Virus reconstitution and the proof of the existence of genomic RNA.

This paper is a historical overview of the work done on the tobacco mosaic virus. The primary finding was that a virus is capable of reassembling itself from its component protein and RNA, and that only the RNA carries the genomic capability of the virus. This was followed by detailed studies of the chemical and biological properties of viral RNA.

A 55-kDa protein isolated from human cells shows DNA glycosylase activity toward 3,N4-ethenocytosine and the G/T mismatch.

Etheno adducts in DNA arise from multiple endogenous and exogenous sources. Of these adducts we have reported that, 1,N6-ethenoadenine (epsilonA) and 3,N4-ethenocytosine (epsilonC) are removed from DNA by two separate DNA glycosylases. We later confirmed these results by using a gene knockout mouse lacking alkylpurine-DNA-N-glycosylase, which excises epsilonA. The present work is directed toward identifying and purifying the human glycosylase activity releasing epsilonC. HeLa cells were subjected to multiple steps of column chromatography, including two epsilonC-DNA affinity columns, which resulted in >1,000-fold purification. Isolation and renaturation of the protein from SDS/polyacrylamide gel showed that the epsilonC activity resides in a 55-kDa polypeptide. This apparent molecular mass is approximately the same as reported for the human G/T mismatch thymine-DNA glycosylase. This latter activity copurified to the final column step and was present in the isolated protein band having epsilonC-DNA glycosylase activity. In addition, oligonucleotides containing epsilonC.G or G/T(U), could compete for epsilonC protein binding, further indicating that the epsilonC-DNA glycosylase is specific for both types of substrates in recognition. The same substrate specificity for epsilonC also was observed in a recombinant G/T mismatch DNA glycosylase from the thermophilic bacterium, Methanobacterium thermoautotrophicum THF.

An unusual mechanism for the major human apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) endonuclease involving 5' cleavage of DNA containing a benzene-derived exocyclic adduct in the absence of an AP site.

The major human apurinic/apyrimidinic (AP) endonuclease (class II) is known to cleave DNA 5' adjacent to an AP site, which is probably the most common DNA damage produced hydrolytically or by glycosylase-mediated removal of modified bases. p-Benzoquinone (pBQ), one of the major benzene metabolites, reacts with DNA to form bulky exocyclic adducts. Herein we report that the human AP endonuclease directly catalyzes incision in a defined oligonucleotide containing 3,N4-benzetheno-2'-deoxycytidine (pBQ-dC) without prior generation of an AP site. The enzyme incises the oligonucleotide 5' to the adduct and generates 3'-hydroxyl and 5'-phosphoryl termini but leaves the pBQ-dC on the 5' terminus of the cleavage fragment. The AP function of the enzyme is not involved in this action, as no preexisting AP site is present nor is a DNA glycosylase activity involved. Nicking of the pBQ-dC adduct also leads to the same "dangling base" cleavage when two Escherichia coli enzymes, exonuclease III and endonuclease IV, are used. Our finding of this unusual mode of action used by both human and bacterial AP endonucleases raises important questions regarding the requirements for substrate recognition and catalytic active site(s) for this essential cellular repair enzyme. We believe this to be the first instance of the presence of a bulky carcinogen adduct leading to this unusual mode of action.

All four known cyclic adducts formed in DNA by the vinyl chloride metabolite chloroacetaldehyde are released by a human DNA glycosylase.

We have previously reported that human cells and tissues contain a 1,N6-ethenoadenine (epsilon A) binding protein, which, through glycosylase activity, releases both 3-methyladenine (m3A) and epsilon A from DNA treated with methylating agents or the vinyl chloride metabolite chloroacetaldehyde, respectively. We now find that both the partially purified human epsilon A-binding protein and cell-free extracts containing the cloned human m3A-DNA glycosylase release all four cyclic etheno adducts--namely epsilon A, 3,N4-ethenocytosine (epsilon C), N2,3-ethenoguanine (N2,3-epsilon G), and 1,N2-ethenoguanine (1,N2-epsilon G). Base release was both time and protein concentration dependent. Both epsilon A and epsilon C were excised at similar rates, while 1,N2-epsilon G and N2,3-epsilon G were released much more slowly under identical conditions. The cleavage of glycosyl bonds of several heterocyclic adducts as well as those of simple methylated adducts by the same human glycosylase appears unusual in enzymology. This raises the question of how such a multiple, divergent activity evolved in humans and what may be its primary substrate.

Further studies of the mixed acetals of nucleosides.

We reported in 1988 on a new nucleoside modification reaction: the exocyclic amino groups of (d)adenosine and (d)cytidine react rapidly at ambient temperature with acetaldehyde and alcohols to give stable mixed acetals (N-ethylethoxy-acetal). NH2 + O = CH(CH3) + ROH-->NH-CH(CH3)-O-R + H2O. Here we report in detail on the occurrence of this reaction in very dilute aqueous solution (ie under biological conditions), on its mechanism and kinetics, on the mixed acetal formation with other aldehydes and other nucleic acid components, and on the question of whether these adducts are mutagenic.

Both purified human 1,N6-ethenoadenine-binding protein and purified human 3-methyladenine-DNA glycosylase act on 1,N6-ethenoadenine and 3-methyladenine.

We previously described a protein, isolated from human tissues and cells, that bound to a defined double-stranded oligonucleotide containing a single site-specifically placed 1,N6-ethenoadenine. It was further demonstrated that this protein was a glycosylase and released 1,N6-ethenoadenine. We now find that this enzyme also releases 3-methyladenine from methylated DNA and that 3-methyladenine-DNA glycosylase behaves in the same manner, binding to the ethenoadenine-containing oligonucleotide and cleaving both ethenoadenine and 3-methyladenine from DNA containing these adducts. The rate and extent of glycosylase activities toward the two adducts are similar.

Tryptophan analogues form adducts by cooperative reaction with aldehydes and alcohols or with aldehydes alone: possible role in ethanol toxicity.

Previous work showed that the exocyclic amino groups of nucleic acid components react quickly at ambient temperature with acetaldehyde and ethanol to yield mixed acetals [R-NH-CH(CH3)-O-C2H5]. We now find that the same type of reaction occurs readily with the nitrogen of 3-substituted indoles (e.g., indole-3-acetic acid and N-acetyltryptophan), analogues of the amino acid tryptophan. In contrast, unsubstituted indole reacts very rapidly at the carbon in ring position 2 or 3 with acetaldehyde to form bis(indolyl)ethane without ethanol entering into the reaction. Product structures have been confirmed by fast atom bombardment MS and 1H NMR. The former reaction occurs optimally in 30-50% aqueous solution below pH 4. It also proceeds more slowly and with reduced yields in aqueous media at more neutral pH. This reaction may be of biological concern, as it supplies a mechanism for protein modifications with possible toxic effects in human tissues where ethanol is metabolized.

Nucleoside adducts are formed by cooperative reaction of acetaldehyde and alcohols: possible mechanism for the role of ethanol in carcinogenesis.

The exocyclic amino groups of ribonucleosides and deoxyribonucleosides react rapidly at ambient temperature with acetaldehyde and alcohols to yield mixed acetals [--NH--CH(CH3)OR]. Nucleotides and nucleoside di- and triphosphates also react. Depending on the nucleoside used and on the relative amounts of aldehyde, alcohol, and water, preparative reactions reach equilibrium with yields up to 75% in a few hours. The structures have been confirmed by fast atom bombardment MS and proton NMR. Half-lives at 37 degrees C have been determined, and maximum stability is in the pH range of 7.5-9.5. In the absence of alcohol, acetaldehyde-nucleoside adducts could be isolated at 4 degrees C, but these were too unstable to characterize except for their UV spectra, also at 4 degrees C. Ethanol is often present in human blood and tissues, and acetaldehyde is its initial metabolic product, as well as being formed by many other metabolic processes. Both chemicals have separately been implicated in carcinogenic and other cytopathologic processes, but no cooperative mechanism has been proposed. The reactions reported here are of biological concern because they also occur in dilute aqueous solution. These findings supply a mechanism by which ethanol can be covalently bound to nucleic acids under physiological conditions.

Repair of O-alkylpyrimidines in mammalian cells: a present consensus.

Enzymatic repair of the O-alkylpyrimidines (O2- and O4-alkylthymine, O2-alkylcytosine) and alkyl phosphotriesters has been studied in Escherichia coli, and the two proteins involved, a glycosylase (DNA-3-methyladenine glycosylase) and a methyltransferase (DNA-O6-methylguanine:protein-L-cysteine S-methyltransferase, EC 2.1.1.63), have been well characterized. In mammals or mammalian cells treated with carcinogenic alkylating agents, loss of these derivatives has been demonstrated repeatedly. Nevertheless, mammalian repair proteins that are analogous to those from E. coli do not detectably act on these alkyl derivatives. A variety of techniques has been used by many investigators in the United States and Europe, who conclude here that the mode of O-alkylpyrimidine and alkyl phosphotriester repair in mammalian cells differs from that in E. coli. New approaches and methods are needed to characterize these processes at the biochemical and molecular level.

RNA-directed RNA polymerases from healthy and from virus-infected cucumber.

Much work has been done on the isolation, purification, and characterization of the RNA-directed RNA polymerase (EC 2.7.7.48) of cucumber mosaic virus (CMV)-infected cucumbers. Uninfected plants were reported to have no such enzyme, but we recently detected low levels of the activity in cucumber. Since tobacco and cowpea contain such an enzyme that is variably increased in amount by various virus (as well as viroid) infections, we assumed that this would also be the case upon CMV infection of cucumber. However, further purification and characterization of the RNA-directed RNA polymerases from healthy and from infected cucumber suggests that these are different enzymes. The presumed CMV replicase was obtained pure and consists of a major polypeptide of Mr 100,000 and minor components of Mr 110,000 and about 10,000. The Km is 5 microM ([3H]GTP) when tobacco mosaic virus RNA is used as template.

Neutral reactions of haloacetaldehydes with polynucleotides: mechanisms, monomer and polymer products.

The generally accepted mechanism for the formation of etheno derivatives upon reaction of adenosine or cytidine with haloacetaldehydes involves two intermediates. The first, a primary addition to the exocyclic amino group, has not been experimentally verified. The second, a cyclic form of the first intermediate, has been described in monomers but presumed to be too unstable to exist in polynucleotides since such derivatives would be readily dehydrated to other derivatives at pHs below neutrality. We have found that the cyclic intermediates of adenosine and cytidine are the predominant products in polynucleotides, even upon extensive reaction with chloroacetaldehyde at neutrality. The hydrated compounds have half-lives at pH 7, 37 degrees C, of 1.4 h and 13 h for adenosine and cytidine, respectively. Two types of evidence are presented for the existence of the first intermediate, a (1-hydroxy-2-chloroethyl)-substituted exocyclic amino group. Firstly, poly d[A-T] cannot form etheno derivatives (except when denatured) and the observed cross-linking is therefore attributed to alkylation by the chlorinated sidechain of the adenine residue (A), acting on the N6 of A on the opposite strand. Secondly, our results show that blocking of the acceptor nitrogen, needed for cyclization, leads to the formation of relatively stable derivatives of adenosine and cytidine. Guanosine, as a monomer, is modified extensively, but in synthetic polymers no reaction was detected, possibly due to secondary structure.

O4-Methyl, -ethyl, or -isopropyl substituents on thymidine in poly(dA-dT) all lead to transitions upon replication.

In a previous paper, we reported that O4-methyl dTTP can be incorporated into poly(dA-dT) in place of thymidine without distortion of the helical structure, but on replication it could behave as deoxycytidine and misincorporate dGTP. Only weak interactions are possible for any O4-modified T X A pair. While O4-alkyl T X G pairing should be favored, experiments to detect the ability of Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (pol I) to utilize the triphosphate as dCTP were ambiguous. dTTPs with larger alkyl groups (ethyl, isopropyl) have now been synthesized and tested for their recognition as dTTP by pol I. Enhanced steric hindrance could be expected, particularly for O4-isopropyl dTTP, which has a three-carbon branched chain. However, both compounds behaved qualitatively like O4-methyl dTTP, being incorporated into poly(dA-dT) and then directing deoxyguanosine misincorporation by pol I. Quantitative comparisons of mutagenicity were not possible because of the finding that, unlike polymers made with O4-methyl dTTP, those made with ethyl or isopropyl dTTP were resistant to hydrolysis by using a variety of nucleases. The frequent misincorporations of dGTP would be expected to produce transitions in vivo. O4-ethyldeoxythymidine is very poorly repaired in vivo, which would also be expected for repair of O4-isopropyldeoxythymidine. Therefore, under suitable conditions, these particular carcinogen products are likely to be initiators of carcinogenesis.

Purification and characterization of polynucleotide phosphorylase from cucumber.

Polynucleotide phosphorylase (polyribonucleotide:orthophosphate nucleotidyltransferase, EC 2.7.7.8) activity has been found in many prokaryotes and studied in detail since 1955. Such enzymes have been detected also in plants. We now describe the purification of polynucleotide phosphorylase from cucumber cotyledons and leaves. This enzyme is a complex of three subunits, possibly not identical, of about M(r) 50,000. Its enzymatic properties are similar to those of the tobacco enzyme. Unlike the prokaryotic enzymes, the plant enzyme shows activity in the absence of primer but is to various extents stimulated by various ribopolynucleotides or RNAs. RNA-dependent RNA polymerase, not previously shown to exist in non-virus-infected cucumber, has been found to be present at a low level and was separated from the much greater amount of polynucleotide phosphorylase, although some of the physical properties of the two enzymes are rather similar.

N4-Methoxydeoxycytidine triphosphate is in the imino tautomeric form and substitutes for deoxythymidine triphosphate in primed poly d[A-T] synthesis with E. coli DNA polymerase I.

N4- Methoxydeoxycytidine triphosphate ( mo4dCTP ) substitutes for dTTP in poly d[A-T] synthesis with E. coli DNA polymerase I (Pol I). In parallel experiments using as template-primer, poly d[G-C], no incorporation of [14C] mo4dC was detected. This indicates that this deoxy derivative acts as the imino tautomer, as previously found for the riboderivative . Nearest neighbor analysis of transcripts of poly d[A-T] containing mo4dC shows that the derivative substitutes for only one base. In replication, singlestranded mo4dC -containing polymers gave little misincorporation, including that of dATP which can hydrogen-bond to mo4dC in the imino form, if the methoxy group is anti to the N-3. It is therefore assumed that the methoxy group is constrained anti in a polymer such as d[A-T], but can be in the syn form in singlestranded polymers and not recognized by DNA polymerase. mo4dC destabilizes the poly d[A-T] helix, as indicated by a lowered and less cooperative melting. Steric factors such as adjacent base displacement were invoked for similar findings with the doublestranded r( U61 , mo4C39 ) X r(A).

In vitro discrimination of replicases acting on carcinogen-modified polynucleotide templates.

Three different poly(dC)s with modifications that block the N-3 of deoxycytidine were used as templates for polymer synthesis by Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I (EC 2.7.7.7). In contrast to previously reported results with transcriptases, the hydrated form of 3,N(4)-ethenodeoxycytidine (epsilondC.H(2)O) did not mispair. Both 3,N(4)-ethenodeoxycytidine (epsilondC) and 3-methyldeoxycytidine (m(3)dC) led to dTMP misincorporation: 1/20 epsilondC and 1/80 m(3)dC. No other misincorporations appeared to be significant in amount. Thus, both qualitatively and quantitatively, replication errors resulting from carcinogen-modified bases are less frequent than errors in transcription of the same deoxypolynucleotides. Replication of comparable ribopolynucleotide templates by cucumber RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (EC 2.7.7.48) was strongly inhibited by epsilonrC.H(2)O and epsilonrC, so that the fidelity of this enzyme could not be assessed. However, both poly(dC) and poly(rC) containing dU or rU led to incorporation of rA. The presence of even small amounts of purines in poly(rC) greatly depressed synthesis, but the complementary base was incorporated. The finding that an RNA replicase can utilize a deoxypolynucleotide template is a further indication that, at least in vitro, the specificity of the relationship of enzymes and their natural templates is not absolute.

RNA-dependent RNA polymerases of plants.

The existence of RNA-dependent RNA polymerases (EC 2.7.7.48) in plants has been definitely proven by their isolation in pure form from cucumber and tobacco in our laboratory and from cowpea at Wageningen. These enzymes are single-chain proteins of 100-130 kilodaltons. They show clear physical and biochemical differences characteristic for a given plant species, even when their amounts in the plants were greatly increased prior to isolation by infection with the same virus. The role of these enzymes in plant physiology remains unknown.

Comparative studies on ribonucleic acid dependent RNA polymerases in cucumber mosaic virus infected cucumber and tobacco and uninfected tobacco plants.

RNA-dependent RNA polymerases have been isolated in almost pure form from cucumber mosaic virus (CMV) infected cucumber cotyledons and from tobacco leaves and were compared with the less pure enzyme from uninfected tobacco. The purified polymerase from cucumber shows on sodium dodecyl sulfate gels two peptide chains of about 100 and 112 kdaltons. The enzyme from tobacco shows a close doublet of about 125 kdaltons, which is also present in the less pure preparation from healthy tobacco. While both the cucumber and tobacco enzymes can use many polynucleotides and RNAs as templates, considerable quantitative differences exist, poly(C) being by far the most effective template for the cucumber enzyme but of low activity with the tobacco enzyme and poly(UG) being highly active with the latter but not the former. Poly(A) and poly(G) are inactive. Different viral RNAs, including CMV RNA, show smaller differences. The sedimentation rates of the enzyme from both sources are the same as that of gamma-globulin. A uridine 5'-triphosphate (UTP) terminal transferase also present in both plants sediments much more slowly and can be completely removed from the RNA polymerases. However, slight nucleolytic activity remains associated with the purified polymerases and appears to be proportional to the polymerase activity. The conclusion derived from these data is that the RNA-dependent RNA polymerases of different plants differ and are not detectably affected by virus infection in qualitative terms while being produced in greatly increased amounts upon some virus infections. Similar conclusions were previously reached with less purified enzyme preparations from tobacco as compared to cowpea, infected with different viruses, if any.

Reconstitution of rods from tobacco mosaic virus protein and RNA modified with bulky carcinogens.

Tobacco mosaic virus (TMV) RNA was treated with radioactive N-acetoxy-2-acetylaminofluorene (N-acetoxy-AAF) and (+/-)-7 beta, 8 alpha-dihydroxy-9 alpha, 10 alpha-epoxy-7,8,9,10-tetrahydrobenzo(a)pyrene (BaP diol epoxide) to obtain 3-25 adducts per molecule. Modified full length 30S RNAs and unmodified RNA were reconstituted for various time periods with TMV protein. The particulate products were separated by ultracentrifugation, and the amounts of virus-like material were quantitated by UV spectrophotometry. The length distribution and general appearance of the virus-like rods were studied by electron microscopy. Neither type of carcinogen prevented typical rod formation, but the rate of formation and the maximal yield of reconstituted particles diminished with increasing modification by both agents. The rod length distribution also showed progressively lesser numbers of full-length virus rods. The particulate material contained approximately the same number of adducts as the modified RNA. Thus, it appears that these carcinogen modifications of guanine residues at the N-2 or C-8 atoms did not prevent orderly protein assembly on the RNA but instead slowed up this process and frequently stopped it, possibly at sites where adducts happen to be clustered.