. Inner membrane preparations from the symbiotically competent downstream mutants labeled less well than did those from wild type with UDP-[U-14C] glucose and did not show distinct bands after polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and fluorography, suggesting that C-terminal truncations of NdvB might affect the stability of this molecule. These downstream mutants had reduced amounts of periplasmic beta-(1----2)-glucan and exhibited several vegetative defects seen also in the upstream mutants. These included alterations in phage and antibiotic sensitivity, in motility, and in growth in low osmolarity media. Bacteroids produced by two of the downstream mutants were morphologically abnormal, indicating that ndvB is involved not only in invasion but also in bacteroid development.