Flow cytometric determination of aberrant intra-epithelial lymphocytes predicts T-cell lymphoma development more accurately than T-cell clonality analysis in Refractory Celiac Disease.

BACKGROUND: Refractory celiac disease (RCD) patients with aberrant, often clonal, intraepithelial T-cells are at high risk for development of enteropathy associated T-cell lymphoma (EATL). Early detection of those patients that actually develop EATL is of utmost importance for curative intervention. AIM: First, to establish an optimal cut-off value for the percentage of aberrant lymphocytes, previously determined based on clinical observations, via reference ranges for aberrant T-cells in the duodenal mucosa of celiac disease patient and control groups. Secondly, to compare aberrancy with intestinal T-cell clonality as a prognostic parameter for EATL development in RCD. METHODS: Immunophenotyping using flow cytometry was performed on small intestinal biopsy-derived lymphocytes, obtained from distinct celiac disease (CD) patient and control groups (N=167 in total). T-cell clonality in duodenal biopsy specimens was assessed by PCR in RCD, ulcerative jejunitis and EATL patients (N=31 in total). RESULTS: In 95% of non-refractory CD patients, the highest percentage aberrant T-cells was 20%. Using this cut-off value, EATL development was exclusively seen in RCD with more than 20% aberrant T-cells (median 52% aberrant T-cells, range 27-94%). When compared with T-cell clonality analysis, >20% aberrancy showed a much higher negative predictive value and sensitivity (both 100%) for EATL development in RCD patients than T-cell clonality analysis (respectively 75% and 78%). CONCLUSIONS: Quantification of aberrant T-cells by flow cytometry is preferable to T-cell clonality analysis for identification of RCD patients at risk for EATL development. A cut-off value of 20% is of use in risk stratification, therapeutic options and subsequent follow-up of RCD patients.

Cladribine therapy in refractory celiac disease with aberrant T cells.

BACKGROUND & AIMS: Refractory celiac disease (RCD) may be subdivided into RCD types I and II with phenotypically normal and aberrant intraepithelial T-cell populations, respectively. In RCD II, transition into enteropathy-associated T-cell lymphoma (EATL) is seen frequently. We have evaluated the effect of cladribine (2-CDA), a purine analogue inducing T-cell depletion, on clinical, histopathologic, and immunologic parameters, as well as the toxicity and side effects in a group of RCD II patients. METHODS: Between 2000 and 2005, 17 patients were included (8 men, 9 women). All patients had a clonal rearrangement of the T-cell receptor gamma gene and immunophenotyping showed an aberrant T-cell population lacking surface expression of CD3, CD8, and T-cell receptor alphabeta, in the presence of expression of surface CD103 and intracytoplasmic CD3. Treatment consisted of 2-CDA (0.1 mg/kg/day) intravenously for 5 days, given in 1-3 courses every 6 months depending on the response. RESULTS: All patients tolerated 2-CDA without serious side effects. Six patients (35.8%) showed a clinical improvement (weight gain, improvement of diarrhea, and hypoalbuminemia). In 10 patients (58.8%) a significant histologic improvement and in 6 patients (35.2%) a significant decrease in aberrant T cells was seen. Seven patients (41.1%) developed EATL and died subsequently. One patient died of progressive refractory state with emaciation. CONCLUSIONS: Treatment with 2-CDA in RCD II is feasible, well tolerated, and can induce clinical and histologic improvement as well as a significant decrease of aberrant T cells in a subgroup of patients, albeit it does not prevent EATL development. However, the earlier reported potential risk of precipitating an overt lymphoma should be taken into consideration.

Human leukocyte antigen-DQ2 homozygosity and the development of refractory celiac disease and enteropathy-associated T-cell lymphoma.

BACKGROUND & AIMS: Celiac disease (CD) is a common gluten-sensitive enteropathy associated with human leukocyte antigen (HLA)-DQ2 and HLA-DQ8. The aim of this study was to determine if a particular HLA-DQ subtype predisposes to complications such as refractory CD with (RCD II) or without aberrant T cells (RCD I), and enteropathy-associated T-cell lymphomas (EATL). METHODS: Molecular HLA-DQ typing was performed on 43 RCD I, 43 RCD II, and 30 EATL patients, and compared with age-matched groups of 121 patients with histologically defined uncomplicated CD and 183 healthy controls. All individuals were Dutch Caucasians and were at least 21 years of age. RESULTS: HLA-DQ2 was present in 79% of RCD I, 97.7% of RCD II, and 96.6% of EATL patients. The differences were significant when compared with 28.9% in controls but not with 91.7% in uncomplicated CD. Homozygosity for HLA-DQ2 was observed in 25.5% of RCD I, 44.1% of RCD II, and 53.3% of EATL patients vs 20.7% of uncomplicated CD patients and 2.1% of controls. HLA-DQ8 was present in 10.7% of CD, 16.2% of RCD I, 9.3% of RCD II, and 6.6% of EATL patients vs 20.2% of controls. CONCLUSIONS: Homozygosity for HLA-DQ2 is associated with RCD II and EATL. Early identification of HLA-DQ2 homozygous CD patients may help to recognize CD patients at risk for developing these severe complications.

Antiendomysial and antihuman recombinant tissue transglutaminase antibodies in the diagnosis of coeliac disease: a biopsy-proven European multicentre study.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the value of serum antitissue transglutaminase IgA antibodies (IgA-TTG) and IgA antiendomysial antibodies (IgA-EMA) in the diagnosis of coeliac disease in cohorts from different geographical areas in Europe. The setting allowed a further comparison between the antibody results and the conventional small-intestinal histology. METHODS: A total of 144 cases with coeliac disease [median age 19.5 years (range 0.9-81.4)], and 127 disease controls [median age 29.2 years (range 0.5-79.0)], were recruited, on the basis of biopsy, from 13 centres in nine countries. All biopsy specimens were re-evaluated and classified blindly a second time by two investigators. IgA-TTG were determined by ELISA with human recombinant antigen and IgA-EMA by an immunofluorescence test with human umbilical cord as antigen. RESULTS: The quality of the biopsy specimens was not acceptable in 29 (10.7%) of 271 cases and a reliable judgement could not be made, mainly due to poor orientation of the samples. The primary clinical diagnosis and the second classification of the biopsy specimens were divergent in nine cases, and one patient was initially enrolled in the wrong group. Thus, 126 coeliac patients and 106 controls, verified by biopsy, remained for final analysis. The sensitivity of IgA-TTG was 94% and IgA-EMA 89%, the specificity was 99% and 98%, respectively. CONCLUSIONS: Serum IgA-TTG measurement is effective and at least as good as IgA-EMA in the identification of coeliac disease. Due to a high percentage of poor histological specimens, the diagnosis of coeliac disease should not depend only on biopsy, but in addition the clinical picture and serology should be considered.

Coeliac disease--has the time come for routine mass screening? In 2002--2010--2020?

It might be clinically relevant to have a very low threshold when screening for coeliac disease. The question is how low? In countries familiar with coeliac disease, the classic pattern of severe malabsorption and cachexia, as described in textbooks, has become rare. Coeliac disease is not born in the minds of doctors diagnosing dyspepsia and/or irritable bowel syndrome, or associated auto-immune diseases, such as thyroid, diabetes mellitus type I, Sjögren's disease etc. The consequence is a delay in diagnosis, with secondary problems as long term autoimmune stimulation, osteoporosis and secondary malignancies. Enteropathy associated T-cell lymphomas are well known, but considering coeliac disease in T-cell lymphomas outside the gastrointestinal tract is not yet common sense. Large-scale screening studies on coeliac disease have been published and suggest a prevalence of coeliac disease in USA, Europe, Middle-East and Australia of about 1:200. Coeliac disease can be classified due to all these studies as an important health problem. However nation-wide screening programmes have not started yet, which are common for phenylketonuria and other metabolic defects. Probably they will be initiated as pilot-studies in national programmes within 10 years at the age of 2, and due to the bimodal distribution in CD with a later peak in the fourth decade, at 40 years. Additional data about cohorts of certain age groups are mandatory (f.i. 40 and/or 60 years), while initial discussions begin with national health authorities.

Coeliac disease: more than villous atrophy.

A continuing flow of new scientific developments concerning coeliac disease in the last decade asks for the formulation of a new concept of pathophysiology and clinical approach of the coeliac condition. Immunogenetic studies have shown a correlation of the disease to the HLA region on the short arm of chromosome 6. Immunological research has led to the concept of a T-cell driven immunologic response of the small intestine, with the identification of highly sensitive and specific antibodies, and in addition the understanding of the histopathology of coeliac disease has changed dramatically, initiated by the proposition of a spectrum of gluten sensitive enteropathy by Marsh in 1992. Clinical studies report a significant change in patient characteristics and epidemiology. The incidence of the disease has shifted to a majority of adult coeliacs and the disease may present with less severe symptoms of malabsorption while screening studies suggest an overall prevalence of up to 1 in 200-300. In the present paper (an update on histopathology) we specifically describe the work of our group in Arnhem, concerning the identification and validation of the spectrum of intestinal histopathology in gluten sensitive enteropathy, i.e. lymphocytic enteritis (Marsh I lesion), lymphocytic enteritis with crypthyperplasia (Marsh II lesion), and villous atrophy, subdivided in partial villous atrophy (Marsh IIIA), subtotal villous atrophy (Marsh IIIB) and total villous atrophy (Marsh IIIC). Special attention is given to a subgroup of "refractory coeliacs", including the identification of (pre-) malignant aberrant T-cells in the intestinal mucosa of these patients. The new data on immunogenetics, epidemiology, histo-pathology and patient characteristics point to a significant change of views on coeliac disease.