Effects of Walking Speed and Added Mass on Hip Joint Quasi-Stiffness in Healthy Young and Middle-Aged Adults.

Joint quasi-stiffness has been often used to inform exoskeleton design. Further understanding of hip quasi-stiffness is needed to design hip exoskeletons. Of interest are wearer responses to walking speed changes with added mass of the exoskeleton. This study analyzed hip quasi-stiffness at 3 walking speed levels and 9 added mass distributions among 13 young and 16 middle-aged adults during mid-stance hip extension and late-stance hip flexion. Compared to young adults, middle-aged adults maintained a higher quasi-stiffness with a smaller range. For a faster walking speed, both age groups increased extension and flexion quasi-stiffness. With mass evenly distributed on the pelvis and thighs or biased to the pelvis, both groups maintained or increased extension quasi-stiffness. With mass biased to the thighs, middle-aged adults maintained or decreased extension quasi-stiffness while young adults increased it. Young adults decreased flexion quasi-stiffness with added mass but not in any generalizable pattern with mass amounts or distributions. Conversely, middle-aged adults maintained or decreased flexion quasi-stiffness with even distribution on the pelvis and thighs or biased to the pelvis, while no change occurred if biased to the thighs. In conclusion, these results can guide the design of a hip exoskeleton's size and mass distribution according to the intended user's age.

How Do Joint Kinematics and Kinetics Change When Walking Overground with Added Mass on the Lower Body?

Lower-limb exoskeletons, regardless of their control strategies, have been shown to alter a user's gait just by the exoskeleton's own mass and inertia. The characterization of these differences in joint kinematics and kinetics under exoskeleton-like added mass is important for the design of such devices and their control strategies. In this study, 19 young, healthy participants walked overground at self-selected speeds with six added mass conditions and one zero-added-mass condition. The added mass conditions included +2/+4 lb on each shank or thigh or +8/+16 lb on the pelvis. OpenSim-derived lower-limb sagittal-plane kinematics and kinetics were evaluated statistically with both peak analysis and statistical parametric mapping (SPM). The results showed that adding smaller masses (+2/+8 lb) altered some kinematic and kinetic peaks but did not result in many changes across the regions of the gait cycle identified by SPM. In contrast, adding larger masses (+4/+16 lb) showed significant changes within both the peak and SPM analyses. In general, adding larger masses led to kinematic differences at the ankle and knee during early swing, and at the hip throughout the gait cycle, as well as kinetic differences at the ankle during stance. Future exoskeleton designs may implement these characterizations to inform exoskeleton hardware structure and cooperative control strategies.

How Does Added Mass Affect the Gait of Middle-Aged Adults? An Assessment Using Statistical Parametric Mapping.

To improve exoskeleton designs, it is crucial to understand the effects of the placement of such added mass on a broad spectrum of users. Most prior studies on the effects of added mass on gait have analyzed young adults using discrete point analysis. This study quantifies the changes in gait characteristics of young and middle-aged adults in response to added mass across the whole gait cycle using statistical parametric mapping. Fourteen middle-aged and fourteen younger adults walked during 60 s treadmill trials under nine different loading conditions. The conditions represented full-factorial combinations of low (+3.6 lb), medium (+5.4 lb), and high (+10.8 lb) mass amounts at the thighs and pelvis. Joint kinematics, kinetics and muscle activations were evaluated. The young and middle-aged adults had different responses to added mass. Under pelvis loading, middle-aged adults did not adopt the same kinematic responses as younger adults. With thigh loading, middle-aged adults generally increased knee joint muscle activity around heel strike, which could have a negative impact on joint loading. Overall, as age may impact the user's response to an exoskeleton, designers should aim to include sensors to directly monitor user response and adaptive control approaches that account for these differences.

Spatiotemporal and muscle activation adaptations during overground walking in response to lower body added mass.

BACKGROUND: Lower-extremity exoskeletons have been used in rehabilitation and performance augmentation for the past two decades. An exoskeleton adds a significant load to certain segments of the user's body and the underlying science about the effects of adding mass to the different lower-body segments is limited. RESEARCH QUESTION: What are the adaptive changes that occur when mass is placed on three lower body segments (pelvis, thigh, and shank)? METHODS: Healthy adults (n = 24) completed 5 overground walking trials for 7 added mass conditions. The seven added mass conditions included a Baseline (no-load) condition, + 2 and + 4 lb on either the shanks or the thighs, and + 8 and + 16 lb on the pelvis. Spatiotemporal metrics, surface electromyography (EMG) data from 5 lower-limb muscles, and ground reaction force data were analyzed and compared between conditions. RESULTS: Pelvis mass of 16 lb increased the double support time (p < 0.001) and decreased the single support time (p < 0.001) from the Baseline. Loading rate for none of the added mass conditions were significantly different from the Baseline. The highest activation of the considered thigh muscles and gastrocnemius generally occurred when High Mass was added either to the pelvis or the thigh. SIGNIFICANCE: The results demonstrate how added mass affects muscle activity, which could inform design of EMG-based exoskeleton controllers. With respect to spatiotemporal changes, results indicate that adding masses equal to or greater than 16 lb on the pelvis can cause significant differences when compared to unloaded walking. This finding implies that all other mass loadings in this study, regardless of location, are regulated. Thus, as a guideline to exoskeleton design, we recommend mass distributions over the pelvis and the thigh to take advantage of the larger muscle groups in adapting to the added mass.

Simulation on the Effect of Gait Variability, Delays, and Inertia with Respect to Wearer Energy Savings with Exoskeleton Assistance.

Exoskeletons are human-robot interfaces that have enormous potential to assist people with everyday tasks. To improve the design of exoskeletons for use in clinical populations, it is important to further our understanding of how exoskeleton design and control parameters lead to sub-optimal effectiveness. Here we simulated the effect of three factors, gait variability, wearer-exoskeleton delays, and exoskeleton inertia, have on the predicted energy assistance provided by an exoskeleton with a finite-state controller trained on a set of stroke survivors' free walking gait data. Results indicate that larger errors between the wearer's desired ankle trajectory and the exo's estimated ankle trajectory result in statistically large reductions in the actual assistance provided. Specifically lags on the order of even 10 ms can illustrate statistically sub-optimal performance. Likewise subjects that exhibit large gait variability will have a statistical reduction in actual assistance. However, reasonably low exoskeleton inertias are not significant as a factor in terms of sensitivity to wearer assistance. Therefore, to improve cooperative control algorithms for exoskeletons and achieve true assistance based on wearer induced motion, this work implies that designers should prioritize minimizing delays and wearers should train to reduce variability in order to maximize energy savings.