Evaluation of false positive responses by mass spectrometry and ion mobility spectrometry for the detection of trace explosives in complex samples.

Secondary electrospray ionization-ion mobility-time of flight mass spectrometry (SESI-IM-TOFMS) was used to evaluate common household products and food ingredients for any mass or mobility responses that produced false positives for explosives. These products contained ingredients which shared the same mass and mobility drift time ranges as the analyte ions for common explosives. The results of this study showed that the vast array of compounds in these products can cause either mass or mobility false positive responses. This work also found that two ingredients caused either enhanced or reduced ionization of the target analytes. Another result showed that an IMS can provide real-time separation of ion species that impede accurate mass identifications due to overlapping isotope peak patterns. The final result of this study showed that, when mass and mobility values were used to identify an ion, no false responses were found for the target explosives. The wider implication of these results is that the possibility exists for even greater occurrences of false responses from complex mixtures found in common products. Neither IMS nor MS alone can provide 100% assurance from false responses. IMS, due to its low cost, ease of operation, rugged reliability, high sensitivity and tunable selectivity, will remain the field method of choice for the near future but, when combined with MS, can also reduce the false positive rate for explosive analyses.

Comparison of reactant and analyte ions for 6³Nickel, corona discharge, and secondary electrospray ionization sources with ion mobility-mass spectrometry.

(63)Nickel radioactive ionization ((63)Ni) is the most common and widely used ion source for ion mobility spectrometry (IMS). Regulatory, financial, and operational concerns with this source have promoted recent development of non-radioactive sources, such as corona discharge ionization (CD), for stand-alone IMS systems. However, there has been no comparison of the negative ion species produced by all three sources in the literature. This study compares the negative reactant and analyte ions produced by three sources on an ion mobility-mass spectrometer: conventional (63)Ni, CD, and secondary electrospray ionization (SESI). Results showed that (63)Ni and SESI produced the same reactant ion species while CD produced only the nitrate monomer and dimer ions. The analyte ions produced by each ion source were the same except for the CD source which produced a different ion species for the explosive RDX than either the (63)Ni or SESI source. Accurate and reproducible reduced mobility (K0) values, including several values reported here for the first time, were found for each explosive with each ion source. Overall, the SESI source most closely reproduced the reactant ion species and analyte ion species profiles for (63)Ni. This source may serve as a non-radioactive, robust, and flexible alternative for (63)Ni.

Accurate and reproducible ion mobility measurements for chemical standard evaluation.

Chemical standards are used to calibrate ion mobility spectrometers (IMS) for accurate and precise identification of target compounds. Research over the past 30 years has identified several positive and negative mode compounds that have been used as IMS standards. However, the IMS research community has not come to a consensus on any chemical compound(s) for use as a reference standard. Also, the reported K(0) values for the same compound analyzed on several IMS systems can be inconsistent. In many cases, mobility has not been correlated with a mass identification of an ion. The primary goal of this work was to provide mass-identified mobility (K(0)) values for standards. The results of this work were mass-identified K(0) values for positive and negative mode IMS chemical standards. The negative mode results of this study showed that TNT is a viable negative mode reference standard. New temperature-dependent K(0) values were found by characterizing drift gas temperature and water content; several examples were found of temperature-dependent changes for the ion species of several standards. The overall recommendation of this study is that proposed IMS standards should have temperature-dependent K(0) values quoted in the literature instead of using a single K(0) value for a compound.

Structural analysis of phosphatidylcholines by post-source decay matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry.

The utility of post-source decay (PSD) matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF-MS) was investigated for the structural analysis of phosphatidylcholine (PC). PC did not produce detectable negative molecular ion from MALDI, but positive ions were observed as both [PC+H](+) and [PC+Na](+). The PSD spectra of the protonated PC species contained only one fragment corresponding to the head group (m/z 184), while the sodiated precursors produced many fragment ions, including those derived from the loss of fatty acids. The loss of fatty acid from the C-1 position (sn-1) of the glycerol backbone was favored over the loss of fatty acid from the C-2 position (sn-2). Ions emanating from the fragmentation of the head group (phosphocholine) included [PC+Na-59](+), [PC+Na-183](+) and [PC+Na-205](+), which corresponded to the loss of trimethylamine (TMA), non-sodiated choline phosphate and sodiated choline phosphate, respectively. Other fragments reflecting the structure of the head group were observed at m/z 183, 146 and 86. The difference in the fragmentation patterns for the PSD of [PC+Na](+) compared to [PC+H](+) is attributed to difference in the binding of Na(+) and H(+). While the proton binds to a negatively charged oxygen of the phosphate group, the sodium ion can be associated with several regions of the PC molecule. Hence, in the sodiated PC, intermolecular interaction of the negatively charged oxygen of the phosphate group, along with sodium association at multiple sites, can lead to a complex and characteristic ion fragmentation pattern. The preferential loss of sn-1 fatty acid group could be explained by the formation of an energetically favorable six-member ring intermediate, as apposed to the five-member ring intermediate formed prior to the loss of sn-2 fatty acid group.

Electrospray ionization with ambient pressure ion mobility separation and mass analysis by orthogonal time-of-flight mass spectrometry.

Rapid screening and identification of drug and other mixtures are possible using a novel ambient pressure high-resolution ion mobility (APIMS) orthogonal reflector time-of-flight mass spectrometer (TOFMS). Departing ions from the APIMS drift tube traversed a pressure interface between the APIMS and TOFMS where they were subjected to numerous gas collisions that could produce selective fragmentation. By increasing the accelerating field in the pressure interface region, the ions generated using water-cooled electrospray ionization (ESI) underwent collision-induced dissociation (CID). Mixtures of ESI ions were separated by APIMS based on their respective size-to-charge (s/z) ratios while CID and analysis of mass-to-charge (m/z) ratios occurred in the pressure interface and TOFMS. Product ions that were formed in this pressure interface region could be readily assigned to precursor ions by matching the mobility drift times. This process was demonstrated by the examination of a mixture of amphetamines and the resulting fragmentation patterns of the mobility-separated precursor ion species [M + H](+).

Electrospray ionization high-resolution ion mobility spectrometry for the detection of organic compounds, 1. Amino acids.

Our aim in this investigation was to demonstrate the potential of the high-resolution electrospray ionization ion mobility spectrometry (ESI-IMS) technique as an analytical separation tool in analyzing biomolecular mixtures to pursue astrobiological objectives of searching for the chemical signatures of life during an in-situ exploration of solar system bodies. Because amino acids represent the basic building blocks of life, we used common amino acids to conduct the first part of our investigation, which is being reported here, to demonstrate the feasibility of using the ESI-IMS technique for detection of the chemical signatures of life. The ion mobilities of common amino acids were determined by electrospray ionization ion mobility spectrometry using three different drift gases (N2, Ar, and CO2). We demonstrated that the selectivity can be vastly improved in ion mobility spectroscopy (IMS) in detecting organic molecules by using different drift gases. When a judicial choice of drift gas is made, a vastly improved separation of two different amino acid ions resulted. It was found that each of the studied amino acids could be uniquely identified from the others, with the exception of alanine and glycine, which were never separable by more then 0.1 ms. This unique identification is a result of the different polarizabilities of the various drift gases. In addition, a better separation was achieved by changing the drift voltage in successive experimental runs without significantly degrading the resolution. We also report the result of our analysis of liquid samples containing mixtures of amino acids.

Analysis of plant phosphatidylcholines by matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry.

The use of matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) time-of-flight (TOF) mass spectrometry (MS) for the quantitative determination of phospholipid (PL) molecular species has been problematic, due primarily to the formation of multiple signals (corresponding to the molecular ion and other adducts) for some classes of PL. For example, analysis of phosphatidylcholine (PC) yielded signals that corresponded to protonated and sodiated molecules in the MALDI spectrum. The resulting spectral overlap among various molecular species (e.g. [PC(16:0/18:2) + Na] and [PC(18:2/18:3)]) made it impossible to ascertain their relative amounts using this technique. Other spectral ambiguities existed among different structural isomers, such as PC(18:1/18:1) and PC(18:0/18:2). We determined that molecular species could be resolved by MALDI-TOFMS by first removing the polar head (e.g. phosphocholine) from the phospholipid to effect production of only the sodiated molecules of the corresponding diacylglycerols (DAGs). Analysis of the resulting spectrum allowed unequivocal determination of the molecular species profile of PC from potato tuber and soybean. Estimation of fatty acid composition based on the molecular species determined by MALDI-TOFMS analysis agreed with that from GC-FID analysis. Post-source decay (PSD) was used to resolve standard isomers of PC (e.g. 18:1/18:1 vs. 18:0/18:2). Our results indicated that PSD is a useful approach for resolving structural isomers of PL molecular species.

Evaluation of opiate separation by high-resolution electrospray ionization-ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry.

The separation of opiates and the primary metabolites was evaluated with ESI-IMS/MS. Seven opiate molecules were analyzed, and spectra were shown for each compound. The IMS separation of two isomers (morphine and norcodeine) was shown with baseline separation. Differences in the mobilities were found for the nonacetylated, monoacetylated, and biacetylated compounds. In this study, two primary findings are reported. First, IMS can easily separate metabolic isomers, and second, the two-dimensional separation capability of IMS/MS can be employed to confidently identify and separate both the opiates and metabolites. Although previous IMS studies have shown the separation of isomers, this is the first example to show the capability of IMS to separate metabolic isomers (within 70 s), a significant advantage in high-throughput screening for pharmacokinetic studies. Second, the monoacetylated and biacetylated compounds were found to form more compact ions for the sodium adducts in comparison to the protonated molecular ions. On the basis of the mobilities, information on structures and conformation can be deduced when sodium and protonated ions are compared.

Evaluation of suspected interferents for TNT detection by ion mobility spectrometry.

The use of ion mobility spectrometry systems to detect explosives in high security situations creates a need to determine compounds that interfere and may compromise accurate detection. This is the first study to identify possible interfering air contaminants common in airport settings by IMS. Seventeen suspected contaminants from four major sources were investigated. Due to the ionization selectivity gained by employing chloride reactant ion chemistry, only 7 of the 17 compounds showed an IMS response. Of those seven compounds, only 4,6-dinitro-o-cresol (4,6DNOC) was found to have a similar mobility to 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT) with K(o) values of 1.55 and 1.50 cm(2) V(-1) s(-1), respectively. Although baseline resolution between TNT and 4,6DNOC was not achieved, the drift time for TNT was still easily identified. Alkyl-nitrated phenols, due to acidic fog, responded the strongest in the IMS. The effect of contamination on TNT sensitivity was investigated. Charge competition between TNT and 2,4-dinitrophenol (2,4DNP) was found to occur and to effect TNT sensitivity.

Secondary electrospray ionization ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry of illicit drugs.

A secondary electrospray ionization (SESI) method was developed as a nonradioactive ionization source for ion mobility spectrometry (IMS). This SESI method relied on the gas-phase interaction between charged particles created by electrospray ionization (ESI) and neutral gaseous sample molecules. Mass spectrometry (MS) was used as the detection method after ion mobility separation for ion identification. Preliminary investigations focussed on understanding the ionization process of SESI. The performance of ESI-IMS and SESI-IMS for illicit drug detection was evaluated by determining the analytical figures of merit. In general, SESI had a higher ionization efficiency for small volatile molecules compared with the electrospray method. The potential of developing a universal interface for both GC- and LC-MS with an addition stage of mobility separation was demonstrated.

Separation of isomeric peptides using electrospray ionization/high-resolution ion mobility spectrometry.

In this paper, the first examples of baseline separation of isomeric macromolecules by electrospray ionization/ion mobility spectrometry (ESI/IMS) at atmospheric pressure are presented. The behavior of a number of different isomeric peptides in the IMS was investigated using nitrogen as a drift gas. The IMS was coupled to a quadrupole mass spectrometer, which was used for identification and selective detection of the electrosprayed ions. The mobility data were used to determine their average collision cross sections. The gas-phase ions of isomeric peptides were found to have different collision cross sections. In all cases, doubly charged ions exhibited significantly (8-20%) larger collision cross sections than the respective singly charged species. The analysis of mixtures of the isomeric peptides clearly demonstrated the capability of IMS to separate gas-phase peptide ions due to small differences in their conformational structures, which cannot be determined by mass spectrometry. An actual resolving power of 80 was achieved for two doubly charged reversed sequenced pentapeptides. Baseline separation was provided for ions differing by only 2.5% in their measured collision cross sections; partial separation was shown for isomeric ions exhibiting differences as small as 1.1%.

Separation of amino acids by ion mobility spectrometry.

The mobilities of the 20 common amino acids were determined by electrospray ionization ion mobility spectrometry. It was found that each amino acid had a different drift time and hence a different reduced mobility constant K0. This difference in drift time was less than 0.1 ms in many cases. With the instrument used in this study it would not be possible to resolve mixtures of some of the amino acids. It would however be possible to determine any single amino acid. In addition, the detection limits were determined for the 20 amino acids. They ranged from 50 to 700 pg. This indicates that the detection limits were less than 3 pmol for all of the amino acids and that many amino acids had detection limits less than 1 pmol.

Analysis of explosives using electrospray ionization/ion mobility spectrometry (ESI/IMS).

The analysis of explosives with ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) directly from aqueous solutions was shown for the first time using an electrospray ionization technique. The IMS was operated in the negative mode at 250 degrees C and coupled with a quadrupole mass spectrometer to identify the observed IMS peaks. The IMS response characteristics of trinitrotoluene (TNT), 2,4-dinitrotoluene (2,4-DNT), 2-amino-4,6-dinitrotoluene (2-ADNT), 4-nitrotoluene (4-NT), trinitrobenzene (TNB), cyclo-1,3,5-trimethylene-2,4,6-trinitramine (RDX), cyclo-tetramethylene-tetranitramine (HMX), dinitro-ethyleneglycol (EGDN) and nitroglycerine (NG) were investigated. Several breakdown products, predominantly NO(2)(-) and NO(3)(-), were observed in the low-mass region. Nevertheless, all compounds with the exception of NG produced at least one ion related to the intact molecule and could therefore be selectively detected. For RDX and HMX the [M+Cl(-)](-) cluster ion was the main peak and the signal intensities could be greatly enhanced by the addition of small amounts of sodium chloride to the sprayed solutions. The reduced mobility constants (K(0)) were in good agreement with literature data obtained from experiments where the explosives were introduced into the IMS from the vapor phase. The detection limits were in the range of 15-190 microg l(-1) and all calibration curves showed good linearity. A mixture of TNT, RDX and HMX was used to demonstrate the high separation potential of the IMS system. Baseline separation of the three compounds was attained within a total analysis time of 6.4 s.

Atmospheric pressure ion mobility spectrometry of protonated and sodiated peptides.

A number of peptides were studied with electrospray ionization--ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry (ESI-IMS/MS). The ion mobility data were used to calculate the average collision cross sections of the different detected peptide ions in the nitrogen drift gas. By comparing the cross sections of related ions, structural information about the most probable location of the charge and the gas-phase ion conformations was deduced. For bradykinin and kemptide, a significant mobility difference between protonated and sodiated species (where sodium replaced a proton in singly and doubly charged peptides) was demonstrated. Surprisingly, the doubly charged sodiated peptides had a smaller collision cross section than the doubly charged protonated ones leading to the conclusion that the gas-phase conformations of these ions are different with respect to intramolecular interactions.

Surface ionization ion mobility spectrometry.

A surface ionization (SI) source was designed and constructed for ion mobility spectrometry (IMS). Compared with a conventional (63)Ni source, the surface ionization source is as simple and reliable, has an extended dynamic response range, is more selective in response, and does not have regulatory problems associated with radioactive ionization sources. The performance of this SI-IMS was evaluated with several different classes of compounds. Triethylamine was employed for studying the behavior of the ionization source under different source conditions and gaseous environments. Amines, tobacco alkaloids, and triazine herbicides were also investigated. Picogram level detection limits were achieved for target compounds with a response dynamic range of 5 orders of magnitude. Selective monitoring by IMS was also demonstrated. While the surface ionization source does not have the universality of response that is obtained with a (63)Ni ionization source, it is an excellent nonradioactive alternative for the ionization and ion mobility detection of those compounds to which it responds.

Gas chromatography.

This review of the fundamental developments in gas chromatography (GC) includes articles published from 1996 and 1997 and an occasional citation prior to 1996. The literature was reviewed principally using CA Selects for Gas Chromatography from Chemical Abstracts Service, and some significant articles from late 1997 may be missing from the review. In addition, the online SciSearch Database (Institute for Scientific Information) capability was used to abstract review articles or books. As with the prior recent reviews, emphasis has been given to the identification and discussion of selected developments, rather than a presentation of a comprehensive literature search, now available widely through computer-based resources. During the last two years, several themes emerged from a review of the literature. Multidimensional gas chromatography has undergone transformation encompassing a broad range of activity, including attempts to establish methods using chromatographic principles rather than a totally empirical approach. Another trend noted was a comparatively large effort in chromatographic theory through modeling efforts; these presumably became resurgent with inexpensive and powerful computing tools. Finally, an impressive level of activity was noted through the themes highlighted in this review, and this was particularly true with detectors and field instruments.

Electrospray ionization high-resolution ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry.

A hybrid atmospheric pressure ion mobility spectrometer is described which exhibits resolving power approaching the diffusion limit for singly and multiply charged ions (over 200 for the most favorable case). Using an electrospray ionization source and a downstream quadrupole mass spectrometer with electron multiplier as detector, this ESI-IMS-MS instrument demonstrates the potential of IMS for rapid analytical separations with a resolving power similar to liquid chromatography. The first measurements of gas-phase mobility spectra of mass-identified multiply charged ions migrating at atmospheric pressure are reported. These spectra confirm that collision cross sections are strongly affected by charge state. Baseline separations of multiply charged states of cytochrome c and ubiquitin demonstrate the improved resolving power of this instrument compared with previous atmospheric pressure ion mobility spectrometers. The effects of electric potential, initial pulse duration, ion-molecule reactions, ion desolvation, Coulombic repulsion, electric field homogeneity, ion collection, and charge on the resolving power of this ion mobility spectrometer are discussed.