Patient volume per surgeon does not predict survival in adult level I trauma centers.

BACKGROUND: The 1999 American College of Surgeons resources for optimal care document added the requirement that Level I trauma centers admit over 240 patients with Injury Severity Score (ISS) > 15 per year or that trauma surgeons care for at least 35 patients per year. The purpose of this study was to test the hypothesis that high volume of patients with ISS > 15 per individual trauma surgeon is associated with improved outcome. METHODS: Data were obtained from the trauma registry of the five American College of Surgeons-verified adult Level I trauma centers in our mature trauma system between January 1, 1998, and March 31, 1999. Data abstracted included age, sex, Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score, intensive care unit length of stay, hospital length of stay, probability of survival (Ps), mechanism of injury, number of patients per each trauma surgeon and institution, and mortality. Multiple logistic regression was performed to select independent variables for modeling of survival. RESULTS: From the five Level I centers there were 11,932 trauma patients in this time interval; of these, 1,754 patients (14.7%) with ISS > 15 were identified and used for analysis. Patients with ISS > 15 varied from 173 to 625 per institution; trauma surgeons varied from 8 to 25 per institution; per-surgeon patient volume varied from 0.8 to 96 per year. Logistic regression analysis revealed that the best independent predictors of survival were Ps, GCS score, age, mechanism of injury, and institutional volume (p < 0.01). Age and institutional volume correlated negatively with survival. Analysis of per-surgeon patient caseload added no additional predictive value (p = 0.44). CONCLUSION: The significant independent predictors of survival in severely injured trauma patients are Ps, GCS score, age, mechanism of injury, and institutional volume. We found no statistically meaningful contribution to the prediction of survival on the basis of per-surgeon patient volume. Since this volume criterion for surgeon enpanelment and trauma center designation would not be expected to improve outcome, such a requirement should be justified by other measures or abandoned.

Multiple organ failure: by the time you predict it, it's already there.

OBJECTIVE: Validate an at-risk population to study multiple organ failure and to determine the importance of organ dysfunction 24 hours after injury in determining the ultimate severity of multiple organ failure. METHODS: We evaluated 105 patients admitted to five academic trauma centers during a 1-year period who survived for more than 24 hours with Injury Severity Scores > or = 25 and who received 6 or more units of blood. Organ dysfunction was scored daily with a modified multiple organ failure scoring system made up of individual adult respiratory distress syndrome score, renal dysfunction, hepatic dysfunction, and cardiac dysfunction scores. Multiple organ failure (MOF) severity was quantitated using the maximum daily multiple organ failure score and the cumulative sum of daily multiple organ failure scores for the first 7 days (MOF 7) and 10 days (MOF 10). Independent variables included markers of tissue injury, shock, host factors, physiologic response, therapeutic factors, and organ dysfunction within the first 24 hours after admission. Data were subjected to a conditional stepwise multiple regression analysis, first excluding and then including 24-hour MOF as an independent variable. RESULTS: Of the 105 high-risk patients, 69 (66%) developed a maximum daily multiple organ failure score > or = 1; 50 (72%) did so on day 1 one and 60 (87%) did so by day 2. In multiple regression models, the multiple correlation coefficient increased from 0.537 to 0.720 when maximum MOF was the dependent variable, from 0.449 to 0.719 when maximum daily MOF was the dependent variable, from 0.519 to 0.812 when MOF 7 was the dependent variable, and from 0.514 to 0.759 when MOF 10 was the dependent variable. CONCLUSION: We have confirmed that the population of patients with Injury Severity Scores > or = 25 who received 6 or more units of blood represent a high-risk group for the development of multiple organ failure. Our data also indicate that multiple organ failure after trauma is established within 24 hours of injury in the majority of patients who develop it. It appears that multiple organ failure is already present at the time when most published models are trying to predict whether or not it will occur.

A risk profile of emergency room adult trauma victims: intentional versus unintentional trauma injuries.

This article presents a prospective study of 285 adult trauma victims admitted to a Los Angeles inner-city level 1 trauma center, from November 1991 to February 1992. The purpose of this study was to determine the magnitude of intentional and unintentional trauma injuries in this adult patient population, and to identify sociodemographic, lifestyle and medical risk factors predisposing patients to intentional vs. unintentional trauma injury. Chi-square analysis revealed that intentional trauma victims and unintentional trauma victims significantly differ in 8 of 13 risk factors. The resulting risk profile indicated that intentional trauma victims were more likely to be between the ages of 16-29 years old; African American males and more likely to present to the emergency room with injury severity scores higher than 15 (indicating severe injuries) than unintentional trauma victims. Strategies for prevention and medical social work intervention are discussed.

Geographic and temporal patterns of recurrent intentional injury in south-central Los Angeles.

To better understand geographic and temporal patterns of recurrent intentional injury, 285 consecutive trauma patients were evaluated prospectively. Fifteen were excluded because of immediate death or severe brain injury. The remaining 270 patients were interviewed. Of these, 59 (22%) had been treated in a hospital for a total of 75 previous episodes of intentional trauma (mean: 1.3 episodes/patient). In 66 of the 75 episodes, the patient recalled where treatment had been received (88%). Twenty-eight (42%) of the 66 episodes had been treated at King/Drew Medical Center (KDMC), 36 (55%) had been treated at a hospital within a 3-mile radius of KDMC, 48 (73%) within an 8-mile radius, and 63 (95%) within a 10-mile radius. Sixty-five percent of the episodes occurred 5 years or less prior to the current injury (range: 11 days to 30 years; mean: 4.9 years). Patients currently admitted for intentional injury were more likely to have had intentional injury previously than those with unintentional injury (27% versus 12%). Based on these findings, we conclude that intentional trauma patients in our community remain in a defined geographic region and that there is a definable high-risk period for recurrent intentional injury. These conclusions should enhance the development of a framework on which future violence prevention programs can be designed.

Continuous use of standard process audit filters has limited value in an established trauma system.

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the ability of five quality assurance/ quality improvement audit filters to identify opportunities for improvement in patient care in a mature trauma system. DESIGN: Retrospective analysis of prospectively collected data. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Total patient population at risk and audit filter fallouts were evaluated for the following audit filters: patients with (1) Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score < 14 who did not receive a CT scan within 2 hours of admission; (2) subdural/ epidural hematomas who did not undergo craniotomy within 4 hours; (3) open tibial fractures who did not undergo debridement within 8 hours; (4) abdominal gunshot wounds who did not undergo laparotomy within 4 hours; and (5) all deaths where a quality assurance action was taken. The filters were used for 1 year. Mortality was compared between fallouts and nonfallouts in each category and the frequency of corrective actions for each category were determined. RESULTS: Corrective actions were taken in 97 of the 418 fallouts from 3,787 patients at risk. The majority (77%) of these actions were for patients in the death audit filter group. There were 343 nondeath fallouts, representing 13% of the 2,719 nondeath patients at risk. Of these, 22 corrective actions were taken, representing 6.4% of the fallouts and less than 1% of the patients at risk. CONCLUSION: The non-death process based audit filters that we evaluated in our trauma system documented adherence to care process standards but found few opportunities for quality improvement, suggesting that audit filters should be periodically evaluated and changed when their goals have been accomplished.

Aortoesophageal fistulae due to gunshot wounds: report of two cases with one survivor.

We report the cases of two patients who developed aortoesophageal fistulae after sustaining gunshot wounds to the chest. One suddenly exsanguinated 5 hours postinjury while in the angiography suite. The other manifested 4 weeks postinjury while in a rehabilitation hospital for associated spinal cord injury. The diagnosis and management were complicated, but the patient lived. He is the only survivor of aortoesophageal fistula due to gunshot wound that we could find in the literature.

Incidence of cervical spine injury in patients with gunshot wounds to the head.

Cervical spine immobilization is standard during the early stages of prehospital and hospital care of patients with blunt head injury. However, the need for cervical spine immobilization in patients with gunshot wounds to the head has not been addressed. To determine the incidence and types of cervical spine injury in this group, we retrospectively examined the records of 308 consecutive patients who had computed tomographic (CT) scans of the head to evaluate brain injury after gunshot wounds. Of the 266 patients with data adequate for review, 157 (59%) had a complete lateral x-ray film of the cervical spine. Of these 157, 105 had wounds limited to the calvaria, and none had cervical spine injury. Of 52 patients with complete lateral x-ray films and wounds not limited to the calvaria, 5 (10%) had cervical spine or spinal cord injury. Of the 192 patients who had CT-proven intracranial injury, 86 (45%) required immediate intubation before x-ray films were obtained, and 67 (35%) died. We conclude that cervical spine immobilization may not be required during endotracheal intubation of brain-injured gunshot victims with wounds limited to the calvaria.

Management of penetrating colon injuries.

The management of colon injuries remains an area of major controversy. Selecting the patients who can undergo primary repair safely remains undefined. To address this issue, 231 consecutive patients with penetrating colon injuries were reviewed to determine those factors that affected outcome. Overall, there were 54 (25.2%) septic complications, with 36 (16.8%) wound infections and 18 (8.4%) intra-abdominal abscesses. There were seven (3.3%) deaths in the entire series. The surgical management method of the colon injury was not significant in wound infections (P > .39), intra-abdominal abscesses (P > .24), or mortality (P > .39). A more aggressive approach of primary repair should be performed for civilian colon injuries.

Firearm injuries in girls and women. The unaddressed imperative.

OBJECTIVE: To describe the trends in firearm fatalities in California between 1987 and 1991 and the 153 firearm injuries in girls and women treated at the King/Drew Medical Center, Los Angeles, Calif, from September 1, 1991, to December 31, 1992. DESIGN: Retrospective study. SETTING: The study was conducted at the King/Drew Medical Center, a university-based county hospital, one of the major trauma centers in Los Angeles. PATIENTS: At the King/Drew Medical Center, 32 patients (21%) required at least one major procedure. Of the 16 patients who died, 14 (88%) died in the emergency department of wounds to the head (six patients), chest (five patients), and abdomen (three patients). The odds ratio of dying if injured in the head, face, or neck was 2.23, and in the abdomen, 1.0. Surgeons rarely probe for the underlying cause of injury. MAIN OUTCOME: The outcome has been a 2.28-fold increase in deaths in girls and women aged 10 to 19 years. RESULTS: Much of the violence against girls and women is perpetrated by those known to them. CONCLUSION: Firearms are the most frequently used weapon in female homicides. Firearm fatalities in women represent a significant problem among all ethnic groups. Trauma centers must take the lead in the collection of meaningful data to implement effective gender- and ethnic-specific violence prevention strategies.

Management of extraperitoneal rectal injuries.

Twenty-eight consecutive extraperitoneal rectal injuries for a period of 34 months ending in May 1990 were reviewed retrospectively. All injuries were due to penetrating gunshot wounds. The rectal exam was positive in 75% of patients versus 80.8% with proctosigmoidoscopy. All 28 patients had diversion of the fecal stream. Diverting colostomies were performed in 17 patients, Hartmann's colostomies in 7 patients, and proximal loop colostomies in 4 patients. Presacral drainage was used in 25 patients (89.3%). Distal irrigation was performed in 13 patients (46.4%) and primary repair in 9 patients (32.1%). There was one infectious complication (3.6%) and no deaths (0%). Fecal diversion and presacral drainage are the mainstay of therapy for civilian rectal injuries. The importance of distal irrigation of the rectum has not been established. Primary repair of the rectum has no effect on morbidity and mortality.

Relationship between supranormal circulatory values, time delays, and outcome in severely traumatized patients.

OBJECTIVE: To describe the temporal patterns of hemodynamics and oxygen transport in survivors and nonsurvivors of severe trauma in relation to time delays, mortality, and morbidity. DESIGN: Prospective, empiric analysis. SETTING: University-run, inner city county hospital with a Level I trauma center. PATIENTS: A series of 90 consecutively monitored, severely ill trauma patients. METHODS: We followed 90 patients from admission through their hospital course, and divided the study group into patients with estimated blood loss of < or = 3000 mL and those patients with an estimated blood loss of < 3000 mL. For each patient, vital signs were recorded in the Emergency Department, operating room, recovery room, and surgical ICU. Hemodynamic and oxygen transport variables were measured at least every 12 hrs for 96 hrs postadmission. Final outcome and complications were recorded. RESULTS: In the first 24 hrs, the values of 60 survivors were significantly higher than the values of 30 nonsurvivors for mean cardiac index (4.52 +/- 1.45 vs. 3.80 +/- 1.20 L/min/m2; p < .05), oxygen delivery (670 +/- 230 vs. 540 +/- 200 mL/min/m2; p < .01), and oxygen consumption (166 +/- 48 vs. 134 +/- 47 mL/min/m2; p < .01). Thirteen (50%) of 26 patients who never attained mean survivors' values (defined as the mean survivors' values listed above) died. Also, 12 (57%) of 21 patients who took > 24 hrs to attain these values died. In contrast, only five (12%) of 43 patients who reached mean survivors' values in < or = 24 hrs died. Thirty-five of 90 patients lost < 3000 mL of blood; 17 of these 35 patients failed to reach survivors' values within 24 hrs, and 12 (71%) patients died. However, of 18 patients with an estimated blood loss of > 3000 mL, who reached survivors' values in < or = 24 hrs, only two (12%) died. The patients reaching survivors' values in < or = 24 hrs, > 24 hrs, or not at all had similar Injury Severity Scores (28 +/- 13, 26 +/- 13, and 26 +/- 12, respectively) and Trauma Scores (12 +/- 3, 13 +/- 3, and 12 +/- 3, respectively). Only six (12%) of 43 patients reaching survivors' values in < or = 24 hrs developed adult respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS), while 27 (57%) of 47 patients showed these values in > 24 hrs or never developed ARDS. CONCLUSIONS: Reaching supranormal circulatory values, especially within 24 hrs of injury, may improve survival and reduce the frequency of shock-related organ failure in severely traumatized patients.

Time-related effects of heparin sulfate on regional and systemic anticoagulation.

Optimal timing of vascular clamping to anticoagulation during cardiovascular surgical procedures is poorly defined. This study uses a canine model to determine the effectiveness of three different methods of heparin administration. Heparin sulfate (150 IU/kg) was administered by: injection into the jugular vein 5 minutes before infrarenal aortic clamping (Group 1), injection into the terminal aorta immediately after infrarenal aortic clamping (Group 2), and injection into the jugular vein immediately after infrarenal aortic clamping (Group 3). Thrombin clotting times and partial thromboplastin times were measured in venous blood from the upper and lower extremities before (baseline) heparin administration, and 1, 3, and 5 minutes following heparin administration. Activated clotting times were assessed in lower extremity blood at baseline, and at 1 and 5 minutes after heparin injection. Significant differences existed between groups in both upper and lower extremities. Systemic anticoagulation occurred within 1 minute after intravenous heparin administration in Groups 1 and 2 in the lower extremity, and Groups 1 and 3 in the upper extremity. Delayed anticoagulation in the lower extremity was noted with systemic injection after aortic clamping in Group 3, and after regional intra-aortic administration in the upper extremity of Group 2 subjects. Complete anticoagulation was noted by 5 minutes in all groups in both the upper and lower extremities. These results suggest that the safe time period between heparin administration and vascular clamping varies with the route and the timing of its administration. Intravenous administration prior to aortic cross-clamping provided adequate anticoagulation in this canine model in both the upper and lower extremity blood after 1 minute of heparin circulation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Injury and violence in Los Angeles. Impact on access to health care and surgical education.

The Los Angeles County (California) Trauma Hospital System was designed to ensure that all patients requiring specialized trauma care would be transported directly to a trauma center using established trauma triage criteria. The designation and implementation of all level 1, 2, and 3 (rural) trauma centers were completed between October 1983 and July 1985. However, by February 1, 1985, one level 2 trauma center withdrew, and nine other level 2 and 3 trauma centers followed suit over the next few months and years. The reasons for closure of these 10 trauma centers were almost exclusively related to economic factors. The major impact of trauma center closure on surgical educational programs at the Drew University of Medicine and Science and the Martin Luther King, Jr/Charles R. Drew Medical Center have been additive and cumulative. The high volume of patients with trauma has been cited, sometimes correctly and sometimes incorrectly, as the primary reason for a lack of access to health care for patients without trauma. We have developed a blueprint for survival that, when fully implemented, will improve access to health care for all residents in our catchment area and optimize surgical education. While the Los Angeles County Trauma Hospital System has had many difficulties during the last 9 years, the population it serves is greater than that in 42 states in the United States. The experiences gained in Los Angeles County may be beneficial to statewide systems in the United States and in countries of comparable size.

Splenic injury from gunshot wounds to the chest without diaphragmatic or peritoneal violation: case reports.

Three cases of isolated splenic injury without peritoneal penetration are described. Two patients were explored because of bullet trajectory, one was explored because of a positive physical examination. Two patients had minor splenic injuries. One required splenorrhaphy. A review of intraperitoneal injury from extraperitoneal gunshot wounds is presented.

Evaluation of a blunt and penetrating trauma algorithm for truncal injury.

The authors objective was to develop and test a single branch-chain decision tree for blunt and penetrating truncal injury. Over the 4-month study period there were 979 patients evaluated in the emergency department; 674 of these patients were admitted to the hospital. Thirty-four (5%) of the 674 admitted patients died of truncal injury. The study group consisted of 239 of the most severely injured patients; 41 of these (17%) died. Of the 44 patients managed with major deviations from the algorithm, 27 (61%) died. Only 14 of the 195 patients (7%) whose management complied with the algorithm died. The authors conclude that following the specific management criteria outlined by the algorithm may improve the survival of severely traumatized patients.

The efficacy of central venous and pulmonary artery catheters and therapy based upon them in reducing mortality and morbidity.

The purpose of this study was to (1) evaluate the relative cost effectiveness of the central venous pressure and flow-directed pulmonary artery catheters used to maintain normal hemodynamic values as therapeutic goals in the control groups vs supranormal values empirically observed in critically ill postoperative survivors in the protocol groups, and (2) to evaluate tissue perfusion and oxygenation in relationship to organ failure and mortality. In two prospective clinical trials there were no significant differences in outcome between the central venous pressure and pulmonary artery control groups that used normal values as therapeutic goals. However, there were marked and significant reductions in morbidity and mortality of the protocol groups using the supranormal cardiac index, oxygen delivery, and oxygen consumption values as goals. The cumulative oxygen debt was less and organ failures were fewer and less severe in the protocol groups than in the control groups.

Fibrin glue achieves hemostasis in patients with coagulation disorders.

Fibrin glue (FG), made with highly concentrated human fibrinogen and clotting factors, was used to achieve parenchymal organ hemostasis in patients with disordered coagulation secondary to massive transfusion, chronic disease, and disseminated intravascular coagulation; it was effective in controlling liver hemorrhage in seven patients and in the performance of a splenorrhaphy in one other patient. The coagulation profile was grossly abnormal in all patients, and the mean +/- SD intraoperative blood loss was 5.1 +/- 4.2 L; patients received 14 +/- 10 U of blood perioperatively. The amount of FG required to achieve hemostasis varied directly with the extent of injury and intraoperative blood loss (r = .84), and all patients with a blood loss greater than 4 L required at least 25 mL of FG to stop bleeding. Two patients died postoperatively secondary to cardiac arrest and adult respiratory distress syndrome. Because FG does not depend on adequate platelet or clotting factor levels to be effective, it is especially useful in patients with parenchymal organ hemorrhage and disordered coagulation.