Evaluation of a tool to improve the quality of preceptor written feedback for family medicine residents: training and use of a CanMEDS-MF competency-based criterion guide.

Background: Written feedback is essential in resident teaching, but preceptors are not always well equipped to provide relevant feedback. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of multi-episodic training and the use of a criterion-referenced guide for written feedback for family medicine preceptors in a French-language academic hospital. Method: Twenty-three (23) preceptors participated in the training and used the criterion-referenced guide to guide them during the written evaluation in an evaluation sheet named "Field Notes." The content of these Field Notes was analyzed according to completion, the rate of specific feedback, and the rate of feedback by CanMEDS-MF role before and after the training over a three-month period. Results: Based on the analysis of the Field Notes (n = 70 pre-test; n = 138 post-test), an increase in the percentage of completion (50% vs. 92%, z = 2.97, p = 0.0030) and specific feedback (59% vs. 92%, z = 2.47, p=0.0137) was noted. There was no significant increase in feedback by CanMEDS-MF role. Conclusions: The development of multi-episodic training and a criterion-referenced guide, created according to the CanMEDS-MF repository, suggests an improvement in comprehensive and specific written feedback in family medicine education.

Contexte: La rétroaction écrite est primordiale dans l'enseignement aux résidents, mais les précepteurs ne sont pas toujours outillés pour offrir une rétroaction pertinente. Cette étude visait à évaluer l'efficacité de formations multiépisodiques et l'utilisation d'un guide critérié pour les rétroactions écrites des précepteurs en médecine familiale d'un centre hospitalier académique francophone. Méthode: Vingt-trois (23) précepteurs ont participé aux formations et ont utilisé le guide critérié pour les guider lors de l'évaluation écrite dans une fiche évaluative nommée «feuille de route¼. Le contenu de ces feuilles de route a été analysé selon la complétion, le taux de rétroactions spécifiques et le taux de rétroactions par rôle CanMEDS-MF avant et après les formations sur une période de trois mois. Résultats: Selon l'analyse des feuilles de route (n=70 prétest ; n=138 posttest), une augmentation du pourcentage de complétion (40% vs 92%, z=3.51, p=0.0005) et de rétroactions spécifiques (59% vs 92%, z=2.47, p=0.0137) fut notée. Il n'y avait aucune augmentation significative quant aux rétroactions par rôle CanMEDS-MF. Conclusions: L'élaboration de formations multiépisodiques et d'un guide critérié, créés selon le référentiel CanMEDS-MF, suggère une amélioration de rétroactions écrites complètes et spécifiques en éducation de la médecine familiale.

Early femoral component migration: comparing the anterior and posterior approach to the hip.

PURPOSE: Early femoral component migration is a useful indicator for identifying implants at risk of failure due to aseptic loosening. The goal of this retrospective study was to identify if anterior approach (AA) treated hips are at a higher risk of failure due to aseptic loosening caused by early migration compared to hips operated on using the traditional posterior approach (PA). METHODS: A total of 388 hips were included in this study, 139 AA and 249 PA treated hips. Femoral component migration was evaluated using EBRA-FCA and radiographs were assessed for radiolucency at latest follow-up. Preoperative and 2-year clinical outcomes were reported. RESULTS: The 1- and 2-year migration rates (mm/year), and total migration (mm) at 2-year follow-up were comparable between AA and PA hips, respectively: 0.52 versus 0.41, 0.18 versus 0.19, and 0.64 versus 0.63 (all p > 0.05). Though not statistically significant, a higher percentage of AA hips passed 2-year total migration thresholds that have been associated with aseptic loosening compared to PA hips: 25.4% versus 16.5% for 1.5 mm threshold, and 11.3% versus 4.1% for the 2.7 mm threshold. Migration was not associated with the presence of radiolucent lines. All clinical outcomes improved significantly between preoperative and 2-year follow-up. CONCLUSIONS: There was no association between the AA and any significant increase in femoral component migration. A higher percentage of AA hips exceeded the migration thresholds associated aseptic loosening; however, these stems had no other indications of instability and therefore suggests that this may be a difference in migration pattern.

Technology-assisted toilets: Improving independence and hygiene in stroke rehabilitation.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Dependence on assistance for toileting is a widespread problem for persons receiving healthcare. Technology-assisted toilets, which hygienically wash and dry the perineal region, are devices that could improve toileting independence in a variety of patients. The objective was to investigate whether technology-assisted toilets improve toileting independence, quality of life, and whether technology-assisted toilets can provide sufficient toileting hygiene in stroke rehabilitation. METHODS: This pilot study was carried out in a stroke rehabilitation unit. Thirty participants were recruited. Participants had a bowel movement and cleaned themselves using the technology-assisted toilet on one to three occasions. Participants rated their toileting before using the technology-assisted toilet and after each technology-assisted toilet use with the Psychosocial Impact of Assistive Devices Scale (PIADS). After each session, participants were rated for cleanliness. RESULTS: PIADS scores were analyzed from eight individual participants, five of whom completed the full protocol. PIADS scores were significantly higher with the technology-assisted toilet than with the participants' regular toileting routine (p < 0.05). Technology-assisted toilets cleaned effectively in 73% of cases (16/22, p < 0.05). CONCLUSION: Technology-assisted toilets improved stroke patients' psychosocial outcomes compared to standard toileting and completely cleaned participants in the majority of cases. A larger study should confirm technology-assisted toilet's benefit in stroke rehabilitation through improved independence and hygiene.