Perspectives from B cell immunology: fact and fancy.

In this article, the formation of antibodies during enzyme replacement therapy (ERT) for lysosomal storage diseases (LSDs) is reviewed in the light of present-day immunological concepts of immunogenicity and tolerance. Except in Gaucher disease, anti-enzyme antibodies frequently form (mainly immunoglobulin G) in patients receiving ERT, though they tend to wane as treatment continues. If the therapeutic enzyme is inhibited by antibodies, no significant modification to treatment is normally warranted, in clear contrast to therapy of hemophilia with clotting factors. The main adverse consequences of ERT, observed in only some patients, are sporadic hypersensitivity reactions, which are likely to be humorally mediated. Some infusion-related reactions are probably due to antibodies. In order to minimize immunogenicity, infused enzymes should be deaggregated and administered at low doses. In addition, inadvertent exposure to co-stimuli that might activate antigen-specific T or B lymphocytes should be avoided. The presence of cross-reacting immunological material, such as in patients with low levels or missense mutations of a gene coding for a lysosomal enzyme, tends to correlate with immune tolerance to the administered enzyme. There is a need for reliable biomarkers for therapeutic efficacy: some directions for further exploration are suggested. In animal models of LSDs, gene therapy delivered via viral vectors can rectify the lysosomal defect, and regulatory T cells that suppress antibody formation can be induced. This is a promising strategy that warrants further investigation in patients with LSDs.

Automated classification and analysis of the calcium response of single T lymphocytes using a neural network approach.

The gene activities in T lymphocytes that regulate immune responses are influenced by Ca2+ ([Ca2+]i). The intracellular calcium signals are highly heterogeneous and vitally important in determining the immune outcome. The signals in individual cells can be measured using fluorescence microscopy but to group the cells into classes with similar signal kinetics is currently laborious. Here, we demonstrate a method for the automated classification of the responses into four categories formerly identified by an expert's inspection. This method comprises characterising the response by a second-order model, performing frequency analysis, and using derived features as inputs to two multilayer perceptron neural networks (NNs). We compare the algorithm's performance on an example data set against the human classification: it was found to classify identically more than 70% of the data, despite small sample sizes in two categories and significant overlap between the other two classes. The group characterized by an oscillating signal showed the presence of a number of frequencies, which may be important in determining gene activation. A classification threshold enables the automatic identification of patterns with a low-classification certainty. Future refinement of the algorithm may allow the identification of more classes, which may be important in different immune responses associated with disease.

Anti-Ig-induced calcium influx in rat B lymphocytes mediated by cGMP through a dihydropyridine-sensitive channel.

In contrast to excitable tissues where calcium channels are well characterized, the nature of the B lymphocyte calcium channel is unresolved. Here, we demonstrate by single cell analysis of freshly isolated rat B cells that the anti-immunoglobulin (Ig)-induced calcium influx takes place through a channel which shares pharmacologic and serologic properties with the L-type calcium channel found in excitable tissues. It is sensitive to the dihydropyridines nicardipine and Bay K 8644, to calciseptine, and to an anti-peptide antibody raised against the alpha1 subunit of the L-type calcium channel, but is voltage-insensitive. Anti-alpha1 and anti-alpha2 antibodies stain B but not T lymphocytes. Application of a cGMP agonist, measurement of cGMP levels in anti-Ig-stimulated B cells, and examining the effect of a guanylyl cyclase inhibitor on the anti-Ig response show that cGMP mediates the influx. This possibly involves a cGMP-dependent protein kinase. The anti-Ig-induced response is not abolished by prior treatment of B cells with a high dose of thapsigargin. These findings undermine the widely held belief of a categorical divide between excitable and non-excitable tissue calcium channels, demonstrate the limitations of the capacitative calcium influx theory, and point to a distinction between the calcium response mechanisms utilized by B and T lymphocytes.

Enrichment of early fetal-liver hemopoietic stem cells of the rat using monoclonal antibodies against the transferrin receptor, Thy-1, and MRC-OX82.

Fetal livers from inbred rat fetuses at 14 days' gestation were dispersed into a single-cell suspension by physical disruption and collagenase digestion. Pluripotent stem cells were characterized and partially purified by a combination of monoclonal antibodies. These included CD71 (anti-transferrin receptor, MRC-OX26, used for rosetting), Cdw90 (anti-Thy-1, MRC-OX7), and the newly described MRC-OX82 (reacting with myeloiid cells in peritoneal exudate), employed in FACS sorting. Enrichment was monitored by long-term reconstitution of lethally irradiated congenic rats genetically distinguishable from the donor by an allelomorphic variant of the CD45 cell-surface antigen. At intervals from 3 months to 1 year, lymph-node cells and peritoneal exudate cells were biopsied for analysis by two-color flow cytometry--one color to determine donor origin, the other to identify Th cell (CD4+), Tc cell (CD8+), B cell (sIg+ or CD45RC+), neutrophil (OX82+ or OX43-), and macrophage (OX43+) compartments. The degree of chimaerism was taken as the read out of stem-cell activity. No significant differentials between lymph-node and peritoneal exudate chimaerisms were detected in any of the recipients; therefore, the enrichment procedure revealed only pluripotent cells, not stem cells of restricted potency. All recovered stem-cell activity was in the OX26(CD71)-negative, OX7(CDw90)-positive, OX82-positive fraction. In the optimum case, an enrichment of very roughly 200-fold in cell-for-cell activity was obtained. Rat bone-marrow colony-forming units in the spleen (CFUs-12) were found to lack the surface antigens recognized by the monoclonal antibodies CD53 (MRC-OX44), MRC-OX39, MRC-OX59, and 144.2.15. These would provide a strategy for their enrichment by depletion.

The extent of clonal structure in different lymphoid organs.

To gain insight into the clonal organization of lymphoid organs, we studied the distribution in situ of donor-derived cells in near-physiological chimeras. We introduced RT7b fetal liver cells into nonirradiated congenic RT7a neonatal rats. The chimerism 6-20 wk after injection ranged from 0.3 to 20%. The numbers of cell clones simultaneously contributing to cell generation in a particular histological feature were deduced from the variance in donor cell distribution. In bone marrow and thymus, donor-derived lymphoid cells were found scattered among host cells, indicating a high mobility of cells. In bone marrow, donor cells were evenly distributed over the entire marrow, even at low chimerism. This indicates that leukopoiesis is maintained by the proliferation of many clones. In the thymus, the various lobules showed different quantities of donor-derived lymphoid cells. Mathematical analysis of these differences indicated that 17-18 cell division cycles occur in the cortex. In spleen, the distribution of donor-derived cells over the germinal centers indicated that 5 d after antigenic stimulation, germinal centers develop oligoclonally. The main conclusions of this work are that (a) bone marrow and thymus are highly polyclonal; (b) 17-18 divisions occur between prothymocyte and mature T cell; and (c) lymphoid cells disperse rapidly while proliferating and differentiating.

Comparison of IgD+ and IgD- thoracic duct B lymphocytes as germinal center precursor cells in the rat.

Genetically marked thoracic duct B cell subpopulations rich in either IgD+ or IgD- B cells were transferred to non-irradiated, congenic rats in order to compare the capacities of IgD+ versus IgD- B cells to form germinal centers (GCs). This comparison was made quantitatively based on flow cytometric analyses of lymph node cells prepared from chimeric rats 7 days after s.c. immunization. Donor-origin and host-origin B cells were distinguished using anti-Igk antibodies, and GC B cells were distinguished from other B cells in suspension by their lack of labeling with the mAb HIS22. IgK+ HIS22- lymph node cells corresponded well to GC B cells: they contained many large cells, were IgM+ but mostly IgD-, expressed relatively lower levels of IgM than HIS22+ B cells, and increased in number and frequency in response to antigen. Results from flow cytometric analyses, corroborated by immunofluorescence histochemical studies, showed that cell-for-cell, IgD- B cells from GCs much more efficiently than IgD+ cells. B cell populations enriched for IgD- cells became relatively more distributed to GCs than to other lymph node B cell areas and gave rise to many more GC B cells of donor origin per transferred B cell than whole, unseparated thoracic duct B cells (for which greater than 97% were IgD+). IgD- B cells from rats primed deliberately with antigen also became relatively more distributed to GCs and gave rise to more GC B cells of donor origin than either IgD+ B cells from primed donors or IgD- B cells from unprimed donors.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Effect of fatty acids on the proliferation of concanavalin A-stimulated rat lymph node lymphocytes.

1. The effect of a range of fatty acids upon concanavalin A-stimulated [3H]thymidine incorporation into rat lymphocytes was investigated. 2. All fatty acids tested inhibited the response to mitogen but the extent of the inhibition was dependent upon the fatty acid concentration used, the time of addition of fatty acid and the duration of exposure of the cells to fatty acid. 3. All fatty acids were inhibitory at concentrations of 50 microM or above; at lower concentrations some were inhibitory and some were stimulatory. Above 50 microM the inhibitory effect was concentration dependent; the greater the fatty acid concentration, the greater the inhibition. 4. The longer the lymphocytes were exposed to the fatty acid the greater was the inhibitory effect. This was true if the fatty acids were added at the same time as the mitogenic stimulus or if they were added before or after the stimulus. Some fatty acids maintained their inhibitory effect when added 24 or 48 hr after the mitogenic stimulus. 5. Generally unsaturated fatty acids were more inhibitory than saturated fatty acids; the greatest inhibition of proliferation was caused by eicosapentaenoate and arachidonate and the least inhibition by myristate and palmitate. 6. Inhibition was greater in the absence of serum. 7. Inhibition by unsaturated fatty acids could be partially or totally relieved by addition in combination with myristate or palmitate, suggesting that the inhibitory effect of fatty acids may be due to alteration of membrane fluidity caused by an imbalance of fatty acids presented to the cells. 8. PGE2 levels were similar in the medium of cells grown in the presence of fatty acids with varying inhibitory effects, indicating that PGE2 production is not the sole mechanism of suppression of the proliferative response. 9. Although the mechanism by which fatty acids exert their effect remains to be determined, these results indicate that lymphocyte proliferation and so an immune response could be influenced by dietary lipid manipulation.

T lymphocytes in rat germinal centres belong to an ER3+ subpopulation of CD4+ cells.

Two-colour immunofluorescence histochemistry showed directly that greater than 90% of CD4+ germinal centre T cells in rat spleen or lymph node examined 7 days after immunization bear the antigen recognized by the monoclonal antibody (mAb) ER3. By contrast, only 30-40% of all thoracic duct or lymph node CD4+ cells were ER3+, as determined by two-colour flow cytometry. CD8+ cells were ER3+, but nearly all B cells were ER3-. Thus, germinal centre T cells belong to a subpopulation of CD4+ cells. Because only 25-30% of CD4+ cells that lack higher molecular weight forms of CD45 (i.e. mAb MRC OX32 cells, equivalent to MRC OX22 cells) express ER3, the CD4+ subpopulations defined by ER3 are neither identical nor complementary to the subsets defined by restricted expression of CD45 epitopes.

Does the availability of either B cells or CD4+ cells limit germinal centre formation?

To determine whether the availability of either B cells or T cells regulates the number and size of germinal centres observed following antigenic challenge, irradiated PVG rats were reconstituted with limiting numbers of thoracic duct B cells (with excess T cells) or with limiting numbers of thoracic duct CD4+ cells (with sufficient B cells). Germinal centre formation was measured histologically in the spleens of reconstituted rats 7 days after immunization with 2 x 10(9) sheep erythrocytes (at the height of the germinal centre reaction). Although reconstitution with B cells and antigen alone, or with thymocytes and antigen alone, produced no germinal centres, saturating numbers of germinal centres on the order observed for normal, non-irradiated rats were observed in irradiated rats reconstituted with only 10(7) B cells and 5 x 10(6) CD4+ cells. Germinal centres in the spleens of minimally reconstituted rats were also comparable in size to those observed in normal rats. Reconstitution with either 4 x 10(7) thoracic duct lymphocytes (including 2 x 10(7) B cells, as well as CD8+ and CD4+ cells) or with 4 x 10(7) thoracic duct lymphocytes and 2 x 10(8) thymocytes also led to saturating numbers of germinal centres. It is concluded therefore that (i) CD4+ cells are sufficient for the T-cell contribution required for germinal centre formation, and (ii) some factor other than the availability of B cells or CD4+ cells normally limits germinal centre formation.

Immigration of thoracic duct B lymphocytes into established germinal centers in the rat.

Immigration of B lymphocytes into established germinal centers in the rat was studied by transferring genetically marked thoracic duct B cells to non-irradiated congenic hosts at various times between 3 days before and 6 days after host immunization. Seven days after host immunization, the distribution of donor B cells to lymph node germinal centers (relative to their distribution to non-germinal center lymph node areas) was measured by two-color flow cytometry in which (a) donor and host B cells were distinguished by their Ig kappa chain allotypes, and (b) germinal center B cells were distinguished by their lack of labeling with the monoclonal antibody HIS22. Thoracic duct B cells from long-term antigen-primed rats were found to immigrate into host germinal centers much better than B cells from unprimed donors. This effect was antigen specific: primed B cells only immigrated well into host germinal centers induced by the priming antigen. Although B cells localized in germinal centers most efficiently when injected before immunization, specifically primed donor B cells injected after immunization were still found to be at least as evenly distributed to germinal centers as to other lymph node areas, whereas unprimed B cells transferred after immunization localized poorly in host germinal centers. These findings are discussed in light of recent suggestions that memory B cell clones are maintained by continued antigenic stimulation within secondary lymphoid follicles.

The origin of T cells in permanently reconstituted old athymic nude rats. Analysis using chromosome or allotype markers.

Athymic PVG-rnu/rnu rats receiving a single intravenous injection of syngeneic euthymic thoracic duct lymphocytes (TDL) develop normal levels of CD4+ T lymphocytes and survive for more than 2 years in a conventional animal house. We investigated the origin of the T cells (and B cells) in reconstituted nude recipients by transferring TDL carrying either the 3T chromosome marker or the RT6b + Igk-1b allotype or the RT7b (leucocyte-common) allotype markers. Karyotype analysis of spleen and lymph node (LN) cells from 1- to 2-year-old PVG-3T/3T-reconstituted nude recipients, stimulated in vitro with phytohaemagglutinin (PHA), unexpectedly revealed that a majority (79-97%) of dividing cells were of nude origin. However, extensive nude cell division was also recorded in PHA-stimulated cultures using mixtures of euthymic (PVG-3T/3T) and unreconstituted nude spleen cells; the assumption that only T cells divide in PHA-stimulated cultures thus appears to be erroneous. In contrast to the karyotype analysis, sIg- RT6b+ LN cells obtained from nude recipients reconstituted 2 years earlier with PVG-RT6b allotype-marked TDL, were all of donor origin with no indication of a nude-derived sIg- RT6a+ population. Igk-1b+ donor B cells were not found in these same recipients. Dual fluorescence analysis of TDL from 18- to 20-month RT7b-reconstituted nudes showed that 91-100% of CD4+ cells were donor-derived. When tested functionally, sIg- RT7b+ (donor) cells, but not sIg- RT7b- (nude-derived) cells, were able to reject skin allografts and induce local graft-versus-host (GVH) responses. Donor T cells, in contrast to CD4+ cells of nude origin, divided extensively in nude recipients; FACS-purified RT7b+ (donor) TDL retransferred from 17-month primary reconstituted nude rats, expanded further (60-100-fold) in secondary nude recipients. In conclusion, only the donor-derived CD4+ cells in reconstituted nude rats displayed T-cell function; evidence to the contrary from karyotype analysis was flawed. At no stage in their life did uninjected or T-cell reconstituted nude rats develop endogenous cells that in any way resembled CD4+ products of the thymus.

Rat immunoglobulin genes have comparable patterns of JH rearrangement in normal peripheral B cells and in pre-B and cultured TdT+ cells from bone marrow.

Pre-B cells from normal rat bone marrow were isolated by first rosette-depleting granulocytes, T cells and stem cells with W3/13 mAb and mature B cells with anti-Ig mAb, and then in some samples enriching by FACS-sorting HIS24+ cells. Presumptive precursors of these pre-B cells possessing terminal deoxy-nucleotidyl transferase were prepared by culture of normal marrow. The extent of rearrangement of kappa and heavy chain genes was estimated on both these types of cells and on mature peripheral B cells by measuring the disappearance of the germ-line restriction fragments encoding J segments (other than JH1) relative to a non-rearranging CK fragment. Pre-B cells and B cells showed similar degrees of rearrangement of their kappa genes, leaving roughly half in germ-line form; the TdT+-enriched cells showed approximately similar heavy chain rearrangement as the peripheral B cells. Some non-germ-line restriction fragments hybridising with JH in sufficient amount to register as discrete bands on Southern blots were found in common between these different cell populations taken from different individual donors. These may represent preferred D-JH or perhaps V-D-JH rearrangement arising repetitively in independent clones, or may be due to dominance by a few preferred clones.

A stathmokinetic study of B lymphocytopoiesis in rat bone marrow: proliferation of cells containing cytoplasmic mu-chains, terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase and carrying HIS24 antigen.

In rat bone marrow (BM), the B lineage surface antigen HIS24 is expressed by all surface mu chain-bearing (s mu+) B cells, by cytoplasmic mu chain-containing (c mu+s mu-) pre-B cells and TdT+ cells, and by lymphoid cells lacking both mu and TdT. Because TdT+ and HIS24+TdT-mu- cells may represent stages in B lymphocytopoiesis before mu chain expression, we investigated their kinetics. The metaphase arrest method was combined with immunofluorescence staining to detect proliferation and to quantitate cell production in the BM pre-B, TdT+, and HIS24+TdT-mu- compartments. Their apparent cell cycle times (tC(a)) were 38, 36, and 19 hr, and the number of cells produced per hour per femur were 58, 9, and 41 X 10(4), respectively. The HIS24+ compartments showed further phenotypic heterogeneity. Six percent of TdT+ cells expressed mu chains and were therefore pre-B cells. Twenty percent of HIS24+TdT-mu- cells expressed Ig other than mu chains, with size distribution and kinetics similar to HIS24+TdT-Ig- cells. Thus, the rate of production in the truly Ig-HIS24+ compartment was about 40 X 10(4)/hr/femur (8.5 by TdT+mu- and 33 by TdT-Ig-). In each phenotypic compartment, mitoses were confined to subsets of large (greater than 11 to 12 micron) cells with tC(a) of 13 to 15 hr. Surface mu+ B cells were essentially non-cycling. To quantitate whole body BM cell production, the recovery of marrow from bone and the distribution of BM were measured in 59Fe distribution experiments. The number of cells produced by whole body BM was estimated as follows: for pre-B cells, 4.5 X 10(8)/day; for TdT+mu-, 0.7 X 10(8)/day; and for HIS24+TdT-Ig- 2.6 X 10(8)/day. From the derived cell flux in these compartments we suggest that 1) many more pre-B cells are produced than needed by the peripheral B cell pool; 2) if TdT is an obligatory stage in B cell genesis, there must be at least two cell cycles in the pre-B cell compartment; 3) if it is not, the TdT+ stage may be bypassed, with HIS24+TdT-Ig- cells perhaps feeding directly into the pre-B cell compartment.

B lymphocyte-associated antigens on terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-positive cells and pre-B cells in bone marrow of the rat.

To investigate early stages of B lymphocytopoiesis in rat bone marrow (BM) before the expression of surface IgM (s mu), the populations of cytoplasmic mu-chain-positive (c mu+) pre-B cells and terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase-positive (TdT+) cells were studied by double immunofluorescence microscopy. B lymphocytes that were s mu+ constituted 5%, c mu+s mu- pre-B cells 23%, and TdT+ cells 4% of nucleated cells in the BM of juvenile rats. TdT+ and pre-B cells ranged between 7 and 17 microns in diameter. TdT+ cells were slightly larger, with a modal diameter of 10.5 microns against 9 microns for pre-B cells. mu-Chains were absent from nearly all TdT+ cells. Their surface antigenic phenotype was studied by using a panel of mouse monoclonal antibodies (MAb) to rat B lymphocyte-associated antigens (Ig, Ia, and others) and T lymphocyte-associated antigens. Both pre-B cells and TdT+ lacked surface Ig and Ia but carried most of the other B lymphocyte-associated antigens analyzed. TdT+ and pre-B cells lacked those antigens found only on the T lineage. By using MAb HIS24 (detecting a non-Ig/Ia B lymphocyte-associated antigen) and fluorescence-activated cell sorting, TdT+ and pre-B cells were highly enriched. The results show that most TdT+ cells in rat BM are mu- but demonstrate strong similarity with pre-B cells in surface antigenic phenotype. Therefore, as suggested for man, a major proportion of rat BM TdT+ cells may be B lineage-cells before mu heavy chain gene expression.

The host component of the popliteal lymph node graft-versus-host reaction. Selective representation of lymphocyte subsets and the requirement for alloantigenic incompatibility between donor cells and activated host B cells.

We have examined the cellular changes taking place in rat popliteal lymph nodes undergoing a graft-versus-host (GvH) reaction. Examination of immunoperoxidase-stained lymph node sections, using a panel of mouse monoclonal antibodies directed against different rat lymphoid cell subsets, revealed a disorganization of the lymph node architecture with disappearance of the follicles, and an intermingling of T and B cells, so that no distinct T- and B-cell areas were visible any more. Since the GvH nodes showed a preferential accumulation of host B cells over host T cells (particularly over the W 3/25+ T helper cell subset), we also investigated the requirements for host B cell activation. The popliteal lymph node GvH reaction was induced in (PVG X DA)F1 rats by the injection of PVG cells into one foot and by DA cells into the other foot, and then immunoglobulin kappa allotype marked PVG B cells from athymic donors were injected intravenously. The allotype marked B cells proliferated vigorously in response to the DA T cells, but much less in response to the PVG T cells. These results indicate that the massive B-cell activation taking place in GvH reactions may require an alloantigen incompatibility between donor T cells and host B cells, and argue against non-specific mitogenic induction of the B cells.

Analysis of lymphopoietic stem cells with a monoclonal antibody to the rat transferrin receptor.

A mouse monoclonal IgG2a antibody, designated MRC OX-26, is shown to be specific for the rat transferrin receptor, but does not block transferrin binding. The antibody labelled a myeloma, three leukaemia cell lines and normal dividing cells of various types, but also bound to a number of nondividing normal tissues. No labelling of lymphopoietic stem cells could be detected, even though approximately 25% of bone marrow and over 95% of fetal liver cells were clearly labelled.