The use of presurgical psychological screening to predict the outcome of spine surgery.

BACKGROUND CONTEXT: Several previous studies have shown that psychosocial factors can influence the outcome of elective spine surgery. PURPOSE: The purpose of the current study was to determine how well a presurgical screening instrument could predict surgical outcome. STUDY DESIGN/SETTING: The study was conducted by staff of a psychologist's office. They performed preoperative screening for spine surgery candidates and collected the follow-up data. PATIENT SAMPLE: Presurgical screening and follow-up data collection was performed on 204 patients who underwent laminectomy/discectomy (n=118) or fusion (n=86) of the lumbar spine. OUTCOME MEASURES: The outcome measures used in the study were visual analog pain scales, the Oswestry Disability Questionnaire, and medication use. METHODS: A semi-structured interview and psychometric testing were used to identify specific, quantifiable psychological, and "medical" risk factors for poor surgical outcome. A presurgical psychological screening (PPS) scorecard was completed for each patient, assessing whether the patient had a high or low level of risk on these psychological and medical dimensions. Based on the scorecard, an overall surgical prognosis of "good," "fair," or "poor" was generated. RESULTS: Results showed spine surgery led to significant overall improvements in pain, functional ability, and medication use. Medical and psychological risk levels were significantly related to outcome, with the poorest results obtained by patients having both high psychological and medical risk. Further, the accuracy of PPS surgical prognosis in predicting overall outcome was 82%. Only 9 of 53 patients predicted to have poor outcome achieved fair or good results from spine surgery. CONCLUSIONS: These findings suggest that PPS should become a more routine part of the evaluation of chronic pain patients in whom spine surgery is being considered.

Reported pain during lumbar discography as a function of anular ruptures and disc degeneration. A re-analysis of 833 discograms.

STUDY DESIGN: This re-analysis was based on 833 computed tomography/discograms collected from 306 candidates for back surgery. OBJECTIVES: The goal was to test the hypothesis that outer anular ruptures are the main determinant of the pain of discography. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Previous analyses indicated univariate associations of pain with disc degeneration and anular ruptures. METHODS: If present, pain was classified as "exact", "similar", or "dissimilar" reproduction of the previously experienced pain. For each disc, ruptures and degeneration were separately evaluated by a four-point scale. Multiple logistic regression with random effects was used in the analysis. RESULTS: Outer anular ruptures were the only predictor of the responses "similar" and "exact". General disc degeneration was the only predictor of the response "dissimilar". There was no effect modification due to gender, age, and spinal level. CONCLUSIONS: During discography, the outer anulus appears to be the origin of pain reproduction.

Laser disc decompression. The importance of proper patient selection.

STUDY DESIGN: The value of adherence to selection criteria for laser disc decompression (LDD) was evaluated. A total of 204 patients who underwent LDDs were identified. Follow-up information could be obtained for 164 (80.8%) patients. Results were compared based on the selection criteria. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Laser disc decompression is a relatively new procedure. Few reports concerning outcome of LDD exist; and none deal specifically with patient selection. OBJECTIVE: This study compared the results of LDD performed among patients who met appropriate selection criteria with those who did not. Also, the value of discography in patient selection for LDD was investigated. METHODS: Two independent reviewers extracted data from patient charts. From this information, each patient was assigned to one of three groups: 1) those who met all selection criteria for LDD (leg pain, positive physical examination finding such motor, sensory, or reflex deficits, and/or straight leg raise, contained disc herniation confirmed by discography); 2) those who did not meet the selection criteria (had a normal physical examination, the presence of stenosis, spondylolisthesis, extruded disc fragment, leakage of discographic dye from the outer annulus, multiple prior lumbar surgeries); or 3) those who could not be assigned to either of the first two groups for reasons such as discography not being performed or inadequate physical examination data recorded in the chart. At 1 year follow-up, each patient was sent a questionnaire assessing outcome. Successful outcome was defined to be no subsequent lumbar surgery, the patient felt that LDD had helped, and if the patient was working before symptom onset, he was able to work at the time of follow-up. RESULTS: Among the 41 patients who met all selection criteria, the success rate was 70.7% (29/41); among patients who did not meet all the criteria, the success rate was only 28.6% (12/42); significantly less than in the first group (P < 0.005). Among patients who could not be assigned definitively to either of the first two groups, the success rate was 55.6% (45/81). Also, the success rate among patients with discographic confirmation of a contained disc herniation was significantly greater than among those who either did not have discography performed or extravasation of contrast was noted (70.7% vs. 44.4%, P < 0.035). CONCLUSIONS: These results emphasize the importance of strict adherence to appropriate selection criteria to obtain satisfactory results from LDD.

The relationship of facet tropism to degenerative disc disease.

The role of facet tropism (asymmetry) in the pathogenesis of degenerative disc disease is unknown, and several conflicting reports have been published. We studied this association using CT/discography performed at 324 lumbar levels (108 patients). The stage of disc degeneration as well as the patient's pain response upon discographic injection were scored using a standardized protocol. The facet angles were measured directly from the axial CT/discographic images and defined, in each case, as the angle formed by the facet orientation with respect to the midsagittal plane. The facet tropism angle was defined as the difference between the left and right facet angles at each disc level. The mean and standard deviation (SD) of the tropism angles were calculated. From this calculation, each pair of facet joints was classified as symmetric (within 1 SD of the mean), moderately asymmetric (between 1 and 2 SD), or severely asymmetric (beyond 2 SD of the mean). There were no differences in degree of disc degeneration or pain response with respect to the facet tropism. The total facet angle was also studied. The total facet angle was greater at the more caudal levels. The total angle size was not associated, however, with disc degeneration or pain provocation. These findings do not support the hypothesis that there is an association between facet tropism and degenerative lumbar disc disease.

The effect of sensory deprivation in the reduction of pain in patients with chronic low-back pain.

Patients who suffer from persistent pain for prolonged periods of time (6 months or more) are often influenced to an increasing extent by psychological factors. Patients begin to focus on their pain as the problem rather than its physical origin. This study evaluated the effectiveness of sensory deprivation in reducing pain in patients with chronic low-back pain. Sixty patients were divided into two groups of 30 patients each: One group underwent 1 hour of sensory deprivation; the other received a lecture on relaxation skills. In the group receiving sensory deprivation, statistically significant decreases in pain and stiffness were noted. Sensory deprivation is an effective treatment to reduce pain and thus interrupt the pain cycle in patients with chronic low-back pain.

Choice of lasers for minimally invasive spinal surgery.

Recently, there has been increased interest in less invasive spinal surgery techniques. This has led to the development of procedures such as automated percutaneous lumbar discectomy and arthroscopic microdiscectomy. Lasers are now used in many areas of medicine and may have applications in minimally invasive spinal surgery. A number of different laser systems have been evaluated for their effectiveness in removing disc tissue in the laboratory, but technical problems have limited their clinical use. Only the Nd:YAG (1,064 nm and 1,320 nm) and KTP (532 nm) systems have been used clinically. Unsuccessful clinical results were obtained with the 1,064 nm Nd:YAG, whereas the other two systems appeared to produce results similar to the present mechanical systems but required less time for disc removal. This paper discusses considerations for choosing a laser system for spinal applications and reviews the work performed in this area.

Techniques for lumbar discography and computed tomography/discography in clinical practice.

The technique for lumbar discography is not well standardized. To better understand lumbar pathology, we have developed a consistent, reproducible, and relatively simple procedure for lumbar discography. We describe our technique and discuss variables that may differ among individual lumbar discography procedures.

Pain provocation and disc deterioration by age. A CT/discography study in a low-back pain population.

The computed tomography (CT)/discograms and discographic pain provocation reports of 291 clinical patients, 790 discs (mean age, 38; range, 17-79) were collected. The CT/discograms were classified separating anular disruption and degeneration and recording the pain provoked during discography as no pain, dissimilar, similar, or exact reproduction of the patient's clinical pain. Nondegenerated discs usually were found to be painless, and deteriorated discs painful. The proportion of severely degenerated but painless discs increased with age, as did the discs producing dissimilar pain. This may help explain the poor correlation of low-back pain with radiographic degenerative changes reported in previous epidemiologic studies.

Disc deterioration in low-back syndromes. A prospective, multi-center CT/discography study.

Disc deterioration and pain provocation in different low-back pain syndromes was studied using computed tomography (CT) discography. Data were prospectively collected for 300 patients (816 discs). Patients were classified by their pre-discography diagnosis of disc herniation (DH), degenerated disc (DD), lumbar syndrome (LS), lumbar radicular syndrome (LRS), or other. The CT/discograms were classified by discographic pain response, the amount of degeneration and annular disruption. Eighty-two percent of DH patients, 80% of DD, 56% of LS, and 59% of LRS patients had both positive discographic pain provocation and moderate or severe disc deterioration. The study indicates that intradiscal pathology plays a major role in nonspecific low-back pain syndromes.

Discitis after discography.

A series of nine patients with post-discography discitis were evaluated to help delineate the clinical course. The most consistent sign was the marked exacerbation of neck or back pain. This then was followed by an elevated sedimentation rate at an average of 20 days, followed by a positive bone scan at an average of 33 days. Of note is that seven patients initially had negative bone scans at an average of 18 days. Five out of nine patients had changes on plain roentgenograms between 14 and 51 days after discography. Magnetic resonance imaging was performed in six patients; two of these patients were scanned twice. Three scans were negative and five were positive (2 patients initially had negative scans that later became positive). The course of lumbar discitis ranged from 8 to 11 weeks, and cervical discitis from 6 to 7 weeks, with the latter usually resulting in spontaneous fusion.

A comparison of CT/discography, pain response and radiographic disc height.

CT/discograms of 107 low-back patients were classified by annular degeneration, annular disruption, and pain response. These parameters were compared with the heights of the corresponding discs. Disc height correlated significantly with degenerative annular changes. Comparison of the painless and exact reproduction groups at the L5-S1 level showed a significant increase in exact pain reproduction in narrow discs compared with normal discs. Discs demonstrating slight degenerative changes were often painful but narrowing was detected only when degeneration increased to moderate or severe levels. Some severely degenerated discs were painless and only part of the severe group was narrow. Measuring disc height is a poor method for detecting early, painful degeneration changes.

Extraosseous spinal lesions mimicking disc disease.

To identify characteristics of patient presentation that would help distinguish extraosseous spinal tumors from the more common herniated disc, nine cases of intraspinal tumors were reviewed. These nine patients were identified in a group of 744 patients who presented with symptoms similar to disc herniation but failed to respond to conservative care and underwent spinal surgery. This study indicates that intraspinal tumor should be suspected in patients with the following characteristics: 1) painless neurological deficit; 2) night pain or pain which increases in the supine position; 3) pain disproportionate to that normally expected with lumbar disc disease; 4) no change in symptoms after successful surgery for herniated disc; 5) elevated spinal fluid protein; or 6) a teenager with symptoms of disc herniation. Myelography is an effective radiologic procedure for the diagnosis of spinal tumor but MRI should be equally effective if the procedure includes a scan of the conus as well as cauda equina.

Proplast reconstruction of iliac crest defects.

Proplast reconstruction of iliac crest defects resulting from bone grafts taken for anterior lumbar and cervical fusions is described. The procedure improves the cosmetic result, prevents postoperative muscle herniation and may decrease postoperative donor site pain. It is a simple procedure with low complication rate when performed in the manner described.

Anterior lumbar interbody fusion.

This is a report of 85 patients who underwent anterior lumbar interbody fusion (ALIF) for treatment of painful disc disruption (PDD) or symptomatic pseudarthrosis. The fusion rate was 80% by disc. The pseudarthrosis rate increased from 16% at L5-S1 to 21% and 31% at L4-5 and L3-4, respectively. There was a significant increase in pseudarthrosis rate in patients who smoked more than one pack per day. There was no difference in the fusion rate whether autogenous or cadaveric iliac crest graft or dowel versus tricortical block graft was used. Sixty-eight percent of patients were "able to work" after ALIF. The complication rate was low and retrograde ejaculation occurred in only one patient.

The relationship of pain provocation to lumbar disc deterioration as seen by CT/discography.

The CT/discographic findings from 225 discs in 91 low-back pain patients were compared to the pain provocation during the injection of contrast into the disc. The radiographic appearance of disc deterioration demonstrating disc degeneration and annular disruption of each disc was classified separately using a fourpoint scale: normal, slight, moderate, or severe. Pain reaction to the discogram at each level was recorded as follows: no pain, dissimilar pain, similar pain, or exact reproduction of the patient's clinical pain. This more precise analysis demonstrated a significant relationship between pain and deterioration of discs. The CT/discogram presents an axial view of the disc that allows a subgrouping of disc deterioration that can discriminate between peripheral deterioration (degeneration) and internal deterioration (disruption). The disruption supposedly occurs earlier and is more likely to be the source of exact pain reproduction.

Dallas discogram description. A new classification of CT/discography in low-back disorders.

A new classification method for CT/discography was developed. The Dallas discogram description (DDD) related five separate categories of information. Degeneration and annular disruption were regarded as separate phenomena. Additionally, provoked pain response, contrast volume, and miscellaneous information were recorded. Discogram findings of 59 patients with low-back and/or leg pain were graded according to the new method and compared with standard methods using routine anteroposterior and lateral discographic images. Findings from routine discography and CT/discography were graded and correlated with myelographic and plain computerized axial tomography (CAT) scans. This study demonstrated that the contrast-enhanced axial view provided by CT/discography served as a useful projection for demonstrating disc pathology. CT/discography analyzed according to DDD offered a more sensitive discriminator of disc degeneration from annular disruption (disc protrusion/leaking). This evaluation can be recommended as the procedure of choice when revision of spine surgery is considered or when there is an equivocal or negative correlation between clinical information and myelography or CAT scan.

Diagnostic studies in clinical practice.

In conclusion, it has become obvious that the diagnostic approach to the patient with low back pain is multidisciplinary in nature. The diagnostic and treatment modalities available to the spine surgeon in 1983 have been expanded greatly. No longer does the frustration of dealing with a nebulous realm of pain complaints involving the low back have be tolerated. Specific diagnoses can be made and treatment instituted. New, less invasive diagnostic techniques continue to evolve, including such things as nuclear magnetic resonance. In addition, the importance of diet, physical exercise, relaxation, and overall fitness has become generally accepted in the United States today. It has also become much easier to gain the patient's cooperation in regard to his or her responsibility in the treatment program.