Analysis of potential mercury policies: the impact of stream basin characteristics on susceptible populations.

Human exposure to Hg through fish consumption from local waterways is an ongoing concern to regulatory decision makers. Previously described population exposure and bioaccumulation models were combined to analyze the impact of potential policies on susceptible populations. The combined model simulated the problem of Hg exposure by examining the system from the point of Hg in the water column to its concentration in population biomarkers. Evaluated policy scenarios included the protectiveness of fish consumption advisories, total maximum daily load changes, and watershed management strategies. Simulations indicated that the characteristics of a basin combined with the unique pattern of intake rates of susceptible populations determine the risk associated with fish consumption from a given waterway. Each population had a unique pattern of biomarker response to changes in fish tissue Hg. Management strategies that lowered bioaccumulation rates also reduced ecosystem services. Reducing fish tissue contamination through reductions in Hg loading to watersheds is a long-term solution. For the short-term, fish consumption advisories should be used to protect populations from adverse exposures. The combination of characteristics of the basin and the populations that fish from the waterway should be the determinant for setting advisories.

A dynamic model using monitoring data and watershed characteristics to project fish tissue mercury concentrations in stream systems.

A complex interplay of factors determines the degree of bioaccumulation of Hg in fish in any particular basin. Although certain watershed characteristics have been associated with higher or lower bioaccumulation rates, the relationships between these characteristics are poorly understood. To add to this understanding, a dynamic model was built to examine these relationships in stream systems. The model follows Hg from the water column, through microbial conversion and subsequent concentration, through the food web to piscivorous fish. The model was calibrated to 7 basins in Kentucky and further evaluated by comparing output to 7 sites in, or proximal to, the Ohio River Valley, an underrepresented region in the bioaccumulation literature. Water quality and basin characteristics were inputs into the model, with tissue concentrations of Hg of generic trophic level 3, 3.5, and 4 fish the output. Regulatory and monitoring data were used to calibrate and evaluate the model. Mean average prediction error for Kentucky sites was 26%, whereas mean error for evaluation sites was 51%. Variability within natural systems can be substantial and was quantified for fish tissue by analysis of the US Geological Survey National Fish Database. This analysis pointed to the need for more systematic sampling of fish tissue. Analysis of model output indicated that parameters that had the greatest impact on bioaccumulation influenced the system at several points. These parameters included forested and wetlands coverage and nutrient levels. Factors that were less sensitive modified the system at only 1 point and included the unfiltered total Hg input and the portion of the basin that is developed.

Development and evaluation of a dynamic model that projects population biomarkers of methylmercury exposure from local fish consumption.

A dynamic model was developed to project Hg concentrations in common biomarkers of exposure in response to changes in Hg concentrations in predatory fish from local waters. The model predicts biomarkers in susceptible populations for intake rates representing the mean, 90th, 95th, and 99 th percentiles of populations of interest. The biomarkers the model calculates are blood methylmercury, total hair Hg, and fetal blood methylmercury. Decision makers can use the model to determine the degree of reduction in fish tissue Hg levels necessary to protect the health of susceptible populations. Biomarker output was calibrated with literature sources. Output was then compared to additional literature sources to evaluate model function. Projected biomarkers were not different from literature sources. The model can be used as a tool to understand the impact of local fish consumption on susceptible populations.

History and results of the two inter-laboratory round robin endotoxin assay studies on cotton dust.

BACKGROUND: In the US cotton industry, airborne cotton dust levels are regulated, and other countries are moving to specify safety limits for airborne endotoxins. There is concern about potential respiratory health hazards associated with agricultural and other organic dusts. In laboratories, ranking which samples have high and low levels of endotoxin is usually in good agreement between laboratories. When different laboratories assay identical samples, the levels differ. The objective of this research was to evaluate the intra- and inter-laboratory variability for 13 laboratories measuring endotoxin in cotton dust. METHOD: Two inter-laboratory round robin endotoxin assay studies were conducted using cotton dust. In the first round robin, each laboratory used their normal in-house assay method and then used a common extraction protocol. In the second round robin, a common extraction protocol and endotoxin assay kit was used. RESULTS: The intra-laboratory results had small variations but inter-laboratory results had very high variations. The inter-laboratory results using a common extraction protocol showed reduced differences. Using the same extraction protocol and endotoxin assay kit, the intra-laboratory variation was small and inter-laboratory variation was reduced but not enough for inter-laboratory agreement. Most of the laboratories were able to discern between the high and low endotoxin concentration dusts. CONCLUSIONS: Standardization has reduced the differences in results between laboratories and possibly further standardization may bring closer inter-laboratory agreement.

Inter-laboratory analysis of endotoxin in cotton dust samples.

BACKGROUND: Currently there are no mandated exposure limits for endotoxin, but recommended limits have been proposed and interest expressed in developing quantitative standards for endotoxin. A limitation for developing a quantitative standard for endotoxin is the measurement variability between laboratories. Inter-laboratory variability of up to four orders of magnitude has been reported for replicate samples. To evaluate both the intra- and inter-laboratory variability, Round-Robin studies were conducted using replicate samples of cotton dust. METHODS: Replicate samples of cotton dust were collected using vertical elutriators (VE) in a model cardroom. Each participating laboratory evaluated the samples for endotoxin using: their normal extraction procedure; a common extraction procedure; and a common extraction procedure and the same type and lot of a commercially available endotoxin kit. RESULTS: These studies demonstrated that both intra- and inter-laboratory variability is reduced by using a common extraction protocol and a common assay kit; however, significant differences remained between the laboratories. CONCLUSIONS: The data suggest that intra-laboratory assays can be used to assess the relative differences between endotoxin samples, however, the inter-laboratory variability suggests that limitations remain for developing a reliable exposure assessment assay that could be used for a quantitative exposure standard.

Partially opened triple helix is the biologically active conformation of 1-->3-beta-glucans that induces pulmonary inflammation in rats.

1-->3-beta-Glucans produce pulmonary inflammation in rats and are commonly found in indoor air dust samples. Conformation is an important factor determining the biological activity of 1-->3-beta-glucans. The partially opened triple-helix conformation induced by NaOH treatment and the annealed triple-helix conformation have been identified by fluorescence resonance energy transfer spectroscopy in our previous study. The objective of this study was to examine the role of these conformations of 1-->3-beta-glucans in the induction of pulmonary inflammation in rats. A partially opened triple-helix conformation of the known inflammatory 1-->3-beta-glucan zymosan was prepared by treating zymosan with NaOH followed by neutralization and dialysis. The annealed triple-helix conformation was prepared by allowing the partially opened triple-helix conformation to anneal for 9 d at room temperature. Rats were exposed to fresh or annealed NaOH-treated zymosan via intratracheal instillation. The results show that the zymosan-induced pulmonary inflammatory responses were significantly reduced after the 9-d annealing period, which suggests that this inflammatory response was dependent on the conformation of zymosan. Freezing NaOH-treated zymosan (for 7 d) inhibited the annealing process. Exposure of rats to thawed preparations of zymosan resulted in the same inflammatory responses as the freshly prepared partially opened triple-helix zymosan. In contrast, the potency of untreated zymosan did not change significantly following a 7-d annealing period, indicating that annealing occurs only after the conformation has been modified by NaOH treatment. This study indicates that the partially opened triple helix of 1-->3-beta-glucans is more active than the closed conformation in inducing pulmonary inflammation in rats.