The HMG-box: a versatile protein domain occurring in a wide variety of DNA-binding proteins.

The HMG-box domain of approximately 75 amino acid residues was originally identified as the domain that mediates the DNA-binding of chromatin-associated high-mobility group (HMG) proteins of the HMGB type. In the last few years, HMG-box domains have been found in various DNA-binding proteins including transcription factors and subunits of chromatin-remodeling complexes. HMG-box domains mediate either non-sequence-specific (e.g., HMGB-type proteins) or sequence-specific (e.g., transcription factors) DNA binding. Both types of HMG-box domains bind non-B-type DNA structures (bent, kinked and unwound) with high affinity. In addition, HMG-box domains are involved in a variety of protein-protein interactions. Here, we have examined the human and plant genomes for genes encoding HMG-box domains. Compared to plants, human cells contain a larger variety of HMG-box proteins. Whereas in humans transcription factors are the most divergent group of HMG-box proteins, in plants the chromosomal HMGB-type proteins are most variable.

Differential chromatin association and nucleosome binding of the maize HMGA, HMGB, and SSRP1 proteins.

In plants, chromosomal high mobility group (HMG) proteins have been identified in the HMGA family, containing A/T-hook DNA binding motifs, and in the HMGB family, containing an HMG-box DNA binding domain, that are considered architectural factors in chromatin. We have characterized the association of the HMGA protein, five different HMGB proteins, and the structure-specific recognition protein 1 (SSRP1) with maize chromatin by extraction experiments using NaCl, ethidium bromide, spermine, and distamycin A. The difference in the release of the proteins from chromatin by these reagents indicates that they are differentially associated with chromatin. This was confirmed by treatment of chromatin with micrococcal nuclease, demonstrating that the HMGA, HMGB2/3, and SSRP1 proteins are enriched in the highly nuclease-sensitive fraction of chromatin, which is likely to be transcriptionally competent. As examined by electrophoretic mobility shift analyses, the HMGA protein and the proteins containing an HMG domain (HMGB proteins and SSRP1) bind specifically to purified maize mononucleosomes that contain a histone octamer and approximately 165 bp of DNA. The mode of interaction with the nucleosomes differs for HMGA and HMGB proteins. In the case of the HMGB1 protein, the full-length protein is required for specific nucleosome binding, as the individual HMG-box DNA binding domain (which is sufficient for DNA interactions) interacts nonspecifically with the nucleosomes. Collectively, these findings indicate that HMGA, the various HMGB proteins, and SSPR1 are differentially associated with plant chromatin and may act as architectural factors in different nucleoprotein structures.

DNA-interactions and nuclear localisation of the chromosomal HMG domain protein SSRP1 from maize.

The structure-specific recognition protein 1 (SSRP1) is a member of the protein family containing a high mobility group (HMG) domain DNA-binding motif. We have functionally characterised the 71.4 kDa Zm-SSRP1 protein from maize. The chromatin-associated Zm-SSRP1 is detected by immunoblot analysis in maize leaves, kernels and suspension culture cells, but not in roots. Mediated by its HMG domain, recombinant Zm-SSRP1 interacts structure-specifically with supercoiled DNA and DNA minicircles when compared with linear DNA. In linear duplex DNA, the protein does not recognise a specific sequence, but it binds preferentially to sequences containing the deformable dinucleotide TG, as demonstrated by a random oligonucleotide selection experiment. Zm-SSRP1 modulates DNA structure by bending the target sequence, since it promotes the circularisation of short DNA fragments in the presence of DNA ligase. Moreover, Zm-SSRP1 facilitates the formation of nucleoprotein structures, as measured using the bacterial site-specific beta-mediated recombination reaction. Analysis of the subcellular localisation of various SSRP1-GFP fusions revealed that, in contrast to HMG domain transcription factors, the nuclear localisation sequence of Zm-SSRP1 is situated within a 20-amino acid residue region adjacent to the HMG domain rather than within the DNA-binding domain. The results are discussed in the context of the likely function of SSRP1 proteins in transcription and replication.

Occurrence of five different chromosomal HMG1 proteins in various maize tissues.

The nuclear HMG1 proteins of higher plants are small non-histone proteins that have DNA-bending activity and are considered architectural factors in chromatin. The occurrence of the chromosomal HMG1 proteins, HMGa, HMGc1/2 and HMGd, in various maize tissues was analyzed, and in the course of these studies a novel HMG1 protein, now termed HMGe, was identified. Purification and characterization of HMGe (M(r) 13,655) and cloning of the corresponding cDNA revealed that it displays only moderate similarity to other members of the plant HMG1 protein family. The five maize HMG1 proteins could be detected in kernels, leaves, roots and suspension culture cells, indicating that these proteins can be expressed simultaneously and occur relatively ubiquitously. However, the various HMG1 proteins are present in significantly different quantities with HMGa and HMGc1/2 being the most abundant HMG1 proteins in all tissues tested. Furthermore, the relative amounts of the various HMG1 proteins differ among the tissues examined. The HMG1 proteins were found to be relatively stable proteins in vivo, with HMGc1/2, HMGd and HMGe having a half-life of ca. 50 h in cultured cells, while the half-life of the HMGa protein is ca. 65 h. Collectively, these findings are compatible with the concept that the different plant HMG1 proteins might act as general architectural proteins in concert with site-specific factors in the assembly of certain nucleoprotein structures involved in various biological processes.

HMG1 proteins from evolutionary distant organisms distort B-DNA conformation in similar way.

The abundant high-mobility group proteins 1/2 (HMG1/2) represent a group of potent architectural elements of chromatin. They are able to induce strong bends and untwist DNA. Here, we compared the abilities of diverse HMG1 proteins to distort the B-DNA conformation of 30-base pair DNA fragment. The DNA bending was measured in solution by monitoring fluorescence resonance energy transfer between fluorescence probes attached to opposite ends of the DNA fragment. Various insect and plant proteins which differ in size, in composition of their HMG1-box domains (HMG1-BD), and in composition of the N- and the C-terminally flanking regions were analyzed in these experiments. Despite these structural differences the extent of the induced changes in DNA conformation upon binding to various proteins was similar, as the estimated bend angle was 150+/-20 degrees for all the tested proteins. Our results suggest that a set of highly conserved residues stabilizing the tertiary structure of the HMG1-BD mainly determines the extent of DNA bending in the complex. Even extended positively charged regions flanking the HMG1-BD are apparently not able to influence this conformational distortion of DNA.

Structure of genes encoding chromosomal HMG1 proteins from maize.

The high mobility group (HMG) proteins of the HMG1 family are architectural proteins in chromatin that are considered to facilitate the formation of complex nucleoprotein structures in various biological processes such as transcription and recombination. Plants express a variety of these non-sequence-specific DNA-bending proteins. The sequences encoding the maize HMGa and HMGc1 proteins were isolated from a genomic DNA library. Determination of the nucleotide sequences of these genes revealed that the coding region of both genes has a similar genomic structure, comprising seven exons and six introns. The positioning of the introns is conserved between the two genes, whereas the number of introns and their positions are entirely different in the related animal genes. In the 5' flanking region of the hmgc1 gene, a copia-like retrotransposon was identified. In addition to the genes encoding HMGa and HMGc1, several genomic fragments (retropseudo gene, fragments of the genes) were isolated and characterised.

Plant chromosomal HMGI/Y proteins and histone H1 exhibit a protein domain of common origin.

The chromosomal high-mobility-group (HMG) proteins of the HMGI/Y family interact with A/T-rich stretches in duplex DNA, and are considered assistant factors in transcriptional regulation. A cDNA encoding an HMGI/Y protein of 190 amino acid residues was isolated from maize and characterized. Like other plant HMGI/Y proteins, the maize HMGI/Y protein contains four copies of the AT-hook DNA-binding motif and an amino-terminal 'histone H1-like region' with a similarity to the globular domain of H1. The maize hmgi/y gene that was isolated from a genomic DNA library contains a single intron that is localized in the region of sequence similarity to histone H1. Interestingly, the genes encoding plant H1 contain an intron at exactly the same relative position, indicating an evolutionary relationship of the plant genes encoding HMGI/Y and H1 proteins.

DNA-binding properties of the tandem HMG boxes of high-mobility-group protein 1 (HMG1).

High-mobility-group protein 1 (HMG1) is a conserved chromosomal protein with two homologous DNA-binding HMG-box domains, A and B, linked by a short basic region to an acidic carboxy-terminal tail. NMR spectroscopy on the free didomain (AB) shows that the two HMG boxes do not interact. The didomain has a higher affinity for all DNA substrates tested than single HMG-box domains and has a significantly higher ability to distort DNA by bending and supercoiling. The interaction of the didomain with DNA is stabilized by the presence of the basic region (approximately 20 residues, 9 of which are Lys) that links the second HMG box to the acidic tail in intact HMG1; this may be, at least in part, why this region also enhances supercoiling of relaxed circular DNA by the didomain and circularization of short DNA fragments (in the presence of ligase). Competition assays suggest significantly different structure-specific preferences of single and tandem HMG boxes for four-way junction and supercoiled plasmid DNA. Binding to supercoiled DNA appears to be promoted by protein oligomerization, which is pronounced for the didomains. Electron microscopy suggests that the oligomers are globular aggregates, associated with DNA looping. One box versus two (or several) is likely to be an important determinant of the properties of (non-sequence specific) HMG-box proteins.

Four differently chromatin-associated maize HMG domain proteins modulate DNA structure and act as architectural elements in nucleoprotein complexes.

In contrast to other eukaryotes which usually express two closely related HMG1-like proteins, plant cells have multiple relatively variable proteins of this type. A systematic analysis of the DNA-binding properties of four chromosomal HMG domain proteins from maize revealed that they bind linear DNA with similar affinity. HMGa, HMGc1/2 and HMGd specifically recognise diverse DNA structures such as DNA mini-circles and supercoiled DNA. They induce DNA-bending, and constrain negative superhelical turns in DNA. In the presence of DNA, the HMG domain proteins can self-associate, whereas they are monomeric in solution. The maize HMG1-like proteins have the ability to facilitate the formation of nucleoprotein structures to different extents, since they can efficiently replace a bacterial chromatin-associated protein required for the site-specific beta-mediated recombination. A variable function of the HMG1-like proteins is indicated by their differential association with maize chromatin, as judged by their 'extractability' from chromatin with spermine and ethidium bromide. Collectively, these findings suggest that the various plant chromosomal HMG domain proteins could be adapted to act in different nucleoprotein structures in vivo.

Nanogram scale separations of proteins using capillary high-performance liquid chromatography with fully-automated on-line microfraction collection followed by matrix-assisted laser desorption ionisation time-of-flight mass spectrometry, protein sequencing and western blot analysis.

Capillary HPLC was applied for highly sensitive protein separations on a nanogram scale. A crude extract of acid soluble proteins from maize kernels was used as a model extract and separated on a 300-micron I.D. reversed-phase capillary column. Protein fractions of 1-4 microliters volume were fully automatically collected with a new robot microfraction collection system. Fraction collection was performed onto matrix assisted laser desorption ionisation time-of-flight targets for mass spectrometric analysis, onto sequencing membranes for automated Edman degradation and onto nitrocellulose membranes for Western blot analysis.

Basic and acidic regions flanking the HMG domain of maize HMGa modulate the interactions with DNA and the self-association of the protein.

The maize HMGa protein is a typical member of the family of plant chromosomal HMG1-like proteins. The HMG domain of HMGa is flanked by a basic N-terminal domain characteristic for plant HMG1-like proteins, and is linked to the acidic C-terminal domain by a short basic region. Various derivatives of the HMGa protein were expressed in Escherichia coli and purified. The individual HMG domain can functionally complement the defect of the HU-like chromatin-associated Hbsu protein in Bacillus subtilis. The basic N-terminal domain which contacts DNA enhances the affinity of the protein for linear DNA, whereas it has little effect on the structure-specific binding to DNA minicircles. The acidic C-terminal domain reduces the affinity of HMGa for linear DNA, but does not affect to the same extent the recognition of DNA structure which is an intrinsic property of the HMG domain. The efficiency of the HMGa constructs to facilitate circularization of short DNA fragments in the presence of DNA ligase is like the binding to linear DNA altered by the basic and acidic domains flanking the HMG domain, while the supercoiling activity of HMGa is only slightly influenced by the same regions. Both the basic N-terminal and the acidic C-terminal domains contribute directly to the self-association of HMGa in the presence of DNA. Collectively, these findings suggest that the intrinsic properties of the HMG domain can be modulated within the HMGa protein by the basic and acidic domains.

A rapid and sensitive procedure for the micro-purification and subsequent characterization of peptides and protein samples by N-terminal sequencing and matrix assisted laser desorption ionization time of flight mass spectrometry.

The characterization of the proteome, a key activity in the post-genome era, is made extremely challenging by the microheterogeneity introduced by post translational modifications such as glycosylation in the diverse set of proteins expressed in a cellular system. High resolution separation systems, such as 2D-gel electrophoresis and more recently liquid chromatography (LC) have been used to fractionate these complex mixtures, however, subsequent mass analysis is hindered by the low level of the purified components. Off-line coupling of matrix assisted laser desorption ionization time of flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF/MS) is an attractive technique for the analysis of such samples, but suffers from sensitivity to the degree of salt contamination that is unavoidable in the isolation of low level protein samples from biological extracts. In this publication we will report on a novel application of a commercially available system for the micro-purification of peptides and proteins. In this procedure micro-columns (normally used for sequencing of electroblotted samples) were used to rapidly purify protein digests or crude extracts of proteins in sufficient amounts for further analyses by protein sequencing and MALDI-TOF/MS. To demonstrate the applicability of these techniques we isolated and performed structural analysis of the following samples: a high-mannose glycopeptide isolated from a digest of the glycoprotein rt-PA, a poly-His tagged recombinant DNA-binding protein isolated by Ni2+-chelating agarose and a polyclonal antibody sample.

The recombinant product of the Chryptomonas phi plastid gene hlpA is an architectural HU-like protein that promotes the assembly of complex nucleoprotein structures.

The HlpA protein which is encoded by the hlpA gene in the plastid genome of the cryptomonad alga Chryptomonas phi is structurally related to the non-sequence-specific DNA-binding and DNA-bending HU family of chromatin-associated proteins. The expression of the HlpA protein complements the mutant phenotype of Bacillus subtilis cells impaired in the Hbsu protein (B. subtilis HU), as measured by the resistance of the cells to methylmethane sulphonate. To analyse the interactions of HlpA with DNA, we expressed the protein in Escherichia coli and purified it to homogeneity. HlpA interacts preferentially with four-way junction DNA or DNA minicircles, when compared with linear DNA, recognising DNA structure. HlpA and E. coli HU display comparable affinities for all types of DNA tested; however, HlpA exhibits a stronger tendency to self-associate in the presence of DNA. Accordingly, HlpA oligomerises more readily than HU in protein crosslinking experiments. In the presence of topoisomerase I, HlpA constrains negative superhelical turns in closed circular plasmid DNA. The HlpA protein mediates the joining of distant recombination sites into a complex nucleoprotein structure, as judged by beta-mediated site-specific recombination. The results presented provide evidence that HlpA is a functional plastid equivalent of nuclear and mitochondrial HMG1-like proteins and bacterial HU proteins.

Purification and cDNA cloning of maize HMGd reveal a novel plant chromosomal HMG-box protein with sequence similarity to HMGa.

We have purified the chromosomal high mobility group (HMG) protein HMGd from maize suspension culture cells, determined the N-terminal amino acid (aa) sequence, and isolated the corresponding cDNA. Sequence analysis showed that the cDNA encoded a protein of 126 aa residues with a theoretical mass of 14,104 Da. The protein contains an HMG-box DNA-binding domain and a short acidic C-terminal tail. HMGd is in approx. 65% of its residues identical to maize HMGa, whereas it is only approx. 46% identical to maize HMGcl/2. The differences to the previously reported HMG proteins in aa sequence, in overall charge and in protein size indicate that we have identified a third type of plant chromosomal HMG-box protein belonging to the HMG1 protein family. Immunoblot analysis with a HMGd antiserum reveals that HMGd is expressed in all tissues tested.

Variability in Arabidopsis thaliana chromosomal high-mobility-group-1-like proteins.

The vertebrate high-mobility-group (HMG) protein HMG1 is an abundant non-histone protein which is considered as an architectural element in chromatin. In the monocotyledonous plant maize, four different HMG1-like proteins (HMGa, HMGc1/2, HMGd) have been identified, whereas other eukaryotes usually express only two different proteins of this type. We have examined here the HMG1-like proteins of the dicotyledonous plant Arabidopsis thaliana. The isolation and analysis of cDNAs encoding five different so far uncharacterised HMG1-like proteins (now termed HMG alpha, HMG beta1/2, HMG gamma, HMG delta) from Arabidopsis indicates that the expression of multiple HMG1-like proteins is a general feature of (higher) plants. The Arabidopsis HMG1-like proteins contain an HMG domain as a common feature, but outside this conserved DNA-binding motif the amino acid sequences are significantly different indicating that this protein family displays a greater structural variability in plants than in other eukaryotes. The five HMG1-like proteins were expressed in Escherichia coli and purified. They bind with somewhat different affinity to linear double-stranded DNA. The recognition of DNA structure is evident from their preferential interaction with DNA minicircles relative to linear DNA. Reverse-transcribed PCR suggested that the five HMG1-like genes are simultaneously expressed in Arabidopsis leaves and suspension culture cells.

Maize chromosomal HMGc. Two closely related structure-specific DNA-binding proteins specify a second type of plant high mobility group box protein.

The chromosomal high mobility group (HMG) proteins are small and abundant non-histone proteins common to eukaryotes. We have purified the maize HMGc protein from immature kernels and characterized it by mass spectrometry and amino acid sequence analysis. HMGc could be resolved into two similar proteins by reversed phase chromatography. Cloning and characterization of the corresponding cDNAs revealed that they encode two closely related maize HMGc proteins, now termed HMGc1 and HMGc2. Their theoretical masses of 15,316 and 15,007 Da are >300 Da lower than the masses determined for the proteins purified from maize, indicating post-translational modifications of the proteins. Despite sequence similarity to maize HMGa (and previously described homologous proteins of other species) amino acid sequence alignments reveal that HMGc is in several conserved regions distinct from these proteins. Consequently, we have identified a novel type of plant protein containing an HMG box DNA binding domain and belonging to the HMG1 protein family. HMGc1 and HMGc2 were expressed in Escherichia coli, purified to homogeneity, and analyzed for their DNA binding properties. They proved to bind to DNA structure-specifically since they formed complexes with DNA minicircles at concentrations approximately 100-fold lower than the concentrations required to form complexes with linear fragments of identical sequence. Furthermore, HMGc1 and HMGc2 can constrain negative superhelical turns in plasmid DNA.

Structure of the A-domain of HMG1 and its interaction with DNA as studied by heteronuclear three- and four-dimensional NMR spectroscopy.

HMG1 has two homologous, folded DNA-binding domains ("HMG boxes"), A and B, linked by a short basic region to an acidic C-terminal domain. Like the whole protein, which may perform an architectural role in chromatin, the individual boxes bind to DNA without sequence specificity, have a preference for distorted or prebent DNA, and are able to bend DNA and constrain negative superhelical turns. They show qualitatively similar properties with quantitative differences. We have previously determined the structure of the HMG box from the central B-domain (77 residues) by two-dimensional NMR spectroscopy, which showed that it contains a novel fold [Weir et al. (1993) EMBO J. 12, 1311-1319]. We have now determined the structure of the A-domain (as a Cys-->Ser mutant at position 22 to avoid oxidation, without effect on its DNA-binding properties or structure) using heteronuclear three- and four-dimensional NMR spectroscopy. The A-domain has a very similar global fold to the B-domain and the Drosophila protein HMG-D [Jones et al. (1994) Structure 2, 609-627]. There are small differences between A and B, in particular in the orientation of helix I, where the B-domain is more similar to HMG-D than it is to the A-domain; these differences may turn out to be related to the subtle differences in functional properties between the two domains [Teo et al. (1995) Eur. J. Biochem. 230, 943-950] and will be the subject of further investigation. NMR studies of the interaction of the A-domain of HMG1 with a short double-stranded oligonucleotide support the notion that the protein binds via the concave face of the L-shaped structure; extensive contacts with the DNA are made by the N-terminal extended strand, the N-terminus of helix I, and the C-terminus of helix II. These contacts are very similar to those seen in the LEF-1 and SRY-DNA complexes [Love et al. (1995) Nature 376, 791-795; Werner et al. (1995) Cell 81, 705-714].

Two mutations in the HMG-box with very different structural consequences provide insights into the nature of binding to four-way junction DNA.

Mutation of the highly conserved tryptophan residue in the A-domain HMG-box of HMG1 largely, but not completely, destroys the protein tertiary structure and abolishes its supercoiling ability, but does not abolish structure-specific DNA binding to four-way junctions. Circular dichroism shows that the protein has some residual alpha-helix (< 10%) and does not re-fold in the presence of DNA. Structure-specific DNA binding might therefore be a property of some primary structure element, for example the N-terminal extended strand, which even in the unfolded protein would be held in a restricted conformation by two, largely trans, X-Pro peptide bonds. However, mutation of P5 or P8 of the A-domain to alanine does not abolish the formation of the (first) complex in a gel retardation assay, which probably arises from binding to the junction cross-over, although the P8 mutation does affect the formation of higher complexes which may arise from binding to the junction arms. Since mutation of P8 in the W49R mutant has no effect on structure-specific junction binding, we propose that some residual alpha-helix in the protein might be involved, implicating this element in the interactions of HMG-boxes generally with DNA.

Differences in the DNA-binding properties of the HMG-box domains of HMG1 and the sex-determining factor SRY.

High-mobility-group protein 1 (HMG1) is an abundant, non-sequence-specific, chromosomal protein with two homologous, HMG-box, DNA-binding domains, A and B, and an acidic tail. The HMG-box motif also occurs, as a single copy, in some sequence-specific transcription factors, e.g. the sex-determining factor, SRY. We have investigated whether or not there are differences in the DNA-binding properties of the isolated A and B HMG-box domains of HMG1 and SRY and whether, in the case of A and B, there might also be differences due to different sequence contexts within the native protein. The basic regions that flank the HMG1 B box, giving B', enhance its DNA-binding, supercoiling and DNA-bending activities, and promote the self-association of the DNA-bound B-box. All the HMG-box domains bind with structure specificity to four-way junctions, but the structure selectivity is significantly greater for A and the SRY box than for the HMG1 B or B' domains, as judged by competition with excess plasmid DNA. The domains self-associate to different extents on supercoiled DNA and this may explain differences in the ability to discriminate between four-way junctions and supercoiled DNA. The HMG1 A, B and B' domains constrain negative superhelical turns in DNA, but the SRY HMG box does not. Only the full B domain (B') bends DNA in a ligase-mediated circularisation assay; the minimal B box, the A domain and the SRY box do not. Thus, despite a common global fold, the HMG box appears to have been adapted to various functions in different protein contexts.