Hyperthermia sensitizes pigmented cells to laser damage without changing threshold damage temperature.

We studied the efficacy of mild hyperthermia as a protective measure against subsequent laser-induced thermal damage. Using a well established in vitro retinal model for laser bioeffects, consisting of an artificially pigmented human retinal pigment epithelial (RPE) cell culture (hTERT-RPE1), we found both protection and sensitization to laser damage that depended upon the location of pigment granules during the hyperthermia preconditioning (PC). Photothermal challenge of cell monolayers consisted of 16 independent replicate exposures of 65 W/cm2 at 514 nm and post laser damage was assessed using fluorescence indicator dyes. Untreated cells had 44% damage, but when melanosome particles (MPs) were intracellular or extracellular during the hyperthermia treatment, laser-induced cell damage occurred 94% or 25% of the time, respectively. Using a recently published method called microthermography, we found that the hyperthermia pretreatment did not alter the threshold temperature for cell death, indicating an alteration in absorption or localization of heat as the mechanism for sensitization and protection. Raman microspectroscopy revealed significant chemical changes in MPs when they were preconditioned within the cytoplasm of cells. Our results suggest intracellular pigment granules undergo chemical modifications during mild hyperthermia that can profoundly affect absorption or heat dissipation.

Spatially correlated microthermography maps threshold temperature in laser-induced damage.

We measured threshold temperatures for cell death resulting from short (0.1-1.0 s) 514-nm laser exposures using an in vitro retinal model. Real-time thermal imaging at sub-cellular resolution provides temperature information that is spatially correlated with cells at the boundary of cell death, as indicate by post-exposure fluorescence images. Our measurements indicate markedly similar temperatures, not only around individual boundaries (single exposure), but among all exposures of the same duration in a laser irradiance-independent fashion. Two different methods yield similar threshold temperatures with low variance. Considering the experimental uncertainties associated with the thermal camera, an average peak temperature of 53 ± 2 °C is found for laser exposures of 0.1, 0.25, and 1.0 s. Additionally, we find a linear relationship between laser exposure duration and time-averaged integrated temperature. The mean thermal profiles for cells at the boundary of death were assessed using the Arrhenius rate law using parameter sets (frequency factor and energy of activation) found in three different articles.

In-vitro retinal model reveals a sharp transition between laser damage mechanisms.

We use laser damage thresholds in an in-vitro retinal model, and computational simulations to examine the laser exposure durations at which damage transitions from photothermal to photochemical at 413 nm. Our results indicate a dramatic shift in 1-h damage thresholds between exposure durations of 60 and 100 s. The trend in our in-vitro results is similar to a trend found in a recent study where retinal lesions were assessed 1-h post laser exposure in the rhesus eye Our data suggest that nonthermal mechanisms did not significantly contribute to cell death, even for exposures of 60 s. Knowledge of the transition point, and lack of concurrent thermal and nonthermal damage processes, are significant for those wishing to devise a comprehensive computational damage model.

In vitro model that approximates retinal damage threshold trends.

Without effective in vitro damage models, advances in our understanding of the physics and biology of laser-tissue interaction would be hampered due to cost and ethical limitations placed on the use of nonhuman primates. We extend our characterization of laser-induced cell death in an existing in vitro retinal model to include damage thresholds at 514 and 413 nm. The new data, when combined with data previously reported for 532 and 458 nm exposures, provide a sufficiently broad range of wavelengths and exposure durations (0.1 to 100 s) to make comparisons with minimum visible lesion (in vivo) data in the literature. Based on similarities between in vivo and in vitro action spectra and temporal action profiles, the cell culture model is found to respond to laser irradiation in a fundamentally similar fashion as the retina of the rhesus animal model. We further show that this response depends on the amount of intracellular melanin pigmentation.

Damage thresholds for cultured retinal pigment epithelial cells exposed to lasers at 532 nm and 458 nm.

The determination of safe exposure levels for lasers has come from damage assessment experiments in live animals, which typically involve correlating visually identifiable damage with laser dosimetry. Studying basic mechanisms of laser damage in animal retinal systems often requires tissue sampling (animal sacrifice), making justification and animal availability problematic. We determined laser damage thresholds in cultured monolayers of a human retinal pigment epithelial (RPE) cell line. By varying exposure duration and laser wavelength, we identified conditions leading to damage by presumed photochemical or thermal mechanisms. A comparison with literature values for ocular damage thresholds validates the in vitro model. The in vitro system described will facilitate molecular and cellular approaches for understanding laser-tissue interaction.

Damage Thresholds for Exposure to NIR and Blue Lasers in an In Vitro RPE Cell System.

PURPOSE: Until reliable nonanimal systems of analysis are available, animal models will be necessary for ocular laser hazard analysis and for evaluating clinical applications. The purpose of this work was to demonstrate the utility of an in vitro system for laser bioeffects by identifying photothermal and photochemical cytotoxicity thresholds for continuous-wave (cw) and mode-locked (ml) laser exposures. METHODS: Exogenous melanosomes were added to hTERT-RPE1 cells in exposure wells 1 day before laser exposure. Thermal or photochemical laser exposures were delivered to artificially pigmented retinal pigment epithelial (RPE) cultures, with subsequent assay for viability 1 hour after exposure. Beam delivery for the 1-hour photochemical exposures was via a modified culture incubator. The cytoprotective effect of pretreatment with two antioxidants was investigated. RESULTS: Phagocytosis of melanosomes by the RPE cells was efficient, yielding cultures of uniform pigmentation. The damage threshold for the thermal exposure was consistent with published in vivo results. Thresholds for both blue exposures (cw and ml) were identical. Overnight treatment of cells with ascorbic acid (AA) minimized cell death from both cw and ml blue laser exposure, whereas similar treatment with N-acetyl-L-cysteine (NAC) was less effective. CONCLUSIONS: The in vitro system described is suitable for measuring meaningful thermal and photochemical laser damage thresholds. The system is also useful in comparative laser bioeffects studies, such as comparisons between cw and ml laser exposures, cells with various degrees of pigmentation, and studies determining the efficacy and mechanisms of treatments altering the response of cells to lasers.