Elevated thyroid manganese reduces thyroid iodine to induce hypothyroidism in mice, but not rats, lacking SLC30A10 transporter.

Elevated manganese (Mn) accumulates in the brain and induces neurotoxicity. SLC30A10 is an Mn efflux transporter that controls body Mn levels. We previously reported that full-body Slc30a10 knockout mice (1) recapitulate the body Mn retention phenotype of humans with loss-of-function SLC30A10 mutations and (2) unexpectedly develop hypothyroidism induced by Mn accumulation in the thyroid, which reduces intra-thyroid thyroxine. Subsequent analyses of National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey data identified an association between serum Mn and subclinical thyroid changes. The emergence of thyroid deficits as a feature of Mn toxicity suggests that changes in thyroid function may be an underappreciated, but critical, modulator of Mn-induced disease. To better understand the relationship between thyroid function and Mn toxicity, here we further defined the mechanism of Mn-induced hypothyroidism using mouse and rat models. Slc30a10 knockout mice exhibited a profound deficit in thyroid iodine levels that occurred contemporaneously with increases in thyroid Mn levels and preceded the onset of overt hypothyroidism. Wild-type Mn-exposed mice also exhibited increased thyroid Mn levels, an inverse correlation between thyroid Mn and iodine levels, and subclinical hypothyroidism. In contrast, thyroid iodine levels were unaltered in newly generated Slc30a10 knockout rats despite an increase in thyroid Mn levels, and the knockout rats were euthyroid. Thus, Mn-induced thyroid dysfunction in genetic or Mn exposure-induced mouse models occurs due to a reduction in thyroid iodine subsequent to an increase in thyroid Mn levels. Moreover, rat and mouse thyroids have differential sensitivities to Mn, which may impact the manifestations of Mn-induced disease in these routinely used animal models.

Loss of SLC30A10 manganese transporter alters expression of neurotransmission genes and activates hypoxia-inducible factor signaling in mice.

The essential metal manganese (Mn) induces neuromotor disease at elevated levels. The manganese efflux transporter SLC30A10 regulates brain Mn levels. Homozygous loss-of-function mutations in SLC30A10 induce hereditary Mn neurotoxicity in humans. Our prior characterization of Slc30a10 knockout mice recapitulated the high brain Mn levels and neuromotor deficits reported in humans. But, mechanisms of Mn-induced motor deficits due to SLC30A10 mutations or elevated Mn exposure are unclear. To gain insights into this issue, we characterized changes in gene expression in the basal ganglia, the main brain region targeted by Mn, of Slc30a10 knockout mice using unbiased transcriptomics. Compared with littermates, >1000 genes were upregulated or downregulated in the basal ganglia sub-regions (i.e. caudate putamen, globus pallidus, and substantia nigra) of the knockouts. Pathway analyses revealed notable changes in genes regulating synaptic transmission and neurotransmitter function in the knockouts that may contribute to the motor phenotype. Expression changes in the knockouts were essentially normalized by a reduced Mn chow, establishing that changes were Mn dependent. Upstream regulator analyses identified hypoxia-inducible factor (HIF) signaling, which we recently characterized to be a primary cellular response to elevated Mn, as a critical mediator of the transcriptomic changes in the basal ganglia of the knockout mice. HIF activation was also evident in the liver of the knockout mice. These results: (i) enhance understanding of the pathobiology of Mn-induced motor disease; (ii) identify specific target genes/pathways for future mechanistic analyses; and (iii) independently corroborate the importance of the HIF pathway in Mn homeostasis and toxicity.

Hepatic and intestinal manganese excretion are both required to regulate brain manganese during elevated manganese exposure.

Manganese (Mn) is essential but neurotoxic at elevated levels. Under physiological conditions, Mn is primarily excreted by the liver, with the intestines playing a secondary role. Recent analyses of tissue-specific Slc30a10 or Slc39a14 knockout mice (SLC30A10 and SLC39A14 are Mn transporters) revealed that, under physiological conditions: 1) excretion of Mn by the liver and intestines is a major pathway that regulates brain Mn; and surprisingly, 2) the intestines compensate for loss of hepatic Mn excretion in controlling brain Mn. The unexpected importance of the intestines in controlling physiological brain Mn led us to determine the role of hepatic and intestinal Mn excretion in regulating brain Mn during elevated Mn exposure. We used liver- or intestine-specific Slc30a10 knockout mice as models to inhibit hepatic or intestinal Mn excretion. Compared with littermates, both knockout strains exhibited similar increases in brain Mn after elevated Mn exposure in early or later life. Thus, unlike physiological conditions, both hepatic and intestinal Mn excretion are required to control brain Mn during elevated Mn exposure. However, brain Mn levels of littermates and both knockout strains exposed to elevated Mn only in early life were normalized in later life. Thus, hepatic and intestinal Mn excretion play compensatory roles in clearing brain Mn accumulated by early life Mn exposure. Finally, neuromotor assays provided evidence consistent with a role for hepatic and intestinal Mn excretion in functionally modulating Mn neurotoxicity during Mn exposure. Put together, these findings substantially enhance understanding of the regulation of brain Mn by excretion.NEW & NOTEWORTHY This article shows that, in contrast with expectations from prior studies and physiological conditions, excretion of manganese by the intestines and liver is equally important in controlling brain manganese during human-relevant manganese exposure. The results provide foundational insights about the interorgan mechanisms that control brain manganese homeostasis at the organism level and have important implications for the development of therapeutics to treat manganese-induced neurological disease.

Analysis of 1,25-Dihydroxyvitamin D3 Genomic Action Reveals Calcium-Regulating and Calcium-Independent Effects in Mouse Intestine and Human Enteroids.

Although vitamin D is critical for the function of the intestine, most studies have focused on the duodenum. We show that transgenic expression of the vitamin D receptor (VDR) only in the distal intestine of VDR null mice (KO/TG mice) results in the normalization of serum calcium and rescue of rickets. Although it had been suggested that calcium transport in the distal intestine involves a paracellular process, we found that the 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 [1,25(OH)2D3]-activated genes in the proximal intestine associated with active calcium transport (Trpv6, S100g, and Atp2b1) are also induced by 1,25(OH)2D3 in the distal intestine of KO/TG mice. In addition, Slc30a10, encoding a manganese efflux transporter, was one of the genes most induced by 1,25(OH)2D3 in both proximal and distal intestine. Both villus and crypt were found to express Vdr and VDR target genes. RNA sequence (RNA-seq) analysis of human enteroids indicated that the effects of 1,25(OH)2D3 observed in mice are conserved in humans. Using Slc30a10-/- mice, a loss of cortical bone and a marked decrease in S100g and Trpv6 in the intestine was observed. Our findings suggest an interrelationship between vitamin D and intestinal Mn efflux and indicate the importance of distal intestinal segments to vitamin D action.

Tamoxifen blocks retrograde trafficking of Shiga toxin 1 and 2 and protects against lethal toxicosis.

Shiga toxin 1 (STx1) and 2 (STx2), produced by Shiga toxin-producing Escherichia coli, cause lethal untreatable disease. The toxins invade cells via retrograde trafficking. Direct early endosome-to-Golgi transport allows the toxins to evade degradative late endosomes. Blocking toxin trafficking, particularly at the early endosome-to-Golgi step, is appealing, but transport mechanisms of the more disease-relevant STx2 are unclear. Using data from a genome-wide siRNA screen, we discovered that disruption of the fusion of late endosomes, but not autophagosomes, with lysosomes blocked the early endosome-to-Golgi transport of STx2. A subsequent screen of clinically approved lysosome-targeting drugs identified tamoxifen (TAM) to be a potent inhibitor of the trafficking and toxicity of STx1 and STx2 in cells. The protective effect was independent of estrogen receptors but dependent on the weak base property of TAM, which allowed TAM to increase endolysosomal pH and alter endosomal dynamics. Importantly, TAM treatment enhanced survival of mice injected with a lethal dose of STx1 or STx2. Thus, it may be possible to repurpose TAM for treating Shiga toxin-producing E. coli infections.

SLC30A10 transporter in the digestive system regulates brain manganese under basal conditions while brain SLC30A10 protects against neurotoxicity.

The essential metal manganese becomes neurotoxic at elevated levels. Yet, the mechanisms by which brain manganese homeostasis is regulated are unclear. Loss-of-function mutations in SLC30A10, a cell surface-localized manganese efflux transporter in the brain and liver, induce familial manganese neurotoxicity. To elucidate the role of SLC30A10 in regulating brain manganese, we compared the phenotypes of whole-body and tissue-specific Slc30a10 knockout mice. Surprisingly, unlike whole-body knockouts, brain manganese levels were unaltered in pan-neuronal/glial Slc30a10 knockouts under basal physiological conditions. Further, although transport into bile is a major route of manganese excretion, manganese levels in the brain, blood, and liver of liver-specific Slc30a10 knockouts were only minimally elevated, suggesting that another organ compensated for loss-of-function in the liver. Additional assays revealed that SLC30A10 was also expressed in the gastrointestinal tract. In differentiated enterocytes, SLC30A10 localized to the apical/luminal domain and transported intracellular manganese to the lumen. Importantly, endoderm-specific knockouts, lacking SLC30A10 in the liver and gastrointestinal tract, had markedly elevated manganese levels in the brain, blood, and liver. Thus, under basal physiological conditions, brain manganese is regulated by activity of SLC30A10 in the liver and gastrointestinal tract, and not the brain or just the liver. Notably, however, brain manganese levels of endoderm-specific knockouts were lower than whole-body knockouts, and only whole-body knockouts exhibited manganese-induced neurobehavioral defects. Moreover, after elevated exposure, pan-neuronal/glial knockouts had higher manganese levels in the basal ganglia and thalamus than controls. Therefore, when manganese levels increase, activity of SLC30A10 in the brain protects against neurotoxicity.

Hypothyroidism induced by loss of the manganese efflux transporter SLC30A10 may be explained by reduced thyroxine production.

SLC30A10 and SLC39A14 are manganese efflux and influx transporters, respectively. Loss-of-function mutations in genes encoding either transporter induce hereditary manganese toxicity. Patients have elevated manganese in the blood and brain and develop neurotoxicity. Liver manganese is increased in patients lacking SLC30A10 but not SLC39A14. These organ-specific changes in manganese were recently recapitulated in knockout mice. Surprisingly, Slc30a10 knockouts also had elevated thyroid manganese and developed hypothyroidism. To determine the mechanisms of manganese-induced hypothyroidism and understand how SLC30A10 and SLC39A14 cooperatively mediate manganese detoxification, here we produced Slc39a14 single and Slc30a10/Slc39a14 double knockout mice and compared their phenotypes with that of Slc30a10 single knockouts. Compared with wild-type controls, Slc39a14 single and Slc30a10/Slc39a14 double knockouts had higher manganese levels in the blood and brain but not in the liver. In contrast, Slc30a10 single knockouts had elevated manganese levels in the liver as well as in the blood and brain. Furthermore, SLC30A10 and SLC39A14 localized to the canalicular and basolateral domains of polarized hepatic cells, respectively. Thus, transport activities of both SLC39A14 and SLC30A10 are required for hepatic manganese excretion. Compared with Slc30a10 single knockouts, Slc39a14 single and Slc30a10/Slc39a14 double knockouts had lower thyroid manganese levels and normal thyroid function. Moreover, intrathyroid thyroxine levels of Slc30a10 single knockouts were lower than those of controls. Thus, the hypothyroidism phenotype of Slc30a10 single knockouts is induced by elevated thyroid manganese, which blocks thyroxine production. These findings provide new insights into the mechanisms of manganese detoxification and manganese-induced thyroid dysfunction.

Deficiency in the manganese efflux transporter SLC30A10 induces severe hypothyroidism in mice.

Manganese is an essential metal that becomes toxic at elevated levels. Loss-of-function mutations in SLC30A10, a cell-surface-localized manganese efflux transporter, cause a heritable manganese metabolism disorder resulting in elevated manganese levels and parkinsonian-like movement deficits. The underlying disease mechanisms are unclear; therefore, treatment is challenging. To understand the consequences of loss of SLC30A10 function at the organism level, we generated Slc30a10 knock-out mice. During early development, knock-outs were indistinguishable from controls. Surprisingly, however, after weaning and compared with controls, knock-out mice failed to gain weight, were smaller, and died prematurely (by ∼6-8 weeks of age). At 6 weeks, manganese levels in the brain, blood, and liver of the knock-outs were ∼20-60-fold higher than controls. Unexpectedly, histological analyses revealed that the brain and liver of the knock-outs were largely unaffected, but their thyroid exhibited extensive alterations. Because hypothyroidism leads to growth defects and premature death in mice, we assayed for changes in thyroid and pituitary hormones. At 6 weeks and compared with controls, the knock-outs had markedly reduced thyroxine levels (∼50-80%) and profoundly increased thyroid-stimulating hormone levels (∼800-1000-fold), indicating that Slc30a10 knock-out mice develop hypothyroidism. Importantly, a low-manganese diet produced lower tissue manganese levels in the knock-outs and rescued the phenotype, suggesting that manganese toxicity was the underlying cause. Our unanticipated discovery highlights the importance of determining the role of thyroid dysfunction in the onset and progression of manganese-induced disease and identifies Slc30a10 knock-out mice as a new model for studying thyroid biology.

SLC30A10 is a cell surface-localized manganese efflux transporter, and parkinsonism-causing mutations block its intracellular trafficking and efflux activity.

Manganese (Mn) is an essential metal, but elevated cellular levels are toxic and may lead to the development of an irreversible parkinsonian-like syndrome that has no treatment. Mn-induced parkinsonism generally occurs as a result of exposure to elevated Mn levels in occupational or environmental settings. Additionally, patients with compromised liver function attributable to diseases, such as cirrhosis, fail to excrete Mn and may develop Mn-induced parkinsonism in the absence of exposure to elevated Mn. Recently, a new form of familial parkinsonism was reported to occur as a result of mutations in SLC30A10. The cellular function of SLC30A10 and the mechanisms by which mutations in this protein cause parkinsonism are unclear. Here, using a combination of mechanistic and functional studies in cell culture, Caenorhabditis elegans, and primary midbrain neurons, we show that SLC30A10 is a cell surface-localized Mn efflux transporter that reduces cellular Mn levels and protects against Mn-induced toxicity. Importantly, mutations in SLC30A10 that cause familial parkinsonism blocked the ability of the transporter to traffic to the cell surface and to mediate Mn efflux. Although expression of disease-causing SLC30A10 mutations were not deleterious by themselves, neurons and worms expressing these mutants exhibited enhanced sensitivity to Mn toxicity. Our results provide novel insights into the mechanisms involved in the onset of a familial form of parkinsonism and highlight the possibility of using enhanced Mn efflux as a therapeutic strategy for the potential management of Mn-induced parkinsonism, including that occurring as a result of mutations in SLC30A10.

Cocaine-induced adaptations in cellular redox balance contributes to enduring behavioral plasticity.

Impaired glutamate homeostasis in the nucleus accumbens has been linked to cocaine relapse in animal models, and results in part from cocaine-induced downregulation of the cystine-glutamate exchanger. In addition to regulating extracellular glutamate, the uptake of cystine by the exchanger is a rate-limiting step in the synthesis of glutathione (GSH). GSH is critical for balancing cellular redox in response to oxidative stress. Cocaine administration induces oxidative stress, and we first determined if downregulated cystine-glutamate exchange alters redox homeostasis in rats withdrawn from daily cocaine injections and then challenged with acute cocaine. Among the daily cocaine-induced changes in redox homeostasis were an increase in protein S-glutathionylation and a decrease in expression of GSH-S-transferase pi (GSTpi). To mimic reduced GSTpi, a genetic mouse model of GSTpi deletion or pharmacological inhibition of GSTpi by administering ketoprofen during daily cocaine administration was used. The capacity of cocaine to induce conditioned place preference or locomotor sensitization was augmented, indicating that reducing GSTpi may contribute to cocaine-induced behavioral neuroplasticity. Conversely, an acute cocaine challenge after withdrawal from daily cocaine elicited a marked increase in accumbens GSTpi, and the expression of behavioral sensitization to a cocaine challenge injection was inhibited by ketoprofen pretreatment; supporting a protective effect by the acute cocaine-induced rise in GSTpi. Together, these data indicate that cocaine-induced oxidative stress induces changes in GSTpi that contribute to cocaine-induced behavioral plasticity.

Cellular resistance to a nitric oxide releasing glutathione S-transferase P-activated prodrug, PABA/NO.

PABA/NO is a diazeniumdiolate selectively activated by glutathione S-transferase P (GSTP) to release nitric oxide (NO) and is a potent inducer of protein S-glutathionylation, a redox-sensitive post-translational modification of cysteine residues. Using a procedure that incrementally increased exposure of cells to PABA/NO, an acquired drug resistant human promyelocytic leukemia HL60 cell line (HL60(PABA)) that exhibited 1.9-fold resistance to the drug (IC(50) 15 µM vs ~8 µM for wild-type) was created. HL60(PABA) cells had a decreased growth rate attributable to altered cellular differentiation, as measured by increased expression of CD11b; decreased expression of CD14; decreased nuclear to cytoplasmic ratios and a condensation of nuclear chromatin. This was accompanied by alterations in both plasma and mitochondrial membrane potentials. Both GSTP expression and nitric oxide release were reduced two-fold, while increased expression levels of genes involved in the unfolded protein response (UPR) were evident in HL60(PABA) cells. Wild type cells treated with PABA/NO had increased levels of protein S-glutathionylation and JNK activation, while JNK was constitutively active in HL60(PABA) cells and these cells had reduced levels of S-glutathionylation. By removing PABA/NO from the growth medium, HL60(PABA) cells reverted to sensitivity within 21 days suggesting that resistance was not genetically stable. Mechanistically, PABA/NO resistance is mediated through reduced levels of GSTP resulting in reduced NO release and its subsequent alterations in cellular response to nitrosative stress.

Diazeniumdiolate mediated nitrosative stress alters nitric oxide homeostasis through intracellular calcium and S-glutathionylation of nitric oxide synthetase.

BACKGROUND: PABA/NO is a diazeniumdiolate that acts as a direct nitrogen monoxide (NO) donor and is in development as an anticancer drug. Its mechanism of action and effect on cells is not yet fully understood. METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: We used HPLC and mass spectrometry to identify a primary nitroaromatic glutathione metabolite of PABA/NO and used fluorescent assays to characterize drug effects on calcium and NO homeostasis, relating these to endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) activity. Unexpectedly, the glutathione conjugate was found to be a competitive inhibitor of sarcoplasmic/endoplasmic reticulum Ca2+-ATPase (SERCA) presumably at the same site as thapsigargin, increasing intracellular Ca2+ release and causing auto-regulation of eNOS through S-glutathionylation. CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE: The initial direct release of NO after PABA/NO was followed by an eNOS-mediated generation of NO as a consequence of drug-induced increase in Ca2+ flux and calmodulin (CaM) activation. PABA/NO has a unique dual mechanism of action with direct intracellular NO generation combined with metabolite driven regulation of eNOS activation.

Nitrosative stress-induced s-glutathionylation of protein disulfide isomerase leads to activation of the unfolded protein response.

The rapid proliferation of cancer cells mandates a high protein turnover. The endoplasmic reticulum (ER) is intimately involved in protein processing. An accumulation of unfolded or misfolded proteins in the ER leads to a cascade of transcriptional and translational events collectively called the unfolded protein response (UPR). Protein disulfide isomerase (PDI) is one of the most abundant ER proteins and maintains a sentinel function in organizing accurate protein folding. Treatment of cells with O(2)-[2,4-dinitro-5-(N-methyl-N-4-carboxyphenylamino)phenyl]1-(N,N-dimethylamino)diazen-1-ium-1,2-diolate (PABA/NO) resulted in a dose-dependent increase in intracellular nitric oxide that caused S-glutathionylation of various proteins. Within 4 h, PABA/NO activated the UPR and led to translational attenuation as measured by the phosphorylation and activation of the ER transmembrane kinase, pancreatic ER kinase, and its downstream effector eukaryotic initiation factor 2 in human leukemia (HL60) and ovarian cancer cells (SKOV3). Cleavage of the transcription factor X-box protein 1 and transcriptional activation of the ER resident proteins BiP, PDI, GRP94, and ERO1 (5- to 10-fold induction) also occurred. Immunoprecipitation of PDI showed that whereas nitrosylation was undetectable, PABA/NO treatment caused S-glutathionylation of PDI. Mass spectroscopy analysis showed that single cysteine residues within each of the catalytic sites of PDI had a mass increase [+305.3 Da] consistent with S-glutathionylation. Circular dichroism confirmed that S-glutathionylation of PDI results in alterations in the alpha-helix content of PDI and is concurrent with inhibition of its isomerase activity. Thus, it appears that S-glutathionylation of PDI is an upstream signaling event in the UPR and may be linked with the cytotoxic potential of PABA/NO.

Novel role for glutathione S-transferase pi. Regulator of protein S-Glutathionylation following oxidative and nitrosative stress.

Glutathione S-transferase Pi (GSTpi) is a marker protein in many cancers and high levels are linked to drug resistance, even when the selecting drug is not a substrate. S-Glutathionylation of proteins is critical to cellular stress response, but characteristics of the forward reaction are not known. Our results show that GSTpi potentiates S-glutathionylation reactions following oxidative and nitrosative stress in vitro and in vivo. Mutational analysis indicated that the catalytic activity of GST is required. GSTpi is itself redox-regulated. S-Glutathionylation on Cys47 and Cys101 autoregulates GSTpi, breaks ligand binding interactions with c-Jun NH2-terminal kinase (JNK), and causes GSTpi multimer formation, all critical to stress response. Catalysis of S-glutathionylation at low pK cysteines in proteins is a novel property for GSTpi and may be a cause for its abundance in tumors and cells resistant to a range of mechanistically unrelated anticancer drugs.

NOV-002, a glutathione disulfide mimetic, as a modulator of cellular redox balance.

NOV-002 is a novel glutathione disulfide mimetic that when administered in combination with standard chemotherapeutic regimens has resulted in increased efficacy (survival, tumor response) and improved tolerance to chemotherapy (e.g., hematologic recovery) in advanced non-small cell lung cancer patients. We show that NOV-002, which is not cytotoxic as a single agent, generated time- and concentration-dependent oxidative signals at the cell surface (reduction in protein thiols) and intracellularly [altered oxidized glutathione (GSSG) and reduced glutathione levels and ratio; increased reactive oxygen species] in the premyeloid HL-60 cell line and that this was associated with an increase in S-glutathionylation of cell proteins, particularly actin. Commensurate with these effects, NOV-002 activated p38, c-Jun-NH(2)-kinase, and extracellular signal-regulated kinase and caused a dose-dependent increase in phosphorylation of three proteins that have previously been linked with hematopoiesis, AKT, JAK2, and STAT5. The effect of NOV-002 on enzymes involved in glutathione metabolism was evaluated. Relative to oxidized glutathione, NOV-002 was an equivalent substrate for glutathione reductase and was an inhibitor of protein disulfide isomerase, one of the components of the redox-sensitive unfolded protein response pathway. These redox-stimulated cell signaling actions occurred in the context of increased HL-60 cell proliferation after treatment with NOV-002. Overall, the pleiotropic pharmacologic effects of NOV-002 can be attributed to the GSSG component of the drug, and modulation of cellular redox balance is a feature central to the mechanism of action of NOV-002. Such modulation may underlie its clinical actions, including hematologic recovery and immunostimulation in the face of chemosuppression.

Identification of genes required for embryo development in Arabidopsis.

A long-term goal of Arabidopsis research is to define the minimal gene set needed to produce a viable plant with a normal phenotype under diverse conditions. This will require both forward and reverse genetics along with novel strategies to characterize multigene families and redundant biochemical pathways. Here we describe an initial dataset of 250 EMB genes required for normal embryo development in Arabidopsis. This represents the first large-scale dataset of essential genes in a flowering plant. When compared with 550 genes with other knockout phenotypes, EMB genes are enriched for basal cellular functions, deficient in transcription factors and signaling components, have fewer paralogs, and are more likely to have counterparts among essential genes of yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae) and worm (Caenorhabditis elegans). EMB genes also represent a valuable source of plant-specific proteins with unknown functions required for growth and development. Analyzing such unknowns is a central objective of genomics efforts worldwide. We focus here on 34 confirmed EMB genes with unknown functions, demonstrate that expression of these genes is not embryo-specific, validate a strategy for identifying interacting proteins through complementation with epitope-tagged proteins, and discuss the value of EMB genes in identifying novel proteins associated with important plant processes. Based on sequence comparison with essential genes in other model eukaryotes, we identify 244 candidate EMB genes without paralogs that represent promising targets for reverse genetics. These candidates should facilitate the recovery of additional genes required for seed development.