A Global Evaluation of Surgical Techniques and Results of Unilateral Cleft Lip Repairs.

BACKGROUND: Variations in the clinical presentation of the unilateral cleft lip resulted in numerous surgical repair techniques used around the world. No universally accepted method exists to evaluate aesthetic surgical results. The purpose of this study is to use the Hubli lip grading system, developed by Smile Train, to evaluate the aesthetic results of unilateral cleft lip repairs based on the surgical technique used. METHODS: A retrospective review was conducted of unilateral cleft lip repair operations performed by Smile Train surgeons throughout Africa, Americas, Asia Pacific, and Europe and Middle East between 2014 and 2018. Using the Hubli lip grading criteria, factoring in cleft severity, acceptable outcomes were identified and compared with the surgical technique used. RESULTS: Eight thousand forty-one unilateral cleft lip repairs were reviewed. The majority utilized the rotational advancement technique (n = 5541, 68.9%) with a statistically significant percentage of acceptable outcomes (92.1%), followed by an acceptance rate of 91.9% with variations of the z-plasty technique, 90.5% with the straight-line repair and its variations, and 88.4% using "other" techniques (P < 0.05). The rotational advancement had the highest acceptable outcomes for complete cleft lips (94.7%, P < 0.0001), associated alveolar clefting (94.2%, P < 0.05), and concomitant clefting of the hard and/or soft palate (94.3%, P < 0.05). CONCLUSION: Regardless of surgical technique used, Smile Train surgeons maintain high rates of successful surgical outcomes. Results of our study will help complement and support existing medical infrastructure and training systems Smile Train employs for surgeons working with comprehensive cleft care teams around the world.

Validation of the Hubli Grading System for Assessing Unilateral and Bilateral Cleft Lip Outcomes.

BACKGROUND: When determining whether a cleft lip repair outcome is acceptable, the severity of a patient's cleft at initial presentation must be considered. Currently, there is not a widely agreed upon scale for grading the pre-operative severity or post-operative surgical outcome for patients with unilateral and/or bilateral cleft lip. The aim of this study is to validate the Hubli grading system as a reliable and reproducible system for characterizing cleft lip repair outcomes. METHODS: Craniofacial surgeon graders independently evaluated 2489 patients from 56 different countries undergoing both unilateral and bilateral cleft lip repair from April 2004 to December 2018. Preoperative severity and postoperative surgical results were assessed, and these grades were combined to determine surgical outcome acceptability based on initial cleft severity. Intrarater and interrater reliability were calculated as percentages of agreement. RESULTS: Intrarater and interrater acceptability scores had an agreement of 94.50% and 87.04%, respectively. These results indicate that using the Hubli grading system, independent raters are able to reliably and reproducibly measure the acceptability of a cleft lip repair. CONCLUSIONS: This study validates the use of the Hubli grading system to evaluate the acceptability of unilateral and bilateral cleft lip repairs. This is the largest study to date to evaluate cleft lip severity and repair outcomes, and the Hubli grading system is the only scale to determine the acceptability of surgical outcomes based on initial cleft severity. This system is designed to identify surgeons with sub-optimal outcomes in order to implement timely, individualized training on a global scale.

Correction of metopic synostosis utilizing an in situ bandeau approach.

Metopic craniosynostosis is a common growth disturbance in the infant cranium, second only to sagittal synostosis. Presenting symptoms are usually of a clinical nature and are defined by an angular forehead, retruded lateral brow, bitemporal narrowing, and a broad-based occiput. These changes create the pathognomonic trigonocephalic cranial shape. Aesthetic in nature, these morphological changes do not constitute the only developmental issues faced by children who present with this malady. Recent studies and anecdotal evidence have also demonstrated that children who present with metopic synostosis may face issues with respect to intellectual and/or psychological development. The authors present an elegant approach to the surgical reconstruction of the trigonocephalic cranium using an in situ bandeau approach.

A functional aesthetic approach to correcting the sequelae of sagittal synostosis.

Sagittal synostosis is the most commonly treated form of craniosynostosis exhibiting an incidence of 1:5000 births.(1) Early closure of the sagittal suture is the cause of the classic phenotypic presentation of an elongated head, which is characterized by a narrow and low occiput, a saddle-shaped parietal region, and noticeable frontal bossing. Early surgical intervention is the treatment of choice and surgical options range from simple suture excision to total cranial vault remodeling. Noting that a significant proportion of patients present with limited frontal bossing and asymmetry that is more pronounced in the posterior cranium, the author developed the functional aesthetic approach to reconstruction. This operative technique addresses the changes noted in the posterior two-thirds of the cranial vault, completely correcting the sequelae associated with early closure of the sagittal suture. As an added advantage, the reconstructive paradigm is designed to create a dynamic temporal-occipital component that will activate when a child rests in the supine position. This enhances widening of the posterior cranium thus improving long-term results.

Smile train: changing the world one smile at a time.

Smile Train was founded with one, clear aim--to help as many children as possible who are needlessly suffering with unrepaired clefts. Its unique "teach-a-man-to-fish" strategy supports local medical professionals to provide free, safe, and high-quality cleft care by offering free education and training opportunities, free equipment, and financial support for cleft treatment. Smile Train is continuing to expand its reach and enhance its ability to serve by developing and implementing new and innovative approaches in the delivery of comprehensive cleft care, so that each and every child born into the world with a cleft has the opportunity to live a full, productive life.

Role of free-tissue transfer in the treatment of recalcitrant palatal fistulae among patients with cleft palates.

Recurrent palatal fistulae present a particularly vexing problem for patients with cleft lips and palates and their surgeons. When primary closure fails, conventional wisdom and the standard of care suggest local flap techniques for defect closure. For the large majority of patients, this approach is successful. There is, however, a small subset of patients who undergo multiple surgical procedures in unsuccessful attempts to close recalcitrant fistulae, particularly at the anterior, densely scarred, hard palate. In this setting, repair calls for the introduction of well-vascularized pliable tissue to close the defect and to avoid hampering further palatal growth. Local muscle flaps and oral axial pattern flaps have been advocated and used successfully. However, those approaches have their own drawbacks, such as multiple surgical interventions, patient compliance, and intraoral scarring. In an effort to avoid the problems associated with local flaps, distant microvascular tissue transfers were investigated. During a 6-year period, six free-tissue transfers were performed as a primary means of treating recalcitrant palatal fistulae. Three dorsalis pedis flaps and three osseous angular scapular flaps were used. The conditions of all patients improved, with five patients achieving complete long-term closure of the palatal defect. This experience indicates that modern microvascular techniques have reached a level of success commensurate with that of other flap techniques; therefore, it is concluded that free-tissue transfer should be considered as a primary means of addressing these difficult cleft problems.

Efficacy of primary wound cultures in long bone open extremity fractures: are they of any value?

The management of long bone open extremity fractures has included initial wound cultures, antibiotics, operative debridement, and fracture repair, if indicated. The value of initial wound cultures is unclear. We examined whether primary wound cultures predict which wounds will become infected, and whether bacterial growth on primary wound cultures correlates with bacteria cultured from infected wounds. This prospective study involved patients presenting to a regional trauma center. Before any interventions were performed, initial aerobic and anaerobic cultures of the wounds of 117 consecutive open extremity fractures grades I-III were obtained. The results of these cultures were correlated with the development of a wound infection, and if an infection occurred, the organism grown from the infected wound was compared with any organism grown from the primary wound cultures. Of the initial cultures, 76% (89/117) did not demonstrate any growth, while the other 24% (28/117) only grew skin flora. There were only 7 (6%) wound infections, and 71% (5/7) initially did not grow any organisms. Of the isolates that grew from the initial cultures, none were the organisms that eventually led to wound infections. The use of primary wound cultures in open extremity injuries has no value in the management of patients suffering long bone open extremity fractures.