Prevalence and pharmacological modulation of humoral immunity to AAV vectors in gene transfer to synovial tissue.

Antibodies against adeno-associated viral (AAV) vectors are highly prevalent in humans. Both preclinical and clinical studies showed that antibodies against AAV block transduction even at low titers, particularly when the vector is introduced into the bloodstream. Here we measured the neutralizing antibody (NAb) titer against AAV serotypes 2, 5, 6 and 8 in the serum and matched synovial fluid (SF) from rheumatoid arthritis patients. The titer in the SF was lower than that in the matched plasma samples, indicating a difference in distribution of NAb to AAV depending on the body fluid compartment. This difference was more evident for AAV2, against which higher titers were measured. Of all serotypes, anti-AAV5 antibodies were the least prevalent in both the serum and SF. We next evaluated the impact of B-cell depletion on anti-AAV antibodies in rheumatoid arthritis patients who received one or two courses of the anti-CD20 antibody rituximab as part of their disease management. A drop of NAb titer was observed in a subset of those subjects carrying NAb titers ≤1:1000; however, only in a minority of subjects titers dropped below 1:5. This work provides insights into strategies to overcome the limitation of pre-existing humoral immunity to AAV vectors.

Gene therapy for haemophilia: a long and winding road.

BACKGROUND: Cure, or improvement of disease phenotype, has been a long-term goal in the treatment of haemophilia. An obvious strategy for achieving this goal is the use of gene therapy. OBJECTIVES: This paper summarises prior and current clinical trials of gene therapy for haemophilia A and B, and briefly describes additional strategies in pre-clinical development. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: Approximately 50 human subjects with severe haemophilia A or B have been enrolled in seven different trials of gene therapy. These have used plasmids, retroviral, adenoviral, and AAV vectors, directed to autologous fibroblasts, skeletal muscle, liver, and other target cell types accessed by intravenous injection of vector. Four separate trials have used AAV vectors, three of these targeting liver. Data from animal models suggest that several different gene replacement strategies may eventually yield long-term expression of factor at therapeutic levels, and that in situ correction of gene defects in hepatocytes may eventually be a therapeutic option.

Prevention of spontaneous bleeding in dogs with haemophilia A and haemophilia B.

Dogs with haemophilia A or haemophilia B exhibit spontaneous bleeding comparable with the spontaneous bleeding phenotype that occurs in humans with severe haemophilia. The phenotypic and genotypic characteristics of haemophilic dogs have been well-described, and such dogs are suitable for testing prophylactic protein replacement therapy and gene transfer strategies. In dogs with haemophilia, long-term effects on spontaneous bleeding frequency (measured over years) can be used as an efficacy endpoint in such studies. Although complete correction of coagulopathy has not been achieved, published data show that prophylactic factor replacement therapy and gene transfer can markedly reduce the frequency of spontaneous bleeding in haemophilic dogs. Further studies are currently ongoing.

Gene therapy in haemophilia--going for cure?

Traditional treatment for haemophilia consists of bolus infusion of the missing coagulation factor, either prophylactically or on demand, but is complicated by the development of inhibitory antibodies to the infused factor. In those cases, as well as in patients with platelet defects or factor VII (FVII) deficiency, recombinant human activated FVII has been successfully used, but carries the disadvantage of a short plasma half-life. As an alternative, emerging methodology based on gene transfer may be utilized to provide effective haemostasis in patients with coagulation defects. The goal of this article is to introduce the novel concept of continuous expression of activated FVII from a donated gene for the treatment of haemophilia, and to review the safety and efficacy data that have been produced so far by this approach in small and large animal models.

Special lectures in haemophilia management.

SUMMARY: During the last two decades major advances have been achieved in the management of haemophilia. Modern approaches aimed at preventing the recurrent bleedings and their sequelae have been widely adopted. Major challenges of intensive treatment regimens employed today, such a short half life of haemophilia therapeutics with a need for frequent injections and the risk of inhibitor, encourage further development towards the production of factor concentrates with prolonged efficacy and reduced immunogenicity. Intensive research work on gene therapy aimed at ultimate cure of haemophilia by the restoration of missing factor FVIII (FVIII) and factor IX (FIX) production is ongoing. The current issues of gene therapy and mechanisms, modifying the host immune response to the FVIII and FIX transgene material and the coagulation factors expressed are the topic of the Arosenius lecture by Katherine High. Despite an extensive research on mechanisms leading to inhibitor development, the real reason of these serious complications of haemophilia therapy still remains unclear. Alessandro Gringeri will discuss the immunogenicity of plasma derived FVIII (pd FVIII) and recombinant FVIII (rFVIII) concentrates as one of potential, treatment related, and probably 'modifiable' risk factors for inhibitor development. The SIPPET study--a new prospective, randomised study aimed to reveal real incidence of inhibitors in patients treated with either pdFVIII or rFVIII will be presented.

Generation of a novel factor IX with augmented clotting activities in vitro and in vivo.

BACKGROUND: Hemophilia B is an X-linked inherited disorder caused by the lack of functional factor IX (FIX). Currently, treatment of hemophilia B is performed by intravenous infusion of plasma-derived or recombinant FIX. OBJECTIVE: In an effort to reduce factor usage and cost, we investigated the potential use of FIX variants with enhanced specific clotting activity. METHODS: Seven recombinant FIX variants using alanine replacement were generated and assayed for their activity in vitro and in vivo. RESULTS: One variant containing three substitutions (V86A/E277A/R338A, FIX-Triple) exhibited 13-fold higher specific clotting activity and a 10-fold increased affinity for human FVIIIa compared with FIX-wild-type (FIX-WT) and was thus investigated systematically in vivo. Liver-specific FIX-Triple gene expression following hydrodynamic plasmid delivery revealed a 3.5-fold higher specific clotting activity compared with FIX-WT. Human FIX-Triple and FIX-WT knock-in mice were generated and it was confirmed that FIX-Triple has 7-fold higher specific clotting activity than FIX-WT under normal physiological conditions. Protein infusion of FIX-Triple into hemophilia B mice resulted in greater improvement of hemostasis than that achieved with FIX-WT. Moreover, tail-vein administration of a serotype 8 recombinant Adeno-associated vector (AAV8) expressing either FIX-WT or FIX-Triple in hemophilia B mice demonstrated a 7-fold higher specific clotting activity of FIX-Triple than FIX-WT. CONCLUSIONS: Our results indicate that the FIX-Triple variant exhibits significantly enhanced clotting activity relative to FIX-WT due to tighter binding to FVIIIa, as demonstrated both in vitro and in vivo. Therefore, FIX-Triple is a good candidate for further evaluation in protein replacement therapy as well as gene-based therapeutic strategies.

High AAV vector purity results in serotype- and tissue-independent enhancement of transduction efficiency.

The purity of adeno-associated virus (AAV) vector preparations has important implications for both safety and efficacy of clinical gene transfer. Early-stage screening of candidates for AAV-based therapeutics ideally requires a purification method that is flexible and also provides vectors comparable in purity and potency to the prospective investigational product manufactured for clinical studies. The use of cesium chloride (CsCl) gradient-based protocols provides the flexibility for purification of different serotypes; however, a commonly used first-generation CsCl-based protocol was found to result in AAV vectors containing large amounts of protein and DNA impurities and low transduction efficiency in vitro and in vivo. Here, we describe and characterize an optimized, second-generation CsCl protocol that incorporates differential precipitation of AAV particles by polyethylene glycol, resulting in higher yield and markedly higher vector purity that correlated with better transduction efficiency observed with several AAV serotypes in multiple tissues and species. Vectors purified by the optimized CsCl protocol were found to be comparable in purity and functional activity to those prepared by more scalable, but less flexible serotype-specific purification processes developed for manufacture of clinical vectors, and are therefore ideally suited for pre-clinical studies supporting translational research.

AAV-mediated gene transfer for the treatment of hemophilia B: problems and prospects.

Adeno-associated viral vector-mediated gene transfer of coagulation factor IX to the skeletal muscle or to liver has resulted in sustained correction of hemophilia B in mice and dogs. The two initial phase I/II AAV clinical trials for hemophilia B, delivering a factor IX cDNA to skeletal muscle or liver, showed no serious adverse events. Although the muscle trial failed to achieve a therapeutic level of factor IX in the circulation, long-term expression of clotting factor was demonstrated on muscle biopsies taken up to 3 years after vector injection. Administration of vector to liver via the hepatic artery identified a therapeutic dose, which agreed closely with the doses predicted by studies in hemophilic dogs. However, expression in human subjects lasted for only a period of weeks, followed by a gradual decline in factor IX levels accompanied by a self-limited, asymptomatic rise and fall in liver enzymes. Immune responses to vector capsid may account for this difference in outcome between humans and other species. Here we review the results from both preclinical and clinical studies of adeno-associated viral vector gene transfer for hemophilia B, and the problems that have been identified and that must be overcome to achieve successful transduction and sustained expression.

A viable mouse model of factor X deficiency provides evidence for maternal transfer of factor X.

BACKGROUND: Activated factor X (FXa) is a vitamin K-dependent serine protease that plays a pivotal role in blood coagulation by converting prothrombin to thrombin. There are no reports of humans with complete deficiency of FX, and knockout of murine F10 is embryonic or perinatal lethal. OBJECTIVE: We sought to generate a viable mouse model of FX deficiency. METHODS: We used a socket-targeting construct to generate F10-knockout mice by eliminating F10 exon 8 (knockout allele termed F10(tm1Ccmt), abbreviated as '-'; wild-type '+'), and a plug-targeting construct to generate mice expressing a FX variant with normal antigen levels but low levels of FX activity [4-9% normal in humans carrying the defect, Pro343-->Ser, termed FX Friuli (mutant allele termed F10(tm2Ccmt), abbreviated as F)]. RESULTS: F10 knockout mice exhibited embryonic or perinatal lethality. In contrast, homozygous Friuli mice [F10 (F/F)] had FX activity levels of approximately 5.5% (sufficient to rescue both embryonic and perinatal lethality), but developed age-dependent iron deposition and cardiac fibrosis. Interestingly, F10 (-/F) mice with FX activity levels of 1-3% also showed complete rescue of lethality. Further study of this model provides evidence supporting a role of maternal FX transfer in the embryonic survival. CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrate that, while complete absence of FX is incompatible with murine survival, minimal FX activity as low as 1-3% is sufficient to rescue the lethal phenotype. This viable low-FX mouse model will facilitate the development of FX-directed therapies as well as investigation of the FX role in embryonic development.

Progress and prospects: gene therapy clinical trials (part 2).

This is the second part of a review summarizing progress and prospects in gene therapy clinical research. Twenty key diseases/strategies are succinctly described and commented on by leaders in the field. This part includes clinical trials for skin diseases, neurological disorders, HIV/AIDS, ornithine transcarbamylase deficiency, alpha(1)-antitrypsin deficiency, haemophilia and cancer.

A novel missense mutation responsible for factor VII deficiency in research Beagle colonies.

BACKGROUND: Canine factor VII (cFVII) deficiency, an autosomal recessive trait originally identified in research Beagles, is associated with a mild to moderate bleeding tendency. OBJECTIVE: Our aim was to identify and characterize the mutation causing cFVII deficiency. METHODS: In order to sequence the coding regions of the cFVII gene, we cloned the cFVII cDNA. Genomic DNA and plasma from FVII-deficient Beagles and obligate carriers were utilized. RESULTS: In all FVII-deficient dogs, we identified a single causative G to A missense mutation in exon 5, encoding the second epidermal growth factor-like domain, resulting in substitution of glycine 96 by glutamic acid, with plasma FVII coagulant activity of

Role of the gamma-carboxyglutamic acid domain of activated factor X in the presence of calcium during inhibition by antithrombin-heparin.

BACKGROUND: Factor (F)Xa has 11 gamma-carboxylated glutamic acid (Gla) residues that are involved in calcium-dependent membrane binding. The serpin antithrombin (AT) is an important physiological regulator of FXa activity in an inhibition reaction that is enhanced by heparin. Recently, Rezaie showed that calcium further enhanced the heparin-catalyzed AT inhibition of FXa by promoting 'ternary complex' formation, and these results showed a role for the gamma-carboxyl-glutamate (Gla)-domain of FXa. OBJECTIVES: In this study, we used recombinant FXa mutants to assess the role of individual Gla residues in augmenting or antagonizing the AT-heparin inhibition reaction in the presence of calcium. RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS: In the absence of heparin, AT inhibition of plasma and the recombinant FXas were essentially equivalent. Similar to plasma-derived FXa, calcium increased about 3-fold the inhibition rate of wild-type recombinant FXa by AT-heparin over that in the presence of EDTA. Interestingly, three different effects were found with the recombinant FXa Gla-mutants for AT-heparin inhibition: (i) Gla-->Asp 14 and 29 were enhanced without calcium; (ii) Gla-->Asp 16 and 26 were not enhanced by calcium; and (iii) Gla-->Asp 19 was essentially the same as wild-type recombinant FXa. These results support a theory that mutating individual Gla residues in FXa alters the calcium-induced conformational changes in the Gla region and affects the antithrombin-heparin inhibition reaction.

Lack of germline transmission of vector sequences following systemic administration of recombinant AAV-2 vector in males.

A potential consequence of systemic administration of viral vectors is the inadvertent introduction of foreign DNA into recipient germ cells. To evaluate the safety of in vivo recombinant adeno-associated virus (rAAV) mediated gene transfer approaches for hemophilia B, we explored the risk of germline transmission of vector sequences following intramuscular (IM) injection of rAAV in four species of male animals (mouse, rat, rabbit and dog). In vector biodistribution studies in mice and rats, there is a dose-dependent increase in the likelihood that vector sequences can be detected in gonadal DNA using a sensitive PCR technique. However, in dogs DNA extracted from semen is negative for vector sequences. To address this discrepancy, studies were done in rabbits, and both semen and testicular DNAs were analyzed for the presence of vector sequences. These studies showed that no AAV vector sequences were detected in DNA extracted from rabbit semen samples collected at time points ranging from 7 to 90 days following IM injection of 1 x 10(13) vector genomes rAAV (vg) per kg. In contrast, DNA extracted from gonadal tissue was positive for vector sequences, but the positive signals diminished in number and strength with time. By FISH analysis, AAV signals were localized to the testis basement membrane and the interstitial space; no intracellular signal was observed. We observed similar findings following hepatic artery administration of rAAV in rats and dogs, suggesting that our findings are independent of the route of administration of vector. Attempts to transduce isolated murine spermatogonia directly with AAV-lacZ were unsuccessful. In clinical studies human subjects injected IM with an AAV vector at doses up to 2 x 10(12) vg/kg have shown no evidence of vector sequences in semen. Together, these studies suggest that rAAV introduced into skeletal muscle or the hepatic artery does not transduce male germ cells efficiently. We conclude that the risk of inadvertent germline transmission of vector sequences following IM or hepatic artery injection of AAV-2 vectors is extremely low.

Muscle-directed gene transfer and transient immune suppression result in sustained partial correction of canine hemophilia B caused by a null mutation.

The X-linked bleeding disorder hemophilia B is caused by absence of functional blood coagulation factor IX (F9) and can be treated by adeno-associated viral (AAV) mediated gene transfer to skeletal muscle. The safety of this approach is currently being evaluated in a phase I clinical trial. Efficacy of this and several other gene therapy strategies has been addressed in hemophilia B dogs, an important preclinical model of the disease. While previously published data demonstrated sustained expression of canine F9 in dogs with a missense mutation in the gene F9, we show here that AAV-mediated canine F9 gene transfer to skeletal muscle of hemophilia B dogs carrying a null mutation of F9 (causing an early stop codon and an unstable mRNA) results in induction of inhibitory anti-canine F9 at comparable vector doses (1 x 10(12) vector genomes/kg). Thus, the risk of inhibitor formation following AAV-mediated F9 gene therapy may be influenced by the nature of the underlying mutation in F9. Transient immune suppression with cyclophosphamide at the time of vector administration blocked formation of anti-canine F9 antibodies in the one animal treated with this approach. Treatment with this combination of gene transfer and transient immune modulation has resulted in sustained expression (>8 months) of canine F9 at levels sufficient for partial correction of coagulation parameters.

Risk and prevention of anti-factor IX formation in AAV-mediated gene transfer in the context of a large deletion of F9.

The safety of several gene therapy approaches for treatment of the severe, X-linked bleeding disorder hemophilia is currently being evaluated in early phase clinical trials. One strategy seeks to correct deficiency of functional coagulation factor IX (hemophilia B) by intramuscular (IM) administration of an adeno-associated viral (AAV) vector. A potentially serious complication of any treatment for hemophilia is formation of inhibitory antibodies against the coagulation factor protein, a risk that increases in the setting of null mutations in the factor IX gene (F9). Here, we describe hemophilia B mice with a large F9 deletion that form inhibitors within 1 to 2 months after IM administration of an AAV vector expressing mouse F9 or after repeated intravenous infusion of mouse F9 concentrate. In both cases, inhibitors are primarily IgG1 immunoglobulins representing a Th2-driven humoral immune response. We further demonstrate that anti-mouse F9 antibody formation in the gene-based approach can be reduced by transient immune modulation at the time of vector administration. Moreover, this maneuver resulted in complete absence of anti-mouse F9 and sustained expression of functional mouse F9 in some hemophilia B mice, particularly in those animals treated with the immunosuppressive drug cyclophosphamide. These data have direct relevance for design of clinical trials and strategies aimed at avoiding immune responses against a secreted transgene product.

Intravenous administration of an E1/E3-deleted adenoviral vector induces tolerance to factor IX in C57BL/6 mice.

Inbred immunocompetent C57BL/6 mice have been a favored strain to study transgene expression of human blood coagulation factor IX (hF.IX) from viral vectors because systemic expression of the secreted protein is not limited by antibody responses following intravenous (i.v.) injection of vector. For example, i.v. injection of an adenoviral (Ad) vector results in sustained expression of hF.IX in normal or hemophilic C57BL/6 mice, while anti-hF.IX antibodies rapidly emerge in other strains (Gene Therapy 4: 473; Blood 91: 784). To investigate these observations further, we injected naive C57BL/6 mice and C57BL/6 mice with pre-existing anti-hF.IX with Ad-hF.IX vector via peripheral vein. All mice expressed hF.IX antigen without detectable anti-hF.IX, even when challenged with hF.IX in different immunogenic settings at later time points. Moreover, in mice with pre-existing immunity, anti-hF.IX titers diminished to undetectable levels after i.v. administration of Ad-hF.IX. Lymphocytes from mice that had received Ad-hF.IX i.v. failed to proliferate when stimulated with hF.IX in vitro after the animals had been repeatedly challenged with hF.IX protein formulated in complete Freund's adjuvant. Thus, absence of anti-hF.IX in C57BL/6 mice after i.v. injection of Ad vector is not due to ignorance to the foreign transgene product. Similar experiments in other strains showed that immune tolerance to hF.IX does not correlate with the strain haplotype or expression of IL-10 cytokine. Given the well-documented immunogenicity of the first-generation adenoviral vector, data from C57BL/6 mice may therefore grossly underestimate immunological consequences in certain gene therapy protocols.

Gene therapy: a 2001 perspective.

In the past year, three clinical trials of gene therapy for haemophilia have been initiated. Years of preclinical studies have culminated in translation of research findings into the clinical arena. It is too early to predict which, if any, of these strategies will show efficacy. This paper will review basic aspects of gene therapy for haemophilia and will briefly outline current clinical trials. The three clinical trials all share a dose escalation design. The ongoing trial for haemophilia B involves the intramuscular administration of an adeno-associated virus (AAV) vector expressing human factor IX. In preclinical studies, this strategy has produced therapeutic levels of circulating factor IX in haemophilic mice and dogs.