Should Organizational Investment in Robotic Surgical Technology Ever Influence Surgeons' Decisions About Surgical Approach to Patients' Surgical Care?

This commentary on a case considers balancing prospective benefits and harms of robotic technology use and argues that health care organizations should invest in centralizing robotic expertise in departments rather than having a mere collection of surgeons trained in robotics. This commentary also examines costs that should be considered in organizational determinations of robotics investments.

A Multicenter Analysis of the Early Impact of COVID-19 on Junior Resident Operative Case Volume.

INTRODUCTION: Institutions have reported decreases in operative volume due to COVID-19. Junior residents have fewer opportunities for operative experience and COVID-19 further jeopardizes their operative exposure. This study quantifies the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on resident operative exposure using resident case logs focusing on junior residents and categorizes the response of surgical residency programs to the COVID-19 pandemic. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A retrospective multicenter cohort study was conducted; 276,481 case logs were collected from 407 general surgery residents of 18 participating institutions, spanning 2016-2020. Characteristics of each institution and program changes in response to COVID-19 were collected via surveys. RESULTS: Senior residents performed 117 more cases than junior residents each year (P < 0.001). Prior to the pandemic, senior resident case volume increased each year (38 per year, 95% confidence interval 2.9-74.9) while junior resident case volume remained stagnant (95% confidence interval 13.7-22.0). Early in the COVID-19 pandemic, junior residents reported on average 11% fewer cases when compared to the three prior academic years (P = 0.001). The largest decreases in cases were those with higher resident autonomy (Surgeon Jr, P = 0.03). The greatest impact of COVID-19 on junior resident case volume was in community-based medical centers (246 prepandemic versus 216 during pandemic, P = 0.009) and institutions which reached Stage 3 Program Pandemic Status (P = 0.01). CONCLUSIONS: Residents reported a significant decrease in operative volume during the 2019 academic year, disproportionately impacting junior residents. The long-term consequences of COVID-19 on junior surgical trainee competence and ability to reach cases requirements are yet unknown but are unlikely to be negligible.

Effective Large Group Teaching for General Surgery.

Large group settings display no signs of disappearing. Most surgeons charged with this education have received no formal training. Lecturing remains the most common method of educating large groups. Even though factors required for an excellent lecture are known, their inconsistent application results in variation of effectiveness. Long-standing principles of rhetoric and recent advances in neuroscience, cognitive science, learning models, and teaching theory play a role in achieving effectiveness. This article makes recommendations for creating and delivering lectures, including active learning opportunities and modern innovations in information technology supporting teaching methods. Effective lecturing skills are acquired by persistent deliberate practice.

Signet-Ring Cell Colon Cancer in a Teenager: A Case Report.

The majority of colon cancers are diagnosed in the older population, though recent trends have demonstrated an increase in younger patients. Most colon cancers are considered adenocarcinoma. There are multiple histologic subtypes with varying prognoses. Mucinous types such as signet-ring cell carcinoma (SRCC) are more aggressive with poor outcomes. SRCC frequently presents with metastatic disease which contributes to its poor prognosis. It is most commonly diagnosed around age 40. SRCC of colonic origin is very rare and comprises only 1% of colorectal cancers. Rarer still is presentation in the teenaged patient, especially in the absence of any risk factors. We present a case of an 18-year-old male with colonic SRCC. The patient presented initially with vague abdominal discomfort and three weeks later was found to have a near-obstructing right-sided colon mass. He was taken to the operating room and found to have diffuse carcinomatosis. The patient underwent palliative loop ileostomy with plans for subsequent chemotherapy.

Impact of Surgery Program Characteristics on Fate of Non-designated Preliminary Surgery Interns.

OBJECTIVE: Non-designated preliminary (NDP) general surgery residents face the daunting challenge of obtaining a categorical residency position while undertaking the rigors of a general surgery residency. This additional application cycle represents a stressful time for these trainees and limited data exists to help guide applicants and program directors regarding the factors predictive of application success. While previous studies have focused solely on applicant related factors, no study to date has evaluated the effect of the residency program structure, institutional resources, or administrative support on these outcomes. DESIGN/SETTING: A multicenter retrospective review of 10 general surgery residency programs over a 5-year period from 2014 to 2019 was performed. Applicant related information was compiled from NDP general surgery residents and the results of their attempted second application into a categorical position. Applicant factors including age, gender, standardized test scores (USMLE/ABSITE), and professional training were examined. Program and administrative structure including residency class size, number of NDP PGY-2 positions, number of assistant program directors and program director (PD) background were also examined. Primary success was defined as a NDP resident successfully obtaining a categorical position within general surgery or a surgical subspecialty. Secondary success was obtaining a categorical residency position in any field of medical practice other than surgery or a surgical subspecialty in the United States. RESULTS: A total of 260 NDP trainees were evaluated with an average age of 29.1. Almost seventy percent of applicants were male, 40% graduated from a non-U.S. medical school and 24.2% required a visa to work in the United States. Thirty 4 percent of NDPs successfully obtained a categorical surgery position and an additional 35% obtained a categorical residency position in a nonsurgical field for an overall match success rate of 68.9%. Factors associated with primary success included ABSITE score (p < 0.001), US medical school graduation (p = 0.02), visa status (p = 0.03), presence of preliminary PGY-2 positions (p = 0.02), and PD professional development time (p = 0.004). Overall success was associated USMLE Step 1 scores (p = 0.02), number of approved chiefs (p = 0.03), presence of dedicated faculty researchers (p = 0.001), and PD professional development time (p < 0.001). CONCLUSIONS: Applicant, program-related, and administrative factors all have a significant impact on the success of NDP general surgery residents in obtaining a categorical surgical position. Trainees should consider all of these factors when applying to NDP residencies and in approaching their second application cycle to maximize their likelihood of a successful match.

A survey of current state of training of plastic surgery residents.

BACKGROUND: Plastic surgery training is undergoing major changes however there is paucity of data detailing the current state of training as perceived by plastic surgical trainees. Our aim was to determine the quality of training as perceived by the current trainee pool and their future plans. METHODS: A 25-item anonymous survey with three discrete sections (demographics, quality of training, and post-graduate career plans) was developed and distributed to plastic surgery residents during the academic year 2013. With the confidence interval of 95% and margin of error of 10%, our target response rate was 87 responders. RESULTS: We received a total of 114 respondents with all levels of Post Graduate Year in training represented. Upon comparison of residents with debt of <100,000 to residents with a debt of >250,000, those with higher debt were significantly less interested in fellowship training (p value 0.05) and were more likely to pursue private practice (p value <0.01). Disciplines within plastic surgery least offered as a separate rotation were microsurgery (45%) followed by aesthetic surgery (33%). 53.7% of the residents felt that they were least trained in aesthetic surgery followed by burn surgery 45.4%. Of note 56.4% intended to seek additional training after residency. Moreover residents with an average of 6.4 months of experience in an individual subspecialty were more likely to feel comfortable with that specialty. CONCLUSIONS: This survey highlights the areas and subspecialties that deserve attention as perceived by the current trainee pool.

Small bowel obstruction caused by self-anchoring suture used for peritoneal closure following robotic inguinal hernia repair.

Laparoscopic inguinal herniorraphy is a commonly performed procedure given the reported decrease in pain and earlier return to activity when compared with the open approach. Moreover, robotic assistance offers the operating surgeon considerable ergonomic advantages, making it an attractive alternative to conventional laparoscopic herniorraphy. Robotic herniorraphy utilizes the transabdominal preperitoneal approach where following repair peritoneal closure is necessary to avoid mesh exposure to the viscera. Self-anchoring sutures are frequently used to this end given the ease of use and knotless application. We present an unusual case of post-operative small bowel obstruction following robotic inguinal hernia repair caused by the self-anchoring suture used for peritoneal closure. This patient presented 3 days post-procedure with symptoms and cross-sectional imaging indicative of small bowel obstruction with a clear transition point. Underwent laparoscopic lysis of a single adhesive band originating from the loose intraperitoneal end of the suture leading to resolution of symptoms.

Impact of inappropriate initial antibiotics in critically ill surgical patients with bacteremia.

BACKGROUND: Bloodstream infections in critically ill patients are associated with mortality as high as 60% and a prolonged hospital stay. We evaluated the impact of inappropriate antibiotic therapy (IAAT) in a critically ill surgical cohort with bacteremia. METHODS: This retrospective study evaluated adults with intensive care unit admission greater than 72 hours and bacteremia. Two groups were evaluated: appropriate antibiotic therapy (AAT) vs IAAT. RESULTS: In 72 episodes of bacteremia, 57 (79%) AAT and 15 (21%) IAAT, mean age was 54 ± 17 years and APACHE II of 17 ± 8. Time to appropriate antibiotics was longer for IAAT (3 ± 5 IAAT vs 1 ± 1 AAT days, P = .003). IAAT was seen primarily with Acinetobacter spp (33% IAAT vs 9% AAT, P = .01) and Enterococcus faecium (26% IAAT vs 7% AAT, P = .03). If 2 or more bacteremic episodes occurred, Acinetobacter spp. was more likely, 32% vs 2%, P = .001. CONCLUSIONS: AAT selection is imperative in critically patients with bacteremia to reduce the significant impact of inappropriate selection. Repeated episodes of bacteremia should receive special attention.

An automated system for video documentation of all instances of fundamentals of laparoscopic surgery training: feasibility and potential advantages of extended assessment.

INTRODUCTION: Documentation of the acquisition of surgical skills is mandated during and after training. Assessment-driven feedback interspersed during Fundamentals of Laparoscopic Surgery (FLS) training is expected to improve the quality of practice and increase skill acquisition. But the direct observation of FLS task performance by experts required to form this feedback is not feasible because of staffing and cost limits. Video recordings can reproduce a display of FLS task performance identical to the original camera view and can provide the critical observations needed for FLS assessment. METHODS: We report the design and operation of an automated system for the capture of digital video clips of all FLS practice trials and for the support of remote, distributed assessments. RESULTS: Advantages included permanent documentation of performance, quality controlled assessment by non-Medical Doctor personnel, accurate quantification of practice frequency, and emergence of new observations on patterns of intermediate skill development. The completeness and accuracy of the dataset support analyses of group learning rates and lay the foundation for scientific training curriculum development. CONCLUSIONS: We conclude that video documentation of FLS training is feasible and worthwhile.

Establishing technical performance norms for general surgery residents.

BACKGROUND: Surgery residents are required to achieve performance milestones to advance in their residency. Level-specific, technical performance norms that could be used as milestones, however, do not currently exist. Our aim was to develop level-specific, technical performance norms for general surgery residents on select simulated tasks across multiple institutions. STUDY DESIGN: An IRB-approved, prospective, multi-institutional collaborative study with voluntary participation of residents was undertaken at the start of the 2011-2012 academic year. General surgery residents (PGY I-V) from seven institutions were tested on three laparoscopic and five open simulated surgical tasks, and their performance was assessed based on task time and errors. Means and standard deviations of performance for each resident level were calculated and compared. Residents with performance 1 standard deviation below the mean were considered outliers. RESULTS: A total of 147 residents were evaluated. Mean resident age was 28 ± 3 years; 42 % were female; and they had attended 74 different medical schools. Senior residents (PGY III-V) had more clinical and simulator experience than junior residents (PGY I-II) (p < 0.001). Resident performance scores progressively increased in all tasks reaching a plateau at a lower PGY level for open tasks. Depending on the task, 0-18 % of residents were outliers. When surveyed, 66 % of residents agreed that national performance norms for residents should exist. CONCLUSIONS: Performance norms were established for select tasks in a representative sample of US surgery residents. Such performance norms allow a more informed assessment of resident skill through comparison to national data and enable the identification of outliers who may benefit from additional training.

Organ failure in the obese adipocytes prime polymorphonuclear cell inflammation under stress conditions.

BACKGROUND: Obesity is associated with a higher risk of remote organ failure after shock and trauma. The mechanism(s) is poorly understood. Polymorphonuclear cell (PMN) inflammatory responses are important in the pathogenesis of organ injury following shock. Morbid obesity is a low-grade inflammatory state associated with proinflammatory mediator production from adipose tissue. We hypothesized that adipose tissue may modulate PMN inflammatory potential and is dependent on the magnitude of the injury-related stress response. This was studied in an in vitro model. METHODS: Adipose-derived stem cells (ADSCs) conditioned to behave as mature adipocytes were incubated with physiologic and stress concentrations of adrenaline for 12 hours, and cell culture supernatants were obtained. PMNs from normal human volunteers were cocultured with the ADSC supernatants (priming) followed by addition of 1-µM fMLP (activation). PMNs alone served as control. PMN activation was indexed by superoxide anion (O2) production, elastase release (%) and CD11b expression (mean fluorescent intensity). RESULTS: Physiologic and stress levels of adrenaline resulted in significantly increased PMN activation in the presence or absence of adipocytes. However, the largest increase was noted in PMNs exposed to ADSC culture supernatants that had been cocultured with stress levels of adrenaline for 12 hours, twofold increase in CD11b expression and fourfold increase in superoxide anion and percent elastase release. CONCLUSION: Adipocyte-derived mediators prime PMNs in vitro. There was a graded PMN response to adrenaline concentration with or without adipocytes in these experiments. The most profound increase in PMN inflammatory potential was noted with the adipocyte supernatant + stress adrenaline group. The clinical impact of obesity on remote organ injury is likely dependent on patient body mass index and the injury-related sympathetic responses. These data suggest a potential role for ß blockade in this patient population.

Value of fundamentals of laparoscopic surgery training in a fourth-year medical school advanced surgical skills elective.

BACKGROUND: Few data are available describing the benefits of initiating fundamentals of laparoscopic surgery (FLS) training during medical school. We hypothesized that an intense 1-month surgical skills elective that included FLS task training for fourth-year medical students (MS4s) would result in performance levels indistinguishable from graduating chief residents (PGY5) who had received clinical skill training and access to self-guided FLS curriculum. METHODS: From July 2007 through June 2011, 114 MS4s participated in a 1-month advanced surgical skills elective. The curriculum for the elective included cadaver dissections, patient management presentations, and surgical skill training (open surgical skills and basic laparoscopic skills modules performed on FLS trainers and virtual reality laparoscopic simulators). From June 2009 through June 2011, 21 PGY5s graduated who had never received formalized FLS skills training. These residents were tested on FLS by a certified proctor and the results recorded. The performance outcome measure was task completion time. Unpaired Student's t-test was used to compare the performance measures for each group. RESULTS: All PGY5s achieved FLS certification on their first attempt and completed enough cases for graduation. The MS4 group showed significantly better performance than the PGY5 group in the peg transfer and circle cut (P < 0.05). No difference was seen in the knot tying tasks between the two groups (P > 0.05) CONCLUSIONS: Incorporating FLS training into a 1 month-long medical school surgery elective enabled MS4s to achieve FLS performance similar to, or better than, the performance achieved by PGY5 surgery residents. We support the integration of FLS skills task training as a standard part of the skills training curriculum for medical students.

Combined endoscopic and laparoscopic approach to a gastroesophageal tumor.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: Smooth muscle tumors of the stomach, especially when benign, are a common clinical entity and can represent a therapeutic challenge. Classically the removal of such a tumor requires open laparotomy. We sought to perform this surgery utilizing minimally invasive technology. METHODS: We describe a minimally invasive technique combining laparoscopy with endoscopy to remove a sub-mucosal leiomyoma at the gastroesophageal junction. RESULTS: A 3.3-cm smooth muscle tumor of the gastroesophageal junction was removed completely and safely with the described procedure and thus saved the patient from requiring a laparotomy. CONCLUSION: Minimally invasive techniques can be used in combination to tackle difficult problems in general surgery leading to shorter hospital stays and improved patient satisfaction.

Impact of fundamentals of laparoscopic surgery training during medical school on performance by first year surgical residents.

BACKGROUND: Fundamentals of Laparoscopic Surgery (FLS) certification is a high stakes examination. The best training methods to enable successful certification are undetermined. We hypothesized that first year surgical residents (R01s) who had been pretrained as medical students would perform better during skills training than previously un-trained R01s. METHODS: This is an IRB-approved, retrospective review of FLS training data generated from a single surgical skills laboratory from July 2007 through June 2010. During the study period, there were 24 R01s with no previous FLS exposure (NOVICE group) and seven R01s who had undergone FLS task training while medical students (MS4 group). All R01s practiced the FLS skill tasks weekly for portions of the training sessions with informal feedback and teaching. Performance goals were proposed for each task based on local and national proficiency figures. The performance outcome measure was task completion time (TCT). Pretraining performance was designated iTCT and post-training fTCT. RESULTS: The MS4 group began with iTCTs for all four tasks that were significantly lower than the NOVICE iTCTs. At completion of the 16-wk training period, the MS4 group continued to demonstrate mean fTCTs that were lower for all four FLS skill tasks but only significantly for PEG, CIRCLE, and INTRA skill tasks. Both NOVICE and MS4 groups showed significant improvement for all four skill tasks (P < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: In the current milieu of work-hour limitations, the integration of FLS skill training into medical school curriculum provided a durable advantage to the pretrained R01s, which was associated with higher levels of final performance.

Potentially curable lung cancer patients not offered operation.

BACKGROUND: Recent reports have noted the decreased resection rate in early stage lung cancer. Our surgical population includes 25% second surgical opinion (SSO) patients not offered surgical intervention after initial evaluation at other institutions. This study assesses the reasons those patients were initially rejected for operation at other institutions and determines the outcome of operative intervention. METHODS: This report is an analysis of 103 consecutive patients undergoing lung operation for cancer by a single surgeon from June 2006 through June 2008. This included 26 patients (25%) in the SSO group and 77 patients (75%) seen initially at our cancer center (control). RESULTS: Reasons for initial rejection in the SSO group were the following: (1) anatomically unresectable (14 patients); (2) radiologic contraindication (11 patients); (3) multiple lesions (6 patients); (4) inadequate pulmonary reserve (5 patients); (5) significant medical comorbidities (2 patients); (6) advanced age (2 patients); (7) patient misunderstandings (2 patients); (8) prior high dose radiation (1 patient); (9) negative diagnostic study (1 patient) and negative exploratory thoracotomy (1 patient). Age and comorbidities were similar for both groups. The planned resection was completed in 25 of 26 patients. Two SSO patients (8%) and nine control patients (11%) had positive N2 nodes. Length of stay was identical and the single death was in a control patient. CONCLUSIONS: An SSO after initial rejection for resection of lung cancer is highly desirable. The short-term outcomes in these SSO patients screened at a multidisciplinary lung cancer center are comparable with patients offered resection after initial evaluation at a large multidisciplinary cancer center.

Appendectomy in the gynecological setting: intraoperative findings and corresponding histopathology.

BACKGROUND/AIMS: To evaluate the intraoperative findings and corresponding histopathology associated with appendectomies performed during benign gynecological surgery. METHODS: Retrospective case series. RESULTS: Twenty-two appendectomies were performed from 2002 through 2008 at Hutzel Women's Hospital due to intraoperative findings of inflammation or erythema (n = 8), periappendiceal adhesions (n = 5), injury to the appendix or mesoappendix (n = 2), fecalith (n = 2), dilation of the appendix (n = 1), adnexal mass involving the appendix (n = 1), and suspected lipoma (n = 1). Final pathology was consistent with significant findings such as acute inflammation, periappendicitis, and adhesions or endometriosis involving the appendix in 68.2% of cases. CONCLUSION: In the benign gynecological setting, appendectomies were primarily performed due to inflammation or erythema. In the majority of cases, significant appendiceal pathology was confirmed.

FLS skill retention (learning) in first year surgery residents.

BACKGROUND: Fundamentals of Laparoscopic Surgery (FLS) certification is reliable and valid; the American Board of Surgery requires FLS certification. Dynamics of skill retention after FLS training effect training schedules for residents. We hypothesized that the initial elevation of performance levels after FLS training would deteriorate predictably with time. METHODS: FLS performance data on 16 new surgical residents (R01s) was examined retrospectively. These R01s trained at 16 weekly sessions. Training included 4 FLS tasks, VR simulator tasks, and open surgical skills. FLS skills were practiced weekly with feedback but no instruction. Performance was tested PRE, POST, and DELAY. Outcome metrics were task completion times (TCTs). RESULTS: POST TCTs were below PRE TCTs in all R01s for all FLS tasks (P < 0.05). No difference was seen between the DELAY TCT and POST TCT for peg transfer (P = 0.726) and pattern cut (P = 0.114). The DELAY TCTs were longer than POST TCTs for extra- and intra corporeal knot-tying (P < 0.0001 and P = 0.029). Relative retention was 103% for peg transfer, 85% for pattern cut, 47% for extracorporeal knot tying, and 59% for intracorporeal knot tying. However, many individual's displayed DELAY TCT equal to or lower than POST TCT implying full retention. CONCLUSIONS: This study extends the data on FLS skill retention to an actual "production" training curriculum. This FLS training provided effective learning in R01s. Although performance levels fell across these tasks on average and for the majority of individual R01s, significant skill retention remained at 7-8 months. Early training will enable R01s to maintain or elevate skill levels with additional training sessions.

Prophylactic laparoscopic gastrectomy for hereditary diffuse gastric cancer: a case series in a single family.

BACKGROUND: Hereditary diffuse gastric carcinomas (HDGCs) are particularly troubling because of autosomal dominant heritance, high penetrance, early age of onset, and a lack of effective treatment once symptomatic. HDGC is further complicated by difficulty of effective screening. Gastrectomy provides definitive treatment for CDH1 mutation-positive patients. Attempting to minimize the morbidity and mortality of this procedure via a laparoscopic approach is appropriate. METHODS: Six consanguineous patients, 21 to 51 years of age, were identified as carriers of the CDH1 gene mutation. All of the patients' gastric mucosa was normal by endoscopic appearance and biopsy. After appropriate multispecialty counseling, all patients elected to undergo a laparoscopic total gastrectomy. Demographics, genealogy, operative approach, outcomes, and pathology were reviewed. RESULTS: All gastrectomies were completed using a laparoscopic approach. Gross examination of resected stomachs was unremarkable. Histological examination demonstrated multiple foci of invasive signet ring adenocarcinoma in all patients. There were no anastomotic leaks, one small bowel obstruction requiring reoperation, and one esophageal stricture requiring dilation. CONCLUSIONS: This series demonstrates the utility and safety of the laparoscopic approach for prophylactic total gastrectomy for carriers of the CDH1 gene mutation. It serves to highlight that patients with CDH1 mutations may be more likely to undergo gastrectomy if they are offered the lower risk laparoscopic approach.