Treatment of oropharyngeal carcinoma by irradiation or by surgery.

Of previously untreated patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the oropharynx, 145 are reviewed in this study. All were treated in the Department of Head and Neck Surgery at the University of Liverpool from 1990 to 1997. Seventy-seven patients were treated with irradiation, 28 patients by surgery and 40 patients were deemed not suitable for any curative treatment. Univariate analysis showed no difference in the two groups treated by curative modalities but multivariate analysis did suggest that the surgical group tended to have larger neck node metastases. The 5-year tumour specific actuarial survival for all patients was 53%, 65% for the radiotherapy group and 51% for the surgery group. The difference was not statistically significant (chi (1)2 = 1.5070). The modality of treatment had no affect on either the development of a primary or neck node recurrence or the survival after such a recurrence. Where neck node disease was present it was treated as appropriate. As is generally standard practice, lymph nodes over 2 cm were treated with radical neck dissection whether the patient was having irradiation therapy or surgery. If the patient was having irradiation therapy, the neck dissection was carried out before and irradiation after operation, both on the primary and on the neck, if appropriate. It is concluded that irradiation therapy in properly selected cases in combined head and neck clinics is a safe and effective treatment for squamous cell carcinoma of the oropharynx. Neck node disease should be treated appropriately, but there is no support for the old adage that whatever form of treatment is being used for the neck node should also be used for the primary site.

The treatment of early squamous cell carcinoma of the piriform fossa.

The treatment of early piriform fossa cancer can be either primary radiotherapy with salvage surgery, if necessary, or with primary surgery. The present study investigates 65 patients with T1, > or = 2 or T3 stage disease with no cervical lymph node metastases at presentation. Of this group, 17 were treated by primary irradiation, 34 underwent primary surgery and 14 were unsuitable for any curative treatment. The adjusted actuarial 5-year survival rate for those patients receiving primary radiotherapy was 55% (95% CI 16-78%) and for the surgery group it was 44% (95% CI 18-67%). This difference was not significant (chi 2(1) = 1.29). The median survival for untreated patients was 7 months (4-12 months). There was no significant differences in the time to recurrence at the primary site or in the neck, or in survival after recurrence at these sites. Thirty-five per cent of patients treated by primary irradiation were controlled at the primary site compared with 68% in the surgical group. Failure in the neck was similar for the two groups at 12% and 15% respectively. Salvage surgery was effective for the radiotherapy group with eight out of 11 patients being suitable for treatment. In the final analysis in the radiotherapy group two patients were alive and with their larynx and two alive without their larynx, the remainder of patients having died from the original tumour, intercurrent disease or second primary tumours. The survival figures for the surgery group were proportionately similar except of course, that all patients had lost their larynx.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)