Complete characterization of the edited transcriptome of the mitochondrion of Physarum polycephalum using deep sequencing of RNA.

RNAs transcribed from the mitochondrial genome of Physarum polycephalum are heavily edited. The most prevalent editing event is the insertion of single Cs, with Us and dinucleotides also added at specific sites. The existence of insertional editing makes gene identification difficult and localization of editing sites has relied upon characterization of individual cDNAs. We have now determined the complete mitochondrial transcriptome of Physarum using Illumina deep sequencing of purified mitochondrial RNA. We report the first instances of A and G insertions and sites of partial and extragenic editing in Physarum mitochondrial RNAs, as well as an additional 772 C, U and dinucleotide insertions. The notable lack of antisense RNAs in our non-size selected, directional library argues strongly against an RNA-guided editing mechanism. Also of interest are our findings that sites of C to U changes are unedited at a significantly higher frequency than insertional editing sites and that substitutional editing of neighboring sites appears to be coupled. Finally, in addition to the characterization of RNAs from 17 predicted genes, our data identified nine new mitochondrial genes, four of which encode proteins that do not resemble other proteins in the database. Curiously, one of the latter mRNAs contains no editing sites.

Non-templated addition of nucleotides to the 3' end of nascent RNA during RNA editing in Physarum.

RNAs in Physarum: mitochondria contain extra nucleotides that are not encoded by the mitochondrial genome, at least in the traditional sense. While it is known that insertion of non-encoded nucleotides is linked to RNA synthesis, the exact nature of this relationship remains unclear. Here we demonstrate that the efficiency of editing is sensitive not only to the concentration of the nucleotide that is inserted, but also to the concentration of the nucleotide templated just downstream of an editing site. These data strongly support a co-transcriptional mechanism of Physarum: RNA editing in which non-encoded nucleotides are added to the 3' end of nascent RNAs. These results also suggest that transcription elongation and nucleotide insertion are competing processes and that recognition of editing sites most likely involves transient pausing by the Physarum: mitochondrial RNA polymerase. In addition, the pattern of nucleotide concentration effects, the context of editing sites and the accuracy of the mitochondrial RNA polymerase argue that the mechanism of Physarum: editing is distinct from that of other co-transcriptional editing systems.

Functions and mechanisms of RNA editing.

RNA editing can be broadly defined as any site-specific alteration in an RNA sequence that could have been copied from the template, excluding changes due to processes such as RNA splicing and polyadenylation. Changes in gene expression attributed to editing have been described in organisms from unicellular protozoa to man, and can affect the mRNAs, tRNAs, and rRNAs present in all cellular compartments. These sequence revisions, which include both the insertion and deletion of nucleotides, and the conversion of one base to another, involve a wide range of largely unrelated mechanisms. Recent advances in the development of in vitro editing and transgenic systems for these varied modifications have provided a better understanding of similarities and differences between the biochemical strategies, regulatory sequences, and cellular factors responsible for such RNA processing events.

Transcription and RNA editing in a soluble in vitro system from Physarum mitochondria.

The dissection of RNA editing mechanisms in PHYSARUM: mitochondria has been hindered by the absence of a soluble in vitro system. Based on our studies in isolated mitochondria, insertion of non-encoded nucleotides into PHYSARUM: mitochondrial RNAs is closely linked to transcription. Here we have fractionated mitochondrial lysates, enriching for run-on RNA synthesis, and find that editing activity co-fractionates with pre-formed transcription elongation complexes. The establishment of this soluble transcription-editing system allows access to the components of the editing machinery and permits manipulation of transcription and editing substrates. Thus, the availability of this system provides, for the first time, a means of investigating roles for cis-acting elements, trans-acting factors and nucleotide requirements for the insertion of non-encoded nucleotides into PHYSARUM: mitochondrial RNAs. This methodology should also be broadly applicable to the study of RNA processing and editing mechanisms in a wide range of mitochondrial systems.

Insertional editing in isolated Physarum mitochondria is linked to RNA synthesis.

The mitochondrial RNAs of Physarum polycephalum are edited efficiently by nucleotide insertion both in vivo and in isolated mitochondria. Our recent studies have demonstrated that nucleotide addition can occur within 14-22 nt of the 3' end of a nascent RNA, suggesting that insertional editing may be linked to transcription. To investigate the relationship between these processes, we have examined the effects of nucleotide concentration on templated and nontemplated nucleotide addition in isolated mitochondria. At very low CTP concentrations, transcription and editing proceed with high fidelity, but the efficiency of cytidine insertional editing decreases. Insertion of single uridine and dinucleotides is not diminished under conditions that yield unedited or partially edited C insertion sites, indicating that editing events occur independently of one another. Moreover, analysis of partially edited RNA demonstrates that single nucleotides can be added at dinucleotide insertion sites. Importantly, pulse-chase experiments indicate that nontemplated nucleotides are not inserted into previously synthesized RNA once editing conditions are restored, although RNA downstream of the unedited region is edited efficiently. This result indicates that insertional editing cannot occur posttranscriptionally under these conditions, and suggests that there is only a small "window of opportunity" in which nucleotide insertion can occur. Our data are consistent with an editing activity that functions in a strictly 5' to 3' direction and adds nucleotides at, or close to, the 3' end of nascent RNA in association with the transcription complex. Several possible models for the mechanism of insertional editing in Physarum are discussed.

Insertional editing of nascent mitochondrial RNAs in Physarum.

Maturation of Physarum mitochondrial RNA involves the highly specific insertion of nonencoded nucleotides at multiple locations. To investigate the mechanism(s) by which this occurs, we previously developed an isolated mitochondrial system in which run-on transcripts are accurately and efficiently edited by nucleotide insertion. Here we show that under limiting concentrations of exogenous nucleotides the mitochondrial RNA polymerases stall, generating a population of nascent RNAs that can be extended upon addition of limiting nucleotide. Several of these RNA species have been characterized and were found to be fully edited, indicating that nascent RNA is a substrate for nucleotide insertion in isolated Physarum mitochondria. Remarkably, these RNAs are edited at positions located within 14-22 nucleotides of the polymerase active site, suggesting that insertional editing may be physically or functionally associated with transcription. The absence of unedited RNA in these experiments indicates that large tracts of RNA downstream of editing sites are not required for nucleotide addition, and argues that insertional editing in Physarum occurs with a 5' to 3' polarity. These data also provide strong evidence that insertional editing in Physarum is mechanistically distinct from editing in kinetoplastid systems.

Accurate and efficient insertional RNA editing in isolated Physarum mitochondria.

RNA editing is a process whereby nucleotide insertion, deletion, or base substitution results in the production of an RNA whose sequence differs from that of its template. The mitochondrial RNAs of Physarum polycephalum are processed specifically at multiple sites by both mono- and dinucleotide insertions, as well as apparent cytidine (C) to uridine (U) changes. The precise mechanism and timing of these processing events are currently unknown. We describe here the development of an isolated mitochondrial system in which exogenously supplied nucleotides can be incorporated into RNAs under defined conditions. The results of S1 nuclease protection, nearest neighbor and RNase T1 fingerprint analyses indicate that the vast majority of these newly synthesized mitochondrial RNAs have been accurately and efficiently processed by both mono- and dinucleotide insertions. This work provides a direct demonstration of faithful nucleotide insertion in a mitochondrial editing system. In contrast, the newly synthesized RNAs are not processed by C to U changes in the isolated mitochondria, suggesting that the base changes observed in Physarum are unlikely to occur via a deletion/insertion mechanism.

Proton NMR and structural features of a 24-nucleotide RNA hairpin.

The three-dimensional conformation of a 24-nucleotide variant of the RNA binding sequence for the coat protein of bacteriophage R17 has been analyzed using NMR, molecular dynamics, and energy minimization. The imino proton spectrum is consistent with base pairing requirements for coat protein binding known from biochemical studies. All 185 of the nonexchangeable protons were assigned using a variety of homonuclear 2D and 3D NMR methods. Measurements of nuclear Overhauser enhancements and two-quantum correlations were made at 500 MHz. New procedures were developed to characterize as many resonances as possible, including deconvolution and path analysis methods. An average of 21 distance constraints per residue were used in molecular dynamics calculations to obtain preliminary folded structures for residues 3-21. The unpaired A8 residue is stacked in the stem, and the entire region from G7 to C15 in the upper stem and loop appears to be flexible. Several of these residues have a large fraction of S-puckered ribose rings, rather than the N-forms characteristic of RNA duplexes. There is considerable variation in the low-energy loop conformations that satisfy the distance constraints at this preliminary level of refinement. The Shine-Dalgarno ribosome binding site is exposed, and only two apparently weak base pairs would have to break for the 16S ribosomal RNA to bind and the ribosome to initiate translation of the replicase gene. Although the loop form must be regarded as tentative, the known interaction sites with the coat protein are easily accessible from the major groove side of the loop.

RNA editing of the coI mRNA throughout the life cycle of Physarum polycephalum.

Editing of RNA via the insertion, deletion or substitution of genetic information affects gene expression in a variety of systems. Previous characterization of the Physarum polycephalum cytochrome c oxidase subunit I (coI) mRNA revealed that both nucleotide insertions and base substitutions occur during the maturation of this mitochondrial message. Both types of editing are known to be developmentally regulated in other systems, including mammals and trypanosomatids. Here we show that the coI mRNA present in Physarum mitochondria is edited via specific nucleotide insertions and C to U conversions at every stage of the life cycle. Primer extension sequencing of the RNA indicates that this editing is both accurate and efficient. Using a sensitive RT-PCR assay to monitor the extent of editing at individual sites of C insertion, we estimate that greater than 98% of the steady-state amount of coI mRNA is edited throughout the Physarum developmental cycle.

Substitutional and insertional RNA editing of the cytochrome c oxidase subunit 1 mRNA of Physarum polycephalum.

The term RNA editing encompasses two types of specific alterations in the coding potential of RNA molecules: base substitution and the insertion (or deletion) of nucleotides. Such changes in RNA sequence can have profound effects on gene expression, and, indeed, most genes in the mitochondria of plants, trypanosomatids, and Physarum appear to require editing for their expression. We describe here the first instance of the utilization of both types of RNA editing in the processing of a single mRNA, that of the mitochondrially encoded cytochrome oxidase subunit I of the acellular slime mold, Physarum polycephalum. Editing of this mRNA includes the insertion of cytidine, guanosine, and uridine residues, as well as the apparent conversion of cytidines to uridines. No edited version of this gene was detected in Physarum DNA, and amino acid alignments suggest that both types of RNA editing are required to produce a functional protein.

Using circular permutation analysis to redefine the R17 coat protein binding site.

The bacteriophage R17 coat protein binding site consists of an RNA hairpin with a single purine nucleotide bulge in the helical stem. Circular permutation analysis (CPA) was used to examine binding effects caused by a single break in the phosphodiester backbone. This method revealed that breakage of all but one phosphodiester bond within a well-defined binding site substantially reduced the binding affinity. This is probably due to destabilization of the hairpin structure upon breaking the ribose phosphates at these positions. One circularly permuted isomer with the 5' and 3' ends at the bulged nucleotide bound with wild-type affinity. However, extending the 5' end of this CP isomer greatly reduces binding, making it unlikely that this circularly permuted binding site will be active when embedded in a larger RNA. CPA also locates the 5' and 3' boundaries of protein binding sites on the RNA. The 5' boundary of the R17 coat protein site as defined by CPA was two nucleotides shorter (nucleotides -15 to +2) than the previously determined site (-17 to +2). The smaller binding site was verified by terminal truncation experiments. A minimal-binding fragment (-14 to +2) was synthesized and was found to bind tightly to the coat protein. The site size determined by 3-ethyl-1-nitrosourea-modification interference was larger at the 5' end (-16 to +1), probably due, however, to steric effects of ethylation of phosphate oxygens. Thus, the apparent site size of a protein binding site is dependent upon the method used.

RNA binding properties of the coat protein from bacteriophage GA.

The coat protein of bacteriophage GA, a group II RNA phage, binds to a small RNA hairpin corresponding to its replicase operator. Binding is specific, with a Ka of 71 microM -1. This interaction differs kinetically from the analogous coat protein-RNA hairpin interactions of other RNA phage and also deviates somewhat in its pH and salt dependence. Despite 46 of 129 amino acid differences between the GA and group I phage R17 coat proteins, the binding sites are fairly similar. The essential features of the GA coat protein binding site are a based-paired stem with an unpaired purine and a four nucleotide loop having an A at position -4 and a purine at -7. Unlike the group I phage proteins, the GA coat protein does not distinguish between two alternate positions for the unpaired purine and does not show high specificity for a pyrimidine at position -5 of the loop.

A specific, UV-induced RNA-protein cross-link using 5-bromouridine-substituted RNA.

The well-characterized RNA binding site of the bacteriophage R17 coat protein has been used to investigate the cross-linking of protein to 5-bromouridine (BrU)-substituted RNA using medium-wavelength UV light. We have demonstrated a specific RNA-protein cross-link and identified the site on the RNA of protein attachment. Formation of the covalent complex is dependent upon the presence of BrU at position -5 of the RNA and specific binding of the RNA by coat protein. The amount of cross-linking increases with time and depends on the light source and conditions used. Irradiations using a broad-spectrum UV transilluminator (peak at 312 nm) or monochromatic XeCl excimer laser (308 nm) gave levels of cross-linking exceeding 20 and 50%, respectively. The quantum yield of photo-cross-linking, determined with 308-nm excitation, was 0.003. While little strand breakage or debromination of the RNA occurred, significant protein photodamage was observed.

A self-splicing group I intron in the DNA polymerase gene of Bacillus subtilis bacteriophage SPO1.

We report a self-splicing intron in bacteriophage SPO1, whose host is the gram-positive Bacillus subtilis. The intron contains all the conserved features of primary sequence and secondary structure previously described for the group IA introns of eukaryotic organelles and the gram-negative bacteriophage T4. The SPO1 intron contains an open reading frame of 522 nucleotides. As in the T4 introns, this open reading frame begins in a region that is looped out of the secondary structure, but ends in a highly conserved region of the intron core. The exons encode SPO1 DNA polymerase, which is highly similar to E. coli DNA polymerase I. The demonstration of self-splicing introns in viruses of both gram-positive and gram-negative eubacteria lends further evidence for their early origin in evolution.

Genes within genes: independent expression of phage T4 intron open reading frames and the genes in which they reside.

The td, nrdB, and sunY introns of bacteriophage T4 each contain a long open reading frame (ORF). These ORFs are preceded by functional T4 late promoters and, in the case of the nrdB intron ORF, a functional middle promoter. Expression of phage-encoded intron ORF-lacZ fusions indicates that these T4 genes are highly regulated. The lack of translation of these ORFs from early pre-mRNAs can be accounted for by the presence of secondary structures that are absent from the late RNAs. Because translation of the intron ORFs could disrupt core structural elements required for pre-mRNA splicing, such regulation may be necessary to allow expression of the genes in which they reside.

Structural conservation among three homologous introns of bacteriophage T4 and the group I introns of eukaryotes.

Three group I introns of bacteriophage T4 have been compared with respect to their sequence and structural properties. The introns include the td intervening sequence, as well as the two newly described introns in the nrdB and sunY genes of T4. The T4 introns are very closely related, containing phylogenetically conserved sequence elements that allow them to be folded into a core structure that is characteristic of eukaryotic group IA introns. Similarities extend outward to the exon sequences surrounding the three introns. All three introns contain open reading frames (ORFs). Although the intron ORFs are not homologous and occur at different positions, all three ORFs are looped-out of the structure models, with only the 3' ends of each of the ORFs extending into the secondary structure. This arrangement invites interesting speculations on the regulation of splicing by translation. The high degree of similarity between the T4 introns and the eukaryotic group I introns must reflect a common ancestry, resulting either from vertical acquisition of a primordial RNA element or from horizontal transfer.

Multiple self-splicing introns in bacteriophage T4: evidence from autocatalytic GTP labeling of RNA in vitro.

RNA from T4-infected cells yielded multiple end-labeled species when incubated with alpha-32P-GTP under self-splicing conditions. One of these corresponds to the previously identified intron from the td gene of T4, while others appear to represent additional group I introns in T4. Two loci distinct from the td gene were found to hybridize to a mixed alpha-32P-GTP-labeled T4 RNA probe. These mapped in or near the unlinked genes nrdB and nrdC. A fragment from the nrdB region that contains the intron has been cloned and shown to generate characteristic group I splice products with RNA synthesized in vivo and in vitro. Multiple introns, and the prospect that these occur within several genes in the same metabolic pathway, suggest a possible regulatory role for splicing in T4.