Elderly patients undergoing mechanical ventilation in and out of intensive care units: a comparative, prospective study of 579 ventilations.

INTRODUCTION: Many mechanically ventilated elderly patients in Israel are treated outside of intensive care units (ICUs). The decision as to whether these patients should be treated in ICUs is reached without clear guidelines. We therefore conducted a study with the aim of identifying triage criteria and factors associated with in-hospital mortality in this population. METHODS: All mechanically invasive ventilated elderly (65+) medical patients in the hospital were included in a prospective, non-interventional, observational study. RESULTS: Of the 579 ventilations, 283 (48.9%) were done in ICUs compared with 296 (51.1%) in non-ICU wards. The percentage of ICU ventilations in the 65 to 74, 75 to 84, and 85+ age groups was 62%, 45%, and 23%, respectively. The decision to ventilate in ICUs was significantly and independently influenced by age (Odds Ratio (OR) = 0.945, P < 0.001), and pre-hospitalization functional status by functional independence measure (FIM) scale (OR = 1.054, P < 0.001). In-hospital mortality was 53.0% in ICUs compared with 68.2% in non-ICU wards (P < 0.001), but the rate was not independently and significantly affected by hospitalization in ICUs. CONCLUSIONS: In Israel, most elderly patients are ventilated outside ICUs and the percentage of ICU ventilations decreases as age increases. In our study groups, the lower mortality among elderly patients ventilated in ICUs is related to patient characteristics and not to their treatment in ICUs per se. Although the milieu in which this study was conducted is uncommon today in the western world, its findings point to possible means of managing future situations in which the demand for mechanical ventilation of elderly patients exceeds the supply of intensive care beds. Moreover, the findings of this study can contribute to the search for ways to reduce costs without having a negative effect on outcome in ventilated elderly patients.

How do older ventilated patients fare? A survival/functional analysis of 641 ventilations.

BACKGROUND: The outcome of mechanical ventilation in elderly patients should be evaluated by integrating survival rates with functional state over time after the ventilation episode. OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to measure the survival rate and functional state of elderly ventilated patients and to present an integrated analysis of both outcome measures. METHODS: This is a prospective observational, noninterventional study of 641 invasive medical ventilations of elderly (65+ years) patients in medical wards and intensive care units. The functional state, by the Functional Independence Measure scale, was measured before hospitalization, at discharge from the hospital, and 1 year later. RESULTS: Survival rates at the end of hospitalization and 3, 6, and 12 months later were 33%, 28%, 25%, and 22%, respectively. According to a combined survival/functional analysis, only 11% of all ventilated elderly patients were doing well (Functional Independence Measure scale score, >or=90) a year after the hospitalization. The rates for this condition ranged from 23% for acute exacerbation of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease to 0% for stroke and hospital-acquired pneumonia. CONCLUSIONS: In elderly patients treated with mechanical ventilation, the outcomes in the period immediately after ventilation and later on are poor. In this group of patients, functional outcomes should be integrated with survival analysis for a meaningful assessment of the outcomes of treatment with mechanical ventilation to provide patients, families, practitioners, and society with reliable information on which life or death decisions can be based.