The Mutant ßE202K Sliding Clamp Protein Impairs DNA Polymerase III Replication Activity.

Expression of the Escherichia coli dnaN-encoded ß clamp at ≥10-fold higher than chromosomally expressed levels impedes growth by interfering with DNA replication. We hypothesized that the excess ß clamp sequesters the replicative DNA polymerase III (Pol III) to inhibit replication. As a test of this hypothesis, we obtained eight mutant clamps with an inability to impede growth and measured their ability to stimulate Pol III replication in vitro. Compared with the wild-type clamp, seven of the mutants were defective, consistent with their elevated cellular levels failing to sequester Pol III. However, the ßE202K mutant that bears a glutamic acid-to-lysine substitution at residue 202 displayed an increased affinity for Pol IIIα and Pol III core (Pol IIIαεθ), suggesting that it could still sequester Pol III effectively. Of interest, ßE202K supported in vitro DNA replication by Pol II and Pol IV but was defective with Pol III. Genetic experiments indicated that the dnaNE202K strain remained proficient in DNA damage-induced mutagenesis but was induced modestly for SOS and displayed sensitivity to UV light and methyl methanesulfonate. These results correlate an impaired ability of the mutant ßE202K clamp to support Pol III replication in vivo with its in vitro defect in DNA replication. Taken together, our results (i) support the model that sequestration of Pol III contributes to growth inhibition, (ii) argue for the existence of an additional mechanism that contributes to lethality, and (iii) suggest that physical and functional interactions of the ß clamp with Pol III are more extensive than appreciated currently. IMPORTANCE The ß clamp plays critically important roles in managing the actions of multiple proteins at the replication fork. However, we lack a molecular understanding of both how the clamp interacts with these different partners and the mechanisms by which it manages their respective actions. We previously exploited the finding that an elevated cellular level of the ß clamp impedes Escherichia coli growth by interfering with DNA replication. Using a genetic selection method, we obtained novel mutant ß clamps that fail to inhibit growth. Their analysis revealed that ßE202K is unique among them. Our work offers new insights into how the ß clamp interacts with and manages the actions of E. coli DNA polymerases II, III, and IV.

Elevated Levels of the Escherichia coli nrdAB-Encoded Ribonucleotide Reductase Counteract the Toxicity Caused by an Increased Abundance of the ß Clamp.

Expression of the Escherichia coli dnaN-encoded ß clamp at ≥10-fold higher than chromosomally expressed levels impedes growth by interfering with DNA replication. A mutant clamp (ßE202K bearing a glutamic acid-to-lysine substitution at residue 202) binds to DNA polymerase III (Pol III) with higher affinity than the wild-type clamp, suggesting that its failure to impede growth is independent of its ability to sequester Pol III away from the replication fork. Our results demonstrate that the dnaNE202K strain underinitiates DNA replication due to insufficient levels of DnaA-ATP and expresses several DnaA-regulated genes at altered levels, including nrdAB, that encode the class 1a ribonucleotide reductase (RNR). Elevated expression of nrdAB was dependent on hda function. As the ß clamp-Hda complex regulates the activity of DnaA by stimulating its intrinsic ATPase activity, this finding suggests that the dnaNE202K allele supports an elevated level of Hda activity in vivo compared with the wild-type strain. In contrast, using an in vitro assay reconstituted with purified components the ßE202K and wild-type clamp proteins supported comparable levels of Hda activity. Nevertheless, co-overexpression of the nrdAB-encoded RNR relieved the growth defect caused by elevated levels of the ß clamp. These results support a model in which increased cellular levels of DNA precursors relieve the ability of elevated ß clamp levels to impede growth and suggest either that multiple effects stemming from the dnaNE202K mutation contribute to elevated nrdAB levels or that Hda plays a noncatalytic role in regulating DnaA-ATP by sequestering it to reduce its availability. IMPORTANCE DnaA bound to ATP acts in initiation of DNA replication and regulates the expression of several genes whose products act in DNA metabolism. The state of the ATP bound to DnaA is regulated in part by the ß clamp-Hda complex. The dnaNE202K allele was identified by virtue of its inability to impede growth when expressed ≥10-fold higher than chromosomally expressed levels. While the dnaNE202K strain exhibits several phenotypes consistent with heightened Hda activity, the wild-type and ßE202K clamp proteins support equivalent levels of Hda activity in vitro. Taken together, these results suggest that ßE202K-Hda plays a noncatalytic role in regulating DnaA-ATP. This, as well as alternative models, is discussed.

The Macromolecular Machines that Duplicate the Escherichia coli Chromosome as Targets for Drug Discovery.

DNA replication is an essential process. Although the fundamental strategies to duplicate chromosomes are similar in all free-living organisms, the enzymes of the three domains of life that perform similar functions in DNA replication differ in amino acid sequence and their three-dimensional structures. Moreover, the respective proteins generally utilize different enzymatic mechanisms. Hence, the replication proteins that are highly conserved among bacterial species are attractive targets to develop novel antibiotics as the compounds are unlikely to demonstrate off-target effects. For those proteins that differ among bacteria, compounds that are species-specific may be found. Escherichia coli has been developed as a model system to study DNA replication, serving as a benchmark for comparison. This review summarizes the functions of individual E. coli proteins, and the compounds that inhibit them.

DnaC, the indispensable companion of DnaB helicase, controls the accessibility of DnaB helicase by primase.

Former studies relying on hydrogen/deuterium exchange analysis suggest that DnaC bound to DnaB alters the conformation of the N-terminal domain (NTD) of DnaB to impair the ability of this DNA helicase to interact with primase. Supporting this idea, the work described herein based on biosensor experiments and enzyme-linked immunosorbent assays shows that the DnaB-DnaC complex binds poorly to primase in comparison with DnaB alone. Using a structural model of DnaB complexed with the C-terminal domain of primase, we found that Ile-85 is located at the interface in the NTD of DnaB that contacts primase. An alanine substitution for Ile-85 specifically interfered with this interaction and impeded DnaB function in DNA replication, but not its activity as a DNA helicase or its ability to bind to ssDNA. By comparison, substitutions of Asn for Ile-136 (I136N) and Thr for Ile-142 (I142T) in a subdomain previously named the helical hairpin in the NTD of DnaB altered the conformation of the helical hairpin and/or compromised its pairwise arrangement with the companion subdomain in each brace of protomers of the DnaB hexamer. In contrast with the I85A mutant, the latter were defective in DNA replication due to impaired binding to both ssDNA and primase. In view of these findings, we propose that DnaC controls the ability of DnaB to interact with primase by modifying the conformation of the NTD of DnaB.

Dynamic assembly of Hda and the sliding clamp in the regulation of replication licensing.

Regulatory inactivation of DnaA (RIDA) is one of the major regulatory mechanisms of prokaryotic replication licensing. In RIDA, the Hda-sliding clamp complex loaded onto DNA directly interacts with adenosine triphosphate (ATP)-bound DnaA and stimulates the hydrolysis of ATP to inactivate DnaA. A prediction is that the activity of Hda is tightly controlled to ensure that replication initiation occurs only once per cell cycle. Here, we determined the crystal structure of the Hda-ß clamp complex. This complex contains two pairs of Hda dimers sandwiched between two ß clamp rings to form an octamer that is stabilized by three discrete interfaces. Two separate surfaces of Hda make contact with the ß clamp, which is essential for Hda function in RIDA. The third interface between Hda monomers occludes the active site arginine finger, blocking its access to DnaA. Taken together, our structural and mutational analyses of the Hda-ß clamp complex indicate that the interaction of the ß clamp with Hda controls the ability of Hda to interact with DnaA. In the octameric Hda-ß clamp complex, the inability of Hda to interact with DnaA is a novel mechanism that may regulate Hda function.

Substitutions of Conserved Residues in the C-terminal Region of DnaC Cause Thermolability in Helicase Loading.

The DnaB-DnaC complex binds to the unwound DNA within the Escherichia coli replication origin in the helicase loading process, but the biochemical events that lead to its stable binding are uncertain. This study characterizes the function of specific C-terminal residues of DnaC. Genetic and biochemical characterization of proteins bearing F231S and W233L substitutions of DnaC reveals that their activity is thermolabile. Because the mutants remain able to form a complex with DnaB at 30 and 37 °C, their thermolability is not explained by an impaired interaction with DnaB. Photo-cross-linking experiments and biosensor analysis show an altered affinity of these mutants compared with wild type DnaC for single-stranded DNA, suggesting that the substitutions affect DNA binding. Despite this difference, their activity in DNA binding is not thermolabile. The substitutions also drastically reduce the affinity of DnaC for ATP as measured by the binding of a fluorescent ATP analogue (MANT-ATP) and by UV cross-linking of radiolabeled ATP. Experiments show that an elevated temperature substantially inhibits both mutants in their ability to load the DnaB-DnaC complex at a DnaA box. Because a decreased ATP concentration exacerbates their thermolabile behavior, we suggest that the F231S and W233L substitutions are thermolabile in ATP binding, which correlates with defective helicase loading at an elevated temperature.

DnaC traps DnaB as an open ring and remodels the domain that binds primase.

Helicase loading at a DNA replication origin often requires the dynamic interactions between the DNA helicase and an accessory protein. In E. coli, the DNA helicase is DnaB and DnaC is its loading partner. We used the method of hydrogen/deuterium exchange mass spectrometry to address the importance of DnaB-DnaC complex formation as a prerequisite for helicase loading. Our results show that the DnaB ring opens and closes, and that specific amino acids near the N-terminus of DnaC interact with a site in DnaB's C-terminal domain to trap it as an open ring. This event correlates with conformational changes of the RecA fold of DnaB that is involved in nucleotide binding, and of the AAA+ domain of DnaC. DnaC also causes an alteration of the helical hairpins in the N-terminal domain of DnaB, presumably occluding this region from interacting with primase. Hence, DnaC controls the access of DnaB by primase.

Mutant DnaAs of Escherichia coli that are refractory to negative control.

DnaA is the initiator of DNA replication in bacteria. A mutant DnaA named DnaAcos is unusual because it is refractory to negative regulation. We developed a genetic method to isolate other mutant DnaAs that circumvent regulation to extend our understanding of mechanisms that control replication initiation. Like DnaAcos, one mutant bearing a tyrosine substitution for histidine 202 (H202Y) withstands the regulation exerted by datA, hda and dnaN (ß clamp), and both DnaAcos and H202Y resist inhibition by the Hda-ß clamp complex in vitro. Other mutant DnaAs carrying G79D, E244K, V303M or E445K substitutions are either only partially sensitive or refractory to inhibition by the Hda-ß clamp complex in vitro but are responsive to hda expression in vivo. All mutant DnaAs remain able to interact directly with Hda. Of interest, both DnaAcos and DnaAE244K bind more avidly to Hda. These mutants, by sequestrating Hda, may limit its availability to regulate other DnaA molecules, which remain active to induce extra rounds of DNA replication. Other evidence suggests that a mutant bearing a V292M substitution hyperinitiates by escaping the effect of an unknown regulatory factor. Together, our results provide new insight into the mechanisms that regulate replication initiation in Escherichia coli.

Helicase loading at chromosomal origins of replication.

Loading of the replicative DNA helicase at origins of replication is of central importance in DNA replication. As the first of the replication fork proteins assemble at chromosomal origins of replication, the loaded helicase is required for the recruitment of the rest of the replication machinery. In this work, we review the current knowledge of helicase loading at Escherichia coli and eukaryotic origins of replication. In each case, this process requires both an origin recognition protein as well as one or more additional proteins. Comparison of these events shows intriguing similarities that suggest a similar underlying mechanism, as well as critical differences that likely reflect the distinct processes that regulate helicase loading in bacterial and eukaryotic cells.

The rcbA gene product reduces spontaneous and induced chromosome breaks in Escherichia coli.

Elevated levels of DnaA cause excessive initiation, which leads to an increased level of double-strand breaks that are proposed to arise when newly formed replication forks collide from behind with stalled or collapsed forks. These double-strand breaks are toxic in mutants that are unable to repair them. Using a multicopy suppressor assay to identify genes that suppress this toxicity, we isolated a plasmid carrying a gene whose function had been unknown. This gene, carried by the cryptic rac prophage, has been named rcbA for its ability to reduce the frequency of chromosome breaks. Our study shows that the colony formation of strains bearing mutations in rep, recG, and rcbA, like recA and recB mutants, is inhibited by an oversupply of DnaA and that a multicopy plasmid carrying rcbA neutralizes this inhibition. These and other results suggest that rcbA helps to maintain the integrity of the bacterial chromosome by lowering the steady-state level of double-strand breaks.

Replication initiation at the Escherichia coli chromosomal origin.

To initiate DNA replication, DnaA recognizes and binds to specific sequences within the Escherichia coli chromosomal origin (oriC), and then unwinds a region within oriC. Next, DnaA interacts with DnaB helicase in loading the DnaB-DnaC complex on each separated strand. Primer formation by primase (DnaG) induces the dissociation of DnaC from DnaB, which involves the hydrolysis of ATP bound to DnaC. Recent evidence indicates that DnaC acts as a checkpoint in the transition from initiation to the elongation stage of DNA replication. Freed from DnaC, DnaB helicase unwinds the parental duplex DNA while interacting the cellular replicase, DNA polymerase III holoenzyme, and primase as it intermittently forms primers that are extended by the replicase in duplicating the chromosome.

Two forms of ribosomal protein L2 of Escherichia coli that inhibit DnaA in DNA replication.

We purified an inhibitor of oriC plasmid replication and determined that it is a truncated form of ribosomal protein L2 evidently lacking 59 amino acid residues from the C-terminal region encoded by rplB. We show that this truncated form of L2 or mature L2 physically interacts with the N-terminal region of DnaA to inhibit initiation from oriC by apparently interfering with DnaA oligomer formation, and the subsequent assembly of the prepriming complex on an oriC plasmid. Both forms of L2 also inhibit the unwinding of oriC by DnaA. These in vitro results raise the possibility that one or both forms of L2 modulate DnaA function in vivo to regulate the frequency of initiation.

Primase directs the release of DnaC from DnaB.

An AAA+ ATPase, DnaC, delivers DnaB helicase at the E. coli chromosomal origin by a poorly understood process. This report shows that mutant proteins bearing alanine substitutions for two conserved arginines in a motif named box VII are defective in DNA replication, but this deficiency does not arise from impaired interactions with ATP, DnaB, or single-stranded DNA. Despite their ability to deliver DnaB to the chromosomal origin to form the prepriming complex, this intermediate is inactive. Quantitative analysis of the prepriming complex suggests that the DnaB-DnaC complex contains three DnaC monomers per DnaB hexamer and that the interaction of primase with DnaB and primer formation triggers the release of DnaC, but not the mutants, from DnaB. The interaction of primase with DnaB and the release of DnaC mark discrete events in the transition from initiation to the elongation stage of DNA replication.

DnaAcos hyperinitiates by circumventing regulatory pathways that control the frequency of initiation in Escherichia coli.

Mutants of dnaAcos are inviable at 30 degrees C because DnaAcos hyperinitiates, leading to new replication forks that apparently collide from behind with stalled forks, thereby generating lethal double-strand breaks. By comparison, an elevated level of DnaA also induces extra initiations, but lethality occurs only in strains defective in repairing double-strand breaks. To explore the model that the chromosomal level of DnaAcos, or the increased abundance of DnaA, increases initiation frequency by, escaping or overcoming pathways that control initiation, respectively, we developed a genetic selection and identified seqA, datA, dnaN and hda, which function in pathways that either act at oriC or modulate DnaA activity. To assess each pathway's relative effectiveness, we used genetically inactivated strains, and quantified initiation frequency after elevating the level of DnaA. The results indicate that the hda-dependent pathway has a stronger effect on initiation than pathways involving seqA and datA. Testing the model that DnaAcos overinitiates because it fails to respond to one or more regulatory mechanisms, we show that dnaAcos is unresponsive to hda and dnaN, which encodes the beta clamp, and also datA, a locus proposed to titer excess DnaA. These results explain how DnaAcos hyperinitiates to interfere with viability.

Escherichia coli Dps interacts with DnaA protein to impede initiation: a model of adaptive mutation.

During exponential growth, the level of Dps transiently increases in response to oxidative stress to sequester and oxidize Fe2+, which would otherwise lead to hydroxyl radicals that damage the bacterial chromosome. We report that Dps specifically interacts with DnaA protein by affinity chromatography and a solid phase binding assay, requiring the N-terminal region of DnaA to interact. In vitro, Dps inhibits DnaA function in initiation by interfering with strand opening of the replication origin. Comparing isogenic dps+ and dps::kan strains by flow cytometry and by quantitative polymerase chain reaction assays at either the chromosomally encoded level, or at an elevated level encoded by an inducible plasmid, we show that Dps causes less frequent initiations. Results from genetic experiments support this conclusion. We suggest that Dps acts as a checkpoint during oxidative stress to reduce initiations, providing an opportunity for mechanisms to repair oxidative DNA damage. Because Dps does not block initiations absolutely, duplication of the damaged DNA is expected to increase the genetic variation of a population, and the probability that genetic adaptation leads to survival under conditions of oxidative stress.

Escherichia coli DnaA interacts with HU in initiation at the E. coli replication origin.

Escherichia coli HU protein is a dimer encoded by two closely related genes whose expression is growth phase-dependent. As a major component of the bacterial nucleoid, HU binds to DNA non-specifically, but acts at the chromosomal origin (oriC) during initiation by stimulating strand opening in vitro. We show that the alpha dimer of HU is more active than other forms of HU in initiation of an oriC-containing plasmid because it more effectively promotes strand opening of oriC. Other results demonstrate that HU stabilizes the DnaA oligomer bound to oriC, and that the alpha subunit of HU interacts with the N-terminal region of DnaA. These observations support a model whereby DnaA interacts with the alpha dimer or the alphabeta heterodimer, depending on their cellular abundance, to recruit the respective form of HU to oriC. The greater activity of the alpha dimer of HU at oriC may stimulate initiation during early log phase compared with the lesser activity of the alphabeta heterodimer or the beta dimer.

Genetic method to analyze essential genes of Escherichia coli.

The genetic analysis of essential genes has been generally restricted to the use of conditional mutations, or inactivating chromosomal mutations, which require a complementing plasmid that must either be counterselected or lost to measure a phenotype. These approaches are limited because they do not permit the analysis of mutations suspected to affect a specific function of a protein, nor do they take advantage of the increasing abundance of structural and bioinformatics data for proteins. Using the dnaC gene as an example, we developed a genetic method that should permit the mutational analysis of other essential genes of Escherichia coli and related enterobacteria. The method consists of using a strain carrying a large deletion of the dnaC gene, which is complemented by a wild-type copy expressed from a plasmid that requires isopropyl-beta-d-thiogalactopyranoside for maintenance. Under conditions in which this resident plasmid is lost, the method measures the function of a dnaC mutation encoded by a second plasmid. This methodology should be widely applicable to the genetic analysis of other essential genes.

DnaA: controlling the initiation of bacterial DNA replication and more.

Escherichia coli is a model system to study the mechanism of DNA replication and its regulation during the cell cycle. One regulatory pathway ensures that initiation of DNA replication from the chromosomal origin, oriC, is synchronous and occurs at the proper time in the bacterial cell cycle. A major player in this pathway is SeqA protein and involves its ability to bind preferentially to oriC when it is hemi-methylated. The second pathway modulates DnaA activity by stimulating the hydrolysis of ATP bound to DnaA protein. The regulatory inactivation of DnaA function involves an interaction with Hda protein and the beta dimer, which functions as a sliding clamp for the replicase, DNA polymerase III holoenzyme. The datA locus represents a third mechanism, which appears to influence the availability of DnaA protein in supporting rifampicin-resistant initiations.

Escherichia coli DnaA protein: specific biochemical defects of mutant DnaAs reduce initiation frequency to suppress a temperature-sensitive dnaX mutation.

The Escherichia coli dnaA73, dnaA721, and dnaA71 alleles, which encode A213D, R432L, T435K substitutions, respectively, were originally isolated as extragenic suppressors of a temperature-sensitive dnaX mutant. As the A213D substitution resides in a domain that functions in ATP binding and the R432L and T435K substitutions affect residues that recognize the DnaA box motif, they might be expected to reduce ATP and specific DNA binding, respectively. Therefore, a major objective was to quantify the biochemical defects of the mutant DnaAs to understand how the altered proteins suppress the temperature-sensitive phenotype of a dnaX mutant. A second purpose was to address the paradox that mutant proteins with substitutions of amino acids essential for recognition of the DnaA box motifs within the E. coli replication origin (oriC) may well be inactive in initiation, yet chromosomal dnaA mutants expressing DnaA proteins with the R432L and T435K substitutions are viable at temperatures from 30 to 39 degrees C. We show biochemically that mutant DnaAs carrying R432L and T435K substitutions fail to bind to the DnaA box sequence. The A213D mutant is sevenfold reduced in its affinity for ATP compared to wild-type DnaA, and its affinity for the DnaA box sequence is also reduced. However, the reduced activity of the A213D mutant in oriC plasmid replication appears to arise from a defect in DnaA oligomerization. Although the T435K mutant fails to bind to the DnaA box sequence, other results suggest that DnaA oligomerization stabilizes the binding of the mutant DnaA to oriC to support its partial activity in initiation in vitro. These results support a model that suppression of dnaX occurs by reducing the frequency of initiation to a manageable level for the mutant DnaX so that viability is maintained.

An essential tryptophan of Escherichia coli DnaA protein functions in oligomerization at the E. coli replication origin.

In the initiation of bacterial DNA replication, DnaA protein recruits DnaB helicase to the chromosomal origin, oriC, leading to the assemble of the replication fork machinery at this site. Because a region near the N terminus of DnaA is required for self-oligomerization and the loading of DnaB helicase at oriC, we asked if these functions are separable or interdependent by substituting many conserved amino acids in this region with alanine to identify essential residues. We show that alanine substitutions of leucine 3, phenylalanine 46, and leucine 62 do not affect DnaA function in initiation. In contrast, we find on characterization of a mutant DnaA that tryptophan 6 is essential for DnaA function because its substitution by alanine abrogates self-oligomerization, resulting in the failure to load DnaB at oriC. These results indicate that DnaA bound to oriC forms a specific oligomeric structure, which is required to load DnaB helicase.