Longitudinal comparison of dialysis access methods: risk factors for failure.

PURPOSE: To compare dialysis access patency rates and identify risk factors for failure. METHODS: All access procedures at our institution from 1987 to 1996 were reviewed. Primary procedures were surgically implanted dual-lumen central venous hemodialysis catheters (SIHCs), peritoneal dialysis catheters (PDCs), arteriovenous fistulas (AVFs), and prosthetic shunts (PTFEs). RESULTS: Five hundred eighty-five primary procedures (236 PTFEs, 87 AVFs, 112 SIHCs, and 150 PDCs) and 259 secondary procedures (215 PTFEs, 14 AVFs, 0 SIHCs, and 30 PDCs) were performed on 350 patients. By life table analysis, SIHCs exhibited the lowest primary patency rate (9% at 1 year; p < 0.0001), whereas PDCs had the highest primary patency rate (57% at 1 year; p < 0.02). The primary patency rates of AVFs and PTFEs was similar, with 43% and 41% 1-year patency rates, respectively (p = 0.70). Less-stringent reporting methods would have increased apparent 1-year patency rates by 9% to 41%. With regard to secondary patency, there was no significant difference between PTFEs and PDCs, with 1-year patency rates of 59% and 70%, respectively (p = 0.62), but PTFEs were more frequently revised. In addition, there was no significant difference between AVF and PTFE secondary patency rates, with 1-year patency rates of 46% and 59%, respectively. Early differences in patency rates for AVFs, PTFEs, and PDCs diminished over time, and at 4 years AVFs had the best secondary patency rate (p = 0.6). The most common reasons for access failure were: PTFEs, thrombosis; AVFs, thrombosis and failure to mature; SIHCs, inadequate dialysis; PDCs, infection and inadequate exchange. By regression analysis, a history of a previous unsalvageable PTFE was the only significant risk factor for failure of a subsequent PTFE (p < 0.01), and the risk of graft failure increased exponentially with the number of previous PTFE shunts. Diabetes was the only significant risk factor for failure of PDCs (p < 0.02; odds ratio, 2.0). CONCLUSIONS: The patency rate for PTFEs is similar to that for AVFs, but AVFs require fewer revisions. When replacing a failed access graft, the risk of PTFE failure increases with the number of prior unsalvageable PTFE shunts. PDCs have excellent patency rates, but failure rates are doubled in patients with diabetes. Because of poor patency rates and inadequate dialysis flow rates, SIHCs should be avoided when possible. Reporting methods dramatically affect apparent patency rates, and reporting standards are needed to allow meaningful comparisons in the dialysis access literature.

Ultrasound determination of total arterial wall thickness.

PURPOSE: Ultrasonic measurement techniques for determining intima-media thickness and total arterial wall thickness have been described. The intima-media thickness measurements are currently in use in large epidemiologic trials. Intima-media thickness does not evaluate extramedial atherosclerotic change and so may not fully reflect pathologic changes in the arterial wall. METHODS: After we performed variability studies of B-mode image acquisition and measurement, we measured total wall thickness and intima-media thickness of the common carotid arteries in 60 adult subjects in three groups: a control group aged 20 to 29 years, a control group aged 60 to 79 years, and a claudication group aged 60 to 79 years. Measurements were made with B-mode ultrasound images. RESULTS: No statistical difference between sexes was noted. A statistically significant (p < or = 0.05) increase in intima-media thickness and wall thickness was found with increasing age, and an additional increase was observed with clinically significant lower extremity arterial occlusive disease (p < or = 0.05). Image quality had an effect on measurement accuracy. CONCLUSIONS: The finding that the wall thickness of common carotid arteries is increased in those patients with clinically significant lower extremity disease supports the theory that atherosclerosis affects the arterial wall in a systemic fashion. Because intima-media thickness also increases across subject groups without change in its proportional contribution to the total arterial wall thickness, extramedial arterial changes also occur with aging and the development of atherosclerosis. We propose that because increases in wall thickness measurements of common carotid arteries follow intima-media thickness increase (but do not necessarily measure the same physiologic change) and the wall thickness method can be used in cases when the intima-media thickness cannot be measured, arterial wall thickness measurement may serve as an alternate or confirmatory test of peripheral artery atherosclerotic severity.

Ultrasonic three-dimensional reconstruction: in vitro and in vivo volume and area measurement.

This study validates the use of an ultrasound three-dimensional reconstruction system to measure phantom and blood conduit geometry. Independently determined uniform and stenotic phantom dimensions are compared with reconstruction-based measurements. Lower extremity saphenous vein bypass graft reconstructions were performed to demonstrate clinical application. Uniform phantom independent and reconstructed volume correlation was high (r = 0.989), the average volume difference was 4.68 mm3 and the average area difference was 0.4 mm2. An in vitro 28% diameter reduction was detected. Stenotic bypass graft segment volume was 795 mm3; following successful angioplasty the volume increased to 1419 mm3. Advantages of this technique are its accuracy, the luminal information it provides and the absence of mechanical arm or acoustic transmitter limitations. We are exploring the possibility that measurement of luminal change over time may allow stenosis detection prior to hemodynamic disturbance, in an ongoing clinical saphenous vein bypass graft surveillance study.