Comparison of coral reef communities in proximity to ocean effluent pipes off the north coast of Puerto Rico.

Coral reefs are declining globally as a result of multiple stressors, including land-based stressors, such as sedimentation and pollution, and those that are related to a changing climate, such as increases in ocean acidification. Degradation of US Caribbean coral reef biota has been associated with exposure to sewage effluent from wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs). The Puerto Rico Aqueduct and Sewer Authority (PRASA) maintains WWTPs on the north coast of Puerto Rico, which release effluent into the marine environment in the vicinity of coral reefs. Using data collected by PRASA surveys conducted from 1999 to 2013, we examined coral reef condition at survey sites to identify potential changes or differences in reefs with respect to their proximity to the WWTP effluent pipes (e.g., upstream, downstream). The proportion of coverage represented by all coral, sensitive taxa, and tolerant taxa were compared across sites located upstream and downstream of WWTP effluent pipes using multivariate approaches and analysis of variance. The proportion of healthy, sensitive coral species and invasive or tolerant coral species were not different at sites downstream of the WWTP effluent pipe compared to upstream. These results are caveated by the limited sampling design, highly variable communities across WWTP locations, and the sparsity or absence of well-developed coral reef communities at most stations. We evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of the survey design and provide recommendations for future coral reef surveys investigating potential impacts of WWTP effluent.

What is it about coral reefs? Translation of ecosystem goods and services relevant to people and their well-being.

There is an astonishing diversity of ways in which people benefit from coral reefs. They provide recreation, resource extraction, inspirational, and educational opportunities, among many others as well as being valued just for their existence. As the condition of coral reef ecosystems decline, so do their ability to provide these benefits. Prudent management of coral reefs and the benefits they provide are important as some predict most coral reefs globally will be lost by the mid-21st century. Meanwhile, coral reef managers have limited tools and relevant data to design and implement effective environmental management practices that will enable coral reefs to provide benefits demanded by society. We demonstrate an approach to identify and measure environmental components of coral reefs that directly benefit human well-being. The approach views ecosystems through the lens of a specific set of beneficiaries and the biophysical features directly relevant to each. We call these biophysical features Final Ecosystem Goods and Services (FEGS). In our demonstration, we (1) identify a range of beneficiaries of coral reefs; (2) identify metrics of FEGS for those beneficiaries; and (3) describe how data quantifying those biophysical metrics might be used to facilitate greater economic and social understanding.