[The toxic aggregation of proteins: a kind of "molecular delinquency" actively fought in the cell by molecular chaperones and proteases]. / L'agrégation toxique des protéines: une forme de "delinquance moléculaire" activement combattue dans la cellule par les chaperones moléculaires et les protéases.

Under various stresses, mutation-sensitised proteins may spontaneously convert into inactive, aggregation-prone structures, which may be cytotoxic and infectious. In the cell, this new kind of "molecular criminality" is actively fought against by a network of molecular chaperones that can specifically identify, isolate and unfold damaged (delinquent) proteins and favour their subsequent native refolding. Irreversibly damaged molecules unable to natively refold are preferentially "executed" and recycled by proteases. Failing that, they are "imprisoned" within compact amyloids, or "evicted" from the cell. Thus, striking parallels, although of questionable ethical value, exist between protein and human criminality, and between the cellular and social responses to these different types of criminality. Fundamental differences also exist. Whereas programmed death (apoptosis) is the preferred solution chosen by aged and aggregation-stressed cells, collective suicide is seldom an option chosen by lawless human societies. More significantly, there is no clear cellular equivalent for the role of the family and the education system, which are so essential to the proper shaping of functional individuals in the society, and give rise to humanism, that favours crime prevention, reeducation and reinsertion programs over capital punishment. To the cardiologist and transplantation surgeon, the interest of molecular chaperones, in particular of Hsp70, Hsp90 and Hsp27, lays in their ability to inhibit the signalling pathway of programmed cell death. Their induction before and during ischemia, by various treatments and drugs could significantly reduce damages from the post ischemic reperfusion of organs.

Review: mechanisms of disaggregation and refolding of stable protein aggregates by molecular chaperones.

Molecular chaperones are essential for the correct folding of proteins in the cell under physiological and stress conditions. Two activities have been traditionally attributed to molecular chaperones: (1) preventing aggregation of unfolded polypeptides and (2) assisting in the correct refolding of chaperone-bound denatured polypeptides. We discuss here a novel function of molecular chaperones: catalytic solubilization and refolding of stable protein aggregates. In Escherichia coli, disaggregation is carried out by a network of ATPase chaperones consisting of a DnaK core, assisted by the cochaperones DnaJ, GrpE, ClpB, and GroEL-GroES. We suggest a sequential mechanism in which (a) ClpB exposes new DnaK-binding sites on the surface of the stable protein aggregates; (b) DnaK binds the aggregate surfaces and, by doing so, melts the incorrect hydrophobic associations between aggregated polypeptides; (c) ATP hydrolysis and DnaK release allow local intramolecular refolding of native domains, leading to a gradual weakening of improper intermolecular links; (d) DnaK and GroEL complete refolding of solubilized polypeptide chains into native proteins. Thus, active disaggregation by the chaperone network can serve as a central cellular tool for the recovery of native proteins from stress-induced aggregates and actively remove disease-causing toxic aggregates, such as polyglutamine-rich proteins, amyloid plaques, and prions.

Chemical chaperones regulate molecular chaperones in vitro and in cells under combined salt and heat stresses.

Salt and heat stresses, which are often combined in nature, induce complementing defense mechanisms. Organisms adapt to high external salinity by accumulating small organic compounds known as osmolytes, which equilibrate cellular osmotic pressure. Osmolytes can also act as "chemical chaperones" by increasing the stability of native proteins and assisting refolding of unfolded polypeptides. Adaptation to heat stress depends on the expression of heat-shock proteins, many of which are molecular chaperones, that prevent protein aggregation, disassemble protein aggregates, and assist protein refolding. We show here that Escherichia coli cells preadapted to high salinity contain increased levels of glycine betaine that prevent protein aggregation under thermal stress. After heat shock, the aggregated proteins, which escaped protection, were disaggregated in salt-adapted cells as efficiently as in low salt. Here we address the effects of four common osmolytes on chaperone activity in vitro. Systematic dose responses of glycine betaine, glycerol, proline, and trehalose revealed a regulatory effect on the folding activities of individual and combinations of chaperones GroEL, DnaK, and ClpB. With the exception of trehalose, low physiological concentrations of proline, glycerol, and especially glycine betaine activated the molecular chaperones, likely by assisting local folding in chaperone-bound polypeptides and stabilizing the native end product of the reaction. High osmolyte concentrations, especially trehalose, strongly inhibited DnaK-dependent chaperone networks, such as DnaK+GroEL and DnaK+ClpB, likely because high viscosity affects dynamic interactions between chaperones and folding substrates and stabilizes protein aggregates. Thus, during combined salt and heat stresses, cells can specifically control protein stability and chaperone-mediated disaggregation and refolding by modulating the intracellular levels of different osmolytes.

Genetic dissection of the roles of chaperones and proteases in protein folding and degradation in the Escherichia coli cytosol.

We investigated the roles of chaperones and proteases in quality control of proteins in the Escherichia coli cytosol. In DeltarpoH mutants, which lack the heat shock transcription factor and therefore have low levels of all major cytosolic proteases and chaperones except GroEL and trigger factor, 5-10% and 20-30% of total protein aggregated at 30 degrees C and 42 degrees C respectively. The aggregates contained 350-400 protein species, of which 93 were identified by mass spectrometry. The aggregated protein species were similar at both temperatures, indicating that thermolabile proteins require folding assistance by chaperones already at 30 degrees C, and showed strong overlap with previously identified DnaK substrates. Overproduction of the DnaK system, or low-level production of the DnaK system and ClpB, prevented aggregation and provided thermotolerance to DeltarpoH mutants, indicating key roles for these chaperones in protein quality control and stress survival. In rpoH+ cells, DnaK depletion did not lead to protein aggregation at 30 degrees C, which is probably the result of high levels of proteases and thus suggests that DnaK is not a prerequisite for proteolysis of misfolded proteins. Lon was the most efficient protease in degrading misfolded proteins in DnaK-depleted cells. At 42 degrees C, ClpXP and Lon became essential for viability of cells with low DnaK levels, indicating synergistic action of proteases and the DnaK system, which is essential for cell growth at 42 degrees C.

Synechocystis HSP17 is an amphitropic protein that stabilizes heat-stressed membranes and binds denatured proteins for subsequent chaperone-mediated refolding.

The small heat shock proteins (sHSPs) are ubiquitous stress proteins proposed to act as molecular chaperones to prevent irreversible protein denaturation. We characterized the chaperone activity of Synechocystis HSP17 and found that it has not only protein-protective activity, but also a previously unrecognized ability to stabilize lipid membranes. Like other sHSPs, recombinant Synechocystis HSP17 formed stable complexes with denatured malate dehydrogenase and served as a reservoir for the unfolded substrate, transferring it to the DnaK/DnaJ/GrpE and GroEL/ES chaperone network for subsequent refolding. Large unilamellar vesicles made of synthetic and cyanobacterial lipids were found to modulate this refolding process. Investigation of HSP17-lipid interactions revealed a preference for the liquid crystalline phase and resulted in an elevated physical order in model lipid membranes. Direct evidence for the participation of HSP17 in the control of thylakoid membrane physical state in vivo was gained by examining an hsp17(-) deletion mutant compared with the isogenic wild-type hsp17(+) revertant Synechocystis cells. We suggest that, together with GroEL, HSP17 behaves as an amphitropic protein and plays a dual role. Depending on its membrane or cytosolic location, it may function as a "membrane stabilizing factor" as well as a member of a multichaperone protein-folding network. Membrane association of sHSPs could antagonize the heat-induced hyperfluidization of specific membrane domains and thereby serve to preserve structural and functional integrity of biomembranes.

From minichaperone to GroEL 3: properties of an active single-ring mutant of GroEL.

The next step in our reductional analysis of GroEL was to study the activity of an isolated single seven-membered ring of the 14-mer. A known single-ring mutant, GroEL(SR1), contains four point mutations that prevent the formation of double-rings. That heptameric complex is functionally inactive because it is unable to release GroES. We found that the mutation E191G, which is responsible for the temperature sensitive (ts) Escherichia coli allele groEL44 and is located in the hinge region between the intermediate and apical domains of GroEL, appears to function by weakening the binding of GroES, without destabilizing the overall structure of GroEL44 mutant. We introduced, therefore, the mutation E191G into GroEL(SR1) in order to generate a single-ring mutant that may have weaker binding of GroES and hence be active. The new single-ring mutant, GroEL(SR44), was indeed effective in refolding both heat and dithiothreitol-denatured mitochondrial malate dehydrogenase with great efficiency. Further, unlike all smaller constructs of GroEL, the expression of GroEL(SR44) in E. coli that contained no endogenous GroEL restored biological viability, but not as efficiently as does wild-type GroEL. We envisage the notional evolution of the structure and properties of GroEL. The minichaperone core acts as a primitive chaperone by providing a binding surface for denatured states that prevents their self-aggregation. The assembly of seven minichaperones into a ring then enhances substrate binding by introducing avidity. The acquisition of binding sites for ATP then allows the modulation of substrate binding by introducing the allosteric mechanism that causes cycling between strong and weak binding sites. This is accompanied by the acquisition by the heptamer of the binding of GroES, which functions as a lid to the central cavity and competes for peptide binding sites. Finally, dimerization of the heptamer enhances its biological activity.

Size-dependent disaggregation of stable protein aggregates by the DnaK chaperone machinery.

Classic in vitro studies show that the Hsp70 chaperone system from Escherichia coli (DnaK-DnaJ-GrpE, the DnaK system) can bind to proteins, prevent aggregation, and promote the correct refolding of chaperone-bound polypeptides into native proteins. However, little is known about how the DnaK system handles proteins that have already aggregated. In this study, glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase was used as a model system to generate stable populations of protein aggregates comprising controlled ranges of particle sizes. The DnaK system recognized the glucose-6-phosphate dehydrogenase aggregates as authentic substrates and specifically solubilized and refolded the protein into a native enzyme. The efficiency of disaggregation by the DnaK system was high with small aggregates, but the efficiency decreased as the size of the aggregates increased. High folding efficiency was restored by either excess DnaK or substoichiometric amounts of the chaperone ClpB. We suggest a mechanism whereby the DnaK system can readily solubilize small aggregates and refold them into active proteins. With large aggregates, however, the binding sites for the DnaK system had to be dynamically exposed with excess DnaK or the catalytic action of ClpB and ATP. Disaggregation by the DnaK machinery in the cell can solubilize early aggregates that formed accidentally during chaperone-assisted protein folding or that escaped the protection of "holding" chaperones during stress.

Identification of thermolabile Escherichia coli proteins: prevention and reversion of aggregation by DnaK and ClpB.

UNLABELLED: We systematically analyzed the capability of the major cytosolic chaperones of Escherichia coli to cope with protein misfolding and aggregation during heat stress in vivo and in cell extracts. Under physiological heat stress conditions, only the DnaK system efficiently prevented the aggregation of thermolabile proteins, a surprisingly high number of 150-200 species, corresponding to 15-25% of detected proteins. Identification of thermolabile DnaK substrates by mass spectrometry revealed that they comprise 80% of the large (>/=90 kDa) but only 18% of the small (

Sequential mechanism of solubilization and refolding of stable protein aggregates by a bichaperone network.

A major activity of molecular chaperones is to prevent aggregation and refold misfolded proteins. However, when allowed to form, protein aggregates are refolded poorly by most chaperones. We show here that the sequential action of two Escherichia coli chaperone systems, ClpB and DnaK-DnaJ-GrpE, can efficiently solubilize excess amounts of protein aggregates and refold them into active proteins. Measurements of aggregate turbidity, Congo red, and 4,4'-dianilino-1, 1'-binaphthyl-5,5'-disulfonic acid binding, and of the disaggregation/refolding kinetics by using a specific ClpB inhibitor, suggest a mechanism where (i) ClpB directly binds protein aggregates, ATP induces structural changes in ClpB, which (ii) increase hydrophobic exposure of the aggregates and (iii) allow DnaK-DnaJ-GrpE to bind and mediate dissociation and refolding of solubilized polypeptides into native proteins. This efficient mechanism, whereby chaperones can catalytically solubilize and refold a wide variety of large and stable protein aggregates, is a major addition to the molecular arsenal of the cell to cope with protein damage induced by stress or pathological states.

Minimal and optimal mechanisms for GroE-mediated protein folding.

We have analyzed the effects of different components of the GroE chaperonin system on protein folding by using a nonpermissive substrate (i.e., one that has very low spontaneous refolding yield) for which rate data can be acquired. In the absence of GroES and nucleotides, the rate of GroEL-mediated refolding of heat- and DTT-denatured mitochondrial malate dehydrogenase was extremely low, but some three times higher than the spontaneous rate. This GroEL-mediated rate was increased 17-fold by saturating concentrations of ATP, 11-fold by ADP and GroES, and 465-fold by ATP and GroES. Optimal refolding activity was observed when the dissociation of GroES from the chaperonin complex was dramatically reduced. Although GroEL minichaperones were able to bind denatured mitochondrial malate dehydrogenase, they were ineffective in enhancing the refolding rate. The spectrum of mechanisms for GroE-mediated protein folding depends on the nature of the substrate. The minimal mechanism for permissive substrates (i.e., having significant yields of spontaneous refolding), requires only binding to the apical domain of GroEL. Slow folding rates of nonpermissive substrates are limited by the transitions between high- and low-affinity states of GroEL alone. The optimal mechanism, which requires holoGroEL, physiological amounts of GroES, and ATP hydrolysis, is necessary for the chaperonin-mediated folding of nonpermissive substrates at physiologically relevant rates under conditions in which retention of bound GroES prevents the premature release of aggregation-prone folding intermediates from the chaperonin complex. The different mechanisms are described in terms of the structural features of mini- and holo-chaperones.

Temperature-controlled activity of DnaK-DnaJ-GrpE chaperones: protein-folding arrest and recovery during and after heat shock depends on the substrate protein and the GrpE concentration.

Heat-shock proteins DnaK, DnaJ, and GrpE (KJE) from Escherichia coli constitute a three-component chaperone system that prevents aggregation of denatured proteins and assists the refolding of proteins in an ATP-dependent manner. We found that the rate of KJE-mediated refolding of heat- and chemically denatured proteins is decreased at high temperatures. The efficiency and reversibility of protein-folding arrest during and after heat shock depended on the stability of the complex between KJE and the denatured proteins. Whereas a thermostable protein was released and partially refolded during heat shock, a thermolabile protein remained bound to the chaperone. The apparent affinity of GrpE and DnaJ for DnaK was decreased at high temperatures, thereby decreasing futile consumption of ATP during folding arrest. The coupling of ATP hydrolysis and protein folding was restored after the stress. This strongly indicates that KJE chaperones are heat-regulated heat-shock proteins which can specifically arrest the folding of aggregation-prone proteins during stress and preferentially resume refolding under conditions that allow individual proteins to reach and maintain a stable native conformation.

The small heat-shock protein IbpB from Escherichia coli stabilizes stress-denatured proteins for subsequent refolding by a multichaperone network.

The role of small heat-shock proteins in Escherichia coli is still enigmatic. We show here that the small heat-shock protein IbpB is a molecular chaperone that assists the refolding of denatured proteins in the presence of other chaperones. IbpB oligomers bind and stabilize heat-denatured malate dehydrogenase (MDH) and urea-denatured lactate dehydrogenase and thus prevent the irreversible aggregation of these proteins during stress. While IbpB-stabilized proteins alone do not refold spontaneously, they are specifically delivered to the DnaK/DnaJ/GrpE (KJE) chaperone system where they refold in a strict ATPase-dependent manner. Although GroEL/GroES (LS) chaperonins do not interact directly with IbpB-released proteins, LS accelerate the rate of KJE-mediated refolding of IbpB-released MDH, and to a lesser extent lactate dehydrogenase, by rapidly processing KJE-released early intermediates. Kinetic and gel-filtration analysis showed that denatured MDH preferentially transfers from IbpB to KJE, then from KJE to LS, and then forms a active enzyme. IbpB thus stabilizes aggregation-prone folding intermediates during stress and, as an integral part of a cooperative multichaperone network, is involved in the active refolding of stress-denatured proteins.

Structural analysis of GroE chaperonin complexes using chemical cross-linking.

In this chapter, we have shown how chemical cross-linking with a bifunctional reagent, GA, can be used to investigate the structure of large oligomeric complexes such as GroEL14GroES7 and GroEL14(GroES7)2. Cross-linking, followed by denaturing electrophoresis, confirmed the number and arrangement of GroEL and GroES subunits within each individual oligomer, which was previously known from EM analysis. Furthermore, cross-linking permitted a close examination of the effect of regulatory factors, such as nucleotides and free divalent cations, on the molecular structure of GroEL14, GroEL14GroES7, and GroEL14GroES7. Finally, cross-linking analysis permitted characterization and quantitation of various chaperonin heterooligomeric complexes, GroEL14, GroEL14GroES7, and GroEL14GroES7 in solution, under conditions that also supported protein folding and ATP hydrolysis. It was shown that GA does not induce the artifactual association or the dissociation of GroES7 from the chaperonin. On the contrary, chemical cross-linking is an obligatory procedure when the subsequent analysis is carried out using methods that can displace the equilibrium.

GroES binding regulates GroEL chaperonin activity under heat shock.

Chaperonins GroEL14 and GroES7 are heat-shock proteins implicated in the molecular response to stress. Protein fluorescence, crosslinking and kinetic analysis revealed that the bond between the two otherwise thermoresistant oligomers is regulated by temperature. As temperature increased, the affinity of GroES7 and the release of bound proteins from the chaperonin concomitantly decreased. After heat shock, GroES7 rebinding to GroEL14 and GroEL14GroES7 particles correlated with the restoration of optimal protein folding/release activity. Chaperonins thus behave as a molecular thermometer which can inhibit the release of aggregation-prone proteins during heat shock and restore protein folding and release after heat shock.

Evidence for a lipochaperonin: association of active protein-folding GroESL oligomers with lipids can stabilize membranes under heat shock conditions.

During heat shock, structural changes in proteins and membranes may lead to cell death. While GroE and other chaperone proteins are involved in the prevention of stress-induced protein aggregation and in the recovery of protein structures, a mechanism for short-term membrane stabilization during stress remains to be established. We found that GroEL chaperonin can associate with model lipid membranes. Binding was apparently governed by the composition and the physical state of the host bilayer. Limited proteolysis of GroEL oligomers by proteinase K, which removes selectively the conserved glycine- and methionine-rich C terminus, leaving the chaperonin oligomer intact, prevented chaperonin association with lipid membranes. GroEL increased the lipid order in the liquid crystalline state, yet remained functional as a protein-folding chaperonin. This suggests that, during stress, chaperonins can assume the functions of assisting the folding of both soluble and membrane-associated proteins while concomitantly stabilizing lipid membranes.

Fluorescence detection of symmetric GroEL14(GroES7)2 heterooligomers involved in protein release during the chaperonin cycle.

The GroEL14 chaperonin from Escherichia coli was labeled with 5-((((2-iodoacetyl)amino)ethyl)amino)naphthalene-1-sulfonic acid (I-AEDANS), a hydrophobic probe whose fluorescent emission is sensitive to structural changes within the protein. Increasing concentrations of ATP or adenylyl imidodiphosphate but not ADP caused two successive GroES7-dependent changes in the fluorescence intensity of AEDANS-GroEL14, corresponding to the sequential binding of two GroES7 heptamers and the formation of two types of chaperonin heterooligomers, GroEL14GroES7 and GroEL14(GroES7)2. The binding of thermally denatured malate dehydrogenase (MDH) caused a specific increase in fluorescence intensity of AEDANS-GroEL14 that allowed the direct measurement in solution at equilibrium of ATP- and GroES7-dependent protein release from the chaperonin. Structure/function analysis during the generation of ATP from ADP indicated the following sequence of events: 1) ADP-stabilized MDH-GroEL14GroES7 particles bind newly formed ATP. 2) MDH-GroEL14GroES7 particles bind a second GroES7. 3) MDH-GroEL14(GroES7)2 particles productively release MDH. 4) Released MDH completes folding. Therefore, the symmetrical GroEL14(GroES7)2 heterooligomer is an intermediate after the formation of which the protein substrate is productively released during the chaperonin-mediated protein folding cycle.

The protein-folding activity of chaperonins correlates with the symmetric GroEL14(GroES7)2 heterooligomer.

Chaperonins GroEL and GroES form, in the presence of ATP, two types of heterooligomers in solution: an asymmetric GroEL14GroES7 "bullet"-shaped particle and a symmetric GroEL14(GroES7)2 "football"-shaped particle. Under limiting concentrations of ATP or GroES, excess ADP, or in the presence of 5'-adenylyl imidodiphosphate, a correlation is seen between protein folding and the amount of symmetric GroEL14(GroES7)2 particles in a chaperonin solution, as detected by electron microscopy or by chemical crosslinking. Kinetic analysis suggests that protein folding is more efficient when carried out by a chaperonin solution populated with a majority of symmetric GroEL14(GroES7)2 particles than by a majority of asymmetric GroEL14GroES7 particles. The symmetric heterooligomer behaves as a highly efficient intermediate of the chaperonin protein folding cycle in vitro.

Increased efficiency of GroE-assisted protein folding by manganese ions.

This study addresses the role of ATP-bound and free Mg2+ and Mn2+ ions in the activation and modulation of chaperonin-assisted refolding of urea-denatured malate dehydrogenase. As compared with Mg2+, Mn2+ ions caused a significant increase in the rate of GroE-assisted malate dehydrogenase refolding and, concomitantly, a decrease in the rate of ATP hydrolysis. Moreover, Mn2+ increases the affinity of GroES for GroEL, even in the presence of saturating amounts of Mg2+. Chemical cross-linking showed that lower concentrations of Mn-ATP as compared with Mg-ATP are needed to form both asymmetric GroEL14GroES7 and symmetric GroEL14(GroES7)2 particles. The manganese-dependent increase in the rate of protein folding concurred with a specific increase in the amount of symmetric GroEL14-(GroES7)2 particles detected in a chaperonin solution. Thus, Mn2+ is a cofactor that can markedly increase the efficiency of the chaperonin reaction in vitro. Mn2+ ions can serve as an important tool for analyzing the molecular mechanism and the structure of chaperonins.

A mutant at position 87 of the GroEL chaperonin is affected in protein binding and ATP hydrolysis.

The highly conserved aspartic acid residue at position 87 of the Escherichia coli chaperonin GroEL was mutated to glutamic acid. When expressed in an E. coli groEL mutant strain deficient for phage morphogenesis, plasmid-encoded GroEL mutant D87E restored T4 phage morphogenesis. It did not, however, reactivate the transcription of a recombinant luciferase operon from Vibrio fischeri. In vitro, GroEL mutant D87E was found to be impaired in the ability to bind nonnative proteins and to hydrolyze ATP, resulting in less efficient refolding of urea-denatured ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase. Mutant oligomer D87E GroEL14 was able to bind GroES7 as efficiently as wild-type GroEL14. The conserved aspartic acid residue at position 87 located in the equatorial domain of GroEL (Braig, K., Otwinowski, Z., Hegde, R., Boisvert, D.C., Joachimiak, A., Horwich, A.L., and Sigler, P.B. (1994) Nature 371, 578-586) is thus inferred to have a dual effect on the binding of nonnative proteins to the GroEL14 core chaperonin and on ATP hydrolysis.