ABSTRACT
Non-contrast enhanced helical CT has become an accepted technique for evaluating acute ureteric colic. The results of a randomized prospective comparison of the accuracy, cost and radiation dose of CT and intravenous urography (IVU) are presented. All patients presenting to the Emergency Department with symptoms and signs suggestive of ureteric colic over a 16-month period (n = 242) were randomized to CT or IVU. Follow up was obtained for 228 patients (94%), with 14 patients (6%) lost to follow up. One hundred and twenty-three patients (54%) underwent CT and 105 (46%) had an IVU. At follow up the sensitivity and specificity of CT were each 100%, while those of IVU were 99% and 100%, respectively. Computed tomography demonstrated seven of 26 (27%) potential alternative diagnoses, whereas IVU suggested one of 23 (4%). Estimates of the average effective dose were calculated for CT (4.95 mSv) and IVU (1.48 mSv, 95% confidence interval (CI) 0.7-2.27). Radiation dose and intravenous contrast material safety are discussed and the relative costs are considered. Computed tomography is as accurate as IVU in the diagnosis of acute ureteric colic. It confers certain major diagnostic benefits, and is a fast, well-tolerated technique. Its accompanying higher effective radiation dose is recognized.
Subject(s)
Colic/diagnostic imaging , Colic/etiology , Tomography, X-Ray Computed , Ureteral Diseases/diagnostic imaging , Ureteral Diseases/etiology , Urography , Adolescent , Adult , Aged , Cost-Benefit Analysis , Diagnosis, Differential , Female , Humans , Male , Middle Aged , Prospective Studies , Radiation Dosage , Sensitivity and Specificity , Tomography, X-Ray Computed/economics , Ureteral Calculi/complications , Ureteral Calculi/diagnostic imaging , Urography/economicsABSTRACT
The purpose of the present paper is to review the indications, results, clinical correlation and implications for management of a modified CT peritoneography (CTP) technique in the evaluation of continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis (CAPD) patients. Forty CTP in 33 patients were reviewed by two observers blinded to clinical history or outcome. The CTP technique included 100 mL non-ionic intraperitoneal contrast, 1 h of ambulation and prone positioning during the CT. No precontrast or delayed examinations were performed. A CAPD-related complication was diagnosed in 33 of 40 (82%) CTP. Twenty-nine CTP were performed for evaluation of suspected dialysate leaks. In this group there were 18 leaks, a total of seven umbilical hernias (five as isolated findings) and five normal studies. Nine of 18 (50%) leaks resolved with conservative management and six of nine patients (67%) of the remainder continued CAPD after appropriate surgery. Seven patients were evaluated for scrotal swelling (one bilateral), and there were five communicating hydroceles (all with inguinal fat herniation and all surgically confirmed) and three non-communicating hydroceles (none of which progressed). Umbilical hernias were present in nine of 33 patients (27%). No false positive or false negative studies were identified. The CTP technique described provides accurate diagnostic information in the management of common CAPD-related complications, particularly dialysate leak, genital swelling, abdominal wall hernias and peritoneal adhesions. Computed tomography peritoneography directs appropriate conservative or surgical management.
