Interobserver reliability of methods to determine complete resection of adenomas in colonoscopy.

BACKGROUND: Forceps margin biopsy and polypectomy specimen margins have both been used to assess for polypectomy resection adequacy. The interobserver reliability of the two methods has not been well described. METHODS: The interpretability of polypectomy specimens for presence of residual neoplasia at the margin was assessed by two blinded pathologists. Next, the concordance of forceps margin biopsy interpretations between three blinded pathologists was evaluated by calculation of interobserver κ. RESULTS: Rates of polypectomy specimen margin interpretability were low: 24/92 (26 %) for pathologist A, 28/92 (30.4 %) for pathologist B. Concordance of forceps margin biopsy interpretations (n = 129) between pathologists was high. Two internal pathologists showed substantial agreement in margin biopsy interpretations (κ 0.779; 95 %CL 0.543, 0.912). The concordance remained strong after biopsies were reviewed by a third, external pathologist (κ 0.829; 95 %CL 0.658, 0.924). There was complete agreement on 123/129 (95.3 %) between all three pathologists for presence of neoplasia. CONCLUSION: The majority of polypectomy specimen margins were uninterpretable by pathologists for presence of residual neoplasia. Forceps margin biopsy shows strong interobserver reliability in adenomatous lesions.

Alternative approaches to polyp extraction in colonoscopy: a proof of principle study.

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: A limitation of determination of the completeness of resection in polypectomy is polyp fragmentation. When a polyp fragments, the pathologist cannot determine resection completeness. Alternative approaches to reduce polyp fragmentation include reducing shearing forces on the polyp or removing polyps through the instrument channel. The primary aim of this study was to assess fragmentation of polyps extracted using different approaches from conventional polyp retrieval. METHODS: Polyps (5-15 mm) resected by cold snare or cautery by 3 colonoscopists were extracted from the colonoscope using 1 of 4 techniques. Method I was the conventional method of pressing the suction valve button and retrieving the polyp through a trap. Method II involved removing the suction valve, covering the open suction valve cylinder with a finger. Method III used a Roth Net polyp retriever placed through the instrument channel. Method IV involved connecting a polyp trap to suction onto the instrument channel port. Fragmentation was defined as multiple pieces of the specimen in formalin, as grossly described by the pathologist. Alternative approaches (methods II, III, and IV) were all compared with the conventional method (method I). RESULTS: The method I fragmentation rate of polyps was 60.3% (123/204). Method II extraction reduced fragmentation to 43.0% (52/121, P = .003), proving that fragmentation occurs with passage through the suction valve channel. Method III had a lower fragmentation rate of 23.1% (6/26, P < .001). Method IV likewise showed a reduced fragmentation rate of 18.5% (5/27, P < .001). CONCLUSIONS: Polyp fragmentation is reduced by removal of the suction valve button. There is also a decrease in fragmentation rates in removing the polyp by connecting the polyp trap to the instrument port. Our study suggests that decreasing polyp fragmentation and improving pathology margin interpretability is possible through methods that extract polyps through the instrument port with currently available devices.

Tumor scatter after neoadjuvant therapy for rectal cancer: are we dealing with an invisible margin?

BACKGROUND: After the impressive response of rectal cancers to neoadjuvant therapy, it seems reasonable to ask: can we can excise the small ulcer locally or avoid a radical resection if there is no gross residual tumor? Does gross response reflect what happens to tumor cells microscopically after radiation? OBJECTIVE: The aim of this study was to identify microscopic tumor cell response to radiation. DESIGN: This study is a retrospective review of a prospectively collected database. SETTING: This investigation was conducted at a single tertiary medical center. PATIENTS: Patients were selected who had elective radical resection for rectal cancer after preoperative chemotherapy and radiation performed by 2 colorectal surgeons between 2006 and 2011. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The primary outcome measured was tumor presence after radiation therapy RESULTS: Of the 75 patients, 20 patients were complete responders and 55 had residual cancer. Of these patients, 28 had no tumor cells seen outside the gross ulcer, and 27 (49.1%) had tumor outside the visible ulcer or microscopic tumor present with no overlying ulcer. Of these tumors, 81.5% were skewed away from the ulcer center. The mean distance of distal scatter was 1.0 cm from the visible ulcer edge to a maximum of 3 cm; 3 patients had tumor cells more than 2 cm distal to the visible ulcer edge. Tumor scatter outside the ulcer was not associated with poor prognostic factors, such as nodal and distant disease, perineural invasion, or mucin; however, it was associated with lymphovascular invasion (χ2 = 4.12, p = 0.038) LIMITATIONS: There was limited access to clinical information gathered outside our institution. CONCLUSIONS: Our study suggests that 1) after radiation, the gross ulcer cannot be used to determine the sole area of potential residual tumor, 2) cancer cells may be found up to 3 cm distally from the gross ulcer, so the traditional 2-cm margin may not be adequate, and 3) local excision of the ulcer or no excision after apparent complete response appears to be insufficient treatment for rectal cancer.

Tissue yield and diagnostic efficacy of fluoroscopic and cholangioscopic techniques to assess indeterminate biliary strictures.

BACKGROUND & AIMS: Evaluation of indeterminate biliary strictures typically involves collection and analysis of tissue or cells. Single-operator, peroral, cholangioscopic techniques have been developed that allow for a biopsy sample to be obtained from a specific area of the visualized stricture. We investigated whether standard fluoroscopic-guided and cholangioscopic-directed (SpyGlass Direct Visualization System; Boston Scientific, Natick, MA) biopsy collection provide adequate tissue for histologic assessment. METHODS: We examined 110 consecutive bile duct specimens collected from 89 patients with indeterminate biliary strictures at a single institution using fluoroscopy or cholangioscopy (from October 2007 to March 2010). Because of the small nature of the intraductal biopsy fragments, special procedures were followed in the pathology laboratory to maximize the amount of tissue for histopathology analysis. RESULTS: Only 4 specimens (3.6%) had insufficient material for a diagnosis. More tissue was obtained from standard fluoroscopic-guided than cholangioscopic-directed biopsies (more biopsy fragments, P = .018; larger total biopsy size, P = .001). Fluoroscopy-guided biopsies assessed indeterminate biliary strictures with 76% sensitivity and 88% accuracy; these values were 57% and 78%, respectively, for cholangioscopic-directed biopsies. Each procedure had 100% specificity. CONCLUSIONS: Analysis of bile duct biopsies is important in management of patients with indeterminate biliary strictures. Use of a special handling protocol for these small biopsies could reduce the number of cases with insufficient material for diagnosis. Increasing the sample size (either by using larger biopsy forceps or obtaining more biopsy bites) could improve the sensitivity of the SpyGlass technique. As endoscopists and pathologists gain more experience in collecting and handling small biopsies, the diagnostic efficacy of intraductal biopsies will continue to improve.

Transjugular liver biopsy: comparison of sample adequacy with the use of two automated needle systems.

PURPOSE: To compare the adequacy of transjugular liver biopsy (TJLB) specimens with use of the 18-gauge Quick-Core and Flexcore needles. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The records of 233 patients who underwent a TJLB procedure from January 2005 to December 2006 were retrospectively reviewed. Tissue samples from a total of 194 procedures were available for review; 117 TJLB procedures were performed with a Quick-Core needle and 77 were performed with a Flexcore needle. A single pathologist reviewed all the liver biopsy specimens in a blinded fashion. The χ(2), Fisher exact, and Student t tests were used to analyze differences between groups. RESULTS: The TJLB procedure was technically successful in 232 of 233 cases (99.6%). Histologic diagnosis was possible in 96% of cases. Sample fragmentation rates were 24.9% with the Quick-Core needle and 14.3% with the Flexcore needle (P = .1). The mean numbers of complete portal tracts (CPTs) per submitted tissue per procedure were 10.0 ± 4.6 for the Quick-Core needle and 12.2 ± 6.1 for the Flexcore needle (P = .003). The mean numbers of CPTs per liver sample were 2.63 ± 1.8 for the Quick-Core needle and 3.28 ± 3.3 for the Flexcore needle (P = .00004). Complications were more common in patients with multiple comorbidities such as renal failure and coagulopathy and those who had received a liver transplant. CONCLUSIONS: This study demonstrates that the 18-gauge Flexcore TJLB system provided better liver biopsy specimens compared with the 18-gauge Quick-Core needle system.

Histopathology predictors of medically refractory ulcerative colitis.

PURPOSE: The ability of ulcerative colitis histology to predict medically refractory disease was evaluated. METHODS: Twenty patients who underwent colectomy for medically refractory disease were compared with 48 medically managed patients. All patients were followed up for > or =6 months. The study design was a retrospective longitudinal observational chart review to determine whether specific histologic parameters were predictive of a later colectomy for medically refractory disease. RESULTS: On initial biopsy, medically refractory patients were more likely to have severe cryptitis, 75% vs 49%; lymphoid follicles, 78% vs 48%; and erosions, 35% vs 11%. There was no significant difference in the prevalence of crypt abscesses, mucin depletion, crypt distortion, or mucosal ulceration between medically refractory and medically managed patients. Active inflammation on endoscopy was not statistically different between groups (P = .192). In a recursive partition model, the strongest predictors of future colectomy were age dependent. Among older patients (>38 y), severe cryptitis was the strongest determinant of refractory disease. Only 1 of 21 (5%) of the patients who initially did not have severe cryptitis progressed to colectomy. In younger patients (< or =38 y), the presence of lymphoid follicles was the strongest predictor of future colectomy; 9 of 14 (64%) patients with lymphoid follicles progressed to colectomy. CONCLUSIONS: Medically refractory ulcerative colitis was associated with initial biopsy findings of severe cryptitis, lymphoid follicles, and erosions. Refractory disease was not predicted by the severity or extent of endoscopic findings. In younger patients, the presence of lymphoid follicles, and in older patients, severe cryptitis, were the most important predictors of medically refractory disease.

Diffuse cirrhosis-like hepatocellular carcinoma: a clinically and radiographically undetected variant mimicking cirrhosis.

A rare variant of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) is encountered that produces small cirrhosis-like nodules diffusely throughout the liver (CL-HCC), instead of a larger evident mass. This pattern remains undetected as carcinoma clinically and radiographically and is unexpectedly discovered after liver transplantation in the explanted native liver. We studied 10 such cases (9 males and 1 female, age 35 to 80 y) from 4 medical centers. The pretransplant clinical, laboratory, and radiographical studies were reviewed to determine the cause and stage of liver disease, alpha-fetoprotein (AFP) levels, and detectability of a mass on imaging. All 10 cases had underlying cirrhosis of varying etiology [3 hepatitis C virus (HCV), 3 alcoholic hepatitis, 1 hepatitis B virus, 1 autoimmune, and 2 mixed HCV/alcoholic hepatitis and hemochromatosis/HCV] and underwent orthotopic liver transplantation with no preoperative clinical suspicion of HCC. Ultrasound and/or dynamic imaging showed cirrhosis and no definite HCC. AFP levels were only mildly elevated in only 3 of 10 cases (144, 150, and 252 ng/mL). Grossly, there were innumerable (from about 20 to >1000) small CL-HCC nodules (0.2 to 0.6 cm) scattered among cirrhotic nodules. Histologically, these were well or moderately differentiated HCC, often with pseudoglandular pattern, perinodular sclerotic rims, cholestasis, frequent Mallory bodies, and small vessel invasion. In addition to the usual HCC immunophenotype, CL-HCC showed frequent ubiquitin and cytoplasmic and membranous CD10 positivity, relatively low Ki-67 proliferative index and absence of AFP immunohistochemically. CL-HCC warrants recognition as a unique HCC variant that evades pretransplant detection despite massive tumor burden, mimics cirrhotic nodules, and shows some uncommon pathologic and immunophenotypical characteristics.