A Method for Functional Task Alignment Analysis of an Arthrocentesis Simulator.

INTRODUCTION: During simulation-based education, simulators are subjected to procedures composed of a variety of tasks and processes. Simulators should functionally represent a patient in response to the physical action of these tasks. The aim of this work was to describe a method for determining whether a simulator does or does not have sufficient functional task alignment (FTA) to be used in a simulation. METHODS: Potential performance checklist items were gathered from published arthrocentesis guidelines and aggregated into a performance checklist using Lawshe's method. An expert panel used this performance checklist and an FTA analysis questionnaire to evaluate a simulator's ability to respond to the physical actions required by the performance checklist. RESULTS: Thirteen items, from a pool of 39, were included on the performance checklist. Experts had mixed reviews of the simulator's FTA and its suitability for use in simulation. Unexpectedly, some positive FTA was found for several tasks where the simulator lacked functionality. CONCLUSIONS: By developing a detailed list of specific tasks required to complete a clinical procedure, and surveying experts on the simulator's response to those actions, educators can gain insight into the simulator's clinical accuracy and suitability. Unexpected of positive FTA ratings of function deficits suggest that further revision of the survey method is required.

Clinical preceptor evaluation of veterinary students in a distributed model of clinical education.

The study reported here investigates the reliability and validity of a standardized evaluation form used to assess students' knowledge, clinical skills, interpersonal skills, and professionalism during fourth-year clinical rotations in a distributed model of veterinary education. A form designed to assess veterinary knowledge (5 items), clinical skills (7 items), interpersonal skills (3 items), and professionalism (6 items) was used by clinical preceptors to evaluate student performance across different rotations. For the period January--May 2007, 218 evaluations were completed for 81 students; each student was assessed in at least two rotations. Mean scores across the 21 items ranged from 3.42 (SD = 0.61) to 3.87 (SD = 0.37). Construct validity was assessed using exploratory factor analysis. The 21 items loaded on three underlying factors, professionalism, knowledge and clinical skills, accounted for 70.35% of the variance. Internal consistency (Cronbach's alpha) of each subscale was high, ranging from 0.88 for clinical skills to 0.94 for professionalism and 0.96 for the entire tool. Correlations between subscales were significant (p < 0.01), ranging from r = 0.62 to r = 0.76. Preliminary analysis suggests that the evaluation tool has good internal reliability. Construct validity analysis suggests that certain items relating to interpersonal skills and clinical skills were assessing either knowledge or professionalism. Clinical preceptors could differentiate between different skill levels for knowledge and clinical skills. Challenges associated with the assessment of professionalism are discussed.

Zinc supplementation decreases hepatic copper accumulation in LEC rat: a model of Wilson's disease.

The effect of dietary zinc (Zn) supplementation on copper (Cu)-induced liver damage was investigated in Long-Evans Cinnamon rats (LEC), a model for Wilson's disease (WD). Four-week-old LEC (N=64) and control Long-Evans (LE) (N=32) female rats were divided into two groups; one group was fed with a Zn-supplemented diet (group I) and the other was given a normal rodent diet (group II). LEC rats were killed at 6, 8, 10, 12, 18, and 20 wk of age; the LE control rats were killed at 6, 12, 18, and 20 wk of age. Cu concentration in the liver was reduced in LEC rats fed the Zn-supplemented diet compared with LEC rats on the normal diet between 6 and 18 wk of age. Metallothionein (MT) concentration in the livers of LEC rats in group I increased between 12 and 20 wk of age, whereas hepatic MT concentration in LEC rats from group II decreased after 12 wk. Hepatocyte apoptosis, as determined by TUNEL, was reduced in Zn-supplemented LEC rats at all ages. Cholangiocellular carcinoma was observed only in LEC rats in group II at wk 20. These results suggest that Zn supplementation can reduce hepatic Cu concentration and delay the onset of clinical and pathological changes of Cu toxicity in LEC rats. Although the actual mechanism of protection is unknown, it could be explained by sequestration of dietary Cu by intestinal MT, induced by high dietary Zn content.

Role of tumor necrosis factor-alpha in the development of spontaneous hepatic toxicity in Long-Evans Cinnamon rats.

The objective of this study was to evaluate the potential role of TNF-alpha in the onset of acute hepatitis in the Long-Evans Cinnamon (LEC) rat, an animal model for inherited copper (Cu) toxicosis. In LEC rats, Cu is accumulated in the liver with age, and clinical signs of acute hepatitis were observed as, icterus, reduced body weight, nasal bleeding, dehydration, and reduced food intake at 12 weeks of age. Cellular changes such as apoptosis in the liver were evident in these rats with increasing age. Positive TNF-alpha and TNFR1 immunostainings were observed in hepatocytes and Kupffer cells in LEC rats. Hepatic levels of caspase-3 activity, TNF-alpha mRNA, and protein were also increased in LEC rats from 6 to 12 weeks of age as compared with control Long-Evans (LE) rats. The neutralization of TNF-alpha by passive immunization or the inhibition of caspase activity can block the apoptotic process initiated by TNF-alpha. In this study, we evaluated the effects of passive immunization of LEC rats with weekly administration of anti-rat TNF-alpha on Cu-induced acute hepatitis. This treatment resulted in a reduction of the percentage of apoptotic cells in the liver, decreased activity of caspase-3, and also in down-regulation of the TNF-alpha gene expression. Thus, these results suggest a major role for TNF-alpha on the pathogenesis of Cu-induced acute hepatitis in LEC rats.

Animal models of copper-associated liver disease.

Recent advances in molecular biology have made possible the identification of genetic defects responsible for Wilson's disease, Indian childhood cirrhosis and copper toxicosis in Long Evans Cinnamon rats, toxic milk mice, and Bedlington terriers. The Wilson's disease gene is localized on human chromosome 13 and codes for ATP7B, a copper transporting P-type ATPase. A genetic defect similar to that of Wilson's disease occurs in Long Evans Cinnamon rats and toxic milk mice. Familial copper storage disorders in Bedlington and West Highland white terriers are associated with early subclinical disease, and copper accumulation with subsequent liver injury culminating in cirrhosis. The canine copper toxicosis locus in Bedlington terriers has been mapped to canine chromosome region CFA 10q26. Recently, a mutated MURR1 gene was discovered in Bedlington terriers affected with the disease. Idiopathic childhood cirrhosis is biochemically similar to copper toxicosis in Bedlington terriers, but clinically much more severe. Both conditions are characterized by the absence of neurologic damage and Kayser-Fleisher rings, and normal ceruloplasmin levels. A recent study added North Ronaldsay sheep to the list of promising animal models to study Indian childhood cirrhosis. Morphologic similarities between the two conditions include periportal to panlobular copper retention and liver changes varying from active hepatitis to panlobular pericellular fibrosis, and cirrhosis. Certain copper-associated disorders, such as chronic active hepatitis in Doberman pinschers and Skye terrier hepatitis are characterized by copper retention secondary to the underlying disease, thus resembling primary biliary cirrhosis in humans. Copper-associated liver disease has increasingly being recognized in Dalmatians. Copper-associated liver diseases in Dalmatians and Long Evans Cinnamom rats share many morphologic features. Fulminant hepatic failure in Dalmatians is characterized by high serum activities of alanine aminotransferase and aspartate aminotransferase, and severe necrosis of centrilobular areas (periacinar, zone 3) hepatocytes. Macrophages and surviving hepatocytes contain copper-positive material. Liver disease associated with periacinar copper accumulation has also been described in Siamese cats. Many questions regarding copper metabolism in mammals, genetic background, pathogenesis and treatment of copper-associated liver diseases remain to be answered. This review describes the similarities between the clinico-pathological features of spontaneous copper-associated diseases in humans and domestic animals.