An anti-mitotic compound, (+)-6-tuliposide a, isolated from the Canadian glacier lily, Erythronium grandiflorum.

The Canadian prairie ecosystem is subjected to abiotic and biotic conditions that induce plants to produce secondary metabolites that affect mammalian physiology. Extracts prepared from certain plant species native to Canadian prairie and montane cordillera ecosystems have previously been shown to have anti-mitotic activity on human cancer cell lines. In this study, we investigated the glacier lily, Erythronium grandiflorum (Liliaceae), in which the species was the most taxonomically distant from Asteraceae and had anti-mitotic activity. When added to cell lines, E. grandiflorum extracts induced rounded cell morphology and arrested cells in the G2/M phase of the cell cycle. Of the cells that displayed a rounded phenotype, all were positive for phospho-histone H3 and contained a distorted mitotic spindle. This anti-mitotic activity was distinct from that of the compound colchicine, which has been previously isolated from the Liliaceae family. By biology-guided fractionation, we isolated the natural product (+)-6-tuliposide A and are the first to report its anti-mitotic activity. These results reveal a chemical motif in secondary metabolites and expand the range of Canadian prairie plants with anti-mitotic activity that can become new scientific tools or used in the development of anti-proliferative medicines.

Pulchelloid A, a sesquiterpene lactone from the Canadian prairie plant Gaillardia aristata inhibits mitosis in human cells.

BACKGROUND: The Canadian prairie ecosystem presents a rich source of natural products from plants that are subjected to herbivory by grazing mammals. This type of ecological competition may contribute to the production of natural products of interest in cell biology and medical research. We provide the first biological description of the sesquiterpene lactone, pulchelloid A, which we isolated from the prairie plant, Gaillardia aristata (Asteraceae) and report that it inhibits mitosis in human cells. METHODS AND RESULTS: We found that G. aristata (Blanket flower) extracts were cytotoxic to human cell lines and used phenotypic assays to characterize the bioactivity of extracts. Before dying, cells were characterized by a rounded morphology, phospho-histone H3 signals, mitotic spindles, and active Cdk1. By biology-guided fractionation of Gaillardia extracts, we isolated a sesquiterpene lactone named pulchelloid A. We used immunofluorescence microscopy and observed that cells treated with pulchelloid A have phospho-histone H3 positive chromosomes and a mitotic spindle, confirming that they were in mitosis. Treated cells arrest with an unusual phenotype; they enter a prolonged mitotic arrest in which the spindles become multipolar and the chromosomes acquire histone γH2AX foci, a hallmark of damaged DNA. CONCLUSIONS: We propose that pulchelloid A, a natural product present in the prairie plant Gaillardia aristata, delays cells in mitosis. There is a growing body of evidence that a small number of members of the sesquiterpene lactone chemical family may target proteins that regulate mitosis.

Isolation of a natural product with anti-mitotic activity from a toxic Canadian prairie plant.

We are investigating plants from the prairie ecological zone of Canada to identify natural products that inhibit mitosis in cancer cells. Investigation of plant parts from the Canadian plant species Hymenoxys richardsonii (Asteraceae) revealed that leaf extracts (PP-360A) had anti-mitotic activity on human cancer cell lines. Cells treated with leaf extracts acquired a rounded morphology, similar to that of cells in mitosis. We demonstrated that the rounded cells contained mitotic spindles and phospho-histone H3 using the techniques of immunofluorescence microscopy. By biology-guided fractionation of H. richardsonii leaves, we isolated a sesquiterpene lactone named hymenoratin, which had not been previously assigned a biological activity. Cells treated with hymenoratin have phospho-histone H3 positive chromosomes, a mitotic spindle, and enter a prolonged mitotic arrest in which the spindles become distorted. By Western blot analysis, hymenoratin treated cells acquire high levels of cyclin B and dephosphorylated Cdk1. There is a growing body of evidence that select members of the sesquiterpene lactone chemical family have anti-mitotic activity.

Extracts Prepared from a Canadian Toxic Plant Induce Light-Dependent Perinuclear Vacuoles in Human Cells.

We are investigating plant species from the Canadian prairie ecological zone by phenotypic cell assays to discover toxins of biological interest. We provide the first report of the effects of extracts prepared from the shrub Symphoricarpos occidentalis in several human cell lines. S. occidentalis (Caprifoliaceae) extracts are cytotoxic, and, strikingly, treated cells undergo light-dependent vacuolation near the nucleus. The range of irradiation is present in standard ambient light and lies in the visible range (400-700 nm). Vacuolization in treated cells can be induced with specific wavelengths of 408 or 660 nm at 1 J/cm2 energies. Vacuolated cells show a striking phenotype of a large perinuclear vacuole (nuclear associated vacuole, NAV) that is distinct from vesicles observed by treatment with an autophagy-inducing agent. Treatment with S. occidentalis extracts and light induces an intense lamin A/C signal at the junction of a nuclear vacuole and the nucleus. Further study of S. occidentalis extracts and vacuolation provide chemical tools that may contribute to the understanding of nuclear envelope organization and human cell biology.

Experimental Determination of Checkpoint Adaptation by Mitotic Shake-Off and Microscopy.

Cells that undergo checkpoint adaptation arrest at and then abrogate the G2/M cell cycle checkpoint to enter mitosis with damaged DNA. Cells surviving this process frequently contain micronuclei, which can lead to genomic change and chromothripsis. In this chapter we describe how to induce checkpoint adaptation and detect it by time-lapse video and immunofluorescence microscopy and how to isolate cells undergoing checkpoint adaptation from a total cell population.

G2/M-Phase Checkpoint Adaptation and Micronuclei Formation as Mechanisms That Contribute to Genomic Instability in Human Cells.

One of the most common characteristics of cancer cells is genomic instability. Recent research has revealed that G2/M-phase checkpoint adaptation-entering mitosis with damaged DNA-contributes to genomic changes in experimental models. When cancer cells are treated with pharmacological concentrations of genotoxic agents, they undergo checkpoint adaptation; however, a small number of cells are able to survive and accumulate micronuclei. These micronuclei harbour damaged DNA, and are able to replicate and reincorporate their DNA into the main nucleus. Micronuclei are susceptible to chromothripsis, which is a phenomenon characterised by extensively rearranged chromosomes that reassemble from pulverized chromosomes in one cellular event. These processes contribute to genomic instability in cancer cells that survive a genotoxic anti-cancer treatment. This review provides insight into checkpoint adaptation and its connection to micronuclei and possibly chromothripsis. Knowledge about these mechanisms is needed to improve the poor cancer treatment outcomes that result from genomic instability.

Emerging Anti-Mitotic Activities and Other Bioactivities of Sesquiterpene Compounds upon Human Cells.

We review the bio-activities of natural product sesquiterpenes and present the first description of their effects upon mitosis. This type of biological effect upon cells is unexpected because sesquiterpenes are believed to inactivate proteins through Michael-type additions that cause non-specific cytotoxicity. Yet, certain types of sesquiterpenes can arrest cells in mitosis as measured by cell biology, biochemical and imaging techniques. We have listed the sesquiterpenes that arrest cells in mitosis and analyzed the biological data that support those observations. In view of the biochemical complexity of mitosis, we propose that a subset of sesquiterpenes have a unique chemical structure that can target a precise protein(s) required for mitosis. Since the process of mitotic arrest precedes that of cell death, it is possible that some sesquiterpenes that are currently classified as cytotoxic might also induce a mitotic arrest. Our analysis provides a new perspective of sesquiterpene chemical biology.

Cancer cells that survive checkpoint adaptation contain micronuclei that harbor damaged DNA.

We have examined the relationship between checkpoint adaptation (mitosis with damaged DNA) and micronuclei. Micronuclei in cancer cells are linked to genomic change, and may induce chromothripsis (chromosome shattering). We measured the cytotoxicity of the cancer drug cisplatin in M059K (glioma fibroblasts, IC50 15 µM). Nearly 100% of M059K cells were positive for histone γH2AX staining after 48 h treatment with a cytotoxic concentration of cisplatin. The proportion of micronucleated cells, as confirmed by microscopy using DAPI and lamin A/C staining, increased from 24% to 48%, and the total micronuclei in surviving cells accumulated over time. Promoting entry into mitosis with a checkpoint inhibitor increased the number of micronuclei in cells whereas blocking checkpoint adaptation with a Cdk inhibitor reduced the number of micronuclei. Interestingly, some micronuclei underwent asynchronous DNA replication, relative to the main nuclei, as measured by deoxy-bromo-uracil (BrdU) staining. These micronuclei stained positive for histone γH2AX, which was linked to DNA replication, suggesting that micronuclei arise from checkpoint adaptation and that micronuclei may continue to damage DNA. By contrast the normal cell line WI-38 did not undergo checkpoint adaptation when treated with cisplatin and did not show changes in micronuclei number. These data reveal that the production of micronuclei by checkpoint adaptation is part of a process that contributes to genomic change.

Cytotoxic amounts of cisplatin induce either checkpoint adaptation or apoptosis in a concentration-dependent manner in cancer cells.

BACKGROUND INFORMATION: Checkpoint adaptation (entry into mitosis with damaged DNA) is a process that links arrest at the G2/M cell cycle checkpoint and cell death in cancer cells. It is not known, however, whether cells treated with the genotoxic agent, cisplatin, undergo checkpoint adaptation or if checkpoint adaptation is a major pathway leading to cell death or not. Therefore, we investigated the relationship between treatment with cisplatin and cytotoxicity in cancer cells. RESULTS: Treatment of HT-29 human colorectal adenocarcinoma cells with cisplatin can induce cell death by one of two different mechanisms. Cells treated with a cytotoxic 30 µM amount of cisplatin died after undergoing checkpoint adaptation. Before dying, however, almost all treated cells were positive for histone γH2AX staining and contained high levels of cyclin B1. Rounded cells appeared that were positive for phospho-Ser10 histone H3, with low levels of phospho-Tyr15 cyclin-dependent kinase 1, high levels of cyclin-dependent kinase 1 activity, and checkpoint kinase 1 that was not phosphorylated on Ser345. These cells were in mitosis with damaged DNA. Strikingly, with 30 µM cisplatin, 81% of cells had entered mitosis before dying. By contrast, after treatment with 100 µM cisplatin, nearly all cells died but only 7% of cells had entered mitosis. Instead, these cells died by apoptosis; they were positive for annexin-V staining, contained cleaved caspase 3, cleaved caspase 9 and cleaved PARP and did not contain Mcl-1. CONCLUSIONS: Our data demonstrate that cancer cells treated with cisplatin can undergo one of two modes of cell death depending upon concentration used. These findings suggest that checkpoint adaptation is likely a primary pathway in genotoxic cell death at pharmacological concentrations of cisplatin. SIGNIFICANCE: Checkpoint adaptation might be a common biochemical pathway taken by human cancer cells in response to pharmacologically relevant, cytotoxic amounts of damaged DNA.

Measurement of Cdk1/Cyclin B Kinase Activity by Specific Antibodies and Western Blotting.

Quantitative measurement of enzyme activity is a valuable approach to study how cells function. We present a method to measure the activity of the enzyme Cdk1/cyclin B. This enzyme is required by all eukaryotic cells to enter mitosis. Therefore, a biochemical assay to measure Cdk1/cyclin B activity can be used to identify cell populations that are in mitosis or to detect inhibitors of Cdk1/Cyclin B in vitro. A key distinction of the method presented here, compared to others, is that it uses a recombinant protein, a specific antibody, and a western blot apparatus, which makes the technique available to cell and molecular biology laboratories who do not wish to use radioisotopes, which are commonly required for other protein kinase assays.

Natural product extracts of the Canadian prairie plant, Thermopsis rhombifolia, have anti-cancer activity in phenotypic cell-based assays.

Many plant species within the terrestrial ecological zones of Canada have not yet been investigated for anti-cancer activity. We examined the scientific literature describing the endemic flora from the prairie ecological zone and selected the species, Thermopsis rhombifolia, locally known as the buffalo bean, for investigation of its anti-cancer potential. We tested it in cell-based assays using phenotypic screens that feature some of the hallmarks of cancer. An ethanolic extract prepared from T. rhombifolia was cytotoxic to HT-29 (colon) and SH-SY5Y (brain) cancer cell lines, and showed little cytotoxicity to a normal human cell line (WI-38). In phenotypic assays, we identified activities in the extracts that target cell death, cell cycle and cell adhesion. These data highlight the anti-cancer potential of previously untested plants found in northern ecological zones and the feasibility of using pertinent phenotypic assays to examine the anti-cancer potential of natural product extracts.

Genotoxic anti-cancer agents and their relationship to DNA damage, mitosis, and checkpoint adaptation in proliferating cancer cells.

When a human cell detects damaged DNA, it initiates the DNA damage response (DDR) that permits it to repair the damage and avoid transmitting it to daughter cells. Despite this response, changes to the genome occur and some cells, such as proliferating cancer cells, are prone to genome instability. The cellular processes that lead to genomic changes after a genotoxic event are not well understood. Our research focuses on the relationship between genotoxic cancer drugs and checkpoint adaptation, which is the process of mitosis with damaged DNA. We examine the types of DNA damage induced by widely used cancer drugs and describe their effects upon proliferating cancer cells. There is evidence that cell death caused by genotoxic cancer drugs in some cases includes exiting a DNA damage cell cycle arrest and entry into mitosis. Furthermore, some cells are able to survive this process at a time when the genome is most susceptible to change or rearrangement. Checkpoint adaptation is poorly characterised in human cells; we predict that increasing our understanding of this pathway may help to understand genomic instability in cancer cells and provide insight into methods to improve the efficacy of current cancer therapies.

A western blot assay to measure cyclin dependent kinase activity in cells or in vitro without the use of radioisotopes.

We developed a quantitative method to measure the activity of cyclin-dependent kinases (Cdks) by western blotting, without radioisotopes. We prepared a recombinant protein substrate based upon the natural Cdk1 substrate, PP1Cα. By combining this substrate in a western blot method using fluorochrome based antibodies and phospho-imager analysis, we measured the Km of ATP binding to Cdk1 to be 3.5 µM. We then measured Cdk1 activity in cell extracts from interphase or mitotic cells, and demonstrated that previously identified Cdk inhibitors could be detected by this assay. Our data show that we have a safe, reliable assay to identify Cdk1 inhibitors and measure Cdk1 activity.

Human cells enter mitosis with damaged DNA after treatment with pharmacological concentrations of genotoxic agents.

In the present paper, we report that mitosis is a key step in the cellular response to genotoxic agents in human cells. Cells with damaged DNA recruit γH2AX (phosphorylated histone H2AX), phosphorylate Chk1 (checkpoint kinase 1) and arrest in the G2-phase of the cell cycle. Strikingly, nearly all cells escape the DNA damage checkpoint and become rounded, by a mechanism that correlates with Chk1 dephosphorylation. The rounded cells are alive and in mitosis as measured by low phospho-Tyr(15) Cdk1 (cyclin-dependent kinase 1), high Cdk activity, active Plk1 (Polo-like kinase 1) and high phospho-histone H3 signals. This phenomenon is independent of the type of DNA damage, but is dependent on pharmacologically relevant doses of genotoxicity. Entry into mitosis is likely to be caused by checkpoint adaptation, and the HT-29 cell-based model provides a powerful experimental system in which to explore its molecular basis. We propose that mitosis with damaged DNA is a biologically significant event because it may cause genomic rearrangement in cells that survive genotoxic damage.

Synthesis of Cis-fused pyran indolocarbazole derivatives that inhibit FLT3 kinase and the DNA damage kinase, checkpoint kinase 1.

Protein kinases are important enzymes in solid tumour and leukaemia pathologies. Their structures are well understood at the atomic level and their key role in the progression of certain cancers makes them valuable targets for anti-cancer therapy. Through medicinal chemical approaches, we developed an efficient preparative stereospecific synthesis of N12, N13 pyran-bridged indolocarbazoles that opens access to functional diversity within this previously challenging series. We focused upon the indolocarbazole class of chemical inhibitors, which includes S27888, an inhibitor we previously identified. We used biochemical and cell-based assays to identify small molecule inhibitors of Checkpoint kinase 1 (Chk1), a serine/threonine protein kinase that is activated when cancer cells are treated with genotoxic agents. These compounds show a promising inhibitory profile on Chk1. Furthermore, these compounds are active against FLT3, which is a tyrosine kinase that is frequently activated in human leukaemias. These data suggest that this chemical class may provide a source of therapeutic compounds for a broad range of human cancers.

Characterization of novel checkpoint kinase 1 inhibitors by in vitro assays and in human cancer cells treated with topoisomerase inhibitors.

AIMS: We have developed biochemical and cell based assays to characterize small therapeutic molecules that inhibit the DNA damage checkpoint enzyme, Chk1 (Checkpoint kinase 1). MAIN METHODS: To prepare a screen of large chemical libraries, we purified the full-length and the catalytic domain versions of human Chk1. We characterized their properties and then selected full-length Chk1 as the variant most suitable for screening. We then identified and characterized structurally different Chk1 inhibitors in cell based-assays by measuring cytotoxicity and checkpoint bypass activity. KEY FINDINGS: We treated human cells with topoisomerase I inhibitors and demonstrated that at the time of Chk1 inhibitor addition, the cells have damaged DNA and activated Chk1. One Chk1 inhibitor, the indolocarbazole S27888, was active in the checkpoint bypass assay. SIGNIFICANCE: Knowing that the protein kinase inhibitory properties are different for each inhibitor, it seems that only a limited range of inhibitory activity is tolerated by cells. Chk1 has an essential role in determining how cancer cells respond to genotoxic treatments, therefore, inhibitors of this protein kinase are of great medical interest.

An unusual DNA binding compound, S23906, induces mitotic catastrophe in cultured human cells.

The biochemical pathways that lead cells to mitotic catastrophe are not well understood. To identify these pathways, we have taken an approach of treating cells with a novel genotoxic compound and characterizing whether cells enter mitotic catastrophe or not. S23906 is a novel acronycine derivative that forms adducts with the N2 residue of guanine in the minor groove of the DNA helix and destabilizes base pairing to cause helix opening. We observed, in HeLa and HT-29 cells, that S23906 induced gamma-H2AX and activated checkpoint kinase 1, as did bleomycin, camptothecin, and cisplatin, when tested under equi-toxic conditions. S23906 also induced cyclin E1 protein, although this activity was not required for cytotoxicity because knock down of cyclin E1 by RNA interference did not affect the number of dead cells after treatment. Cyclin B1 levels first decreased and then increased after treatment with S23906. Cyclin B1 was associated with Cdk1 kinase activity, which correlated with an increase in the number of mitotic cells. By 32 h after treatment, at least 20% of the cells entered mitotic catastrophe as determined by microscopy. Suppression of the DNA checkpoint response by co-treatment with caffeine increased the number of cells in mitosis. These results suggest that mitotic catastrophe is one of the cellular responses to S23906 and that mitotic catastrophe may be a common cellular response to many different types of DNA damage.

Radiosensitization by Chir-124, a selective CHK1 inhibitor: effects of p53 and cell cycle checkpoints.

Checkpoint kinase-1 (CHK1) is a key regulator of the DNA damage-elicited G(2)-M checkpoints. The aim of the present study was to investigate the effects of a selective CHK1 inhibitor, Chir124, on cell survival and cell cycle progression following ionizing radiation (IR). Treatment with Chir-124 resulted in reduced clonogenic survival and abrogated the IR-induced G(2)-M arrest in a panel of isogenic HCT116 cell lines after IR. This radiosensitizing effect was relatively similar between p53(-/-) and p53-sufficient wild type (WT) HCT116 cells. However, the number of mitotic cells (as measured by assessing the phosphorylation of mitotic proteins) increased dramatically in p53(-/-) HCT116 cells after concomitant Chir-124 exposure, compared to IR alone, while no such effect was observed in p53-sufficient WT HCT116 cells. In p53(-/-) cells, Chir-124 treatment induced a marked accumulation of polyploid cells that were characterized by micronucleation or multinucleation. p21(-/-) HCT116 cells displayed a similar pattern of response as p53(-/-) cells. Chir-124 was able to radiosensitize HCT116 cells that lack checkpoint kinase-2 (CHK2) or that were deficient for the spindle checkpoint protein Mad2. Finally, Chir-124 could radiosensitize tetraploid cell lines, which were relatively resistant against DNA damaging agents. Altogether these results suggest that Chir-124-mediated radiosensitization is profoundly influenced by the p53 and cell cycle checkpoint system.

Synthesis and CHK1 inhibitory potency of Hymenialdisine analogues.

A series of thieno[3,2-b]pyrroloazepinones derivatives related to Hymenialdisine were prepared and tested for CHK1 inhibitory activity. Nanomolar inhibitions were achieved when electron-withdrawing substituents were introduced at position 3 of the thiophene ring.

A three-step synthesis from rebeccamycin of an efficient checkpoint kinase 1 inhibitor.

Rebeccamycin derivative 1 bearing a sugar moiety linked to both indole nitrogens and an amino substituent on the carbohydrate unit was synthesized in three steps from the bacterial metabolite. This compound was found to be a highly potent checkpoint kinase 1 inhibitor with an IC(50) value of 2.8nM.