Integrated management of blood-feeding arthropods in veterinary teaching facilities - Part 3: proposal for a coherent and affordable control plan.

As reviewed in Part 1 of this publication series, numerous haematophagous arthropods have negative direct effects and are involved in the transmission of pathogens to either animals and/or humans in Western Europe. Their control is therefore essential to prevent vector-borne infections. Different control methods, either general or arthropod-specific, were presented in Part 2 of this publication series. Part 3 focuses on integrated management of arthropods and proposes a coherent and affordable plan for facilities housing sick animals in a veterinary faculty, i.e. small animals and large animals, with an educational farm. Control of arthropods should be part of a biosecurity plan, the effectiveness of which requires awareness raising and education of the different actors, i.e. staff, students and animal owners. The originality of the review lies in its specificity to a veterinary faculty and animal housing facilities, from a One Health point of view. As far as it could be ascertained, this is the first review focusing on arthropod control in this specific at-risk environment.

Comme les auteurs l'ont montré dans le premier article de cette série, nombre d'arthropodes hématophages ont des effets néfastes directs et interviennent dans la transmission d'agents pathogènes aussi bien aux animaux qu'aux humains en Europe occidentale. Il est donc essentiel de les contrôler afin de prévenir les infections à transmission vectorielle. Le deuxième article de cette série était consacré aux différentes méthodes de contrôle envisageables, tant générales que ciblant spécifiquement les arthropodes. Dans cette troisième partie, les auteurs traitent de la gestion intégrée des arthropodes et proposent un plan cohérent et peu coüteux destiné aux installations où sont maintenus les animaux malades au sein des établissements d'enseignement vétérinaire qui s'occupent aussi bien des petits animaux que des grands et qui sont donc dotés d'une ferme pédagogique. La lutte contre les arthropodes est une composante essentielle de tout plan de sécurité biologique, lequel sera d'autant plus efficace que l'ensemble des acteurs qui y participent (personnels, étudiants, propriétaires d'animaux) sont sensibilisés et formés. L'originalité de cette étude réside dans la spécificité, dans une perspective Une seule santé, des établissements d'enseignement vétérinaire et de leurs installations pour animaux. À la connaissance des auteurs, il s'agit de la première étude axée sur le contrôle des arthropodes dans cet environnement particulièrement à risque.

Como se explica en la primera parte de esta serie de artículos, numerosos artrópodos hematófagos tienen efectos negativos directos y participan en la transmisión de patógenos a animales y/o personas en Europa Occidental. De ahí que su control sea esencial para prevenir infecciones transmitidas por vectores. En la segunda parte de la serie se exponen diferentes métodos de lucha, que pueden ser genéricos o ir dirigidos selectivamente contra los artrópodos. En esta tercera parte dedicada a la lucha integrada contra los artrópodos se propone un plan coherente y asequible para las granjas pedagógicas de las facultades de veterinaria, esto es, aquellas instalaciones destinadas a alojar a animales enfermos, grandes o pequeños. El control de las poblaciones de artrópodos debería formar parte de todo plan de seguridad biológica, cuya eficacia pasa necesariamente por la sensibilización y formación de los principales interesados, a saber, personal, estudiantes y propietarios de los animales. La originalidad del estudio estriba en referirse específicamente, desde el punto de vista de Una sola salud, a las facultades de veterinaria y las instalaciones donde están alojados los animales. Hasta donde es posible saber, se trata del primer estudio centrado en la lucha contra los artrópodos en este entorno de riesgo en particular.

Integrated management of blood-feeding arthropods in veterinary teaching facilities - Part 2: overview of control methods against adults and immature stages.

Numerous arthropod species are involved in the vector-borne transmission of pathogens either to animals and/or to humans. Part 1 of this paper was dedicated to a review of these species, and their role in the transmission of pathogens in North-western Europe. This part will discuss the different anti-arthropod control methods, which are either general, used as good management practices, or arthropod-specific. The majority of these measures are efficient against several arthropod groups. Management of the environment is crucial for controlling the immature stages of winged arthropods, fleas and lice, but also ticks. Spraying pesticides should be considered carefully, because of the risk of emergence of resistance and the negative impact on the environment and non-targeted insects. Monitoring of haematophagous arthropods is useful when considering its use in the validation of control measures, the follow-up of endemic populations, vigilance for emergence of new species, and the detection of pathogens and, indirectly, resistance to chemicals. Monitoring also helps to determine the most appropriate timing and location for implementing control measures. It is strongly advised to combine control methods targeting adults and others addressing immature stages. Even if challenging, their combination under an integrated pest management programme should be preferred. Indeed, integrated vector management aims at making vector control more efficient, cost-effective, ecologically sound and sustainable.

Nombre d'espèces d'arthropodes participent à la transmission vectorielle d'agents pathogènes aux animaux et/ou aux humains. Dans une première partie de leur étude, les auteurs ont donné une vue d'ensemble de ces espèces et expliqué le rôle qu'elles jouent dans la transmission d'agents pathogènes dans le nord de l'Europe occidentale. Cette deuxième partie est consacrée aux différentes méthodes de contrôle des arthropodes ; elles se répartissent entre d'une part, des méthodes générales qui correspondent aux bonnes pratiques de gestion, et d'autre part, des méthodes ciblant spécifiquement les arthropodes. La plupart de ces mesures sont efficaces contre plusieurs groupes d'arthropodes. Il est essentiel de respecter les principes de bonne gestion de l'environnement afin de parvenir à contrôler les stades immatures des arthropodes ailés tels que les puces et les poux, mais aussi les tiques. L'utilisation de pesticides par aérosols devrait être envisagée avec prudence en raison du risque d'émergence de résistances et de l'impact négatif de ces produits sur l'environnement et sur les insectes non-cibles. La surveillance des arthropodes hématophages présente un intérêt lorsqu'on l'applique pour la validation des mesures de contrôle, le suivi des populations endémiques, la veille face à l'émergence d'espèces nouvelles et la détection d'agents pathogènes, ainsi qu'indirectement pour détecter les résistances aux agents chimiques. La surveillance permet également de déterminer quand et où mettre en oeuvre les mesures de contrôle pour plus de résultats. Il est conseillé d'associer les méthodes ciblant les adultes et celles ciblant les stades immatures. Malgré les difficultés d'une telle association, il conviendra de la privilégier dans le cadre d'un programme intégré de gestion des nuisibles. En effet, la gestion intégrée des vecteurs vise à rendre la lutte anti-vectorielle à la fois plus efficace, plus rentable, plus rationnelle au plan écologique et plus durable.

Numerosas especies de artrópodo participan en la transmisión vectorial de patógenos a animales o personas. En la primera parte de esta serie de artículos se hace un repaso de estas especies y se explica el papel que cumplen en la transmisión de patógenos en el noroeste de Europa. En esta segunda parte se examinan los diferentes métodos de lucha contra los artrópodos, que pueden ser genéricos, esto es, utilizados como buena práctica de gestión, o ir dirigidos selectivamente contra artrópodos. La mayoría de estas medidas son eficaces contra varios grupos de artrópodos. La gestión de las condiciones del entorno es crucial para combatir a las fases inmaduras de artrópodos alados, pulgas y piojos, así como a las garrapatas. El rociado con plaguicidas es un recurso que conviene estudiar con detenimiento, dado el riesgo de que surjan resistencias y su negativo impacto en el medio ambiente y en otros insectos que no se pretende dañar. La vigilancia de las poblaciones de artrópodos hematófagos resulta útil cuando se contempla su uso para la validación de medidas de lucha, el seguimiento de poblaciones endémicas, la vigilancia de la aparición de nuevas especies o la detección de patógenos e, indirectamente, la resistencia a productos químicos. La vigilancia también ayuda a determinar el momento y lugar idóneos para aplicar medidas de lucha. Se aconseja vivamente combinar métodos de lucha dirigidos contra los adultos con otros que combatan a las fases inmaduras. La aplicación de este tipo de planteamiento combinado, por dificultosa que resulte, será siempre la opción preferible para formar parte de un programa de gestión integrada de plagas. La lucha integrada contra los vectores, en efecto, tiene por objetivo hacer más eficaz, rentable, ecológicamente sensata y sostenible la lucha contra los vectores.

Integrated management of blood-feeding arthropods in veterinary teaching facilities - Part 1: overview of haematophagous arthropods of interest in North-western Europe.

Numerous arthropod species negatively affect animal and human health through physical attacks, by generating allergic reactions and as potential vectors of pathogens. Their control is essential to prevent vector-borne diseases and reduce their negative direct effect. Climate change militates for appropriate preparedness towards invasive species, their establishment and their involvement in new potential vector-pathogen-host cycles. This paper reviews the main blood-feeding arthropods of veterinary/zoonotic interest and their role in the transmission of infections in North-western Europe. It is the first part of an approach aimed at proposing a coherent and affordable vector control programme for facilities housing healthy and sick animals in a veterinary faculty, from a global health point of view. It is the first review focusing on this topic in such a specific and at-risk environment. Indeed, considering its multi-disciplinary and multi-species context and the importance of animal welfare, a veterinary faculty should attach great importance to vector control.

Nombre d'espèces d'arthropodes ont un impact négatif sur la santé animale et humaine, soit lors d'attaques directes, soit en déclenchant des réactions allergiques ou encore en tant que vecteurs potentiels d'agents pathogènes. Il est essentiel de contrôler ces espèces afin de prévenir les maladies à transmission vectorielle et de réduire leurs effets négatifs directs. Le changement climatique intensifie le problème des espèces envahissantes, ce qui milite en faveur d'une préparation appropriée face à leur introduction, leur installation et leur probable participation à des cycles vecteur-pathogène-hôte inédits. Les auteurs font le point sur les principales espèces d'arthropodes hématophages d'intérêt vétérinaire et/ou zoonotique ainsi que sur leur rôle dans la transmission de maladies infectieuses dans le nord de l'Europe occidentale. Il s'agit du premier volet d'une approche visant à proposer un programme cohérent et peu coüteux de lutte anti-vectorielle afin de faciliter le maintien dans les installations des établissements d'enseignement vétérinaire d'animaux en bonne santé mais aussi d'animaux malades, dans une perspective sanitaire globale. Il s'agit de la première étude d'ensemble traitant de ce sujet dans un environnement aussi spécifique et à risque. En effet, compte tenu de la nature pluridisciplinaire des établissements d'enseignement vétérinaire, de leur axe pluri-espèces et de l'importance qu'y revêt le bien-être animal, ces institutions devraient attacher une importance majeure à la lutte anti-vectorielle.

Hay numerosas especies de artrópodo que perjudican la salud de personas y animales por las reacciones alérgicas que provoca su ataque físico o porque pueden actuar como vectores de patógenos. La lucha contra esas especies es básica para prevenir enfermedades de transmisión vectorial y reducir sus efectos perjudiciales directos. El cambio climático aconseja una adecuada preparación para hacer frente a las especies invasoras, su implantación y su intervención en eventuales nuevos ciclos vector-patógeno-hospedador. Los autores pasan revista a los principales artrópodos hematófagos de interés veterinario y/o zoonótico y exponen su función en la transmisión de infecciones en el noroeste de Europa. Se trata del primer capítulo de una reflexión encaminada a proponer, desde el punto de vista de la salud mundial, un programa coherente y asequible de lucha antivectorial que se aplique a las instalaciones de las facultades de veterinaria que alojan a animales sanos o enfermos. Se trata del primer trabajo en la materia que se centra específicamente en este tipo de entorno, tan particular como expuesto a riesgo. Toda facultad de veterinaria, en efecto, teniendo en cuenta su contexto pluridisciplinar y multiespecífico y lo importante que es el bienestar animal, debería otorgar suma importancia a la lucha contra los vectores.

Biosecurity practices in Belgian cattle farming: Level of implementation, constraints and weaknesses.

Over the last few years, a shift from curative towards preventive medicine occurred in the livestock sector. This led to an increased importance of biosecurity to better control infectious diseases by preventing their introduction and/or reducing their spread. Farmers are the main responsible actors of biosecurity measures (BSM). Existing studies report a low implementation level of BSM by the cattle farmers. Barriers such as cost, usefulness, importance, workload and lack of knowledge were investigated but the decision-making process of farmers related to a given BSM is not yet clarified. The objectives of this study were to (i) assess the level of implementation of BSM in cattle farms, (ii) assess the correlation between the importance that farmers give to a BSM and its effective implementation and (iii) identify the main reasons of non-implementation. A randomized survey was implemented in Belgium from December 2016 up to April 2017 with face-to-face interviews conducted in 100 Belgian farms. A descriptive analysis of data was performed using Microsoft Excel® and Stata14® . Chi-square and Spearman's rank correlation tests, respectively, allowed comparing implementation levels in dairy herds vs. beef herds and investigating the correlation between the importance that farmers give to a BSM and its implementation level. Biosecurity measures were poorly implemented to prevent disease introduction through direct contact and almost not to avoid indirect transmission. Some measures showed a significant difference in terms of implementation level between beef and dairy herds. A positive correlation was highlighted between the importance that farmers give to a BSM and its actual effective implementation. Perceived lack of efficiency, feasibility and usefulness are the reasons most often mentioned for non-implementation. Other factors potentially influencing the decision-making process should be further investigated and clarified. Evidence-based studies would be useful to convince the farmers of the need of implementing BSM.

Rural veterinarian's perception and practices in terms of biosecurity across three European countries.

The implementation of biosecurity measures in the animal health and production context is quite broad and aims at limiting the risk of introduction and spread of diseases. Veterinarians play a major role in biosecurity as key informants on the subject for cattle holders, key players in terms of disease prevention/control and eradication programs, as well as key risk factor in terms of disease dissemination. Many biosecurity studies have highlighted professional visitors such as veterinary practitioners as representing a high-risk factor in terms of disease introduction in animal facilities but, to date, very few studies have focused on the implementation level of biosecurity measures by veterinarians. An online survey was implemented in three European countries (Belgium, France and Spain) to assess the behaviour of rural veterinarians towards biosecurity, as well as their implementation level of the biosecurity measures. A descriptive analysis of data and a scoring system were applied to assess the implementation level of measures. The influence of different factors on the implementation level of biosecurity measures was investigated through a negative binomial regression model. The study identified different strengths, weaknesses, possible constraints and solutions in terms of veterinary perspectives. Veterinarians are considered as key informants by the farmers and could therefore play a more active role in terms of guidance and improvement of biosecurity at farm level. Based on the survey outcomes, two factors seemed to influence significantly the implementation level of measures: the country where he/she practices and the veterinarian's perception level of biosecurity. The biosecurity stages with the lowest application level, therefore representing the biggest threats, were bio-exclusion (increasing the risk of disease introduction) and biocontainment (increasing the risk of inter-herd transmission).

Methodology for the assessment of brucellosis management practices and its vaccination campaign: example in two Argentine districts.

BACKGROUND: In Argentina, vaccination with Brucella abortus Strain 19 vaccine is mandatory. The objective of the study was to develop and test a method for evaluating, in an innovative way, some farmers' and veterinarians' management practices in relation to brucellosis and to assess the vaccination campaign and coverage. The work took place in Brandsen and Navarro districts. Four questionnaires were designed (for officials from Local Sanitary Entities, vaccinators, vet practitioners and farmers). Responses were coded as "ideal" (0) and "not ideal" (1). To assess the relative weight of each question ("item"), experts ranked the items according to their impact on management practices and vaccination. A weighted score was then calculated. A higher weighted score was assigned to the worse practices. Farmers obtaining a global weighted score above the third quartile were classified as "inappropriately managed farms", to be compared per type of production system and district. To assess the immunization coverage, female calves were sampled 30 to 50 days post vaccination; they were expected to react positively to serological diagnostic tests (DT+). RESULTS: There were significantly more inappropriately managed farms and higher global scores among beef farmers and in Brandsen. Eighty three percent (83%) of female calves were DT+, significantly under the ideal immunization coverage (95%). Only 48% of farms were considered well vaccinated. DT+ results were positively associated with the Brandsen district (OR = 25.94 [4.60-1146.21] and with the farms having more than 200 cow heads ((OR = 78.34 [4.09-1500.00]). On the contrary, DT+ were less associated with vaccinators being veterinary practitioners (OR = 0.07 [0.006-0.78]). Farmers are well advised by their veterinary practitioners but they should improve some management practices. CONCLUSIONS: The vaccination campaign is globally well implemented, but the immunization coverage and some vaccinators' practices should be improved. This study leads to a better understanding of the most common used management and control practices regarding brucellosis, which affect its epidemiology. Any vaccination campaign should be periodically assessed to highlight possible fails. The described methodology can be extrapolated to other countries and different contexts.

Observations as a way to assess the compliance of veterinary students with biosecurity procedures.

In veterinary medicine, biosecurity relies on the implementation and respect of procedures that reduce the risk of the introduction and spread of pathogens. The main objective of the study was to assess the usefulness of observations in estimating the compliance of veterinary students with biosecurity measures implemented in the necropsy room of a Faculty of Veterinary Medicine (n = 122 observations) and in a private slaughterhouse (n = 56 observations) in Belgium, during day sessions of practical work. Checklists compiling the biosecurity rules to apply in both contexts were established (31 rules were considered for the necropsy room and 35 for the slaughterhouse). Observations were performed by a single person to ensure standardisation. The level of compliance with biosecurity rules was intermediate and reached 42% vs. 37% for the necropsy room and the slaughterhouse, respectively. No significant difference was observed between these compliance rates. Increasing staff supervision of students and increasing awareness through education should be encouraged. The follow-up of observations through time could be used to assess the evolution of compliance with biosecurity measures.

En médecine vétérinaire, la biosécurité repose sur la mise en oeuvre et le respect des procédures destinées à réduire le risque d'introduction et de propagation des agents pathogènes. Les auteurs présentent les résultats d'une étude conduite en Belgique dans le but d'évaluer l'utilité des observations pour assurer la conformité de la mise en oeuvre des mesures de biosécurité par les étudiants en médecine vétérinaire lors des séances de travaux pratiques effectuées en salle de nécropsie d'une faculté de médecine vétérinaire (n = 122 observations) et dans un abattoir privé (n = 56 observations). Des listes de vérification compilant les règles de biosécurité à appliquer dans ces deux contextes ont été établies (31 règles prises en compte pour la salle de nécropsie et 35 pour l'abattoir). Les observations étaient effectuées par une seule personne à la fois afin d'assurer leur standardisation. L'étude a révélé une conformité aux règles de biosécurité de niveau intermédiaire, s'élevant respectivement à 42 % dans la salle de nécropsie et à 37 % à l'abattoir. Aucune différence significative n'a été décelée entre ces deux taux de conformité. Une meilleure supervision des étudiants par le personnel encadrant et une sensibilisation accrue dans l'enseignement devraient être encouragées. Le suivi des observations au fil du temps pourrait permettre d'évaluer l'évolution de la conformité aux mesures de biosécurité.

En medicina veterinaria, la seguridad biológica depende de la aplicación y el respeto de procedimientos que reducen el riesgo de introducción y propagación de patógenos. Los autores describen un estudio que tenía por principal objetivo determinar la utilidad de la observación como método para evaluar el cumplimiento, por parte de estudiantes de veterinaria, de las medidas de seguridad biológica aplicadas en la sala de disección de una facultad de veterinaria (n = 122 observaciones) y en un matadero privado (n = 56 observaciones) de Bélgica en el curso de jornadas de prácticas. Se elaboraron listas de control que enumeraban las reglas de seguridad biológica que debían respetarse en ambos contextos (se tuvieron en cuenta 31 reglas para la sala de disección y 35 para el matadero). Para asegurar la uniformidad de las observaciones, estas corrieron a cargo de una sola y misma persona. El nivel de cumplimiento de las reglas de seguridad biológica resultó intermedio: de un 42% en la sala de disección y de un 37% en el matadero, sin que entre ambas tasas se observara ninguna diferencia significativa. Conviene alentar una supervisión más estrecha de los estudiantes por parte del personal y un mayor grado de sensibilización a través de la enseñanza impartida. Para evaluar la evolución del cumplimiento de las medidas de seguridad biológica cabría la posibilidad de ir repitiendo las observaciones en el tiempo.

How to Assess Data Availability, Accessibility and Format for Risk Analysis?

Risk assessments are mostly carried out based on available data, which do not reflect all data theoretically required by experts to answer them. This study aimed at developing a methodology to assess data availability, accessibility and format, based on a scoring system and focusing on two diseases: Venezuelan equine encephalomyelitis (VEE), still exotic to Europe, and alveolar echinococcosis, caused by Echinococcus multilocularis (EM), endemic in several Member States (MSs). After reviewing 36 opinions of the EFSA-AHAW Panel on risk assessment of animal health questions, a generic list of needed data was elaborated. The methodology consisted, first, in implementing a direct and an indirect survey to collect the data needed for both case studies: the direct survey consisted in a questionnaire sent to contact points of three European MSs (Belgium, France and the Netherlands), and the organization of a workshop gathering experts on both diseases. The indirect survey, focusing on the three MSs involved in the direct survey plus Spain, relied on web searches. Secondly, a scoring system with reference to data availability, accessibility and format was elaborated, to, finally, compare both diseases and data between MSs. The accessibility of data was generally related to their availability. Web searches resulted in more data available for VEE compared to EM, despite its current exotic status in the European Union. Hypertext markup language and portable document files were the main formats of available data. Data availability, accessibility and format should be improved for research scientists/assessors. The format of data plays a key role in the feasibility and rapidness of data management and analysis, through a prompt compilation, combination and aggregation in working databases. Harmonization of data collection process is encouraged, according to standardized procedures, to provide useful and reliable data, both at the national and the international levels for both animal and human health; it would allow assessing data gaps through comparative studies. The present methodology is a good way of assessing the relevance of data for risk assessment, as it allows integrating the uncertainty linked to the quality of data used. Such an approach could be described as transparent and traceable and should be performed systematically.

Bovine brucellosis in Argentina and bordering countries: update.

Bovine brucellosis is a zoonotic disease spread worldwide. The infection in cattle is predominantly caused by Brucella abortus and is usually detected in pregnant females through abortions. The disease is endemic in Argentina; however, infection in humans is underestimated and often not reported. The prevalence of bovine brucellosis in countries bordering Argentina is quite variable: 0.04% in Uruguay, 10.20% in the north and 0.06% in the south of Brazil, 0.2% in Chile, 3.15% in Paraguay and 2.27% in Bolivia. In 1999, the Argentine National Control and Eradication Program was implemented. Its strategies include identification of vaccinated animals, compulsory vaccination with B. abortus S19 of 100% of 3- to 8-month-old females, negative serological tests before animal movements and categorization of farms in terms of their brucellosis status. The epidemiological surveillance in milk is performed through the milk ring test and the indirect ELISA. The result of a national brucellosis survey performed in 2004 indicates that 12.4% (95% CI: 10.89-14.0) of Argentine beef farms are seropositive to Brucella and that the apparent prevalence in cattle is 2.10% (95% CI: 1.90-2.40). The official serological diagnostic tests are as follows: buffered plate antigen test, as screening, serum agglutination test, 2-mercaptoethanol and fluorescence polarization assay, competitive ELISA, as confirmatory tests, and complement fixation test, as definitive test. Santa Fe and a district in Córdoba have 'Outstanding Plans'. Tierra del Fuego is a 'Zone free from bovine brucellosis'. One question arising when studying the Argentine situation is why the disease remains endemic if good regulations exist to control and eradicate it. In future, some different aspects might be evaluated to understand it, and further studies should be performed to prioritize, select and refine control strategies.

Risk assessment of Belgian adults for furan contamination through the food chain.

Risk assessment is an interdisciplinary process used to quantify the risk linked to a hazard. In the present paper it is applied to quantify the risk linked to furan ingestion through the food chain for the Belgian adult population. Two approaches, deterministic and probabilistic, were carried out in parallel. The deterministic method relied on a case study, whereas the probabilistic approach involved statistical distributions of contamination and consumption data to calculate a statistical distribution of the daily intake. First, the deterministic method revealed a low estimated daily intake (EDI) for the average population (380 ng*(kg(bw)*day)⁻¹) and a huge contribution of coffee consumption to the EDI (55%). Increasing or decreasing the daily coffee consumption by one cup can affect the EDI by about 22%. Afterwards, the probabilistic approach showed that the average population has a low EDI (494 ng*(kg(bw)*day)⁻¹), and that high contamination levels were only registered in a small proportion of the population. Finally, a comparison of the RfD(chronic oral) showed that less than 10% of the Belgian population had an EDI above the reference dose proposed by the USEPA; the majority of the population had an EDI 20% below the reference dose. The margin of exposure (MoE) approach indicated that the level of risk related to furan intake through ingestion is low, with a MoE > 10,000 for more than 10% of the population and no result < 100.

The use of modelling to evaluate and adapt strategies for animal disease control.

Disease is often associated with debilitating clinical signs, disorders or production losses in animals and/or humans, leading to severe socio-economic repercussions. This explains the high priority that national health authorities and international organisations give to selecting control strategies for and the eradication of specific diseases. When a control strategy is selected and implemented, an effective method of evaluating its efficacy is through modelling. To illustrate the usefulness of models in evaluating control strategies, the authors describe several examples in detail, including three examples of classification and regression tree modelling to evaluate and improve the early detection of disease: West Nile fever in equids, bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) and multifactorial diseases, such as colony collapse disorder (CCD) in the United States. Also examined are regression modelling to evaluate skin test practices and the efficacy of an awareness campaign for bovine tuberculosis (bTB); mechanistic modelling to monitor the progress of a control strategy for BSE; and statistical nationwide modelling to analyse the spatio-temporal dynamics of bTB and search for potential risk factors that could be used to target surveillance measures more effectively. In the accurate application of models, an interdisciplinary rather than a multidisciplinary approach is required, with the fewest assumptions possible.

The importance of awareness for veterinarians involved in cattle tuberculosis skin testing.

France is currently facing a re-emergence of bovine tuberculosis in several regions. To assess the knowledge of veterinary field practitioners concerning skin testing, a questionnaire-based methodology developed in Belgium was adapted to the context of the French department of Dordogne. The veterinarians involved in herds skin testing were solicited to participate to the survey (n = 94), through an anonymous postal questionnaire including items related to each step of the skin test procedure. Each item of the questionnaire was allotted a compliance score by 5 experts in the field of bovine tuberculosis (0, 1 or 2 a correct, acceptable and unacceptable answer, respectively). These scores were balanced over 30 criteria according to their potential impact on the non-detection of reactors, on the basis of 11 experts' opinion. A global score was calculated for each participating veterinarian. In addition, the Departmental sanitary authorities held meetings in December 2005 and June 2006 to make the veterinarians aware of the importance of correctly performing the skin test. The participants to the study were asked to fill in the questionnaire in duplicate: one related to their practices before the meeting, and the other one focusing on their practices after the meeting. A comparison of both situations was carried out (pre- and post-awareness meeting), as well as a comparison with the Belgian situation, arbitrarily selected as reference for the methodology. The participation was representative and reached a 23.4% rate. A significant difference was noticed between the mean global score reached before and after the meeting. These results show the usefulness of an appropriate awareness campaign of veterinarians in relation to skin testing and the importance of frequently holding awareness meetings in areas remaining confronted with bovine tuberculosis problems. It also highlights the interest of a structured auto-assessment process of veterinary practices.

Monitoring of the intra-dermal tuberculosis skin test performed by Belgian field practitioners.

The present study aimed to monitor skin test practices as performed by veterinarian field practitioners in Belgium. For this purpose, an anonymous postal questionnaire was elaborated and dispatched to veterinarians involved in bovine tuberculosis detection. The questionnaire included items focusing on the skin test performance. International experts in the field of bovine tuberculosis were asked to fill the questionnaire and a scoring scale was built as follows: 0 = 'ideal' answer, 1 = acceptable answer, whereas 2 = unacceptable answer. Furthermore, experts were asked to rank the questionnaire's items according to their possible impact on the risk of not detecting reactors. A global score was further calculated for each participant and a comparison of practices was carried out between the two regions of the country, i.e. Wallonia and Flanders. Significant differences were observed between both regions, a harmonization at the country level is thus essential. No veterinarian summed a null score, corresponding to the ideal skin test procedure, which suggests that skin-testing is far from being performed correctly. Field practitioners need to be sensitized to the importance of correctly performing the test. The authors recommend the questionnaire is suitable for application in other countries or regions.

[Economic management of health crises affecting production animals in Europe]. / Instruments de gestion economique des crises sanitaires touchant les animaux de production en Europe.

The importance of animal health crises has considerably increased over the last few years. When a crisis occurs, farmers can receive financial support through various public, private and mixed compensation schemes. Economic losses resulting from diseases may be direct and indirect. If a disease is covered by European Union regulations then countries have a legal obligation to partly compensate farmers for direct losses, either directly through the national budget, or through a specific fund. The European Veterinary Fund also co-finances these losses. Only a few countries provide compensation for indirect losses. The private insurance sector also provides protection against some direct and indirect losses but the risks covered are variable. To encourage farmers to subscribe to this kind of insurance, some public authorities provide subsidies to help pay the premium. Insurance companies do not generally cover the risks linked to contagious diseases, but some companies do extend cover to include this type of risk. Several alternatives, such as mutual funds, are available to improve risk coverage. There is a lack of harmonisation among the various compensation schemes of different countries. Public authorities cannot provide full compensation, but mutual funds and private insurance companies are alternatives that should be further investigated and their use should be extended to other countries. A classification of diseases would harmonise the situation at the European level.

New assessment of bovine tuberculosis risk factors in Belgium based on nationwide molecular epidemiology.

This assessment aimed to elaborate a statistical nationwide model for analyzing the space-time dynamics of bovine tuberculosis in search of potential risk factors that could be used to better target surveillance measures. A database comprising Mycobacterium bovis molecular profiles from all isolates obtained from Belgian outbreaks during the 1995-to-2006 period (n = 415) allowed the identification of a predominant spoligotype (SB0162). Various databases compiling 49 parameters to be tested were queried using a multiple stepwise logistic regression to assess bovine tuberculosis risk factors. Two isolate datasets were analyzed: the first included all Mycobacterium bovis isolates, while the second included only data related to the SB0162 type strain. When all Mycobacterium bovis isolates were included in the model, several risk factors were identified: history of bovine tuberculosis in the herd (P < 0.001), proximity of an outbreak (P < 0.001), cattle density (P < 0.001), and annual amplitude of mean middle-infrared temperature (P < 0.001). The approach restricted to the predominant SB0162 type strain additionally highlighted the proportion of movements from an infected area during the current year as a main risk factor (P = 0.009). This study identified several risk factors for bovine tuberculosis in cattle, highlighted the usefulness of molecular typing in the study of bovine tuberculosis epidemiology, and suggests a difference of behavior for the predominant type strain. It also emphasizes the role of animals' movements in the transmission of the disease and supports the importance of controlling trade movements.

Acute phase proteins assessment for an early selection of treatments in growing calves suffering from bronchopneumonia under field conditions.

Blood samples were taken from calves with respiratory disease the first day of examination for determination of the serum concentration of haptoglobin, fibrinogen, alpha-2- and gamma-globulins, and albumin. A clinical examination was performed daily for the duration of the disease. The animals were retrospectively classified in two categories: those animals requiring no treatment or antibiotics alone (group A), and antibiotics associated to anti-inflammatory drugs (group B). The serum proteins were tested in order to check whether they were able to distinguish, on the first day of clinical examination, between calves requiring anti-inflammatory treatment (group B) or not (group A). About 80% of calves were properly classified in both groups by the combined use of the two serum proteins haptoglobin and fibrinogen: these two proteins, and especially haptoglobin, were useful for the identification of calves requiring an anti-inflammatory treatment.