ABSTRACT
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: Clinical Practice Guidelines (CPGs) provide evidence-based recommendations to healthcare professionals, policy makers, patients and other stakeholders. Mexico is the biggest producer of CPGs in Latin America and Caribbean countries. The National Healthcare Technology Excellence Center (acronym in Spanish: CENETEC) is responsible for the CPG development, adaptation and update. The aim of this study was to assess the adherence to the GRADE framework and to critically appraise the Mexican CPGs with the AGREE-II tool. STUDY DESIGN: We conducted a descriptive cross-sectional study with a random sample of 86 CPGs produced by CENETEC between 2015 and 2017 and published in an online database called "Catalogo Maestro". We assessed the adherence to the GRADE framework and performed a critical appraisal with the AGREE II tool. RESULTS: Of the 86 CPGs, 34 were published in 2015, 21 in 2016 and 31 in 2017. Of the 86 CPGs, 25 (29%) used the GRADE framework; adherence to GRADE standards was, however, inconsistent and generally poor. The overall methodological quality by AGREE II proved a median of 16.6% (Min 16.6%, Max 50%). CONCLUSION: CPGs produced by CENETEC during this period had a poor adherence to the GRADE framework and low score by AGREE II standards. A concerted initiative could rapidly improve CENETEC guidelines.
Subject(s)
Cross-Sectional Studies , Humans , MexicoABSTRACT
BACKGROUND: Acute pericarditis is rare in children; it can evolve to effusion or even cardiac tamponade. The main infectious agents are viruses and bacteria. The pharmacological treatment includes NSAIDs; just a few patients need pericardiocentesis. CLINICAL CASE: A school-age patient was hospitalized because of chest pain; she was diagnosed with acute pericarditis and pericardial effusion, without any other symptoms. The disease pattern then evolved to dry cough, crushing epigastric abdominal pain, vomiting and fever. Due to a poor response to the initial treatment, immunological studies were requested. She tested positive to antinuclear antibodies (ANA), anti-double stranded DNA, direct Coombs and anticardiolipin antibodies; hypocomplementemia with lymphopenia was detected too, which is an indicative of systematic lupus erythematosus. CONCLUSIONS: The torpid evolution or recurrence of pericarditis must direct toward excluding neoplastic or autoimmune bodies. Cardiovascular manifestations rarely appear initially in patients with systemic lupus erythematosus.
Antecedentes: La pericarditis aguda es poco frecuente en los niños; puede evolucionar a derrame o taponamiento cardiaco. Los principales agentes infecciosos son virus y bacterias. El tratamiento farmacológico es con antiinflamatorios no esteroideos; pocos pacientes requieren pericardiocentesis. Caso clínico: Paciente escolar hospitalizada por dolor torácico en zona precordial, quien fue diagnosticada con pericarditis aguda y derrame pericárdico, sin otra sintomatologia clínica. El cuadro progresó a tos seca, dolor abdominal epigástrico opresivo, vómitos gastroalimentarios y fiebre. Por mala respuesta al tratamiento inicial se solicitaron estudios inmunológicos. Se encontró positividad a los autoanticuerpos antinucleares, anti-ADN de doble cadena, Coombs directo y anticardiolipinas; también se encontró hipocomplementemia con linfopenia, indicativos de lupus eritematoso sistémico. Conclusiones: La evolución tórpida o recurrencia de la pericarditis debe orientar a descartar entidades neoplásicas o autoinmunes. Las manifestaciones cardiovasculares se presentan de forma inicial en pocos pacientes con lupus eritematoso sistémico.
