Recurrence after low-dose radioiodine ablation and recombinant human thyroid-stimulating hormone for differentiated thyroid cancer (HiLo): long-term results of an open-label, non-inferiority randomised controlled trial.

BACKGROUND: Two large randomised trials of patients with well-differentiated thyroid cancer reported in 2012 (HiLo and ESTIMABL1) found similar post-ablation success rates at 6-9 months between a low administered radioactive iodine (131I) dose (1·1 GBq) and the standard high dose (3·7 GBq). However, recurrence rates following radioactive iodine ablation have previously only been reported in observational studies, and recently in ESTIMABL1. We aimed to compare recurrence rates between radioactive iodine doses in HiLo. METHODS: HiLo was a non-inferiority, parallel, open-label, randomised controlled factorial trial done at 29 centres in the UK. Eligible patients were aged 16-80 years with histological confirmation of differentiated thyroid cancer requiring radioactive iodine ablation (performance status 0-2, tumour stage T1-T3 with the possibility of lymph-node involvement but no distant metastasis and no microscopic residual disease, and one-stage or two-stage total thyroidectomy). Patients were randomly assigned (1:1:1:1) to 1·1 GBq or 3·7 GBq ablation, each prepared with either recombinant human thyroid-stimulating hormone (rhTSH) or thyroid hormone withdrawal. Patients were followed up at annual clinic visits. Recurrences were diagnosed at each hospital with a combination of established methods according to national standards. We used Kaplan-Meier curves and hazard ratios (HRs) for time to first recurrence, which was a pre-planned secondary outcome. This trial is registered with ClinicalTrials.gov, number NCT00415233. RESULTS: Between Jan 16, 2007, and July 1, 2010, 438 patients were randomly assigned. At the end of the follow-up period in Dec 31, 2017, median follow-up was 6·5 years (IQR 4·5-7·6) in 434 patients (217 in the low-dose group and 217 in the high-dose group). Confirmed recurrences were seen in 21 patients: 11 who had 1·1 GBq ablation and ten who had 3·7 GBq ablation. Four of these (two in each group) were considered to be persistent disease. Cumulative recurrence rates were similar between low-dose and high-dose radioactive iodine groups (3 years, 1·5% vs 2·1%; 5 years, 2·1% vs 2·7%; and 7 years, 5·9% vs 7·3%; HR 1·10 [95% CI 0·47-2·59]; p=0·83). No material difference in risk was seen for T3 or N1 disease. Recurrence rates were also similar among patients who were prepared for ablation with rhTSH and those prepared with thyroid hormone withdrawal (3 years, 1·5% vs 2·1%; 5 years, 2·1% vs 2·7%; and 7 years, 8·3% vs 5·0%; HR 1·62 [95% CI 0·67-3·91]; p=0·28). Data on adverse events were not collected during follow-up. INTERPRETATION: The recurrence rate among patients who had 1·1 GBq radioactive iodine ablation was not higher than that for 3·7 GBq, consistent with data from large, recent observational studies. These findings provide further evidence in favour of using low-dose radioactive iodine for treatment of patients with low-risk differentiated thyroid cancer. Our data also indicate that recurrence risk was not affected by use of rhTSH. FUNDING: Cancer Research UK.

Dosimetry-based treatment for Graves' disease.

OBJECTIVE: The aim of this retrospective study was to assess the long-term outcome of a personalized dosimetry approach in Graves' disease aiming to render patients euthyroid from a planned thyroid absorbed dose of 60 Gy. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A total of 284 patients with Graves' disease were followed prospectively following administration of radioiodine calculated to deliver an absorbed dose of 60 Gy. Patients with cardiac disease were excluded. Outcomes were analysed at yearly intervals for up to 10 years with a median follow-up of 37.5 months. RESULTS: A single radioiodine administration was sufficient to render a patient either euthyroid or hypothyroid in 175 (62%) patients, the remainder requiring further radioiodine. The median radioactivity required to deliver 60 Gy was 77 MBq. Less than 2% patients required 400-600 MBq, the standard activity administered in many centres. In the cohort receiving a single administration, 38, 32 and 26% were euthyroid on no specific thyroid medication at 3, 5 and 10 years, respectively. Larger thyroid volumes were associated with the need for further therapy. The presence of nodules on ultrasonography did not adversely affect treatment outcome. CONCLUSION: A personalized dosimetric approach delayed the long-term onset of hypothyroidism in 26% of patients. This was achieved using much lower administered activities than currently recommended. Future studies will aim to identify those patients who would benefit most from this approach.

Long-term outcomes following low-dose radioiodide ablation for differentiated thyroid cancer.

CONTEXT: Randomized trials show that low-dose (1.1 GBq [30 mCi]) radioiodide (RAI) has efficacy equivalent to high-dose RAI (3.7 GBq [100 mCi]) in thyroid remnant ablation (TRA) for differentiated thyroid cancer. Long-term follow-up is required to ensure detection of late recurrences and to confirm equivalence in terms of survival end points. However, median follow-up duration within randomized trials is currently limited. PATIENTS AND SETTING: We studied 53 patients undergoing TRA for differentiated thyroid cancer with long-term follow-up in the Thyroid Unit of The Royal Marsden Hospital (Sutton, United Kingdom). INTERVENTION: Patients were treated with TRA using low-dose (1.1 GBq) RAI. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Disease-free survival, overall survival, and the incidence of second malignancies were measured. Multivariable analysis was used to determine clinical risk factors for failure to achieve TRA after low-dose RAI. RESULTS: Median follow-up was 24 (range, 4-34) years. Low-dose RAI TRA was successful in 26 (49%) patients (successful ablation [SA] group), whereas 27 (51%) patients required further treatment (unsuccessful ablation [UA] group). Thirty-year disease-free survival was 92% in the SA group vs 87% in the UA group (P = .601). Thirty-year overall survival was 81% in the SA group vs 62% in the UA group (P = .154). Nine (17%) patients developed second malignancies (4 in the SA group and 5 in the UA group). Predictors of failure to achieve TRA with low-dose RAI were male sex and stage pT4 disease. CONCLUSIONS: There is no evidence from long-term follow-up of our cohort that treatment outcomes are compromised for patients that fail TRA with low-dose RAI and subsequently receive high-dose RAI.

Ablation with low-dose radioiodine and thyrotropin alfa in thyroid cancer.

BACKGROUND: It is not known whether low-dose radioiodine (1.1 GBq [30 mCi]) is as effective as high-dose radioiodine (3.7 GBq [100 mCi]) for treating patients with differentiated thyroid cancer or whether the effects of radioiodine (especially at a low dose) are influenced by using either recombinant human thyrotropin (thyrotropin alfa) or thyroid hormone withdrawal. METHODS: At 29 centers in the United Kingdom, we conducted a randomized noninferiority trial comparing low-dose and high-dose radioiodine, each in combination with either thyrotropin alfa or thyroid hormone withdrawal before ablation. Patients (age range, 16 to 80 years) had tumor stage T1 to T3, with possible spread to nearby lymph nodes but without metastasis. End points were the rate of success of ablation at 6 to 9 months, adverse events, quality of life, and length of hospital stay. RESULTS: A total of 438 patients underwent randomization; data could be analyzed for 421. Ablation success rates were 85.0% in the group receiving low-dose radioiodine versus 88.9% in the group receiving the high dose and 87.1% in the thyrotropin alfa group versus 86.7% in the group undergoing thyroid hormone withdrawal. All 95% confidence intervals for the differences were within ±10 percentage points, indicating noninferiority. Similar results were found for low-dose radioiodine plus thyrotropin alfa (84.3%) versus high-dose radioiodine plus thyroid hormone withdrawal (87.6%) or high-dose radioiodine plus thyrotropin alfa (90.2%). More patients in the high-dose group than in the low-dose group were hospitalized for at least 3 days (36.3% vs. 13.0%, P<0.001). The proportions of patients with adverse events were 21% in the low-dose group versus 33% in the high-dose group (P=0.007) and 23% in the thyrotropin alfa group versus 30% in the group undergoing thyroid hormone withdrawal (P=0.11). CONCLUSIONS: Low-dose radioiodine plus thyrotropin alfa was as effective as high-dose radioiodine, with a lower rate of adverse events. (Funded by Cancer Research UK; ClinicalTrials.gov number, NCT00415233.).

Early and late toxicity of radioiodine therapy: detection and management.

OBJECTIVE: To review the early and late toxicity associated with radioiodine (131I) therapy, highlighting the need for early detection and, where possible, preventive measures. METHODS: We performed a literature search on MEDLINE using the terms radioiodine, 131I toxicity, complications, Graves disease, and thyroid cancer and chose the most relevant studies for this review. Where appropriate, we refer to our own published series of patients as well. RESULTS: Uptake of 131I into the salivary glands, lacrimal glands, fetal thyroid, and adult thyroid accounts for the early toxic effects of radioiodine therapy. Delayed radiation effects to the gonads, bone marrow, and cell nuclei give rise to late complications. Toxicity may also arise from uptake into metastatic tumors located at vulnerable sites, including the spinal cord, brain, and lungs. CONCLUSION: Although radioiodine therapy for benign and malignant thyroid disorders is usually well tolerated, clinicians involved in the management of thyroid disorders need to be aware of the potential toxicity of radioiodine and take all measures to reduce these effects to a minimum.

A dose-effect correlation for radioiodine ablation in differentiated thyroid cancer.

PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to determine the range of absorbed doses delivered to thyroid remnants, blood, and red marrow from fixed administrations of radioiodine and to ascertain whether the success of ablation is more dependent on these absorbed doses than on the administered activity. METHODS: Twenty-three patients received 3,000 MBq radioiodine following near-total thyroidectomy. The maximum absorbed dose to remnants was calculated from subsequent single photon emission tomography scans. Absorbed doses delivered to blood and red marrow were calculated from blood samples and from whole-body retention measurements. The protein bound iodine (PBI) was also calculated. RESULTS: Maximum absorbed doses to thyroid remnants ranged from 7 to 570 Gy. Eighteen of the 23 patients had a successful ablation. A significant difference was seen between the absorbed doses delivered to thyroid remnants, blood, and red marrow for those patients that had a successful ablation compared to those with a failed ablation (p = 0.030, p = 0.043 and p = 0.048, respectively). The difference between the PBI values acquired at day 1 and day 6 were also indicative of response (p = 0.074). CONCLUSIONS: A successful ablation is strongly dependent on the absorbed dose to the thyroid remnant. Dosimetry-based personalized treatment can prevent both sub-optimal administrations, which entails further radioiodine therapy, and excessive administration of radioactivity, which increases the potential for radiation toxicity.

Hyperfractionated Accelerated Radiotherapy (HART) for anaplastic thyroid carcinoma: toxicity and survival analysis.

PURPOSE: Anaplastic thyroid carcinoma (ATC) is one of the most aggressive cancers, and the current protocol of hyperfractionated accelerated radiotherapy was initiated to improve survival while limiting toxicities. METHODS AND MATERIALS: All patients with ATC from 1991 to 2002 were accrued and received megavoltage radiotherapy from the mastoid processes to the carina up to 60 Gy in twice-daily fractions of 1.8 and 2 Gy, 6 hours apart. RESULTS: Thirty-one patients were accrued with a median age of 69 years, and 55% were women. Debulking was performed in 26%, and total thyroidectomy, in 6%, whereas 68% received radical radiotherapy alone. Local control data were available for 27 patients: 22% had a complete response, 26% had a partial response, 15% showed progressive disease, and 37% showed static disease. Median overall survival for all 31 patients was 70 days (95% confidence interval, 40-99). There was no significant difference in median survival between patients younger (70 days) and older than 70 years (42 days), between men (70 days) and women (49 days), and between patients receiving postoperative radiotherapy (77 days) and radical radiotherapy alone (35 days). Grade III or higher skin erythema was seen in 56% patients; desquamation in 21%; dysphagia in 74%; and esophagitis in 79%. CONCLUSION: The current protocol failed to offer a significant survival benefit, was associated with severe toxicities, and thus was discontinued. There is a suggestion that younger patients with operable disease have longer survival, but this would require a larger study to confirm it.

Thyroid cancer causing obstruction of the great veins in the neck.

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: To report our experience and review the literature of thyroid cancer obstructing the great veins in the neck, highlighting clinical aspects and response to treatment. METHODS: Clinical data were collected from the thyroid cancer register and from follow-up clinic visits of patients referred to the Thyroid Unit at the Royal Marsden Hospital. A Medline literature search was conducted between 1980 and 2007. RESULTS: Of 1448 patients with thyroid cancer on our cancer register and treated in our unit over the last 60 years, we identified five patients, four women and one man, aged 43 - 81 years with a median follow up of 28 (24-78) months in whom tumour had occluded the great veins in the neck. All patients underwent total thyroidectomy and all subsequently received ablative 131I with the exception of patient 3 whose post-operative isotope scan shown no significant 131I uptake. External beam radiotherapy to the neck and upper mediastinum was used for residual disease control in the 5 patients. The median survival was 28 months and the disease-free survival was 24 months. One patient remains asymptomatic but with disease 53 months after initial presentation. Survival in this small series is significantly better than that previously reported for this condition. CONCLUSION: A multimodality therapeutic approach comprising surgery, radioiodine and external beam radiotherapy may give the best results for patients in whom thyroid cancer is occluding the great veins.

Intensity Modulated Radiotherapy (IMRT) in locally advanced thyroid cancer: acute toxicity results of a phase I study.

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: This phase 1 study was designed to determine the toxicity of accelerated fractionation IMRT in locally advanced thyroid cancer. METHODS: Patients with high risk locally advanced thyroid cancer who required post-operative EBRT were recruited. A single-phase inverse-planned-simultaneous-boost was delivered by IMRT: 58.8 Gy/28F (daily) to the primary tumour and involved nodes and 50 Gy/28F to the elective nodes. Acute (NCICTCv.2.0) and late toxicity (RTOG and modified LENTSOM) was collected. RESULTS: Thirteen patients were treated (7 medullary thyroid, 2 Hurthle cell and 4 well differentiated thyroid cancer). G3 and G2 radiation dermatitis rates were 38.5% and 31%; G3 and G2 mucositis rates 8% and 53% and G3 and G2 pain 23% and 54%. Thirty-one percentage required enteral feeding. G3 and G2 xerostomia rates were 0% and 31%. Recovery was seen, with 62% patients having dysphagia G< or =1 2 months after IMRT. Thirty percent of patients developed L'Hermitte's syndrome. No grade 4 toxicity was observed. No dose limiting toxicity was found. CONCLUSIONS: Accelerated fractionation IMRT in this group of patients is feasible and safe. The acute toxicity appeared acceptable and early indicators of late toxicity moderate and similar to what would be expected with conventional RT. Longer follow up is required to quantify late side effects.

Neuroendocrine carcinoma arising in soft tissue: three case reports and literature review.

BACKGROUND: Neuroendocrine tumours (NET) are tumours arising from neuroendocrine cells of neural crest origin. They are characterised by the presence of neurosecretory granules which react positively to silver stains and to specific markers including neuron specific enolase, synaptophysin and chromogranin. Metastasis to the skin occurs infrequently but primary soft tissue NET is excessively rare. CASE PRESENTATION: We report our experience with 3 such cases. In the first case, the NET originated in muscle and was treated with wide surgical excision and adjuvant radiotherapy. The second case presented as a subcutaneous mass in the foot and the tumour was positive on 123I mIBG scan. She has had prolonged recurrence-free survival following primary hypo-fractionated radiotherapy. In the third case, a cutaneous nodule proved to be a NET and at surgery, lymph node disease was present. He has remained disease-free after surgical excision without the need for external beam radiotherapy. CONCLUSION: These tumours appear to have a good prognosis. Complete excision offers potentially curative treatment. Adjuvant radiotherapy may be helpful when the tumour margin is narrow. For patients with unresectable disease or where surgery would not be appropriate, radiotherapy appears to be an effective therapeutic option.

131I activity for remnant ablation in patients with differentiated thyroid cancer: A systematic review.

CONTEXT: Radioiodine ablation of the thyroid remnant after thyroidectomy is commonly performed in the management of patients with differentiated thyroid cancer. Although many centers administer an activity of 100 mCi, there is uncertainty over using a lower activity. OBJECTIVE: A systematic review of the published literature was used to compare the success rates of remnant ablation using approximately 30 mCi with approximately 100 mCi (1.1 vs. 3.7 GBq). DATA SOURCES: Data were obtained from MEDLINE and EMBASE for the years 1966 to March 2006. STUDY SELECTION: All studies that reported rates of successful ablation associated with approximately 30 or approximately 100 mCi of radioiodine were reviewed. DATA EXTRACTION: Studies were based on reviews of patient case notes (n = 41), prospective cohorts (n = 12), and randomized trials (n = 6). We obtained the success of thyroid remnant ablation according to different administered activities of radioiodine. Where a study reported on two or more activities, the risk ratio of having a successful ablation (approximately 30 vs. approximately 100 mCi) was calculated and combined in a meta-analysis. DATA SYNTHESIS: Observational studies confirmed the high ablation success rate ( approximately 80%) using approximately 100 mCi, although 22% of studies reported a rate of 90% or greater. The pooled ablation success rate in these studies was 10% lower using 30 mCi compared with 100 mCi (95% confidence interval, 3-17%; P = 0.01). The meta-analysis of the randomized trials produced equivocal results. For example, the rate of successful ablation in patients given 30 mCi was 8% lower compared with 100 mCi (95% confidence interval, 29% lower or up to 20% greater, P = 0.58), consistent with there being no difference or that 30 mCi is much less effective. CONCLUSIONS: From the published data, it is not possible to reliably determine whether ablation success rates using 30 mCi are similar to using 100 mCi. Large randomized trials are needed to resolve the issue and guide clinical practice.

Prolonged survival due to spontaneous regression and surgical excision of malignant mesothelioma.

We report a case of malignant pleural mesothelioma with histologically proven spontaneous regression of pleural disease. During a 12-year follow-up there was a single recurrence, which was a lesion in the chest wall at 6 years that was surgically excised. A prominent host response to tumor was seen in both the primary tumor and the recurrence.

Post-surgical use of radioiodine (131I) in patients with papillary and follicular thyroid cancer and the issue of remnant ablation: a consensus report.

OBJECTIVE: To determine, based on published literature and expert clinical experience, current indications for the post-surgical administration of a large radioiodine activity in patients with differentiated thyroid cancer. DESIGN AND METHODS: A literature review was performed and was then analyzed and discussed by a panel of experts from 13 European countries. RESULTS: There is general agreement that patients with unifocal microcarcinomas = 1 cm in diameter and no node or distant metastases have a <2% recurrence rate after surgery alone, and that post-surgical radioiodine confers recurrence and cause-specific survival benefits in patients, strongly suspected of having persistent disease or known to have tumor in the neck or distant sites. In other patients, there is limited evidence that after complete thyroidectomy and adequate lymph node dissection performed by an expert surgeon, post-surgical radioiodine provides clear benefit. When there is any uncertainty about the completeness of surgery, evidence suggests that radioiodine can reduce recurrences and possibly mortality. CONCLUSION: This survey confirms that post-surgical radioiodine should be used selectively. The modality is definitely indicated in patients with distant metastases, incomplete tumor resection, or complete tumor resection but high risk of recurrence and mortality. Probable indications include patients with tumors >1 cm and with suboptimal surgery (less than total thyroidectomy or no lymph node dissection), with age <16 years, or with unfavorable histology.

Metastatic thyroid carcinoma causing superior vena caval obstruction diagnosed on I-131 scan.

An 80-year-old woman was referred for a painless mass arising in right side of her neck of 4 months' duration. Ultrasound revealed a multinodular goiter, but cytology confirmed a follicular carcinoma. Thyroid function was normal. Total thyroidectomy was performed with evidence of tumor infiltration into the strap muscles extending up to the right submandibular gland and right internal jugular vein, which was completely occluded. Radioiodine was considered as the treatment of choice postoperatively. This is an unusual case of SVC obstruction caused by tumor embolus diagnosed on I-131 scan.

Treatment of advanced differentiated thyroid carcinoma with high activity radioiodine therapy.

OBJECTIVES: This was a retrospective study to assess the efficacy and morbidity of high activity I therapy in patients with advanced differentiated thyroid carcinoma. METHODS: From 1975 to 2003, 38 patients with locally advanced or metastatic differentiated thyroid cancer (16 follicular, 20 papillary, one Hurthle cell, one insular) were treated with high activity radioiodine therapy (9 GBq) as the cancers had previously not responded to standard activities (5.5 GBq). RESULTS: Cumulative total activities received ranged from 11.8 to 84.5 GBq (mean 29.4 GBq per patient). Staging at presentation showed pT4 and/or M1 disease in 27/38 of patients (71.1%). Moderate (grade 2) and poorly differentiated (grade 3) tumours were present in a total of 9/38 patients (23.7%). Outcomes were evaluated according to the results of I whole-body scans, serum thyroglobulin, radiological assessments and physical examination. Neither [18F]flurodeoxyglucose positron emission tomography (F-FDG PET) nor 99mTc sestamibi were available during this study. The mean duration of follow-up was 83 months. A complete response was observed in 7/38 patients (18.4%), progressive disease in 27/38 (71.1%) and stable disease in 4/38 (10.5%). The mean survival from initiation of high activity treatment was 36.6 months. For patients with lung disease the mean survival was 45 months, neck disease 38.9 months, bone disease 35 months and multiple sites was 30.9 months. Twelve patients died during follow-up (10 due to thyroid carcinoma). After high activity treatment, 9.7% of patients suffered grade 3 and 3.2% suffered grade 4 WHO haematological toxicity. Significant salivary gland morbidity was observed (30% dry mouth, 27% salivary swelling). CONCLUSIONS: Repeated treatment with high activity (9 GBq) I in patients with advanced differentiated thyroid carcinoma appears to be of no apparent benefit and may lead to late morbidity.

Diagnostic 131I whole body scanning after thyroidectomy and ablation for differentiated thyroid cancer.

OBJECTIVE: To assess the value of the diagnostic whole body (131)I scan after thyroidectomy and (131)I ablation. DESIGN: Retrospective analysis of all patients with differentiated thyroid cancer treated in one centre between 1990 and 2000. RESULTS: A total of 153 consecutive patients who underwent diagnostic scanning following ablative therapy were identified. This diagnostic scan was positive in 20 patients (13%) and faintly positive in 16 patients (11%). The majority (117 patients) had negative scans. Of the 20 patients with positive scans, four received no further treatment, nine showed no abnormal uptake following a second ablative (131)I dose and seven had uptake in the thyroid bed (six) or in neck nodes (one) after repeat ablation. OUTCOME: In the group with positive scans, the four patients who received no further treatment and the nine with a negative second ablation scan remained disease free during follow-up. No patient with a positive diagnostic scan received additional (131)I therapy which would not otherwise have been given based on the clinical findings, serum thyroglobulin (Tg) values or the presence of anti-Tg antibodies. Ten of the patients with negative scans developed recurrent disease which was always detected clinically or by a rising serum Tg value. CONCLUSIONS: Diagnostic whole body (131)I scans add little extra information and in our experience do not influence patient management. They should be reserved for patients in whom serum Tg levels are unreliable because of the presence of antibodies or when there is clinical suspicion of tumour.

Risk of non-medullary thyroid cancer influenced by polymorphic variation in the thyroglobulin gene.

Benign thyroid disorders are strong risk factors for non-medullary thyroid cancer (NMTC). Germline variation in Tg (thyroglobulin) and TSHR (thyroid stimulating hormone receptor) confers an increased risk of benign thyroid disorders. To explore the hypothesis that polymorphic variation in these genes affects the risk of NMTC we compared the frequency of TgQ2511R, TSHR-P52T and TSHR-D727E genotypes in two series of NMTC cases and controls (group 1, Canadian 102 cases and 102 controls; group 2, British 202 cases and 298 controls). No significant association was seen with TSHR-P52T and TSHR-D727E genotypes and risk of NMTC. However, the frequency of the R-allele of TgQ2511R was over represented in NMTC cases in both study populations. The odds ratios associated with hetero- and homozygosity for the R-allele were 1.6 (95% confidence interval, 1.1-2.5) and 2.0 (95% confidence interval, 1.2-3.3), respectively. Although the risk of NMTC associated with the TgQ2511R R-allele is modest, its high prevalence in the general population suggests it may make a significant contribution to the incidence of NMTC.