Mapping the conformational energy landscape of Abl kinase using ClyA nanopore tweezers.

Protein kinases play central roles in cellular regulation by catalyzing the phosphorylation of target proteins. Kinases have inherent structural flexibility allowing them to switch between active and inactive states. Quantitative characterization of kinase conformational dynamics is challenging. Here, we use nanopore tweezers to assess the conformational dynamics of Abl kinase domain, which is shown to interconvert between two major conformational states where one conformation comprises three sub-states. Analysis of kinase-substrate and kinase-inhibitor interactions uncovers the functional roles of relevant states and enables the elucidation of the mechanism underlying the catalytic deficiency of an inactive Abl mutant G321V. Furthermore, we obtain the energy landscape of Abl kinase by quantifying the population and transition rates of the conformational states. These results extend the view on the dynamic nature of Abl kinase and suggest nanopore tweezers can be used as an efficient tool for other members of the human kinome.

Fast slow folding of an outer membrane porin.

In comparison to globular proteins, the spontaneous folding and insertion of ß-barrel membrane proteins are surprisingly slow, typically occurring on the order of minutes. Using single-molecule Förster resonance energy transfer to report on the folding of fluorescently labeled outer membrane protein G we measured the real-time insertion of a ß-barrel membrane protein from an unfolded state. Folding events were rare and fast (<20 ms), occurring immediately upon arrival at the membrane. This combination of infrequent, but rapid, folding resolves this apparent dichotomy between slow ensemble kinetics and the typical timescales of biomolecular folding.

Modifying the pH sensitivity of OmpG nanopore for improved detection at acidic pH.

The outer membrane protein G (OmpG) nanopore is a monomeric ß-barrel channel consisting of seven flexible extracellular loops. Its most flexible loop, loop 6, can be used to host high-affinity binding ligands for the capture of protein analytes, which induces characteristic current patterns for protein identification. At acidic pH, the ability of OmpG to detect protein analytes is hampered by its tendency toward the closed state, which renders the nanopore unable to reveal current signal changes induced by bound analytes. In this work, critical residues that control the pH-dependent gating of loop 6 were identified, and an OmpG nanopore that can stay predominantly open at a broad range of pHs was created by mutating these pH-sensitive residues. A short single-stranded DNA was chemically tethered to the pH-insensitive OmpG to demonstrate the utility of the OmpG nanopore for sensing complementary DNA and a DNA binding protein at an acidic pH.

Tuning Protein Discrimination Through Altering the Sampling Interface Formed between the Analyte and the OmpG Nanopore.

Nanopore sensors capable of distinguishing homologous protein analytes are highly desirable tools for proteomics research and disease diagnostics. Recently, an engineered outer membrane protein G (OmpG) nanopore with a high-affinity ligand attached to a gating loop 6 showed specificity for distinguishing homologous proteins in complex mixtures. Here, we report the development of OmpG nanopores with the other six loops used as the anchoring point to host an affinity ligand for protein sensing. We investigated how the analyte binding to the affinity ligand located at different loops affects the detection sensitivity, selectivity, and specificity. Our results reveal that analytes weakly attracted to the OmpG nanopore surface are only detectable when the ligand is tethered to loop 6. In contrast, protein analytes that form a strong interaction with the OmpG surface via electrostatic attractions are distinguishable by all seven OmpG nanopore constructs. In addition, the same analyte can generate distinct binding signals with different OmpG nanopore constructs. The ability to exploit all seven OmpG loops will aid the design of a new generation of OmpG sensors with increased sensitivity, selectivity, and specificity for biomarker sensing.

A Selective Activity-Based Approach for Analysis of Enzymes with an OmpG Nanopore.

Many enzymatic activity assays are based on either (1) identifying and quantifying the enzyme with methods such as western blot or enzyme-linked substrate assay (ELISA) or (2) quantifying the enzymatic reaction by monitoring the changing levels of either product or substrate. We have generated an outer membrane protein G (OmpG)-based nanopore approach to distinguish enzyme identity as well as analyze the enzyme's catalytic activity. Here, we engineered an OmpG nanopore with a peptide cut site inserted into one of its loops to detect proteolytic behavior. In addition, we generated an OmpG nanopore with a single-stranded DNA attached to a loop for analyzing nucleolytic cleavage. This OmpG nanopore approach may be highly useful in analyzing specific enzymes in complex biological samples, or in directly determining kinetics of enzyme-substrate complex association and dissociation.

Simulation of pH-Dependent, Loop-Based Membrane Protein Gating Using Pretzel.

Bacterial porins often exhibit ion conductance and gating behavior which can be modulated by pH. However, the underlying control mechanism of gating is often complex, and direct inspection of the protein structure is generally insufficient for full mechanistic understanding. Here we describe Pretzel, a computational framework that can effectively model loop-based gating events in membrane proteins. Our method combines Monte Carlo conformational sampling, structure clustering, ensemble energy evaluation, and a topological gating criterion to model the equilibrium gating state under the pH environment of interest. We discuss details of applying Pretzel to the porin outer membrane protein G (OmpG).

Protein Analyte Sensing with an Outer Membrane Protein G (OmpG) Nanopore.

Nanopore sensing is a powerful lab-on-a-chip technique that allows for the analysis of biomarkers present in small sample sizes. In general, nanopore clogging and low detection accuracy arise when the sample becomes more and more complex such as in blood or lysate. To address this, we developed an OmpG nanopore that distinguishes among not only different proteins in a mixture but also protein homologs. Here, we describe this OmpG-based nanopore system that specifically analyzes targets biomarkers in complex mixtures.

A pH-independent quiet OmpG pore with enhanced electrostatic repulsion among the extracellular loops.

Membrane protein pores have emerged as powerful nanopore sensors for single-molecule detection. OmpG, a monomeric nanopore, is comprised of fourteen ß-strands connected by seven flexible extracellular loops. The OmpG nanopore exhibits pH-dependent gating as revealed by planar lipid bilayer studies. Current evidence strongly suggests that the dynamic movement of loop 6 is responsible for the gating mechanism. In this work, we have shown that enhancing the electrostatic repulsion forces between extracellular loops suppressed the pH-dependent gating. Our mutant containing additional negative charges in loop 6 and loop 1 exhibited minimal spontaneous gating and reduced sensitivity to pH changes compared to the wild type OmpG. These results provide new evidence to support the mechanism of OmpG gating controlled by the complex electrostatic network around the gating loop 6. The pH-independent quiet OmpG pores could potentially be used as a sensing platform that operates at a broad range of pH conditions.

A Nanopore Approach for Analysis of Caspase-7 Activity in Cell Lysates.

Caspases are an important protease family that coordinate inflammation and programmed cell death. Two closely related caspases, caspase-3 and caspase-7, exhibit largely overlapping substrate specificities. Assessing their proteolytic activities individually has therefore proven extremely challenging. Here, we constructed an outer membrane protein G (OmpG) nanopore with a caspase substrate sequence DEVDG grafted into one of the OmpG loops. Cleavage of the substrate sequence in the nanopore by caspase-7 generated a characteristic signal in the current recording of the OmpG nanopore that allowed the determination of the activity of caspase-7 in Escherichia coli cell lysates. Our approach may provide a framework for the activity-based profiling of proteases that share highly similar substrate specificity spectrums.

Protein Motion and Configurations in a Form-Fitting Nanopore: Avidin in ClyA.

We probe the molecular dynamics and states of an avidin protein as it is captured and trapped in a voltage-biased cytolysin A nanopore using time-resolved single-molecule electrical conductance signals. The data for very large numbers of single-molecule events are analyzed and presented by a new method that provides clear visual insight into the molecular scale processes. Avidin in cytolysin A has surprisingly rich conductance spectra that reveal transient and more permanently trapped protein configurations in the pore and how they evolve into one another. We identify a long-lasting, stable, and low-noise configuration of avidin in the nanopore into which avidin can be reliably trapped and released. This may prove useful for single-molecule studies of other proteins that can be biotinylated and then transported by avidin to the pore via their coupling to avidin with biotin-avidin linking. We demonstrate the sensitivity of this system with detection of biotin attached to avidin captured by the pore.

Disruption of the open conductance in the ß-tongue mutants of Cytolysin A.

Cytolysin A (ClyA) is a water-soluble alpha pore-forming toxin that assembles to form an oligomeric pore on host cell membranes. The ClyA monomer possesses an α-helical bundle with a ß-sheet subdomain (the ß-tongue) previously believed to be critical for pore assembly and/or insertion. Oligomerization of ClyA pores transforms the ß-tongue into a helix-turn-helix that embeds into the lipid bilayer. Here, we show that mutations of the ß-tongue did not prevent oligomerization or transmembrane insertion. Instead, ß-tongue substitution mutants yielded pores with decreased conductance while a deletion mutation resulted in pores that rapidly closed following membrane association. Our results suggest that the ß-tongue may play an essential structural role in stabilizing the open conformation of the transmembrane domain.

Mechanism of OmpG pH-Dependent Gating from Loop Ensemble and Single Channel Studies.

Outer membrane protein G (OmpG) from Escherichia coli has exhibited pH-dependent gating that can be employed by bacteria to alter the permeability of their outer membranes in response to environmental changes. We developed a computational model, Protein Topology of Zoetic Loops (Pretzel), to investigate the roles of OmpG extracellular loops implicated in gating. The key interactions predicted by our model were verified by single-channel recording data. Our results indicate that the gating equilibrium is primarily controlled by an electrostatic interaction network formed between the gating loop and charged residues in the lumen. The results shed light on the mechanism of OmpG gating and will provide a fundamental basis for the engineering of OmpG as a nanopore sensor. Our computational Pretzel model could be applied to other outer membrane proteins that contain intricate dynamic loops that are functionally important.

Engineering a Novel Porin OmpGF Via Strand Replacement from Computational Analysis of Sequence Motif.

ß-Barrelmembrane proteins (ßMPs) form barrel-shaped pores in the outer membrane of Gram-negative bacteria, mitochondria, and chloroplasts. Because of the robustness of their barrel structures, ßMPs have great potential as nanosensors for single-molecule detection. However, natural ßMPs currently employed have inflexible biophysical properties and are limited in their pore geometry, hindering their applications in sensing molecules of different sizes and properties. Computational engineering has the promise to generate ßMPs with desired properties. Here we report a method for engineering novel ßMPs based on the discovery of sequence motifs that predominantly interact with the cell membrane and appear in more than 75% of transmembrane strands. By replacing ß1-ß6 strands of the protein OmpF that lack these motifs with ß1-ß6 strands of OmpG enriched with these motifs and computational verification of increased stability of its transmembrane section, we engineered a novel ßMP called OmpGF. OmpGF is predicted to form a monomer with a stable transmembrane region. Experimental validations showed that OmpGF could refold in vitro with a predominant ß-sheet structure, as confirmed by circular dichroism. Evidence of OmpGF membrane insertion was provided by intrinsic tryptophan fluorescence spectroscopy, and its pore-forming property was determined by a dye-leakage assay. Furthermore, single-channel conductance measurements confirmed that OmpGF function as a monomer and exhibits increased conductance than OmpG and OmpF. These results demonstrated that a novel and functional ßMP can be successfully engineered through strand replacement based on sequence motif analysis and stability calculation.

Tuning the selectivity and sensitivity of an OmpG nanopore sensor by adjusting ligand tether length.

We have previously shown that a biotin ligand tethered to the rim of an OmpG nanopore can be used to detect biotin-binding proteins. Here, we investigate the effect of the length of the polyethylene glycol tether on the nanopore's sensitivity and selectivity. When the tether length was increased from 2 to 45 ethylene repeats, sensitivity decreased substantially for a neutral protein streptavidin and slightly for a positively charged protein (avidin). In addition, we found that two distinct avidin binding conformations were possible when using a long tether. These conformations were sensitive to the salt concentration and applied voltage. Finally, a longer tether resulted in reduced sensitivity due to slower association for a monoclonal anti-biotin antibody. Our results highlight the importance of electrostatic, electroosmotic and electrophoretic forces on nanopore binding kinetics and sensor readout.

Selective Detection of Protein Homologues in Serum Using an OmpG Nanopore.

Outer membrane protein G is a monomeric ß-barrel porin that has seven flexible loops on its extracellular side. Conformational changes of these labile loops induce gating spikes in current recordings that we exploited as the prime sensing element for protein detection. The gating characteristics, open probability, frequency, and current decrease, provide rich information for analyte identification. Here, we show that two antibiotin antibodies each induced a distinct gating pattern, which allowed them to be readily detected and simultaneously discriminated by a single OmpG nanopore in the presence of fetal bovine serum. Our results demonstrate the feasibility of directly profiling proteins in real-world samples with minimal or no sample pretreatment.

Electrostatic Interactions between OmpG Nanopore and Analyte Protein Surface Can Distinguish between Glycosylated Isoforms.

The flexible loops decorating the entrance of OmpG nanopore move dynamically during ionic current recording. The gating caused by these flexible loops changes when a target protein is bound. The gating is characterized by parameters including frequency, duration, and open-pore current, and these features combine to reveal the identity of a specific analyte protein. Here, we show that OmpG nanopore equipped with a biotin ligand can distinguish glycosylated and deglycosylated isoforms of avidin by their differences in surface charge. Our studies demonstrate that the direct interaction between the nanopore and analyte surface, induced by the electrostatic attraction between the two molecules, is essential for protein isoform detection. Our technique is remarkably sensitive to the analyte surface, which may provide a useful tool for glycoprotein profiling.

Resolved single-molecule detection of individual species within a mixture of anti-biotin antibodies using an engineered monomeric nanopore.

Oligomeric protein nanopores with rigid structures have been engineered for the purpose of sensing a wide range of analytes including small molecules and biological species such as proteins and DNA. We chose a monomeric ß-barrel porin, OmpG, as the platform from which to derive the nanopore sensor. OmpG is decorated with seven flexible loops that move dynamically to create a distinct gating pattern when ionic current passes through the pore. Biotin was chemically tethered to the most flexible one of these loops. The gating characteristic of the loop's movement in and out of the porin was substantially altered by analyte protein binding. The gating characteristics of the pore with bound targets were remarkably sensitive to molecular identity, even providing the ability to distinguish between homologues within an antibody mixture. A total of five gating parameters were analyzed for each analyte to create a unique fingerprint for each biotin-binding protein. Our exploitation of gating noise as a molecular identifier may allow more sophisticated sensor design, while OmpG's monomeric structure greatly simplifies nanopore production.

A non-classical assembly pathway of Escherichia coli pore-forming toxin cytolysin A.

Cytolysin A (ClyA) is an α-pore forming toxin from pathogenic Escherichia coli (E. coli) and Salmonella enterica. Here, we report that E. coli ClyA assembles into an oligomeric structure in solution in the absence of either bilayer membranes or detergents at physiological temperature. These oligomers can rearrange to create transmembrane pores when in contact with detergents or biological membranes. Intrinsic fluorescence measurements revealed that oligomers adopted an intermediate state found during the transition between monomer and transmembrane pore. These results indicate that the water-soluble oligomer represents a prepore intermediate state. Furthermore, we show that ClyA does not form transmembrane pores on E. coli lipid membranes. Because ClyA is delivered to the target host cell in an oligomeric conformation within outer membrane vesicles (OMVs), our findings suggest ClyA forms a prepore oligomeric structure independently of the lipid membrane within the OMV. The proposed model for ClyA represents a non-classical pathway to attack eukaryotic host cells.