The importance of target binding kinetics for measuring target binding affinity in drug discovery: a case study from a CRF1 receptor antagonist program.

In drug discovery, it is essential to accurately measure drug-target binding affinity. Here, we revisit the fact that target binding kinetics impact the measurement of affinity, using a case study: development of corticotropin-releasing factor antagonists. Slow dissociation of the drug-target complex results in affinity assays being far from equilibrium, which results in erroneous estimates of affinity. This scenario can impair prediction of human dosing, assessment of target selectivity, identification of high-affinity ligands and determination of SAR. We describe strategies to detect lack of equilibration in affinity assays and methods to correctly measure affinity of slowly dissociating compounds. These considerations will facilitate drug discovery by ensuring reliable measurement of drug-target binding affinity.

Binding kinetics redefine the antagonist pharmacology of the corticotropin-releasing factor type 1 receptor.

Corticotropin-releasing factor (CRF) receptor antagonists are under preclinical and clinical investigation for stress-related disorders. In this study the impact of receptor-ligand binding kinetics on CRF1 receptor antagonist pharmacology was investigated by measuring the association rate constant (k1), dissociation rate constant (k₋1), and kinetically derived affinity at 37°C. Three aspects of antagonist pharmacology were reevaluated: comparative binding activity of advanced compounds, in vivo efficacy, and structure-activity relationships. Twelve lead compounds, with little previously noted difference of affinity, varied substantially in their kinetic binding activity with a 510-fold range of kinetically derived affinity (k₋1/k1), 170-fold range of k₋1, and 13-fold range of k1. The k₋1 values indicated previous affinity measurements were not close to equilibrium, resulting in compression of the measured affinity range. Dissociation was exceptionally slow for three ligands (k₋1 t(1/2) of 1.6-7.2 h at 37°C). Differences of binding behavior were consistent with in vivo pharmacodynamics (suppression of adrenocorticotropin in adrenalectomized rats). Ligand concentration-effect relationships correlated with their kinetically derived affinity. Two ligands that dissociated slowly (53 and 130 min) produced prolonged suppression, whereas only transient suppression was observed with a more rapidly dissociating ligand (16 min). Investigating the structure-activity relationship indicated exceptionally low values of k1, approaching 100,000-fold less than the diffusion-limited rate. Retrospective interpretation of medicinal chemistry indicates optimizing specific elements of chemical structure overcame kinetic barriers in the association pathway, for example, constraint of the pendant aromatic orthogonal to the ligand core. Collectively, these findings demonstrate receptor binding kinetics provide new dimensions for understanding and potentially advancing the pharmacology of CRF1 receptor antagonists.

Characterization of thien-2-yl 1S,2R-milnacipran analogues as potent norepinephrine/serotonin transporter inhibitors for the treatment of neuropathic pain.

Thien-2-yl 1S,2R-milnacipran analogues were synthesized and characterized as norepinephrine/serotonin transporter inhibitors. These compounds possessed higher potencies than 1S,2R-milnacipran (2R-1) while maintaining low molecular weight and moderate lipophilicity, which are the important features for the pharmacological and pharmacokinetic characteristics of milnacipran (1). Thus, compound 5c exhibited IC50 values of 2.3 and 32 nM, respectively, at NET and SERT, which were more than 10-fold better than those of 1 (NET IC50 = 77 nM, SERT IC50 = 420 nM). Moreover, 5c achieved the same efficacy as 1, but with much lower doses, in a rodent spinal nerve ligation pain model. In addition, 5c displayed desirable pharmacokinetic properties in several species, including high oral availability and significant brain penetration.

Synthesis and structure-activity relationships of selective norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (sNRI) with improved pharmaceutical characteristics.

The design synthesis and SAR of a series of chiral ring-constrained norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors with improved physicochemical properties is described. Typical compounds are potent (IC(50)s<10 nM), selective against the other monoamine transporters, weak CYP2D6 inhibitors (IC(50)s>1 microM) and stable to oxidation by human liver microsomes. In addition, the compounds exhibit a favorable polarity profile.

Synthesis and structure-activity relationships of selective norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (sNRI) with a heterocyclic ring constraint.

The design, synthesis and SAR of a series of heterocyclic ring-constrained norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors are described. As racemates, the best compounds compare favorably with atomoxetine (IC(50)'s<10 nM) in potency at the transporter.

Structure-activity relationship studies on a series of piperazinebenzylalcohols and their ketone and amine analogs as melanocortin-4 receptor ligands.

A series of piperazinebenzylalcohols were prepared and studied to compare with their ketone and amine analogs as MC4R antagonists. Several benzylalcohols such as 14a and 14g displayed low nanomolar binding affinities (K(i)<10 nM), and high selectivities over other melanocortin receptor subtypes.

Structure-activity relationships of chiral selective norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors (sNRI) with increased oxidative stability.

The synthesis and SAR of a series of chiral heterocyclic ring-constrained norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors are described. The best compounds compare favorably with atomoxetine in potency (IC(50)s<10 nM), selectivity against the other monoamine transporters, and inhibition of CYP2D6 (IC(50)s>1 microM). In addition, the compounds are generally more stable than atomoxetine to oxidative metabolism and thus are likely to have lower clearance in humans.

Studies on the structure-activity relationship of bicifadine analogs as monoamine transporter inhibitors.

Compounds with various activities and selectivities were discovered through structure-activity relationship studies of bicifadine analogs as monoamine transporter inhibitors. The norepinephrine-selective 2-thienyl compound S-6j was efficacious in a rodent pain model.

Discovery of a potent, selective, and less flexible selective norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor (sNRI).

The design, synthesis, and SAR of a series of ring-constrained norepinephrine reuptake inhibitors are described. A substantially rigid inhibitor with potent functional activity at the transporter (IC(50)=8 nM) was used to develop a model for the distance and orientation of key features necessary for interaction with the norepinephrine transporter (NET).

Identification of 1S,2R-milnacipran analogs as potent norepinephrine and serotonin transporter inhibitors.

A series of milnacipran analogs were synthesized and studied as monoamine transporter inhibitors, and several potent compounds with moderate lipophilicity were identified from the 1S,2R-isomers. Thus, 15l exhibited IC(50) values of 1.7nM at NET and 25nM at SERT, which were, respectively, 20- and 13-fold more potent than 1S,2R-milnacipran 1-II.

Studies on a series of milnacipran analogs containing a heteroaromatic group as potent norepinephrine and serotonin transporter inhibitors.

A series of milnacipran analogs containing a heteroaromatic group were synthesized and studied as monoamine transporter inhibitors. Many compounds exhibited higher potency than milnacipran at NET and NET/SERT with no significant change in lipophilicity. For example, compound R-26f was about 10-fold more potent than milnacipran with IC(50) values of 8.7 and 26nM at NET and SERT, respectively.

Pharmacological and pharmacokinetic characterization of 2-piperazine-alpha-isopropyl benzylamine derivatives as melanocortin-4 receptor antagonists.

A series of 2-piperazine-alpha-isopropylbenzylamine derivatives were synthesized and characterized as melanocortin-4 receptor (MC4R) antagonists. Attaching an amino acid to benzylamines 7 significantly increased their binding affinity, and the resulting compounds 8-12 bound selectively to MC4R over other melanocortin receptor subtypes and behaved as functional antagonists. These compounds were also studied for their permeability using Caco-2 cell monolayers and metabolic stability in human liver microsomes. Most compounds exhibited low permeability and high efflux ratio possibly due to their high molecular weights. They also showed moderate metabolic stability which might be associated with their moderate to high lipophilicity. Pharmacokinetic properties of these MC4R antagonists, including brain penetration, were studied in mice after oral and intravenous administrations. Two compounds identified to possess high binding affinity and selectivity, 10d and 11d, were studied in a murine cachexia model. After intraperitoneal (ip) administration of 1mg/kg dose, mice treated with 10d had significantly more food intake and weight gain than the control animals, demonstrating efficacy by blocking the MC4 receptor. Similar in vivo effects were also observed when 11d was dosed orally at 20mg/kg. These results provide further evidence that a potent and selective MC4R antagonist has potential in the treatment of cancer cachexia.

Allosteric ligands for the corticotropin releasing factor type 1 receptor modulate conformational states involved in receptor activation.

Allosteric modulators of G-protein-coupled receptors can regulate conformational states involved in receptor activation ( Mol Pharmacol 58: 1412-1423, 2000 ). This hypothesis was investigated for the corticotropin-releasing factor type 1 (CRF(1)) receptor using a novel series of ligands with varying allosteric effect on CRF binding (inhibition to enhancement). For the G-protein-uncoupled receptor, allosteric modulation of CRF binding was correlated with nonpeptide ligand signaling activity; inverse agonists inhibited and agonists enhanced CRF binding. These data were quantitatively consistent with a two-state equilibrium underlying the modulation of CRF binding to the G-protein-uncoupled receptor. We next investigated the allosteric effect on CRF-stimulated G-protein coupling. Ligands inhibited CRF-stimulated cAMP accumulation regardless of their effect on the G-protein-uncoupled state. The modulators reduced CRF E(max) values, suggesting that they reduced the efficacy of a CRF-bound active state to couple to G-protein. Consistent with this hypothesis, the modulators inhibited binding to a guanine nucleotide-sensitive state. Together, the results are quantitatively consistent with a model in which 1) the receptor exists in three predominant states: an inactive state, a weakly active state, and a CRF-bound fully active state; 2) allosteric inverse agonists stabilize the inactive state, and allosteric agonists stabilize the weakly active state; and 3) antagonism of CRF signaling results from destabilization of the fully active state. These findings imply that nonpeptide ligands differentially modulate conformational states involved in CRF(1) receptor activation and suggest that different conformational states can be targeted in designing nonpeptide ligands to inhibit CRF signaling.

Design and synthesis of 3-arylpyrrolidine-2-carboxamide derivatives as melanocortin-4 receptor ligands.

Based on 3-phenylpropionamides, a series of 3-arylpyrrolidine-2-carboxamide derivatives was designed and synthesized to study the effect of cyclizations as melanocortin-4 receptor ligands. It was found that the 2R,3R-pyrrolidine isomer possessed the most potent affinity among the four stereoisomers.

Studies on the SAR and pharmacophore of milnacipran derivatives as monoamine transporter inhibitors.

Derivatives of milnacipran were synthesized and studied as monoamine transporter inhibitors. Potent analogs were discovered at NET (9k) and at both NET and SERT (9s and 9u). A pharmacophore model was established based on the conformational analysis of milnacipran in aqueous solution using NMR techniques and was consistent with the SAR results.

Studies on the structure-activity relationship of the basic amine of phenylpiperazines as melanocortin-4 receptor antagonists.

A series of piperazinephenethylamines were synthesized to study the contribution of a basic amine to binding affinity at the melanocortin-4 receptor. Several potent compounds from this series possessed subnanomolar K(i) values in a competition binding assay.

Syntheses of tetrahydrothiophenes and tetrahydrofurans and studies of their derivatives as melanocortin-4 receptor ligands.

Piperazinebenzylamine derivatives from trans-4-(4-chlorophenyl)tetrahydrothiophene-3-carboxylic acid 6 and its S-oxide 7 and sulfone 8, and the tetrahydrofuran 9 and its two regioisomers 11 and 13 were synthesized and studied for their binding affinities at the human melanocortin-4 receptor. These five-membered ring constrained compounds possessed similar or lower potency compared to the acyclic analogs.

Identification and characterization of pyrrolidine diastereoisomers as potent functional agonists and antagonists of the human melanocortin-4 receptor.

A series of trans-4-phenylpyrrolidine-3-carboxamides were synthesized and characterized as potent ligands of the human melanocortin-4 receptor. Interestingly, a pair of diastereoisomers 13b displayed potent functional agonist and antagonist activity, respectively. Thus, the 3S,4R-pyrrolidine 13b-1 possessed a Ki of 1.0 nM and an EC50 of 3.8 nM, while its 3R,4S-isomer 13b-2 exhibited a Ki of 4.7 and an IC50 of 64 nM. Both compounds were highly selective over other melanocortin receptor subtypes. The MC4R agonist 13b-1 also demonstrated efficacy in a diet-induced obesity model in rats.

Design, synthesis, in vitro, and in vivo characterization of phenylpiperazines and pyridinylpiperazines as potent and selective antagonists of the melanocortin-4 receptor.

Benzylamine and pyridinemethylamine derivatives were synthesized and characterized as potent and selective antagonists of the melanocortin-4 receptor (MC4R). These compounds were also profiled in rodents for their pharmacokinetic properties. Two compounds with diversified profiles in chemical structure, pharmacological activities, and pharmacokinetics, 10 and 12b, showed efficacy in an established murine cachexia model. For example, 12b had a K(i) value of 3.4 nM at MC4R, was more than 200-fold selective over MC3R, and had a good pharmacokinetic profile in mice, including high brain penetration. Moreover, 12b was able to stimulate food intake in the tumor-bearing mice and reverse their lean body mass loss. Our results provided further evidence that a potent and selective MC4R antagonist with appropriate pharmacokinetic properties might potentially be useful for the treatment of cancer cachexia.

Synthesis and characterization of pyrrolidine derivatives as potent agonists of the human melanocortin-4 receptor.

A series of trans-4-phenylpyrrolidine-3-carboxamides were synthesized and characterized as potent ligands of the human melanocortin-4 receptor. Interestingly, a pair of diastereoisomers 20f-1 and 20f-2 displayed potent functional agonist and antagonist activity, respectively. Thus, the 3S,4R-compound 20f-1 possessed a K(i) of 11nM and an EC(50) of 24nM, while its 3R,4S-isomer 20f-2 exhibited a K(i) of 8.6 and an IC(50) of 65nM. Both compounds were highly selective over other melanocortin receptor subtypes. The MC4R agonist 20f-1 also demonstrated efficacy in diet-induced obese rats.