Are Incoming Pediatric Interns Ready to Obtain the Essential Components of an Informed Consent for Lumbar Puncture?

OBJECTIVE: In 2013, the Association of American Medical Colleges created the "Core Entrustable Professional Activities (EPAs) for Entering Residency" to more clearly define the set of activities that entering residents should be able to perform on day 1 of residency without direct supervision. EPA #11 is obtaining informed consent for tests and/or procedures. This EPA acknowledges that an entrustable learner should be able to document a complete consent among other components. The aim of this study is to explore whether incoming pediatric interns demonstrated the behaviors of an "entrustable learner" in the domain of documenting informed consent for a common pediatric procedure. METHODS: All incoming interns in our program (2007-2017) completed a 6-station Objective Structured Clinical Examination during residency orientation. One of the scenarios involves obtaining parental consent for a lumbar puncture (LP). The researchers determined and agreed what components would be important for a complete and accurately documented consent. A retrospective review of the resident's written informed consents occurred looking for accuracy of documented components. RESULTS: Of the 258 consents reviewed, 8 were complete and accurate. Incoming interns appear to be skilled when completing the basics of the informed consent form such as documenting names, obtaining signatures, and correctly identifying the procedure. However, detailing all the risks of the LP were areas for which they did not demonstrate proficiency. CONCLUSIONS: Documenting informed consent is not adequately demonstrated by our learners prior to the beginning of internship. We would recommend specific training before entrusting pediatric interns to obtain LP consent independently.

Impact of individualized learning plans on United States senior medical students advanced clinical rotations.

The individualized learning plan (ILP) is a tool that promotes self-directed learning. The aim of this pilot study was to look at the perception of the ILPs in United States senior medical school students as a way to improve their learning experience during their advanced practice clerkship. We conducted a survey of graduating medical students that contained both quantitative and open-ended questions regarding the students' experiences with the ILP during their advanced practice clerkship from July 2014 to March 2016. We systematically identified and compiled themes among the qualitative responses. Responses from 294 out of 460 subjects were included for analysis (63.9%). Ninety students (30.6%) reported that the ILP was definitely reviewed at the midpoint and 88 (29.9%) at the final evaluation. One hundred sixty one students (54.8%) felt the ILP provided a framework for learning. One hundred sixty one students (61.6%) felt it was a useful tool in helping open a discussion between the student and faculty. The qualitative data was grouped by areas most mentioned and these areas of concern centered on lack of faculty knowledge about ILP, time to complete ILP, and uncertainty of appropriate goal setting. The majority of students perceive the ILP to be helpful. Our results suggest that active intervention is needed by dedicated and trained faculty to improve ILP utilization. It is recommended that faculty gives students examples of learning goals to create their own learning framework and encourages them to discuss and review the ILP.