Biological impact of nanoscale lithium intercalating complex metal oxides to model bacterium B. subtilis.

The wide applications of lithium intercalating complex metal oxides in energy storage devices call for a better understanding of their environmental impact at the end of their life cycle. In this study, we examine the biological impact of a panel of nanoscale lithium nickel manganese cobalt oxides (Li x Ni y Mn z Co1-y-z O2, 0 < x, y, z < 1, abbreviated to NMCs) to a model Gram-positive bacterium, Bacillus subtilis, in terms of cellular respiration and growth. A highly sensitive single-cell gel electrophoresis method is also applied for the first time to understand the genotoxicity of these nanomaterials to bacterial cells. Results from these assays indicate that the free Ni and Co ions released from the incongruent dissolution of the NMC material in B. subtilis growth medium induced both hindered growth and cellular respiration. More remarkably, the DNA damage induced by the combination of the two ions in solution is comparable to that induced by the NMC material, which suggests that the free Ni and Co ions are responsible for the toxicity observed. A material redesign by enriching Mn is also presented. The combined approaches of evaluating their impact on bacterial growth, respiration, and DNA damage at a single-cell level, as well as other phenotypical changes allows us to probe the nanomaterials and bacterial cells from a mechanistic prospective, and provides a useful means to an understanding of bacterial response to new potential environmental stressors.

Next-Generation Complex Metal Oxide Nanomaterials Negatively Impact Growth and Development in the Benthic Invertebrate Chironomus riparius upon Settling.

Most studies of nanomaterial environmental impacts have focused on relatively simple first-generation nanomaterials, including metals or metal oxides (e.g., Ag, ZnO) for which dissolution largely accounts for toxicity. Few studies have considered nanomaterials with more complex compositions, such as complex metal oxides, which represent an emerging class of next-generation nanomaterials used in commercial products at large scales. Importantly, many nanomaterials are not colloidally stable in aqueous environments and will aggregate and settle, yet most studies use pelagic rather than benthic-dwelling organisms. Here we show that exposure of the model benthic species Chironomus riparius to lithium cobalt oxide (Li xCo1- xO2, LCO) and lithium nickel manganese cobalt oxide (Li xNi yMn zCo1- y- zO2, NMC) at 10 and 100 mg·L-1 caused 30-60% declines in larval growth and a delay of 7-25 d in adult emergence. A correlated 41-48% decline in larval hemoglobin concentration and related gene expression changes suggest a potential adverse outcome pathway. Metal ions released from nanoparticles do not cause equivalent impacts, indicating a nanospecific effect. Nanomaterials settled within 2 days and indicate higher cumulative exposures to sediment organisms than those in the water column, making this a potentially realistic environmental exposure. Differences in toxicity between NMC and LCO indicate compositional tuning may reduce material impact.

Quantitative Mapping of Oxidative Stress Response to Lithium Cobalt Oxide Nanoparticles in Single Cells Using Multiplexed in Situ Gene Expression Analysis.

Engineered nanoparticles (NPs) can negatively impact biological systems through induced generation of reactive oxygen species (ROS). Overproduced ROS cause biochemical damage and hence need to be effectively buffered by a sophisticated cellular oxidative stress response system. How this complex cellular system, which consists of multiple enzymes, responds to NP-induced ROS is largely unknown. Here, we apply a single cell analysis to quantitatively evaluate 10 key ROS responsive genes simultaneously to understand how the cell prioritizes tasks and reallocates resources in response to NP-induced oxidative stress. We focus on rainbow trout gill epithelial cells-a model cell type for environmental exposure-and their response to the massive generation of ROS induced by lithium cobalt oxide (LCO) NPs, which are extensively used as cathode materials in lithium ion batteries. Using multiplexed fluctuation localization imaging-based fluorescence in situ hybridization (fliFISH) in single cells, we found a shift in the expression of oxidative stress response genes with initial increase in genes targeting superoxide species, followed by increase in genes targeting peroxide and hydroxyl species. In contrast, Li+ and Co2+, at concentrations expected to be shed from the NPs, did not induce ROS generation but showed a potent inhibition of transcription for all 10 stress response genes. Taken together, our findings suggest a "two-hit" model for LCO NP toxicity, where the intact LCO NPs induce high levels of ROS that elicit sequential engagement of stress response genes, while the released metal ions suppress the expression of these genes. Consequently, these effects synergistically drive the exposed cells to become more vulnerable to ROS stress and damage.

Chronic exposure to complex metal oxide nanoparticles elicits rapid resistance in Shewanella oneidensis MR-1.

Engineered nanoparticles are incorporated into numerous emerging technologies because of their unique physical and chemical properties. Many of these properties facilitate novel interactions, including both intentional and accidental effects on biological systems. Silver-containing particles are widely used as antimicrobial agents and recent evidence indicates that bacteria rapidly become resistant to these nanoparticles. Much less studied is the chronic exposure of bacteria to particles that were not designed to interact with microorganisms. For example, previous work has demonstrated that the lithium intercalated battery cathode nanosheet, nickel manganese cobalt oxide (NMC), is cytotoxic and causes a significant delay in growth of Shewanella oneidensis MR-1 upon acute exposure. Here, we report that S. oneidensis MR-1 rapidly adapts to chronic NMC exposure and is subsequently able to survive in much higher concentrations of these particles, providing the first evidence of permanent bacterial resistance following exposure to nanoparticles that were not intended as antibacterial agents. We also found that when NMC-adapted bacteria were subjected to only the metal ions released from this material, their specific growth rates were higher than when exposed to the nanoparticle. As such, we provide here the first demonstration of bacterial resistance to complex metal oxide nanoparticles with an adaptation mechanism that cannot be fully explained by multi-metal adaptation. Importantly, this adaptation persists even after the organism has been grown in pristine media for multiple generations, indicating that S. oneidensis MR-1 has developed permanent resistance to NMC.

Impact of lithiated cobalt oxide and phosphate nanoparticles on rainbow trout gill epithelial cells.

Metal oxide and phosphate nanoparticles (NPs) are ubiquitous in emerging applications, ranging from energy storage to catalysis. Cobalt-containing NPs are particularly important, where their widespread use raises questions about the relationship between composition, structure, and potential for environmental impacts. To address this gap, we investigated the effects of lithiated metal oxide and phosphate NPs on rainbow trout gill epithelial cells, a model for environmental exposure. Lithium cobalt oxide (LCO) NPs significantly reduced cell viability at10 µg/mL, while a 10-fold higher concentration of lithiated cobalt hydroxyphosphate (LCP) NPs was required to significantly reduce viability. Exposure to Li+ and Co2+ alone, at concentrations relevant to ion released from the NPs, did not reduce cell viability and minimally impacted reactive oxygen species (ROS) levels. Both LCO- and LCP-NPs were found within membrane-bound organelles. However, only LCP-NPs underwent rapid and complete dissolution in artificial lysosomal fluid. Unlike LCP-NPs, LCO-NPs significantly increased intracellular ROS, could be found within abnormal multilamellar bodies, and induced formation of intracellular vacuoles. Increased p53 gene expression, measured in individual cells, was observed at sub-toxic concentrations of both LCO- and LCP-NPs, implicating both in inductions of cellular damage and stress at concentrations approaching predicted environmental levels. Our results implicate the intact NP, not the dissolved ions, in the observed adverse effects and show that LCO-NPs significantly impact cell viability accompanied by increase in intracellular ROS and formation of organelles indicative of cell stress, while LCP-NPs have minimal adverse effects, possibly due to their rapid dissolution in acidic organelles.

Growth-Based Bacterial Viability Assay for Interference-Free and High-Throughput Toxicity Screening of Nanomaterials.

Current high-throughput approaches evaluating toxicity of chemical agents toward bacteria typically rely on optical assays, such as luminescence and absorbance, to probe the viability of the bacteria. However, when applied to toxicity induced by nanomaterials, scattering and absorbance from the nanomaterials act as interferences that complicate quantitative analysis. Herein, we describe a bacterial viability assay that is free of optical interference from nanomaterials and can be performed in a high-throughput format on 96-well plates. In this assay, bacteria were exposed to various materials and then diluted by a large factor into fresh growth medium. The large dilution ensured minimal optical interference from the nanomaterial when reading optical density, and the residue left from the exposure mixture after dilution was confirmed not to impact the bacterial growth profile. The fractions of viable cells after exposure were allowed to grow in fresh medium to generate measurable growth curves. Bacterial viability was then quantitatively correlated to the delay of bacterial growth compared to a reference regarded as 100% viable cells; data analysis was inspired by that in quantitative polymerase chain reactions, where the delay in the amplification curve is correlated to the starting amount of the template nucleic acid. Fast and robust data analysis was achieved by developing computer algorithms carried out using R. This method was tested on four bacterial strains, including both Gram-negative and Gram-positive bacteria, showing great potential for application to all culturable bacterial strains. With the increasing diversity of engineered nanomaterials being considered for large-scale use, this high-throughput screening method will facilitate rapid screening of nanomaterial toxicity and thus inform the risk assessment of nanoparticles in a timely fashion.

Alteration of Membrane Compositional Asymmetry by LiCoO2 Nanosheets.

Given the projected massive presence of redox-active nanomaterials in the next generation of consumer electronics and electric vehicle batteries, they are likely to eventually come in contact with cell membranes, with biological consequences that are currently not known. Here, we present nonlinear optical studies showing that lithium nickel manganese cobalt oxide nanosheets carrying a negative ζ-potential have no discernible consequences for lipid alignment and interleaflet composition in supported lipid bilayers formed from zwitterionic and negatively charged lipids. In contrast, lithiated and delithiated LiCoO2 nanosheets having positive and neutral ζ-potentials, respectively, alter the compositional asymmetry of the two membrane leaflets, and bilayer asymmetry remains disturbed even after rinsing. The insight that some cobalt oxide nanoformulations induce alterations to the compositional asymmetry in idealized model membranes may represent an important step toward assessing the biological consequences of their predicted widespread use.