Sexual differentiation of estrogen receptor alpha subpopulations in the ventromedial nucleus of the hypothalamus.

Estrogen receptor (ER) α-expressing neurons in the ventrolateral area of the ventromedial hypothalamus (VMHvl) are implicated in the control of many behaviors and physiological processes, some of which are sex-specific. Recently, three sex-differentiated ERα subpopulations have been discovered in the VMHvl marked by co-expression with tachikinin1 (Tac1), reprimo (Rprm), or prodynorphin (Pdyn), that may subserve specific functions. These markers show sex differences in adulthood: females have many more Tac1/Esr1 and Rprm/Esr1 co-expressing cells, while males have more Pdyn/Esr1 cells. In this study, we sought to understand the development of these sex differences and pinpoint the sex-differentiating signal. We examined developmental changes in the number of Esr1 cells co-expressing Tac1, Rprm or Pdyn using single-molecule in situ hybridization. We found that both sexes have similarly high numbers of Tac1/Esr1 and Rprm/Esr1 cells at birth, but newborn males have many more Pdyn/Esr1 cells than females. However, the number of cells with Tac1/Esr1 and Rprm/Esr1 co-expression markedly decreases by weaning in males, but not females, leading to sex differences in neurochemical expression. Female mice administered testosterone at birth have expression patterns akin to male mice. Thus, a substantial neurochemical reorganization of the VMHvl occurs in males between birth and weaning that likely underlies the previously reported sex differences in behavioral and physiological responses to estrogens in adulthood.

DNA methylation and demethylation shape sexual differentiation of neurochemical phenotype.

Some of the best-studied neural sex differences depend on differential cell death in males and females, but other sex differences persist even if cell death is prevented. These include sex differences in neurochemical phenotype (i.e., stable patterns of gene expression). Work in our laboratory over the last several years has tested the hypothesis that sex differences in DNA methylation early in life underlie sexual differentiation of neuronal phenotype. We have shown that 1) expression of enzymes that place or remove DNA methylation marks is greatest during the first week of life in the mouse brain and overlaps with the perinatal critical period of sexual differentiation; 2) a transient inhibition of DNA methylation during neonatal life abolishes several sex differences in cell phenotype in the mouse hypothalamus; 3) both DNA methylation and de-methylation contribute to the development of neural sex differences; and 4) the effects of DNA methylation and de-methylation are brain region- and cell type-specific.

Past, present and future of epigenetics in brain sexual differentiation.

Sexual differentiation has long been considered "epigenetic", although the meaning of that word has shifted over time. Here, we track the evolution of ideas about epigenetics in sexual differentiation, and identify principles that have emerged from recent studies. Experiments manipulating a particular epigenetic mechanism during neonatal life demonstrate a role for both histone acetylation and DNA methylation in the development of sex differences in the brain and behaviour of rodents. In addition, hormone-dependent sex differences in the number of neurones of a particular phenotype may be programmed by differences in DNA methylation early in life. Genome-wide studies suggest that many effects of neonatal testosterone on the brain methylome do not emerge until adulthood, and there may be sex biases in the use of epigenetic marks that do not correlate with differences in gene expression. In other words, even when the transcription of a gene does not differ between males and females, the epigenetic underpinnings of that expression may differ. Finally, recent evidence suggests that sex differences in epigenetic marks may primarily serve to make gene expression more similar in males and females. We discuss the implications of these findings for understanding sex differences in susceptibility to disease, and point to recent conceptual and technical advances likely to influence the field going forward.

Differential control of sex differences in estrogen receptor α in the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis and anteroventral periventricular nucleus.

The principal nucleus of the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis (BNSTp) and anteroventral periventricular nucleus of the hypothalamus (AVPV) are sexually dimorphic, hormone-sensitive forebrain regions. Here we report a profound sex difference in estrogen receptor-α (ERα) immunoreactivity (IR) in the BNSTp, with robust ERα IR in females and the near absence of labeling in males. This sex difference is due to the suppression of ERα IR by testicular hormones in adulthood: it was not present at birth and was not altered by neonatal treatment of females with estradiol; gonadectomy of adult males increased ERα IR to that of females, whereas gonadectomy of adult females had no effect. Treating gonadally intact males with an aromatase inhibitor partially feminized ERα IR in the BNSTp, suggesting that testicular suppression required aromatization. By contrast, in AVPV we found a modest sex difference in ERα IR that was relatively insensitive to steroid manipulations in adulthood. ERα IR in AVPV was, however, masculinized in females treated with estradiol at birth, suggesting that the sex difference is due to organizational effects of estrogens. The difference in ERα IR in the BNSTp of males and females appears to be at least in part due to greater expression of mRNA of the ERα gene (Esr1) in females. The sex difference in message is smaller than the difference in immunoreactivity, however, suggesting that posttranscriptional mechanisms also contribute to the pronounced suppression of ERα IR and presumably to functions mediated by ERα in the male BNSTp.

Effects of neonatal treatment with valproic acid on vasopressin immunoreactivity and olfactory behaviour in mice.

Recent findings demonstrate that epigenetic modifications are required for the sexual differentiation of the brain. For example, neonatal administration of the histone deacetylase inhibitor, valproic acid, blocks masculinisation of cell number in the principal nucleus of the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis (BNST). In the present study, we examined the effects of valproic acid on neurochemistry and behaviour, focusing on traits that are sexually dimorphic and linked to the BNST. Newborn mice were treated with saline or valproic acid and the effect on vasopressin immunoreactivity and olfactory preference behaviour was examined in adulthood. As expected, males had more vasopressin immunoreactive fibres than females in the lateral septum and medial dorsal thalamus, which are two projection sites of BNST vasopressin neurones. Neonatal valproic acid increased vasopressin fibre density specifically in females in the lateral septum, thereby reducing the sex difference, and increased vasopressin fibres in both sexes in the medial dorsal thalamus. The effects were not specific to BNST vasopressin projections, however, because valproic acid also significantly increased vasopressin immunoreactivity in the anterior hypothalamic area in both sexes. Subtle sex-specific effects of neonatal valproic acid treatment were observed on olfactory behaviour. As predicted, males showed a preference for investigating female-soiled bedding, whereas females showed a preference for male-soiled bedding. Valproic acid did not significantly alter olfactory preference, per se, although it increased the number of visits females made to female-soiled bedding and the overall time females spent investigating soiled versus clean bedding. Taken together, these results suggest that a transient disruption of histone deacetylation at birth does not have generalised effects on sexual differentiation, although it does produce lasting effects on brain neurochemistry and behaviour.

Control of cell number in the sexually dimorphic brain and spinal cord.

The hormonal control of cell death is currently the best-established mechanism for creating sex differences in cell number in the brain and spinal cord. For example, males have more cells than do females in the principal nucleus of the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis (BNSTp) and spinal nucleus of the bulbocavernosus (SNB), whereas females have a cell number advantage in the anteroventral periventricular nucleus (AVPV). In each case, the difference in cell number in adulthood correlates with a sex difference in the number of dying cells at some point in development. Mice with over- or under-expression of cell death genes have been used to test more directly the contribution of cell death to neural sex differences, to identify molecular mechanisms involved, and to determine the behavioural consequences of suppressing developmental cell death. Bax is a pro-death gene of the Bcl-2 family that is singularly important for apoptosis in neural development. In mice lacking bax, the number of cells in the BNSTp, SNB and AVPV are significantly increased, and sex differences in total cell number in each of these regions are eliminated. Cells rescued by bax gene deletion in the BNSTp express markers of differentiated neurones and the androgen receptor. On the other hand, sex differences in other phenotypically identified populations, such as vasopressin-expressing neurones in the BNSTp or dopaminergic neurones in AVPV, are not affected by either bax deletion or bcl-2 over-expression. Possible mechanisms by which testosterone may regulate cell death in the nervous system are discussed, as are the behavioural effects of eliminating sex differences in neuronal cell number.

Sex differences in NeuN- and androgen receptor-positive cells in the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis are due to Bax-dependent cell death.

The principal nucleus of the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis (BNSTp) is larger in males than in females of several species. We previously demonstrated that in mice lacking the pro-death gene, bax, total BNSTp cell number is increased and sex differences in cell number are eliminated. This suggests that Bax-dependent cell death underlies sexual differentiation of the BNSTp. However, it is not known what cells in the BNSTp are affected by bax deletion. Here we used immunohistochemistry and stereological techniques to quantify phenotypically-identified cells in the BNSTp of adult male and female bax -/- and bax +/+ mice. Sections were thionin-stained, or double-labeled for antigen expressed in neuronal nuclei (NeuN) and glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP) to identify mature neurons and astrocytes, respectively; an additional series was labeled for androgen receptor (AR). As previously demonstrated, sex differences in BNSTp area and overall cell number were seen in wild-type mice, but absent in bax -/- animals. In addition, sex differences (favoring males) were present in the number of NeuN+ and AR+ cells in wild-type mice. Bax gene deletion significantly increased the number of NeuN+ and AR+ cells and reduced or eliminated the sex differences in these cell types. The number of astrocytes in the BNSTp was not sexually dimorphic, nor significantly affected by bax gene status, although there was a trend for more GFAP+ cells in bax -/- mice. Overall brain weight was also greater in bax -/- animals compared with controls. We conclude that the sex differences in neuron and AR+ cell number are due at least in part to Bax-mediated cell death. Increased NeuN+ and AR+ cell number in bax -/- mice suggests that supernumerary cells in bax knockouts differentiate similarly to those in wild-type mice, and retain the capacity to respond to androgens.

Distribution of oxytocin in the brain of a eusocial rodent.

Naked mole-rats are highly social rodents that live in large colonies characterized by a rigid social and reproductive hierarchy. Only one female, the queen, breeds. Most colony members are non-reproductive subordinates that work cooperatively to rear the young and maintain an underground burrow system. Little is known about the neurobiological basis of the complex sociality exhibited by this species. The neuropeptide oxytocin (Oxt) modulates social bonding and other social behaviors in many vertebrates. Here we examined the distribution of Oxt immunoreactivity in the brains of male and female naked mole-rats. As in other species, the majority of Oxt-immunoreactive (Oxt-ir) cells were found in the paraventricular and supraoptic nuclei, with additional labeled cells scattered throughout the preoptic and anterior hypothalamic areas. Oxt-ir fibers were found traveling toward and through the median eminence, as well as in the tenia tecta, septum, and nucleus of the diagonal band of Broca. A moderate network of fibers covered the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis and preoptic area, and a particularly dense fiber innervation of the nucleus accumbens and substantia innominata was observed. In the brainstem, Oxt-ir fibers were found in the periaqueductal gray, locus coeruleus, parabrachial nucleus, nucleus of the solitary tract, and nucleus ambiguus. The high levels of Oxt immunoreactivity in the nucleus accumbens and preoptic area are intriguing, given the link in other rodents between Oxt signaling in these regions and maternal behavior. Although only the queen gives birth or nurses pups in a naked mole-rat colony, most individuals actively participate in pup care.

Cell death and sexual differentiation of the nervous system.

Sex differences in nuclear volume or neuron number often are attributed to the hormonal control of cell death. In the spinal nucleus of the bulbocavernosus, the central portion of the medial preoptic nucleus, and the principal nucleus of the bed nucleus of the stria terminalis testicular hormones decrease cell death during perinatal life, resulting in a male advantage in neuron number in adulthood. Conversely, males have more dying cells during development and fewer neurons in adulthood than do females in the anteroventral periventricular nucleus of the hypothalamus. This review discusses several limitations and unresolved issues in the literature on sexually dimorphic cell death, and identifies molecular mechanisms by which gonadal steroids may control cell survival. In particular, evidence is presented for the hormonal regulation of neurotrophic factors and involvement of Bcl-2 family proteins in the determination of sex differences in neuron number.

Castration reduces motoneuron soma size but not dendritic length in the spinal nucleus of the bulbocavernosus of wild-type and BCL-2 overexpressing mice.

Motoneurons in the spinal nucleus of the bulbocavernosus (SNB) and their target muscles, bulbocavernosus and levator ani (BC/LA), constitute an androgen-sensitive neuromuscular system. Testosterone regulates SNB soma size, SNB dendritic length, and BC/LA muscle mass in adult male rats. Recent evidence indicates that the cell death-regulatory protein, Bcl-2, may also play a role in adult neural plasticity. The present study examined whether gonadal hormones and/or the Bcl-2 protein influence the morphology of the SNB neuromuscular system in adult B6D2F1 mice. In Experiment 1, adult wild-type and Bcl-2 overexpressing males were castrated and implanted with silastic capsules containing testosterone or left blank. Six weeks after castration, cholera toxin-horseradish peroxidase was injected into the BC muscle to label SNB dendrites. Animals were killed 48 h later, and BC/LA muscle mass, SNB soma size, and SNB dendritic arbors were examined. In Experiment 2, wild-type and Bcl-2 overexpressing males were castrated or sham castrated, implanted with testosterone-filled or blank capsules, and examined 12 weeks later. In both experiments, BC/LA muscle mass and SNB soma size were significantly reduced in castrates receiving blank capsules. Surprisingly, however, there was no effect of hormone manipulation on any of several measures of dendritic length. Thus, the dendritic morphology of SNB motoneurons appears to be relatively insensitive to circulating androgen levels in B6D2F1 mice. Bcl-2 overexpression did not influence BC/LA muscle mass, SNB soma size, or SNB dendritic length, indicating that the morphology of this neuromuscular system and the response to castration are not altered by forced expression of the Bcl-2 protein.

Blockade of endogenous neurotrophic factors prevents the androgenic rescue of rat spinal motoneurons.

Target-derived neurotrophic factors are assumed to regulate motoneuron cell death during development but remain unspecified. Motoneuron cell death in the spinal nucleus of the bulbocavernosus (SNB) of rats extends postnatally and is controlled by androgens. We exploited these features of the SNB system to identify endogenously produced trophic factors regulating motoneuron survival. Newborn female rat pups were treated with the androgen, testosterone propionate, or the oil vehicle alone. In addition, females received trophic factor antagonists delivered either into the perineum (the site of SNB target muscles) or systemically. Fusion molecules that bind and sequester the neurotrophins (trkA-IgG, trkB-IgG, and trkC-IgG) were used to block activation of neurotrophin receptors, and AADH-CNTF was used to antagonize signaling through the ciliary neurotrophic factor receptor-alpha (CNTFRalpha). An acute blockade of trkB, trkC, or CNTFRalpha prevented the androgenic sparing of SNB motoneurons when antagonists were delivered to the perineum. Trophic factor antagonists did not significantly reduce SNB motoneuron number when higher doses were injected systemically. These findings demonstrate a requirement for specific, endogenously produced trophic factors in the androgenic rescue of SNB motoneurons and further suggest that trophic factor interactions at the perineum play a crucial role in masculinization of this neural system.

Ciliary neurotrophic factor increases muscle fiber number in the developing levator ani muscle of female rats.

In addition to its well characterized neurotrophic properties, ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) also has myotrophic effects in several experimental paradigms. We have previously observed that the volume of the levator ani (LA) muscle is increased in female rats treated with CNTF during the perinatal period. In order to determine the cellular basis for the effect of CNTF on LA muscle volume, female rat pups were given daily perineal injections of CNTF or a control solution from postnatal day 1 through 6. Mean cross-sectional area of LA muscle fibers and LA fiber number were assessed on postnatal day 7. CNTF treatment increased LA muscle fiber number more than 300% while having no effect on LA fiber size. We conclude that CNTF prevents muscle fiber degeneration and/or increases myogenesis in the developing LA muscle.

Additive effects of ciliary neurotrophic factor and testosterone on motoneuron survival; differential effects on motoneuron size and muscle morphology.

Testosterone and ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) each enhance motoneuron survival in the spinal nucleus of the bulbocavernosus (SNB) of newborn rats. Here we directly compared the effects of CNTF and testosterone, alone and in combination, on SNB motoneuron number, SNB cell size, and morphology of the levator ani (LA) target muscle. Female rat pups were treated daily from postnatal day 1 through 6 (P1-P6) with recombinant human CNTF (hCNTF), testosterone propionate (TP), both hCNTF and TP, or neither. Effects of treatment were assessed on P7. TP and hCNTF each increased the number of SNB motoneurons and did so to a similar degree. Females treated with both hCNTF and TP had significantly more SNB cells than those receiving either hCNTF or TP alone. TP administered from P1 to P6 also increased SNB motoneuron size on P7. In contrast, hCNTF alone did not significantly affect SNB cell size, and hCNTF in combination with TP antagonized the effect of TP on motoneuron size. TP also increased LA muscle fiber number and LA fiber size, whereas hCNTF did not significantly influence LA muscle morphology in this study. Immunohistochemistry established that virtually all SNB motoneurons of both males and females express the CNTF alpha receptor (CNTFRalpha) between embryonic day 20 and postnatal day 6. Thus, effects of TP and hCNTF on SNB motoneuron survival were additive, and increases in motoneuron survival were dissociated from changes in target muscle morphology in hCNTF-treated animals. SNB motoneurons express CNTFRalpha perinatally and are therefore potential direct sites of hCNTF action.

Effects of testosterone on the development of a sexually dimorphic neuromuscular system in ciliary neurotrophic factor receptor knockout mice.

Motoneurons in the spinal nucleus of the bulbocavernosus (SNB) innervate the perineal muscles, bulbocavernosus (BC), and levator ani (LA). Testosterone regulates the survival of SNB motoneurons and BC/LA muscles during perinatal life. Previous findings suggest that effects of testosterone on this system may be mediated by trophic factors-in particular, by a factor acting through the ciliary neurotrophic factor alpha-receptor (CNTFRalpha). To test the role of CNTFRalpha in the response of the developing SNB system to testosterone, CNTFRalpha +/+ and -/- mice were treated with testosterone propionate (TP) or oil during late embryonic development. BC/LA muscle size and SNB motoneuron number were evaluated on the day of birth. Large sex differences in BC and LA muscle size were present in newborn mice of both genotypes, but muscle volumes were reduced in CNTFRalpha -/- animals relative to same-sex, wild-type controls. Prenatal testosterone treatment completely eliminated the sex difference in BC/LA muscle size in wild-type animals, and eliminated the effect of the CNTFRalpha gene deletion on muscle size in males. However, the effect of TP treatment on BC and LA muscle sizes was blunted in CNTFRalpha -/- females. SNB motoneuron number was sexually dimorphic in oil-treated, wild-type mice. In contrast, there was no sex difference in SNB motoneuron number in oil-treated, CNTFRalpha knockout mice. Prenatal treatment with testosterone did not increase SNB motoneuron number in CNTFRalpha -/- mice, but also did not significantly increase SNB motoneuron number in newborn wild-type animals. These findings confirm the absence of a sex difference in SNB motoneuron number in CNTFRalpha -/- mice. Moreover, the CNTFRalpha gene deletion influences perineal muscle development and the response of the perineal muscles to testosterone. Prenatal TP treatment of CNTFRalpha -/- males overcomes the effects of the gene deletion on the BC and LA muscles without a concomitant effect on SNB motoneuron number.

Ciliary neurotrophic factor receptor alpha in spinal motoneurons is regulated by gonadal hormones.

Ciliary neurotrophic factor receptor alpha (CNTFRalpha) is the ligand-binding component of the CNTF receptor. CNTFRalpha expression is essential for the normal development of spinal motoneurons and is required for the development of a sex difference in motoneuron number in androgen-sensitive perineal motoneurons. We used immunocytochemistry to examine the expression and hormone regulation of CNTFRalpha protein in the spinal nucleus of the bulbocavernosus (SNB), dorsolateral nucleus and retrodorsolateral nucleus of the lower lumbar spinal cord of adult rats. CNTFRalpha immunoreactivity (CNTFRalpha-IR) was observed in the somata and dendrites of virtually all motoneurons. In all three motor pools, the intensity of motoneuron soma labeling was greatest among gonadally intact males and was reduced in females and gonadectomized males. The density of CNTFRalpha-IR in neuropil also tended to be highest in intact males. Short-term (2 d) testosterone propionate treatment reversed the decline in the density of soma labeling in the SNB of castrated males but did not reverse any other effects of castration. Long-term hormone treatment, achieved by implanting males with testosterone capsules at the time of gonadectomy, prevented the decline in soma labeling in all motor pools and partially prevented the decline in neuropil label caused by castration. We conclude that expression of CNTFRalpha protein is androgen-regulated in spinal motoneurons.

Androgens and masculinization of genitalia in the spotted hyaena (Crocuta crocuta). 2. Effects of prenatal anti-androgens.

Pregnant spotted hyaenas were treated with anti-androgens to interfere with the unusually masculine 'phallic' development that characterizes females of this species. The effects on genital morphology and plasma androgen concentrations of infants were studied during the first 6 months of life. Although there were consistent 'feminizing' effects of prenatal anti-androgen treatment on genital morphology in both sexes, such exposure did not produce males with extreme hypospadia, as it does in other species, nor did it produce females with a 'typical' mammalian clitoris and external vagina. 'Feminization' of males resulted in a penis with the morphological features of the hyaena clitoris, and 'feminization' of females exaggerated the sex differences that are typical of this species. The effects of treatment were present at birth and persisted for at least 6 months. Treatment of pregnant females with flutamide and finasteride also markedly reduced circulating concentrations of testosterone and dihydrotestosterone in maternal plasma during pregnancy. Plasma delta 4-androstenedione was reduced in the female, but not the male, infants of treated mothers, consistent with an epigenetic hypothesis previously advanced to explain hormonal 'masculinization' of females. The present 'feminizing' effects of prenatal anti-androgen treatment are consistent with contemporary understanding of sexual differentiation, which accounts for morphological variation between the sexes in terms of steroids. However, current theory does not account for the basic genital structure of females and the present data suggest that development of the male penis and scrotum, and the female clitoris and pseudoscrotum, in spotted hyaenas may involve both androgen-dependent and androgen-independent components.

Expression and androgen regulation of the ciliary neurotrophic factor receptor (CNTFRalpha) in muscles and spinal cord.

We have previously observed that ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) can prevent the degeneration of androgen-sensitive perineal motoneurons and their target muscles, the bulbocavernosus and levator ani (BC/LA), in perinatal female rats. Response to CNTF is dependent on the expression of the alpha component of the CNTF receptor (CNTFRalpha). In the present study, we examined the developmental profile and androgen regulation of CNTFRalpha gene expression in BC/LA muscle, thigh muscle, and lumbosacral spinal cord. CNTFRalpha mRNA was abundantly expressed in the BC/LA and thigh around the time of birth; expression declined progressively after birth and remained low into adulthood. In contrast, CNTFRalpha message remained high in the lumbosacral spinal cord throughout development. Androgen regulation of CNTFRalpha expression was examined in prenatal animals by administering the androgen receptor blocker hydroxyflutamide from embryonic days E18 through E21. Four days of androgen deprivation caused a significant up-regulation of CNTFRalpha mRNA in the BC/LA, thigh, and spinal cord of male fetuses. After castration in adulthood, CNTFRalpha expression in the BC/LA transiently increased, then decreased below control levels. Expression of CNTFRalpha in thigh muscles and the lumbosacral spinal cord was not affected by adult castration. Thus, the perineal muscles and motoneurons are potential sites of direct CNTF action, and expression of the CNTFRalpha gene is modulated by androgen, especially in the androgen-sensitive perineal muscles. Transient up-regulation of CNTFRalpha following castration or androgen receptor blockade may represent a protective response designed to counteract the muscle atrophy normally induced by androgen withdrawal.

Sexual dimorphism in the spinal cord is absent in mice lacking the ciliary neurotrophic factor receptor.

Ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF) has potent survival-promoting effects on motoneurons in vitro and in vivo. We examined knockout mice with null mutations of the gene for either CNTF itself or the alpha-subunit of the CNTF receptor (CNTFRalpha) to assess whether CNTF and/or its receptors are involved in the development of a sexually dimorphic neuromuscular system. Male rodents have many more motoneurons in the spinal nucleus of the bulbocavernosus (SNB) than do females. This sex difference is caused by hormone-regulated death of SNB motoneurons and their target muscles. Sexual dimorphism of SNB motoneuron number developed completely normally in CNTF knockout (CNTF -/-) mice. In contrast, a sex difference in the SNB was absent in CNTFRalpha -/- animals: male mice lacking a functional CNTF alpha-receptor had fewer than half as many SNB motoneurons than did wild-type males and no more than did their female counterparts. Size of the bulbocavernosus and levator ani muscles, the main targets of SNB motoneurons, was not affected in either CNTF or CNTFRalpha knockout males. These observations suggest that signaling through the CNTF receptor is involved in sexually dimorphic development of SNB motoneuron number and that target muscle survival per se is not sufficient to ensure motoneuron survival in this system. In addition, our observations are consistent with the suggestion that CNTF itself is not the only endogenous ligand for the CNTF receptor. A second, as yet unknown, ligand may be important for neural development, including sexually dimorphic motoneuron development.