New approaches in the treatment of asthma.

Asthma is a common and complex inflammatory disease of the airways that remains incurable. Current forms of therapy are long term and may exhibit associated side-effect problems. Major participants in the development of an asthma phenotype include the triggering stimuli such as the allergens themselves, cells such as T cells, epithelial cells and mast cells that produce a variety of cytokines including IL-5, GM-CSF, IL-3, IL-4 and IL-13 and chemokines such as eotaxin. Significantly, the eosinophil, a specialized blood cell type, is invariably associated with this disease. The eosinophil has long been incriminated in the pathology of asthma due to its ability to release preformed and unique toxic substances as well as newly formed pro-inflammatory mediators. The regulation of eosinophil production and function is carried out by soluble peptides or factors. Of these IL-5, GM-CSF and IL-3 are of paramount importance as they control eosinophil functional activity and are the only known eosinophilopoietic factors. In addition they regulate the eosinophil life span by inhibiting apoptosis. While one therapeutic approach in asthma is directed at inhibiting single eosinophil products such as leukotrienes or single eosinophil regulators such as IL-5, we believe that the simultaneous inhibition of more than one component is preferable. This may be particularly important with eosinophil regulators in that not only IL-5, but also GM-CSF has been repeatedly implicated in clinical studies of asthma. The fact that GM-CSF is produced by many cells in the body and in copious amounts by lung epithelial cells highlights this need further. Our approach takes advantage of the fact that the IL-5 and GM-CSF receptors (as well as IL-3 receptors) utilize a shared subunit to bind, with high affinity, to these cytokines and the same common subunit mediates signal transduction culminating in all the biological activities mentioned. By generating the monoclonal antibody BION-1 to the cytokine binding region of the common subunit (betac) we have shown that the approach of inhibiting IL-5, GM-CSF and IL-3 binding and the resulting stimulation of eosinophil production and function with a single agent is feasible. Furthermore we have used BION-1 as a tool to crystallize and define the structure of the cytokine binding domain of betac. This knowledge and this approach may lead to the generation of novel therapeutics for the treatment of asthma.

Structure of the activation domain of the GM-CSF/IL-3/IL-5 receptor common beta-chain bound to an antagonist.

Heterodimeric cytokine receptors generally consist of a major cytokine-binding subunit and a signaling subunit. The latter can transduce signals by more than 1 cytokine, as exemplified by the granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF), interleukin-2 (IL-2), and IL-6 receptor systems. However, often the signaling subunits in isolation are unable to bind cytokines, a fact that has made it more difficult to obtain structural definition of their ligand-binding sites. This report details the crystal structure of the ligand-binding domain of the GM-CSF/IL-3/IL-5 receptor beta-chain (beta(c)) signaling subunit in complex with the Fab fragment of the antagonistic monoclonal antibody, BION-1. This is the first single antagonist of all 3 known eosinophil-producing cytokines, and it is therefore capable of regulating eosinophil-related diseases such as asthma. The structure reveals a fibronectin type III domain, and the antagonist-binding site involves major contributions from the loop between the B and C strands and overlaps the cytokine-binding site. Furthermore, tyrosine(421) (Tyr(421)), a key residue involved in receptor activation, lies in the neighboring loop between the F and G strands, although it is not immediately adjacent to the cytokine-binding residues in the B-C loop. Interestingly, functional experiments using receptors mutated across these loops demonstrate that they are cooperatively involved in full receptor activation. The experiments, however, reveal subtle differences between the B-C loop and Tyr(421), which is suggestive of distinct functional roles. The elucidation of the structure of the ligand-binding domain of beta(c) also suggests how different cytokines recognize a single receptor subunit, which may have implications for homologous receptor systems. (Blood. 2000;95:2491-2498)

Molecular determinants of the granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor receptor complex assembly.

The granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) receptor (GMR) is composed of two chains that belong to the superfamily of cytokine receptors typified by the growth hormone receptor. A common structural element found in cytokine receptors is a module of two fibronectin-like domains, each characterized by seven beta-strands denoted A-G and A'-G', respectively. The alpha-chain (GMRalpha) confers low affinity GM-CSF binding (K(d) = 1-5 nM), whereas the beta-chain (beta(c)) does not bind GM-CSF by itself but confers high affinity binding when associated with alpha (K(d) = 40-100 pM). In the present study, we define the molecular determinants required for ligand recognition and for stabilization of the complex through a convergence of several approaches, including the construction of chimeric receptors, the molecular dynamics of our three-dimensional model of the GM.GMR complex, and site-directed mutagenesis. The functional importance of individual residues was then investigated through ligand binding studies at equilibrium and through determination of the kinetic constants of the GM.GMR complex. Critical to this tripartite complex is the establishment of four noncovalent bonds, three that determine the nature of the ligand recognition process involving residues Arg(280) and Tyr(226) of the alpha-chain and residue Tyr(365) of the beta-chain, since mutations of either one of these residues resulted in a significant decrease in the association rate. Finally, residue Tyr(365) of beta(c) serves a dual function in that it cooperates with another residue of beta(c), Tyr(421) to stabilize the complex since mutation of Tyr(365) and Tyr(421) result in a drastic increase in the dissociation rate (Koff). Interestingly, these four residues are located at the B'-C' and F'-G' loops of GMRalpha and of beta(c), thus establishing a functional symmetry within an apparently asymmetrical heterodimeric structure.

Crucial role of the residue R280 at the F'-G' loop of the human granulocyte/macrophage colony-stimulating factor receptor alpha chain for ligand recognition.

The receptor for granulocyte/macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) is composed of two chains, alpha and betac. Both chains belong to the superfamily of cytokine receptors characterized by a common structural feature, i.e., the presence of at least two fibronectin-like folds in the extracellular domain, which was first identified in the growth hormone receptor. The GM-CSF receptor (GMR)-alpha chain confers low affinity binding only (5-10 nM), whereas the other chain, betac, does not bind GM-CSF by itself but confers high affinity binding when associated with GMR-alpha (25-100 pM). The present study was designed to define the assembly of the GMR complex at the molecular level through site-directed mutagenesis guided by homology modeling with the growth hormone receptor complex. In our three-dimensional model, R280 of GMR-alpha, located in the F'-G' loop and close to the WSSWS motif, is in the vicinity of the ligand Asp112, suggesting the possibility of electrostatic interaction between these two residues. Through site directed mutagenesis, we provide several lines of evidence indicating the importance of electrostatic interaction in ligand-receptor recognition. First, mutagenesis of GMR-alphaR280 strikingly ablated ligand binding in the absence of beta common (betac); ligand binding was restored in the presence of betac with, nonetheless, a significant shift from high (26 pM) toward low affinity (from 2 to 13 nM). The rank order of the dissociation constant for the different GMR-alphaR280 mutations where Lys > Gln > Met > Asp, suggesting the importance of the charge at this position. Second, a mutant GM-CSF with charge reversal mutation at position Asp112 exhibited a 1,000-fold decrease in affinity in receptor binding, whereas charge ablation or conservative mutations were the least affected (10-20-fold). Third, removal of the charge at position R280 of GMR-alpha introduced a 10-fold decrease in the association rate constant and only a 2-fold change in the dissociation rate constant, suggesting that R280 is implicated in ligand recognition, possibly through interaction with Asp112 of GM-CSF. For all R280 mutants, the half-efficient concentrations of GM-CSF required for membrane (receptor binding) to nuclear events (c-fos promoter activation) and cell proliferation (thymidine incorporation) were in the same range, indicating that the threshold for biologic activity is governed mainly by the affinity of ligand-receptor interaction. Furthermore, mutation of other residues in the immediate vicinity of R280 was less drastic. Sequence alignment and modeling of interleukin (IL)-3R and IL-5R identified an arginine residue at the tip of a beta turn in a highly divergent context at the F'-G' loop, close to a conserved structural element, the WSXWS motif, suggesting the possibility of a ligand association mechanism similar to the one described herein for GMR.

The apoptosis-inducing granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) analog E21R functions through specific regions of the heterodimeric GM-CSF receptor and requires interleukin-1beta-converting enzyme-like proteases.

The granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) analog E21R induces apoptosis of hemopoietic cells. We examined the GM-CSF receptor subunit requirements and the signaling molecules involved. Using Jurkat T cells transfected with the GM-CSF receptor we found that both receptor subunits were necessary for E21R-induced apoptosis. Specifically, the 16 membrane-proximal residues of the alpha subunit were sufficient for apoptosis. This sequence could be replaced by the corresponding sequence from the interleukin-2 receptor common gamma subunit, identifying this as a conserved cytokine motif necessary for E21R-induced apoptosis. Cells expressing the alpha subunit and truncated betac mutants showed that the 96 membrane-proximal residues of betac were sufficient for apoptosis. E21R, in contrast to GM-CSF, did not alter tyrosine phosphorylation of betac, suggesting that receptor-associated tyrosine kinases were not activated. Consistent with this, E21R decreased the mitogen-activated protein kinase ERK (extracellular signal-regulated kinase). E21R-induced apoptosis was independent of Fas/APO-1 (CD95) and required interleukin-1beta-converting enzyme (ICE)-like proteases. In contrast, Bcl-2, which protects cells from growth factor deprivation-induced cell death, did not prevent this apoptosis. These findings demonstrate the GM-CSF receptor and ICE-like protease requirements for E21R-induced apoptosis.

Interaction of GM-CSF and IL-3 with the common beta-chain of their receptors.

Human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) and interleukin (IL-3) are cytokines active in both normal and abnormal hemopoiesis, inflammation, and immunity. Their biological activity is mediated via receptors that comprise a ligand-specific alpha chain and a beta chain that is common to the GM-CSF, IL-3, and IL-5 receptors. To understand the mechanism of action of GM-CSF and IL-3 in both normal and pathological conditions, we are seeking to define the structural elements required for ligand/receptor and receptor/receptor contact and their role in cellular activation. To this end we have identified a conserved motif in the first helix of GM-CSF, Glu21 that is critical for high affinity binding and biological activity. Charge-reversal mutagenesis of this residue generates a GM-CSF analogue that is devoid of biological activity and can antagonize the activity of wild-type GM-CSF. This probably results from the selective deficiency in interaction with the beta chain of the receptor and suggests that similar antagonists for IL-3 and IL-5 are also feasible. Complementary mutagenesis studies on the receptor beta chain have identified the putative B'-C' loop in the membrane-proximal domain as being critical for the high affinity binding of GM-CSF but not IL-3. Characterization of the specificity of sites of interaction between the ligands and receptors may permit the design of specific or genetic antagonists that may have important therapeutic implications.

Three residues in the common beta chain of the human GM-CSF, IL-3 and IL-5 receptors are essential for GM-CSF and IL-5 but not IL-3 high affinity binding and interact with Glu21 of GM-CSF.

The beta subunit (beta c) of the receptors for human granulocyte macrophage colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF), interleukin-3 (IL-3) and interleukin-5 (IL-5) is essential for high affinity ligand-binding and signal transduction. An important feature of this subunit is its common nature, being able to interact with GM-CSF, IL-3 and IL-5. Analogous common subunits have also been identified in other receptor systems including gp130 and the IL-2 receptor gamma subunit. It is not clear how common receptor subunits bind multiple ligands. We have used site-directed mutagenesis and binding assays with radiolabelled GM-CSF, IL-3 and IL-5 to identify residues in the beta c subunit involved in affinity conversion for each ligand. Alanine substitutions in the region Tyr365-Ile368 in beta c showed that Tyr365, His367 and Ile368 were required for GM-CSF and IL-5 high affinity binding, whereas Glu366 was unimportant. In contrast, alanine substitutions of these residues only marginally reduced the conversion of IL-3 binding to high affinity by beta c. To identify likely contact points in GM-CSF involved in binding to the 365-368 beta c region we used the GM-CSF mutant eco E21R which is unable to interact with wild-type beta c whilst retaining full GM-CSF receptor alpha chain binding. Eco E21R exhibited greater binding affinity to receptor alpha beta complexes composed of mutant beta chains Y365A, H367A and I368A than to those composed of wild-type beta c or mutant E366A. These results (i) identify the residues Tyr365, His367 and Ile368 as critical for affinity conversion by beta c, (ii) show that high affinity binding of GM-CSF and IL-5 can be dissociated from IL-3 and (iii) suggest that Tyr365, His367 and Ile368 in beta c interact with Glu21 of GM-CSF.

Specific human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor antagonists.

Human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) is a pleiotropic hemopoietic growth factor and activator of mature myeloid cell function. We have previously shown that residue 21 in the first helix of GM-CSF plays a critical role in both biological activity and high-affinity receptor binding. We have now generated analogues of GM-CSF mutated at residue 21, expressed them in Escherichia coli, and examined them for binding, agonistic, and antagonistic activities. Binding experiments showed that GM E21A, E21Q, E21F, E21H, E21R, and E21K bound to the GM-CSF receptor alpha chain with a similar affinity to wild-type GM-CSF and had lost high-affinity binding to the GM-CSF receptor alpha-chain-common beta-chain complex. From these mutants, only the charge reversal mutants E21R and E21K were completely devoid of agonistic activity. Significantly we found that E21R and E21K antagonized the proliferative effect of GM-CSF on the erythroleukemic cell line TF-1 and primary acute myeloid leukemias, as well as GM-CSF-mediated stimulation of neutrophil superoxide production. This antagonism was specific for GM-CSF in that no antagonism of interleukin 3-mediated TF-1 cell proliferation or tumor necrosis factor alpha-mediated stimulation of neutrophil superoxide production was observed. E. coli-derived GM E21R and E21K were effective antagonists of both nonglycosylated and glycosylated wild-type GM-CSF. These results show that low-affinity GM-CSF binding can be dissociated from receptor activation and have potential clinical significance for the management of inflammatory diseases and certain leukemias where GM-CSF plays a pathogenic role.

Identification of residues in the first and fourth helices of human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor involved in biologic activity and in binding to the alpha- and beta-chains of its receptor.

Residues within the first and fourth helices of human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (hGM-CSF) were analyzed for their role in biologic activity and interaction with the alpha- and beta-chains of the hGM-CSF receptor. Within the first helix substitution of the surface residues Glu14, Asn17, Gln20, Arg23, Arg24, and Asn27 or the buried residues Ala18, Leu25, and Leu28 did not significantly impair bioactivity or receptor binding. Substitutions at the buried residues Ala22 and Leu26 had intermediate bioactivity. However, substitutions of the surface residue Glu21 or the buried residue Ile19 reduced the relative bioactivity of the analogues to as little as 0.45% and 0.3%, respectively. Substitution of the charged surface residues of the fourth helix showed that substitution at Glu104, Lys107, and Lys111 had no significant effect on bioactivity, but substitution at Glu108 and Asp112 reduced the potency of the analogues to 34% and 7%, respectively. Receptor binding studies showed that, whereas Glu21 is the critical residue for binding to the hGM-CSF-receptor beta-chain, Asp112 is likely to be involved in binding to the GM-CSF-receptor alpha-chain. These results establish the relative contribution of residues in the first and fourth helices for GM-CSF bioactivity and receptor binding, and support a model where the fourth helix of GM-CSF interacts with the alpha-chain, and the first helix with the beta-chain of the GM-CSF receptor.

Residue 21 of human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor is critical for biological activity and for high but not low affinity binding.

The functional role of the predicted first alpha-helix of human granulocyte-macrophage colony-stimulating factor (GM-CSF) was analysed by site-directed mutagenesis and multiple biological and receptor binding assays. Initial deletion mutagenesis pointed to residues 20 and 21 being critical. Substitution mutagenesis showed that by altering Gln20 to Ala full GM-CSF activity was retained but that by altering Glu21 for Ala GM-CSF activity and high affinity receptor binding were decreased. Substitution of different amino acids for Glu21 showed that there was a hierarchy in the ability to stimulate the various biological activities of GM-CSF with the order of potency being Asp21 greater than Ser21 greater than Ala21 greater than Gln21 greater than Lys21 = Arg21. To distinguish whether position 21 was important for GM-CSF binding to high or low affinity receptors, GM-CSF (Arg21) was used as a competitor for [125I]GM-CSF binding to monocytes that express both types of receptor. GM-CSF (Arg21) exhibited a greatly reduced capacity to compete for binding to high affinity receptors, however, it competed fully for [125I]GM-CSF binding to low affinity receptors. Furthermore, GM-CSF (Arg21) was equipotent with wild-type GM-CSF in binding to the cloned low affinity alpha-chain of the GM-CSF receptor. These results show that (i) this position is critical for high affinity but not for low affinity GM-CSF receptor binding thus defining two functional parts of the GM-CSF molecule; (ii) position 21 of GM-CSF is critical for multiple functions of GM-CSF; and (iii) stimulation of proliferation and mature cell function by GM-CSF are mediated through high affinity receptors.

A satellite RNA of barley yellow dwarf virus contains a novel hammerhead structure in the self-cleavage domain.

An RNA molecule with properties of a satellite RNA was found in an isolate of barley yellow dwarf virus (BYDV), RPV serotype. It is 322 nucleotide long, single-stranded, and does not hybridize to the viral genome. Dimers of the RNA, which presumably represent replicative intermediates, were able to self-cleave into monomers. In vitro transcripts from cDNA clones were capable of self-cleavage in both the plus (encapsidated) and minus orientations. The sequence flanking the minus strand cleavage site contained a consensus "hammerhead" structure, similar to those found in other self-cleaving satellite RNAs. Although related to the hammerhead structure, sequences flanking the plus strand termini showed differences from the consensus and may be folded into a different structure containing a pseudo-knot.